Oranga Tamariki's near $2m bill for 'bloated' comms team
Documents show Oranga Tamariki pays nearly $2 million to its 14 communications staff - after cutting five staff and $500,000 in the past year - while other workers are banned from speaking to media without authorisation.
The revelations came from an Official Information Act (OIA) response to questions raised by the Taxpayers Union lobby group.
In it, the Ministry for Children confirmed that as of March 31, it employed two media advisers, two communications advisers, two senior media advisers, six senior communications advisers, a chief media adviser and a manager of organisational communications.
The total salary budget for the team was $1.97m.
"All staff in the roles listed above currently earn over $100,000 per year," the ministry said in its response.
A report from a select committee review shows this was down from 19 staff at a cost of $2.72m as of June 30 the previous year, though staff numbers and costs have fluctuated over the past five financial years. Cost figures have been rounded.
• 2019/20: 23 total staff, $2.47m
• 2020/21: 18 total staff, $2.03m
• 2021/22: 16 total staff, $2.00m
• 2022/23: 19 total staff, $2.55m
• 2023/24: 19 total staff, $2.72m
The OIA response also provided details about Oranga Tamariki's code of conduct relating to engagement with the media, which included a directive that no information was to be provided without explicit authorisation.
It cited privacy and confidential information as a reason, saying that given the nature of Oranga Tamariki's work, "we have access to confidential, sensitive and personal information. It is expected that all our people will show integrity and follow the law, our policies and systems regarding collecting, storing, accessing and sharing of Oranga Tamariki information".
"We do not speak, or provide information, to the media regarding any work-related activity, event or query, unless explicitly authorised," the code states.
"It is important that we continue to hold this duty of confidentiality of information even after we leave Oranga Tamariki."
Staff were encouraged to speak up about any serious wrongdoing they became aware of "using appropriate avenues", pointing to the protected disclosures whistleblowing regime as one option.
In a statement, the Taxpayers' Union said the ministry was "drowning in PR while kids fall through the cracks".
"A bloated comms team paid at least 30 percent more each than the median wage would be bad enough in a company, but in a government agency meant to protect vulnerable children, it's obscene."
RNZ has sought a response from Oranga Tamariki.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
9 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Mayor slams councillor's 'attack' on Tory Whanau
By Nick James and Ellen O'Dwyer of RNZ Porirua's mayor says an "attack" on Wellington Mayor Tory Whanau by mayoral hopeful Ray Chung is disgraceful and not the type of behaviour expected of a councillor. Chung sent an email, seen by RNZ, to three fellow councillors in early 2023 recounting a story he had been told about Whanau by his neighbour about the neighbour's son. Whanau has declined to be interviewed, but in a statement said the claims were a "malicious and sexist rumour". "What's deeply concerning is that some of the individuals spreading these harmful falsehoods are now standing for election," she said. "Ray Chung has circulated a malicious and sexist rumour - a tactic designed to dehumanise, wear people down, and discourage good people from standing for public office." She said she was seeking legal advice. Ray Chung told Morning Report in hindsight sending the email might not have been the best idea. Chung said he had experienced abusive emails, text messages and calls for the last six months. Porirua Mayor Anita Baker has made public comments in the past about her experience of having received death threats and abuse online. Baker told RNZ that Ray Chung's actions were almost slanderous. "You don't attack someone's integrity, especially another mayor or a councillor and someone you work with closely over three years, I think it is absolutely disgraceful. "Whether it's true or not has nothing to do with it." She said that local body politics had never been as dirty as it was now -- especially online. "I've taken myself off social media and I do post but I don't read anything, it's become so vile." Baker said she would not expect behaviour like that demonstrated by Ray Chung around her council table. She believed that there was an increase in misogynistic abuse against female elected representatives. Victoria University associate professor in politics Lara Greaves told RNZ even just taking the politics out of the actions it was quite a gross situation. "I think if any of us think if we are in our work environment if such an email was sent about us how we would feel or feel about that going on for a woman in their life." Greaves said she thought there was more "heat" in local politics with topics such as the Māori wards, rates and three waters. She said that the spotlight was now being put on local government but through "dirty politics" rather than substantive discussion on issues. Last month Local Government New Zealand announced that it would provide a $4500 allowance for the home security of elected members following the upcoming 2025 elections. Anecdotal reports of abuse and the fact the security allowance had been established showed that it was a problem for mayors and councillors, Greaves said. She said that there was a high level of threat for local government while not seeing the same investment. Greaves said that fundamentally people should not talk about sex and colleagues and that the email was not something people would expect to see in New Zealand politics.
RNZ News
12 hours ago
- RNZ News
Tauranga council extends on-demand public transport trial
Bay of Plenty Regional Council Director of Public Transport Oliver Haycock. Photo: Libby Kirkby-McLeod/RNZ Tauranga's on-demand public transport trial is being extended, with the regional council saying it needs more information before making a final decision. Tauranga South, where the on-demand bus operates, had historically been hard to service with public transport, so in March 2024 a trial service started with people ordering up their public transport through an app. There were no pre-timetabled routes or set stops on the service. The on-demand trial was meant to end in September but has been extended until April next year. Bay of Plenty Regional Council director of public transport Oliver Haycock said the extension gave the council more time to assess the service. "When our 12 month review showed our passenger numbers were still increasing, along with the popularity of the trial, our councillors were really keen to understand a bit more about it. In addition, we were really interested to understand how we could improve the financial efficiency of the trial," he said. A review of the trial's first year noted an average of 790 passengers per week used the service, many more than the approximately 115 people a week which once used the old, fixed bus route in Tauranga South. The on-demand service costs significantly more per passenger than a traditional bus service, but because the old buses were hardly used, on-demand was still more efficient than the Route 51 buses. However, a report to the regional council noted that although an improvement on the former Route 51, the fare recovery ratio for on-demand was lower than the Bay of Plenty regional average. This meant that while across the region the fare subsidy was $7.52, for the on-demand service it was $20.59 (still cheaper than the Route 51 subsidy which was $28.72). To address that, the fares for the on-demand service increased at the end of April 2025 and Haycock said it was still too early to know exactly how that would affect the service. "The early indications are that there hasn't been any significant changes in the number of riders using the service," he said. It is now expected that regional councillors will make a decision in April next year as to whether or not the service becomes permanent or whether it might be useful in other parts of the region. "What they're really keen to understand is that balance between community outcomes and financial sustainability, so that trial extension will provide some further clarity on what role on-demand transport might play in the Bay of Plenty," Haycock said. The council said customer feedback on the service was positive, with users praising the convenience, reliability and impact of the service. One rider shared, "Due to a spinal injury, I've been totally dependent on friends and family to get around. Since using Baybus OnDemand, I've got my independence back. I have a new found freedom and I can't tell you how much that means to me." Another customer commented, "Awesome service. I used it last week from Pyes Pā to the hospital and back. No parking worries, and prompt and courteous service." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
15 hours ago
- RNZ News
Judge clears reporting of material on former Deputy Police Commissioner's computer
Deputy Police Commissioner Jevon McSkimming resigned amid a four-month investigation. Photo: Getty Images Former Deputy Police Commissioner Jevon McSkimming's High Court application to prevent media reporting the nature of alleged objectionable material found on his work computer has been dismissed, but the court has suppressed its reasons for doing so. He has been given five working days to appeal the judge's ruling. If an appeal is filed, the current interim injunction remains in place, until the appeal is determined. McSkimming resigned as the country's second-most powerful cop in May, amid a four-month investigation by the Independent Police Conduct Authority and police. His resignation came after Police Minister Mark Mitchell said he was recently informed of allegations of a "very serious nature", separate to the investigation that led to his suspension. RNZ earlier revealed pornography found on McSkimming's work computer was being investigated as alleged objectionable material. His lawyer, Linda Clark, was earlier granted a rare "superinjunction" by Justice Grau that prohibited reporting that disclosed the nature of the allegedly objectionable material, as well as the existence of the injunction itself. Following a teleconference held by Justice Gwyn, the order prohibiting publication of the nature of the allegedly objectionable material was continued - but the order prohibiting the existence of the injunction was not continued, meaning RNZ could report McSkimming's application and the interim result. On 3 June, a hearing was held in the High Court at Wellington before Justice Karen Grau in relation to the injunction. RNZ, NZME and Stuff were jointly represented by Robert Stewart KC. On Friday, Justice Grau released her judgment, declining McSkimming's application, but her reasons for doing so were suppressed and the existing interim injunction was continued to allow McSkimming time to file an appeal, should he wish to do so. If no appeal is filed within five working days, the type of objectionable publication purportedly found on his work devices may be published. At the injunction hearing, Clark began proceedings by telling the court she was seeking orders extending the current interim orders prohibiting media from disclosing the nature of the allegedly objectionable material reportedly found on his work device or devices. The order was sought until further orders of the court. Clark alleged information deemed "essential" to the investigation had been leaked to the media, who were intending to publish the information. The information gathered during the police investigation was "confidential", she said. She said that every time police had provided some substantive piece of information to McSkimming, it had appeared within the media "in a day or two days without exception". Clark said there was public interest in McSkimming's situation. She said public interest had been served to date. Stewart KC said there were two sorts of harm that could be considered, one of which was harm to the police investigation. He said the police had no concern that further disclosure of the material would impact their investigation. In relation to privacy, Stewart KC said McSkimming was "quite clearly" a public figure. "There is a huge public interest in these investigations into Mr McSkimming's abrupt resignation from office, first working day after he had been provided with the material by the Public Service Commission." Stewart KC said his clients submitted that, if the interim restraint should be continued, then "matters should be left to take their course, if there is to be any restraining at all, it should be as limited as possible for as short as possible". Crown prosecutor Stephanie Bishop, appearing for police, told the court that police did not oppose the application. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
