logo
YouTuber Mohak Mangal's video about ANI appears disparaging, says Delhi High Court

YouTuber Mohak Mangal's video about ANI appears disparaging, says Delhi High Court

Mint29-05-2025
The Delhi High Court observed on Thursday that a video published by YouTuber Mohak Mangal which accused news agency ANI of extortion appeared prima facie to be disparaging.
Justice Amit Bansal, hearing a defamation suit filed by ANI, said the content appeared to merit the agency's concerns and asked Mangal's counsel to take instructions on removing certain portions of the video. These include expressions such as 'hafta vasooli', 'kidnapping,' and 'goondaraj', which ANI claims are defamatory. "This video on the face of it is disparaging " said Justice Bansal after the video was played in court.
The matter is expected to resume after the lunch recess, when Mangal's legal team will update the court on whether they are willing to remove the contested language.
The case stems from a video Mangal published on 25 May in which he accused ANI of blackmail and extortion. He alleged that a representative of the agency demanded more than ₹ 40 lakh to lift copyright strikes issued against his channel for using ANI's footage without permission.
Senior advocate Amit Sibal, appearing for ANI, told the court that Mangal had repeatedly used ANI's video clips without permission on his YouTube channel. He explained that ANI had issued copyright strikes through YouTube's automated system, two of which were upheld. The controversy, he said, erupted ahead of a third strike, with Mangal going public instead of engaging with ANI through formal channels.
According to YouTube's support website, if a channel gets three copyright strikes it is subject to termination along with any associated channels. 'If your channel is terminated, all the videos uploaded to your account will be made inaccessible,' it says.
Sibal said ANI had offered a subscription licence to Mangal, which he declined. He suggested Mangal was now attempting to portray a legitimate enforcement of copyright as an act of intimidation or coercion.
He also argued that the video went beyond criticism and was part of a broader, targeted campaign to harm ANI's public standing. He pointed its amplification on social media by public figures such as comedian Kunal Kamra and fact checker Mohammed Zubair of Alt News, which added to the agency's reputational damage.
Sibal noted that the video used inflammatory language such as 'extortion' and 'goondaraj', which triggered a wave of online abuse against ANI and its employees. He sought a John Doe order to prevent its further dissemination by unidentified parties and indicated that ANI would file a separate copyright infringement suit.
In response, senior advocate Chander M. Lall from Mohak's team argued that the agency's demand for ₹ 40 lakh in exchange for lifting the copyright strikes amounted to extortion.
Lall also claimed that ANI could not assert exclusive ownership over news footage that concerned matters of public interest, and that the agency was targeting the YouTuber.
He argued that a series of news reports have suggested that ANI is running an extortion racket targeting content creators. However, ANI has not countered those those reports, he added.
Lall maintained that ANI could not ask him to purchase a license, and that this was a form of extortion by the news agency. If the issue was about copyright infringement, why had ANI not filed a copyright lawsuit, he asked.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Influencer Nazmeen Sulde dances on moving Mercedes in viral video, police action follows: ‘Scared, traumatised'
Influencer Nazmeen Sulde dances on moving Mercedes in viral video, police action follows: ‘Scared, traumatised'

Hindustan Times

time33 minutes ago

  • Hindustan Times

Influencer Nazmeen Sulde dances on moving Mercedes in viral video, police action follows: ‘Scared, traumatised'

An FIR was filed against a 24-year-old content creator who filmed a video of herself dancing on top of a Mercedes in Navi Mumbai sparking outrage online. Nazmeen Sulde, who has over 1 million subscribers on YouTube and 850,000 followers on Instagram, took to social media to share that she was taken to a police station on July 23 after a complaint was filed against her. In the video, which amassed over 8.8 million views, Nazmeen Sulde was seen recreating a viral video of an 11-year-old boy from Indonesia.(Instagram/ "We've been taken to the police station last night. Around 7 policemen came to our house and took us to the police station. We spent 5 hours in the police station. They filed an FIR, 8 sections, a case and whatnot," she said, detailing the action against her and her team. The content creator shared that she was stunned by the police action."Don't know what's gonna happen next. Feeling really scared, alone, and traumatised. Just wanted to share this taki thoda dil halka ho. Aysa kuch pehle kabhi nhi hua. Kuch b smjh nhi aarha aage kya krna h kya hoga (Just wanted to share this so that I feel a little lighter. Something like this has never happened before. I don't understand anything what to do next, what's going to happen)," she said. In the video, which amassed over 8.8 million views, Sulde was seen recreating a viral video of an 11-year-old boy from Indonesia who danced on a moving boat during a race. Sulde, in her recreation, donned sunglasses like the viral kid and danced on a slow-moving Mercedes in Kharghar, Navi Mumbai. As the car moved slowly on the side of the road, many commuters drove past her and watched her actions in shock. "On my way to 69th heartbreak with the same guy," she wrote in the caption. The video sparked outrage online, with many users calling for police action against her for flouting road safety norms. Instagram users tagged Mumbai police's official social media handles in the video's comments, calling for her arrest. At the time of writing this report, the video has not been taken down from her social media handles.

‘Aura Farming' stunt on moving Mercedes lands Navi Mumbai YouTuber in legal trouble; driver had no license
‘Aura Farming' stunt on moving Mercedes lands Navi Mumbai YouTuber in legal trouble; driver had no license

Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • Indian Express

‘Aura Farming' stunt on moving Mercedes lands Navi Mumbai YouTuber in legal trouble; driver had no license

A video of a young woman dancing atop a moving Mercedes-Benz in Navi Mumbai's Kharghar area has taken social media by storm. In the now-viral clip, the woman is seen confidently performing the trending 'Aura Farming' or 'boat dance' on the bonnet of the luxury car while it cruises down the road. The dance, made famous by 11-year-old Indonesian internet star Rayyan Arkan Dikha, has become a global craze, but this particular take has landed its performers in legal trouble. The video was reportedly shot on Sunday but went viral midweek. What added fuel to the controversy was the caption: 'On my way to the 69th heartbreak with the same guy.' However, police later discovered that the man driving the car, identified as Al-fesh Shaikh, 24, didn't even have a valid driving license. His partner in crime, 24-year-old Nazmeen Sulde, who was behind the performance, is a digital content creator with over a million subscribers on YouTube. According to a Times of India report, a passerby recorded the stunt and shared it online, sparking outrage and prompting the authorities to take swift action. Although the viral clip had a blurred number plate, traffic officials used CCTV footage to identify and trace the vehicle back to its owner in Kharghar. Both Sulde and Shaikh were detained and booked under relevant sections of the Bharatiya Nyay Sanhita (BNS) and the Motor Vehicles Act (1988). Likes > Lives — Roads of Mumbai (@RoadsOfMumbai) July 24, 2025 Online, the backlash was swift. One user sarcastically wrote, 'Now I understand why govt keep potholes in the road.' Another user said, 'Make her famous — they need to get fined and arrested for this on road.' Others condemned the pursuit of fame at any cost, with one person commenting, 'People have sold themselves for fame. Ready to stoop to any levels. It's a shame.' Dhika has become an internet sensation, thanks to his effortlessly cool moves at a traditional boat race festival. Captured dancing at the very tip of a long, racing canoe during the Pacu Jalur festival in Riau, Dhika's calm yet charismatic presence has captivated millions online. His signature style and swagger have sparked a global trend. From police officers to the Singapore Navy, Instagram is now flooded with what users are calling the 'Aura Farming' dance, inspired by Rayyan's viral moment.

Thailand-Cambodia clashes and ancient Hindu temples: Which are the 3 Shiva temples near Thai-Cambodia border, they were built by....
Thailand-Cambodia clashes and ancient Hindu temples: Which are the 3 Shiva temples near Thai-Cambodia border, they were built by....

India.com

timean hour ago

  • India.com

Thailand-Cambodia clashes and ancient Hindu temples: Which are the 3 Shiva temples near Thai-Cambodia border, they were built by....

Prasat Ta Muen Thom Temple Thailand-Cambodia clashes: In a significant development between the two countries, Thailand announced that it is closing all its border points with Cambodia after at least three people were injured in a 'targeted attack on civilians' by rockets of Cambodian forces. As per a report by ANI news agency, the development marked an escalation of long-standing dispute between the neighbouring countries in South-East Asia. However, at the heart of the conflict, there are some Ancient Hindu temples dedicated to Lord Shiva that are news. Why Cambodia and Thailand are fighting? As per local media reports, heavy fighting had broke out today between the forces of Cambodia and Thailand near the disputed Ta Muen Thom Temple in Surin Province, as Cambodian forces launched an attack. Additionally, according to the Chakrabongse Bhuvanath Plan, Thai forces responded which is designed to address border incidents. Thailand-Cambodia clashes: Which Shiva temples are in news? As per media reports, a group of three 11th-century Hindu temples, namely, Prasat Ta Muen Thom or 'Great Temple of the Grandfather Chicken' in Khmer built by King Udayadityavarman II, Prasat Ta Muen, and Prasat Ta Muen Toch are at the center of the Cambodia–Thailand border tension. Dedicated to Lord Shiva, the main temple, Ta Muen Thom, features a naturally formed Shivling and Sanskrit inscriptions, reflecting ancient Indian cultural influence. The temples lie in the dense Dangrek mountain range along a historical Khmer route. Notably, both the countries claim the site—Cambodia citing its Khmer heritage, and Thailand referencing current territorial control. What's the long-running border dispute between Thailand and Cambodia? The long-running border disputes between Thailand and Cambodia date back over a century, when France, which occupied Cambodia until 1953, first mapped the land border. Cambodia has cited that map to support its territorial claims, while Thailand rejects it as inaccurate. (With inputs from agencies)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store