Did Donald Trump take his media strategy from Rob Ford?
Today on Commotion, host Elamin Abdelmahmoud discusses the documentary with entertainment reporter Teri Hart and Toronto Star reporter David Rider, who covered Ford's mayoral tenure and is featured in Trainwreck: Mayor of Mayhem.
We've included some highlights below, edited for length and clarity. For the full discussion, listen and follow Commotion with Elamin Abdelmahmoud on your favourite podcast player.
WATCH | Today's episode on YouTube:
Elamin: One of the key throughlines of this documentary, David, is — and I think I forgot about this again, because it's been enough time — but how adversarial Rob Ford was about the media. He would go on every day and say, "The Toronto Star is saying these things about me, they're just not true" — and by the way, he's talking about you! And in this particular case, he is casting you, or casting the media, I should say, as some sort of political opposition. And this is years before you see Donald Trump say the term "fake news."
What was it like trying to tell the Rob Ford story, while also having Rob Ford use the microphone of the mayor's office to try to say, "The media, they're not telling the truth about me" — and having people maybe believe him at the time?
David: Yeah, it was really difficult. I did very early stories on Rob Ford when there were rumours he was going to run and we got along really well. I spent a whole day with him as he did his constituency work and admired him getting people's potholes fixed and stuff like that. So when it became obvious that he had a real shot at being mayor, suddenly it turned…. I think the Fords have an incredible gut political instinct on how to turn situations to their own advantage, even situations that look like they could be a disaster.
And very early on, in a foreshadow of Donald Trump, they said, "We're going to discredit and delegitimize the media. And the Toronto Star are the ones who are the most likely to do us damage." So they started up this drumbeat and they portrayed it as a war. And they said, "Well, they're out to get us." And I always said to people when they'd ask me about it, "It's not a war. We're not trying to get Rob Ford out of office. We're covering him in exactly the same way we would have his two predecessors." And that was our yardstick for whether something was a story or not. But when you portray it as a war, suddenly he's able to just portray everything we do as being unfair and possibly false, when, in fact, he was lying all the time.
Elamin: Teri, the thing that trained us, I think, the most for the Donald-Trump-as-president years was living through this whole period of time of the Rob Ford news cycle. Because every day there was not one new thing, there were three new things — granted, a much more truncated timeline.
Teri: This documentary is certainly drawing that line — certainly a dotted one, sometimes a very, very bold line — between the Rob Ford mayoral temperature and tone in Toronto and the President of the United States in his second term, Donald Trump. And I think that that is really, really fascinating. Will we ever get the answer? Did Donald Trump watch Rob Ford? Did Donald Trump take a playbook from the Ford family, as David quite rightly points out, and their gut political instincts? We'll never know. But it's certainly there and you don't have to dig too deep to find it.
Elamin: David, what do you think Rob Ford's legacy is?
David: I think he was a first sign that a populist politician who had all kinds of baggage, who normally in normal-world politics of past decades wouldn't even be considered for office, can get elected. And part of it is that if they can lie with impunity, if they have no political shame and if the public is willing to let them get away with it — and in some cases even cheer it on — then that's an incredibly powerful political weapon. But it's dangerous for society because they think Rob Ford was the start of the fact-free universe, as far as current affairs and how we view each other, and to public policy, where the vibes about a politician are considered just as valid, or maybe more so, than what they've actually done.
So I think he was an early warning signal. Although there are people who are flooding social media now saying, "He was the best mayor ever, and this documentary proves it." So it all depends on how you look at it, but he was definitely the start of that.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
26 minutes ago
- CBC
Young people more prone to believe in conspiracies, research shows
Hillary Clinton had Jeffrey Epstein killed. Barack Obama was not born in the United States. The pharmaceutical industry was responsible for the spread of COVID-19. These are all conspiracies with no basis in fact, says University of Ottawa professor Daniel Stockemer — but his research shows that theories like them are gaining traction among young people. In fact, people younger than 35 are more likely to believe in conspiracy theories than other age groups, according to a recent study by Stockemer and co-author Jean-Nicolas Bordeleau that surveyed more than 380,000 people internationally. The research was recently published in the journal Political Psychology. "Conspiracy theories are now for everyone," Stockemer told CBC Radio's All In A Day, noting that between 20 and 25 per cent of the population believes in one. "But the young are slightly more likely to believe in them." If the problem isn't addressed, Stockemer said he expects the "democratic backsliding" he's seen all over the world to continue. "If we don't have a young population that stands up for the values of democracy ... who else will?" Why do young adults believe conspiracies? There are many reasons why young people are particularly susceptible, Stockemer said — including the fact the political world has become more divided and chaotic. "Right now, we're in a world of polarization," he said. "There is no compromise, no middle ground." Compounding that effect, Stockemer said, is that young people are being "alienated" from politics as mainstream politicians largely ignore their concerns — including during the last federal election. "The leaders didn't even come to the [University of Ottawa] to have a talk or anything," he said. "And then we wonder why young people have a higher tendency to go the populist or conspiracies route." Then there's technological leaps like the internet, smart phones and social media, Stockemer said, which allow conspiracy and misinformation to spread, especially among young people. The internet also potentially exposes them to every unfortunate incident that happens in the world, said Carmen Celestini, who teaches at the University of Waterloo and studies disinformation, extremists and conspiracy theorists. "That fear and that perpetual sense of disaster can lead people to believe in conspiracy theories," said Celestini, noting she wasn't surprised "even a little bit" by Stockemer and Bordeleau's findings. Influencers who tote extremist views and conspiracies also give their viewers someone or something to blame, she added. No 'quick fix' Widespread conspiracies and the problems inherent to the internet will require a "global response," said Celestini, one that will involve talking about the fears and emotions that led people to these conclusions. "It really is [about] having that transparent talk with your child about what it is that they're feeling, why they might believe some of these ideas and where the emotions behind it come from," she said. Stockemer said there's no "quick fix," but improving civic education and better regulating misinformation online would help. "To bring [young people] back, we need to also include them within the democratic politics much more than now," he said. And there could be immense consequences, he added, if we continue to neglect the susceptibility of young people to conspiracy theories. "Over the past 10 years, the number of democracies has declined [and] long-standing democracies like the United States [and] India are in serious danger of falling," he said. "If we continue the path we are continuing, I don't know how long some established democracies will survive. … And I think that's one of the far-reaching lessons from my research."
CBC
26 minutes ago
- CBC
McGill faculty challenge Quebec's Bill 89, arguing it violates constitutional right to strike
Four McGill University faculty associations representing more than 500 academics have filed a court challenge against Quebec's Bill 89, arguing the provincial legislation violates the constitutional right to strike. The Confederation of Faculty Associations of McGill (COFAM) announced Tuesday that the groups filed an application for judicial review in Quebec Superior Court, seeking to overturn the law — declaring Bill 89 unconstitutional and invalid as of the date it was passed. The bill was adopted May 29. It gives the provincial labour minister broad powers to restrict strikes deemed harmful to the population. "This legislation represents a frontal attack on workers' fundamental rights," said Evan Fox-Decent, a law professor and president of the Association of McGill Professors of Law, in a COFAM news release. Fox-Decent notes the Supreme Court of Canada's 2015 ruling in Saskatchewan Federation of Labour, which found the right to strike has been recognized as the "irreducible minimum" of freedom of association. "Bill 89 attempts to overturn this constitutional protection," he said in the news release. Barry Eidlin, vice-president of the Association of McGill Professors of the Faculty of Arts, said in the news release that the law risks allowing the government to impose service requirements on universities during labour disputes, threatening academic independence. "As university faculty, we have a particular responsibility to defend constitutional rights and the rule of law," says Eidlin, who specializes in labour movements. In an interview with CBC News, Eidlin says this law is dangerous from a labour relations perspective because it "erodes the very foundation on which collective bargaining occurs in Quebec." For meaningful bargaining to exist, the parties need to be on a level playing field, he said. Employers have many tools at their disposal to leverage their power over workers, while workers have only tool at their disposal — the power to collectively withhold their labour, he explained. Taking away that leverage skews the playing field in favour of the employers. "It removes the incentive of the employer to actually reach an agreement, because they know they have a trick up their sleeve," said Eidlin, adding that employers can drag out their process until the employees are ordered back to work. The four associations involved in the legal challenge include the Association of McGill Academic Staff of the School of Continuing Studies, the Association of McGill Professors of the Faculty of Arts, the Association of McGill Professors of Education and the Association of McGill Professors of Law. "This is about protecting fundamental labour rights for all Quebec workers," says Margaret Levey, president of the continuing studies association, in the news release. Back in February, when Quebec Labour Minister Jean Boulet tabled Bill 89, he said such as the labour conflict that lasted years and It caused major delays on mourners being able to bury their loved ones. He also cited the hypothetical situation of an education strike preventing services to children with special needs. Boulet said strikes involving ferries, food transportation and school transit in Quebec were other examples that led his office to draft the bill.
CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
‘I don't want to go back': Toronto pastor and her 2 daughters face deportation to Kenya
A Toronto faith leader and her two young daughters are pleading for help as they face deportation. Rev. Rosalind Wanyeki, who is known to many in the community as Rev. Hadassah, came to Canada in 2020 as a refugee with her now six-year-old daughter Pearl and nine-year-old daughter, Joylene. Over the last five and a half years the family has created a life in Toronto. Wanyeki leads a ministry while her children attend Scarborough's West Hill Public School. However, both their refugee claim as well as application for permanent residency under humanitarian and compassionate grounds have been denied. And while an appeal is underway, it won't stop the trio from being deported on Aug. 7. The family was originally scheduled to be removed from Canada earlier this year, however, that order was deferred to allow the kids to finish the school year. 'I have tried to reach for help from my MP. I'm getting opposition. I'm getting responses that cannot help me right now and I need help,' a tearful Wanyeki told CTV News Toronto on Sunday. Rev. Rosalind Wanyeki Rev. Rosalind Wanyeki, who is facing deportation to Kenya with her two young daughters, speaks during an emergency service on Aug. 3. Wanyeki, who is the founder and senior pastor of North York's Prayer Reign International Church in Canada, says she fears she and her girls will be harmed if they're sent back to Kenya. She told CTV News Toronto that they were forced to flee their homeland to escape persecution from a powerful church leader in Nairobi. 'I've served the community for those five years (here in Canada) and I pray to be safe,' Wanyeki told CTV News Toronto. Eldest daughter Joylene said the thought of being forced to leave their home makes her 'sad.' 'I don't want to go back because I like staying in Canada,' she said. Rev. Rosalind Wenyaki during emergency service Aug. 3 Rev. Rosalind Wanyeki, who along with her two young daughters is facing deportation to Kenya on Aug. 7, speaks during an emergency service on Aug. 3. On Sunday, members of Toronto's Kenya and East African faith communities held an emergency service and news conference at North York's Royal Chapel during which they prayed for a miracle for the pastor and her two children and called on the federal government to intervene in this case. Those in the community say Wanyeki is a contributing member of society, who provides emotional support for families, connects newcomers with resources and is part of a network on Kenyan-Canadian pastors as well as several grassroots and community organizations. Eunice Mbugua, a community mobilizer, said Rev. Hadassah is someone who provides culturally appropriate supports for people facing settlement challenges. 'So what is being taken away from the Kenyan and the broader African community at large is actually a support system that actually is very needed,' she said. Eunice Mbugua, Rev. Rosalind Wenyeki Community mobilizer Eunice Mbugua, right, hugs Rev. Rosalind Wenyeki. The Toronto pastor and her two young daughters are facing deportation to Kenya on Aug. 7. Local faith leaders are also calling on the Canadian government to step in and cancel or at least delay the family's deportation order. 'We are asking the government, across the board. They are already here. They are taxpayers. They are people who are contributing to the society,' Rev. John Munywoki said. Mbugua said people who are returned home can face danger. 'The situations where you hear someone has been deported - even they just disappear or the kid is just abducted. So for her, being here is a safety net,' Mbugua said. CTV News Toronto has reached out to Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada for comment, but we have yet to hear back. With files from CTV News Toronto's Rahim Ladhani
