As residents and dogs again fill Chicago parks, data shows fewer than 1 in 4 reported bites result in citations
But he remembers the phone call he made to his wife: 'I said, 'You have to come get me. I've been attacked by a pit bull,'' Wolf said. 'And she goes, 'Are you kidding?''
A day and 50 stitches later Wolf, 68, went to the police station to report the bite and found himself navigating a morass of different systems as he tried to draw official attention to the dog's owner.
An officer at the Morgan Park District (22nd) police station helped Wolf get started on a bite report, which kickstarts an investigation at Chicago Animal Care and Control.
The city department received some 6,435 bite reports between January 2020 and April 30 of this year, according to a Tribune review of data obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request.
For that same period, data shows that CACC has issued about 1,516 citations, for 'unrestrained violations,' to animal owners. The violations cover dogs found to be off-leash in public areas, but not every violation issued pertains to a bite.
All of the investigations save a single one were marked closed, leaving residents and city officials alike to complain that the path to hold owners to account after dog attacks is opaque at best and useless at worst.
Wolf's was one of them. An animal control investigator spoke with Wolf about the attack, but stated in the report that Wolf didn't know the owner or how to reach him. Someone was trying to locate better information on the dog's owner, according to the investigation report.
The Beverly resident said he tried to follow up with Animal Control but never heard back. A copy of the investigation associated with Wolf's bite report showed the inquiry was marked completed, with no listed resolution.
'I would have liked for there to be some consequences to this,' he said.
In the 19th Ward, where Wolf lives, canine attacks have been a problem since a woman jogging in the Dan Ryan Woods was mauled to death by a trio of vicious dogs in 2003. More recently, city data shows that bites are up in that ward and citywide since 2020.The agency received 1,267 bite reports in 2023 and just over 1,300 reports in 2024, according to Chicago Animal Care and Control data. But the number of unrestrained citations it issued dropped by more than half over the same period — from 390 to 177.
A CACC representative said in a statement that the department was reviewing Wolf's case and one other closed case listed in a request for comment. The department acknowledged it can be frustrating for the public to deal with multiple agencies in the reporting process, but said it largely relies on the Chicago Police Department for accurate information to push cases forward.
CPD representatives didn't respond to multiple requests for comment.Animal Care has been without a permanent leader for more than two years, since then-Mayor Lori Lightfoot appointed Susan Capello as acting director in January 2023.
CACC has cut back on its hours for members of the public to bring in animals and is sounding the alarm on a flood of pet surrenders that is testing the capacity of its space and its staff. On Thursday, it reported on social media that 75 animals entered its shelter over a single day.
As for why more than three-quarters of the animal bites reported to the agency are closed without a clear resolution, Animal Care and Control Operations Manager Angela Rayburn said investigators contend with missing or inaccurate information in bite reports.
'We have no other way to find the person other than what we're seeing in the official police (report),' she said.
Even with the correct information, Rayburn acknowledged, investigators will mark probes closed if they are unable to reach a bite victim or a dog owner. They can reopen investigations if someone calls them back, she added, but said callbacks after the first 24 hours are rare.
'We would probably have over 100 open bite (reports) if we're waiting on people to call us back,' she said. 'We don't want to wait months just to leave it open for someone that's probably never going to call.'
A department spokesperson said CACC officials and CPD were working to update a 2019 police order governing how officers handle animal-related incidents. That order directs officers to determine whether biting animals belong to anyone, and fill out bite reports for city and county animal control officials, among other obligations. If an officer can identify an owner, the order requires him or her to cite the owner for any alleged violations of city code.
CACC investigators will also work with animal owners to 'address concerns rather than defaulting to citations' when appropriate, according to the statement. 'That said, our ability to issue citations or take enforcement action depends on verifiable information, including victim/witness cooperation and confirmed ownership.'
People who have tried to make reports complain of a confusing and frustrating process involving multiple agencies. That can include CPD, Animal Control and potentially Cook County Animal Care and Control, which handles rabies investigations.
Ald. Matt O'Shea, 19th, has resorted to getting personally involved on behalf of his constituents who need help getting bites reported and investigated.
'There seems to be a lot of confusion,' O'Shea said. 'But when I'm on the scene or I'm on the phone, or I'm getting an email from someone who was just viciously attacked, and there's a whole lot of 'Oh, that's not us' on the other end, that's a problem.'
One of those constituents was Kevin Conroy. Conroy, 37, wasn't even sure where he was supposed to report the attack that left his dog Liam with a half-dozen puncture wounds and a $1,300 vet bill while the pair was out for a run on the Major Taylor Trail last fall.
Conroy first called 311, he said, and was then told he needed to go to the police station. He ended up calling the Cook County Forest Preserve to report the bite, which cares for the property on which he and his dog were attacked, and filed a bite report through the Police Department.
'That was the last I heard of that,' he said.
A Cook County Forest Preserve spokesperson, reached for comment, said Forest Preserve police documented the attack but didn't get any more information after the initial phone call with Conroy. According to the investigative file associated with Conroy's bite report, an Animal Control investigator conducted a phone interview but wrote that no owner information was available.
The file does not list an outcome.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
15 hours ago
- Axios
As Tribune offers buyouts, veteran reporter Ray Long announces retirement
Investigative reporter Ray Long has closed his notebook, retiring after almost 30 years at the Chicago Tribune. The latest: Long, 67, announced his departure on Monday, amid the company's request for newsroom employees to consider buyouts. "I took advantage of the buyout because I was already thinking of leaving," Long tells Axios. "It was perfect timing for me." The big picture: Long started at the paper in 1998, serving as the Springfield correspondent, breaking big stories on state government. He moved to the Tribune's investigative watchdog team in 2015. Before the long stint at the Chicago Tribune, Long worked for the Associated Press, the Sun-Times and the Peoria Journal-Star, totalling up over 40 years covering Illinois politics. He's won several awards for his work, including being a Pulitzer Prize finalist twice. In 2022, he wrote a book about now-convicted former House Speaker Michael Madigan called " The House that Madigan Built." What they're saying: " He's made the city and state better through his work," Trib editor John Chase wrote in a staff email obtained by Axios. "He always led with passion and commitment, never allowing himself or others to take the easy way to get the story." Zoom in: Long sent an email to co-workers, saying in part, "Millions of people need you to succeed. Your responsibility grows each day. Drive the beat. Don't let the beat drive you." "Enjoy the journey. I did."
Chicago Tribune
a day ago
- Chicago Tribune
Chesterton, Porter and county officials try to move forward after rift from June shooting
There were glimmers of possibility Tuesday morning for Porter County and the towns of Chesterton and Porter to mend their rift following an officer-involved shooting on June 18. While facts continue to be disputed by the towns and county, Chesterton Town Council President Sharon Darnell, D-4th, and Vice President Erin Collins, D-2nd, engaged in cordial talk with Porter County Board of Commissioners President Jim Biggs, R-North, and Porter County E911 Director Debby Gunn following a news conference organized by Biggs in the commissioners chambers at the county administration building Tuesday morning. County officials did not take questions during the two-part presentation. Biggs and Gunn have called for Chesterton and Porter's dispatch to merge with county dispatch and Biggs has suggested increasing the county's local income tax to cover the expense, as first reported by the Post-Tribune June 22. Officials from both towns have said they are not interested in a merger. The shooting is under investigation by Indiana State Police; the injured officer is recovering at home and he and the second officer involved in the shooting remain on paid leave. The Post-Tribune is not naming the officers because of the open investigation. Gunn, whom the towns have called upon to step down for what they say has been fear mongering regarding the safety and efficacy of their police dispatch center which is independent of the county dispatch consortium, gave a timeline of events on June 18, followed by a refuting of various statements made by the Chesterton Town Council and various entities. Porter County Board of Commissioners President Jim Biggs, R-North, has gotten much criticism for reaching out to The Post-Tribune shortly after a Chesterton officer was shot and airlifted to an Illinois hospital and a suspect died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head after exchanging fire with police and being hit multiple times in front of the Hilton Garden Inn in the 500 block of Gateway Boulevard. 'At no time during or following this incident did I, or anyone from PCCC (Porter County Central Communications), contact the press,' Gunn said as she began her remarks. Collins shook her head throughout the 16 statements pulled primarily from Facebook and news articles that Gunn refuted individually, except one. That statement from a town of Chesterton Facebook post on June 26 reads, 'Officers from area departments have told CPD staff that PCCC never advised many of them that there was an active shooter/officer down over their respective radio channels for which the regional E911 center dispatches.' Gunn said that is true, that the Valparaiso Police Department was not advised of the incident. Regarding the town of Chesterton's intention to draft letters to the Porter County Council, the Board of Commissioners and the state's public access counselor requesting an investigation of potential disclosure of privileged information by Gunn per Indiana Code 5-24-3-6.5, Gunn said that code was repealed in 2019. After Gunn concluded her presentation, Biggs spoke briefly, saying calls for Gunn to step down are 'unwarranted' and 'baseless.' He said considering that 80% of the dispatched calls to the two towns involve first responders dispatched by PC E911, it is untrue that the events of that day are none of the county's business. 'When that incident occurred on the 18th, that broke me,' he said. 'I will apologize to the towns of Chesterton and Porter if I have not conveyed that accurately.' 'We will continue to agree to disagree on the facts that were presented today,' Darnell said after the event. From her perspective, Collins said staffing issues preclude the county from being able to take on police dispatching for the two towns. 'Why don't they have the staffing opportunity for that? I believe it's because of the director,' she said, adding that people are still leaving despite pay increases. 'It's been a constant, the issues within the county dispatch,' she said. 'The toxic environment that is going on in Porter County Dispatch.' After the event, Biggs and Gunn spent time speaking with Collins and Darnell. 'Sharon just told me that years ago, when the consolidation was considered, they had some equipment that allowed them to speak directly to Porter County,' Biggs said. He said he told her that they should see if the county could share the cost of reinstating that system if cost is an issue. He agreed with Collins that absorbing the eight full-time and 11 part-time dispatchers from the Porter/Chesterton Dispatch Center could be challenging if they agreed to consolidate, but not because of leadership. He thinks an additional four to six dispatchers would be needed to consolidate and isn't sure they would be able to absorb all 19. Even a lesser amount would have to be worked out in the county's budgeting process that begins in August for next year. Biggs was asked why he hadn't reached out to the town of Chesterton. 'I did,' he said. 'I talked to (Police Chief) Tim Richardson yesterday. I told him that we're ready to meet. We need to get past this. It is not good for either unit of government.' For his part, Richardson, who watched the news conference on live stream, said Gunn's numbers don't add up on the timeline she provided. 'She's complaining about 57 seconds, when it took the E911 Center one minute and 38 seconds to dispatch an ambulance.' He also said Gunn's Fact Check #15, in which she said a guest commentary to local media outlets from January was written by a PCCC administrative staff member other than herself, was untrue. He provided a copy of an email from Biggs dated Jan. 14 that says in part, 'Tim, I should tell you I reviewed the letter before it was sent out,' and 'This is precisely why I felt Debbie needed to respond.' The Porter Town Council, meanwhile, released a statement Tuesday morning expressing solidarity with the town of Chesterton and their shared dispatch center. The council cited the 'continued onslaught of public pressure and false accusations levied by our own county commissioner and the director of County E911.' The accusations concern the performance of the Chesterton/Porter dispatch center for the June 18 police involved shooting. 'Chesterton's call for the director's resignation is both reasonable and necessary. The Council stands behind our Police Chief's statement 100%,' said the statement signed by Council President Laura Madigan.
Chicago Tribune
a day ago
- Chicago Tribune
Stalled Justice: Mother convicted of killing her toddler, 13 years after charges filed
Thirteen years after she was first charged with killing her toddler, a former Midlothian woman was found guilty of murder this week in a case that highlights just how long the Cook County courts can take to resolve cases. A jury convicted Marles Blackman, 50, after deliberating more than 10 hours Friday and Monday. She had spent more than nine years in jail awaiting trial — and then another four years on electronic monitoring at home — before the jury trial began June 23. With the jury's verdict, she was taken back into custody to await sentencing. Blackman's attorney, Derrick Reese, argued to the jury that Blackman's 2½-year-old child, Lavandis Hudson, died in July 2011 from medical complications that he'd struggled with since birth. 'You've got a mother over here who's been wrongly accused,' Reese said during his closing argument, after walking over to Blackman at the defense table and gently rubbing her shoulders. 'She's been going through hell.' But prosecutors described a woman who 'brutally' beat her child after regaining custody from a foster mother. Prosecutors said that medical experts found no evidence the boy had a seizure, as Blackman initially reported in a call to 911, and that experts had determined the injuries leading to his death could not be explained by medical complications. 'They ruled all of it out, and all they were left with was one thing: intentional inflicted beatings,' assistant state's attorney Robert Rodemeyer told the jury. Blackman was charged seven months after the boy's death. Soon after, the murder case began limping through hearing after hearing at the Markham courthouse. The Tribune profiled the case two years ago as part of its 'Stalled Justice' investigation, which dissected a system that allows pretrial issues to delay cases for months or years. Just like many other cases that stagnate in the county's criminal courts, the docket in Blackman's case shows how a revolving cast of prosecutors, defense attorneys and judges contributed to delays. What made her case relatively unique was that the child's death also prompted a lawsuit in civil court premised on the assumption that Blackman killed the child. The Tribune had previously chronicled how the state's child welfare system allowed the toddler to remain in Blackman's custody despite red flags suggesting abuse. Long before the criminal trial, a civil jury in 2018 determined a child welfare agency bore blame for ignoring signs of child abuse and awarded tens of millions of dollars to be split among lawyers and the boy's relatives. During the civil case, Blackman invoked her Fifth Amendment right not to say anything that could incriminate her in the criminal proceeding. She also did not testify Friday at her murder trial, where Blackman's defense attorney rested his case without calling any witnesses. For years, Blackman has been in line to get roughly $900,000 from the 2018 civil jury award as an heir to her son's estate. The toddler's father, Herbert Hudson, filed a petition in probate court to deny Blackman any of the proceeds, but that petition has been on hold for years waiting for the criminal case to be resolved. With Blackman's conviction for first-degree murder, under state law she no longer qualifies for any money from her son's estate. Through a statement issued Monday by his attorney, Leonard LeRose, Hudson thanked the state's attorney's office for their work 'bringing closure to Herbert and justice to his son, Lavandis.' In a statement, the state's attorney's office said the verdict delivered 'long-overdue justice' for the toddler: 'Despite delays in the court process, our prosecutors remained committed to securing accountability.' Blackman's attorney, Reese, called the verdict a 'miscarriage of justice' and noted in a text to the Tribune that the verdict 'will be reviewed' by judges. 'So it's not over!' he wrote. For now, Blackman's criminal case is still considered pending in the Cook County courts, with a presentencing investigation due July 23. Though Blackman's case may be an extreme example of a defendant waiting years for a trial, county records show that, as of last week, more than 150 people had been jailed at least five years. That figure has shown steady improvement, with 80 fewer people on the list now than two years ago. But it's still far higher than in New York City, where jail records show just 21 defendants, as of Thursday, held at least five years without a trial. Jail records show two murder cases have lingered in the Cook County court system for more than 14 years without a trial. The oldest involves Augustin Toscano, jailed since the first administration of President Barack Obama on allegations he was part of a drug and robbery crew blamed for more than a dozen slayings. Toscano fired his attorney 1½ years ago and began acting as his own lawyer. In January, he filed a motion arguing he should be set free because his case has dragged on so long that he can't possibly track down witnesses from so many years ago. Prosecutors countered that they've been ready to go to trial for nearly four years, arguing that Toscano or his former attorney are to blame for every delay since. The docket doesn't show any indication of a decision on Toscano's motion, and court records show Toscano is still trying to gather records to review for his own defense. No trial date has been set in that case.
