'We need closure at some point': West Cork marks 40th anniversary of Air India disaster
Families placed wreaths on the water at Ahakista on Monday morning after a moving ceremony to mark the 40th anniversary of the Air India explosion which killed 329 people.
A bomb placed on board Flight 182 by militants exploded off the Kerry/West Cork coast on June 23, 1985, with the plane plunging into the Atlantic.
The flight was due to stop over in London's Heathrow before travelling to India for stops in Delhi and Mumbai. Passengers were primarily from Canada, but others on board came from India and Britain, as well as other countries. More than 80 of them were children.
More than 30 relatives travelled to West Cork for the ceremony organised by Cork County Council — including Narayana and Padmini Turlapati who lost two sons on the flight and have travelled to West Cork regularly since 1985, and Sanjay Lazar, whose parents, three-year-old sister and unborn sibling were lost in the tragedy.
Family members of the late Indira Kalsi place flowers in the sea at the Air India memorial service. Included were Lily Thurral, Rajiv Kalsi, Amarjit Dhanjal, Anita Kalsi, Balbir Kaur, with locals Mary Jo Crowley and Kevin Healy. Picture: Dan Linehan
Mr Lazar, who has written a book on the tragedy, told the Irish Examiner he escaped the tragedy because he remained at home to study for exams. He recalled receiving a call to travel to London to meet with his father, but on arriving there, he discovered his family had been killed.
He then travelled to West Cork to wait anxiously for news of their remains being found. However, only his mother's body was found. He said he found out after an autopsy on his mother's remains that she was four months pregnant with his second sibling.
He saw photos of naval officers holding a cabbage patch doll, which he says was his sister's.
'I have been struggling to get it for the last 40 years but it has not been possible. That is all I have — memories and this beautiful memorial,' he said.
'It was difficult. Ironically, I joined Air India the next year — flying for 38 years as a cabin crew member. I became a lawyer because of this.
'I have been an advocate for this case. I came here about four or five years ago and suddenly got an epiphany here. I feel close to my family here. I felt my dad was telling me I had not done enough. I was a trade union leader in India and I felt he felt I did not use my voice enough to promote against terrorism or speak for justice so I gave up my job.'
He has now published a book called On Angel's Wings about the bombing.
Sanjay Lazar. Picture Dan Linehan
'I am glad the RCMP (Royal Canadian Mounted Police) are still pursuing the matter. We need closure at some point. I would like to see it before I die. I want the people who did it to say they did it. That's all. There is no revenge, there is no vengeance. It is about answers and we all want answers. And I want a memorial like this in India and a learning centre where we teach people what radicalism and terrorism is about.'
Two men accused of murder and conspiracy relating to the crash were found not guilty in March 2005.
It was alleged the bombing was plotted by Sikh extremists in Canada as revenge on India for its storming of Sikhism's Golden Temple in Amritsar in 1984.
Speaking to the Irish Examiner in Ahakista, Canadian minister for public safety Gary Anandasangaree said people were still looking for answers.
'Ultimately, the challenge is that as time goes, the ability to complete and charge and go through a legal process becomes more elusive. The frustration is clear.
'If any of us are in the shoes of a family member, what would we want? We wouldn't want answers, we would want people held to account for what happened. That has not happened in this case.
'We don't have the level of closure the families would rightfully desire.'
During the ceremony, Indian minister for petroleum and natural gas Hardeep Singh Puri described the explosion as a 'stain on humanity' and said it had left scars which had not healed in 40 years.
Taoiseach Micheál Martin laying a wreath at the Air India 182 memorial service. Picture: Dan Linehan
Taoiseach Micheal Martin said: 'We feel the tragic scale of the loss, when we see the faces and read the stories on the memorial here before us. Especially moving are the simple descriptions, 'student' or 'child' — so many young lives taken far too soon. While the scale of this tragedy is of international significance, we should not forget that it is an intensely personal tragedy.
"The loss and grief felt by you, the families and loved ones of the people who died that June morning in 1985, is deeply personal. One only needs to come here, on any year, and listen to you speak, witness you placing flowers into the sea, or laying wreaths, to understand how powerful that grief remains.'
Read More
Air India Flight 182: Cork photographer recalls taking iconic image of 1985 bombing tragedy
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
a day ago
- Irish Examiner
Tánaiste backs major tourism plans for historic Camden Fort Meagher in Cork Harbour
The Tánaiste has pledged ongoing Government support for the continued development of a landmark Cork Harbour fort as a key regional tourist attraction. Simon Harris was speaking at the official opening of a new exhibition space at Camden Fort Meagher — widely recognised as one of the finest remaining examples of a classical coastal artillery fort in the world — which has become an award-winning visitor site since it was reclaimed by community volunteers in 2010. This triggered a massive restoration involving extensive collaboration between the community, Cork County Council, and the government. Mr Harris visited the fort in Crosshaven on Friday to officially open the latest phase of restoration: the casemate building with its striking barrel-vaulted roofs and display rooms. He praised the efforts of all involved in the restoration and regeneration work over the years. 'Camden Fort Meagher is a place of national historical significance and a powerful symbol of Ireland's military and maritime heritage,' he said. 'It has been transformed from a derelict stronghold to a fantastic visitor experience. 'I know Cork County Council is working on plans to further develop it, and we in government will continue to partner together with all those involved to further develop the facility.' Fortifications were first built on the site in 1550, with upgrades in the late 1700s and 1800s to support the naval defence of Cork Harbour. Approximately two-thirds of the structure are located underground in a labyrinth of tunnels and chambers. It was handed back to the state in 1938 and remained an Irish military installation until it was transferred to the county council in 1989. The fort was overgrown in 2010 when local community volunteers began reclaiming and restoring it, spearheading its transformation in phases as funding allowed. The fort closed for extensive restoration during 2023 and 2024, focusing on protecting and conserving the casemate building, which houses the fort's main tourist exhibitions. The work was funded through significant investment by Cork County Council, supported by the government through the Historic Structures Fund and Community Monuments Fund. Nicola Radley, Director of Service, Cork County Council; Minister of State at the Department of Children, Disability and Equality, Hildegarde Naughton TD; Minister of State with responsibility for Community Development and Charities and with responsibility for Rural Transport, Jerry Buttimer TD; Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade and Minister for Defence, Simon Harris TD; Cllr Ben Dalton O'Sullivan, Deputising for the Mayor of the County of Cork, and Chief Executive of Cork County Council, Moria Murrell, pictured with elected representatives, volunteers, and other guests, as Cork County Council has officially opened new tourist display rooms at Camden Fort Meagher in Crosshaven. Picture: Michael O'Sullivan Last October, the council and Costello Masonry Conservation Ltd won first prize for the specialist work at the Irish Construction Excellence Awards. The casemate block has now been fully commissioned with new exhibitions telling the story of the fort's history, reclamation, and restoration. Mr Harris said its restoration is a testament to what can be achieved through collaboration between local communities and government. Cllr Ben Dalton O'Sullivan, deputising for the county mayor, said the entire fort is of huge historical and architectural significance. 'For almost 400 years the fort played a key role as a strong strategic position for the defence of Ireland, the west coast of England and Wales. The fort's military and more recent history is told through these new displays and I hope they will inform and entertain,' he said. Minister of State Jerry Buttimer described the fort project as a shining example of community spirit and strategic investment working hand in hand. 'The fort not only tells the story of our nation's past, but also embodies the power of local volunteers and the value of community-led regeneration,' he said. Moira Murrell, the council's chief executive, said they have huge ambition for the fort, but state funding is important to ensure projects of scale are delivered. 'The fort has the potential to be a significant economic driver for Crosshaven and the wider harbour area,' she said. 'We look forward to working with both Fáilte Ireland and government departments to identify funding opportunities to allow Camden Fort Meagher and the wider community to reach its full economic and tourism potential." Camden Fort Meagher is open to the public from Wednesday to Sunday, and on Bank Holiday Mondays between April and October. It will open seven days a week during July and August. See for details. Read More Work on Cork taskforce 'ongoing' as Fine Gael appoints first ever spokesperson on city
Irish Independent
3 days ago
- Irish Independent
‘Hardship' for West Cork communities over protected nature sites
Much of the West Cork coastline has been designated as a Natura 2000 site, either as a Special Protection Area (SPA) or a Special Area of Conservation (SAC). Those designations are now causing hardship for local people and in some cases preventing much-needed development and infrastructure projects, West Cork Councillors say. At this week's meeting of Cork County Council, Councillors Finbarr Harrington and John Michael Foley called on the Council to write to the government to seek permission from the European Union to carry out an urgent review of Cork's designated Natura 2000 sites. 'In my own West Cork, working harbours, piers and slips were taken into SACs and these are causing unbelievable amounts of difficulties for ourselves as a local authority to do repairs to these piers because we must carry out all kinds of EIAs [Environmental Impact Assessment] before we get to do it,' Cllr Harrington said. 'In relation to rural planning, where you have young couples that are just applying for planning permission for a normal family home to live in it, our planners are obliged to notify them that they're building in an SAC or an SPA or an NHA [Natural Heritage Area] and they must go off and do EIAs, which is costing them thousands and thousands of euros,' he added. Cllr Harrington cited the Garnish slipway at the tip of the Beara Peninsula, which is used by recreational sailors, fishermen and the Coast Guard. Sand builds up at the tip of the slipway over the winter but because it's in the Kenmare SAC, ministerial permission has to be sought to remove the sand. Many of the designations were mapped decades ago and have not kept pace with updated ecological knowledge or with the practical realities faced by rural communities, according to Cllr Foley. 'Right now in County Cork, homeowners struggle to get planning permission for modest homes. Farmers are restricted in their ability to work their land. Local councils find critical infrastructure projects delayed or blocked entirely in many coastal areas. Renewable energy and rural development projects, crucial for meeting Ireland and Europe's climate goals, are held back,' he said. 'We're not asking to dismantle conservation efforts, but we need to be able to complete coastal erosion problems where farms are falling into the sea, roads are falling into the sea. We need to be able to work on things, we need to be able to work on essential works like working harbours. We're not asking for a dismantling of the SECs, they're great, but we are asking for a common-sense approach where we can work,' said Cllr Foley. The Council agreed to write to the government to ask for a review of the Natura 2000 mapping.
Irish Examiner
3 days ago
- Irish Examiner
Family in Gaza has no 'flour or clean water, basic necessities', says Cork chef
A soft thud as someone collapses on the street from starvation is an increasingly common sound in Gaza. Cork chef and University College Cork student Habib Al Ostaz's family now hear that sound frequently, with war-weary people suddenly crumpling from starvation and increasingly from thirst. His father narrowly escaped being killed or maimed when a 'death market' — where aid was being delivered by the US and Israeli-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation — was bombed by Israeli forces. They never returned for much-needed aid. His family's voices are now so weak they are barely audible. 'I avoid calling them sometimes now. It's really hard to hear their voices. I sometimes can't handle it, so I chat in messages instead,' Habib told the Irish Examiner. 'I have no words to support them. People often have not eaten in three days An acute water shortage is also a huge problem. Children there are now dying of thirst, the UN said this week. Disease is also rampant due to a block on water distribution, leading to serious problems with sanitation and sewerage. Fuel for trucks to distribute water across the territory has not been allowed into the region. Israel blocked all supplies from early March to the end of May and continues to impose restrictions, rights groups say, and the territory of more than 2m people is suffering from famine-like conditions. More than 56,077 people, including many children, have been killed in Gaza since October 2023. People carrying aid parcels, walk along the Salah al-Din Rd near the Nusseirat refugee camp in the central Gaza Strip, used by food-seeking Palestinians to reach an aid distributution point set up by the privately-run Gaza Humanitarian Foundation. Picture: Eyad Baba/AFP Habib's family is subsisting on lentils, eating one meagre meal every two days. They have no flour, so they ground the lentils to make a flour substitute for bread. It causes intense pain in their stomachs, but they have no other option for food. They have also ground down animal food to make a flour for bread. They laughed that they eat animal food now. It hurts me so much When they can, they make 'coffee' out of chickpeas. 'Their voices sound completely different now. They're so weak. 'Imagine if you haven't eaten in a week, no proper protein, no fresh carbohydrates. It's like a car with no fuel. 'It's not fair. Here we have so much, but they don't even have flour or clean water, basic human necessities.' As most infrastructure has been bombed in Gaza, there is no water supply or electricity. His family walk 500m every day to get a supply of somewhat dirty water for the day. More than 500 people have been killed by Israeli fire at these aid distribution points since the start of last month, and almost 3,800 were wounded, according to figures issued by the Gazan health ministry. Security guards ride aboard trucks carrying humanitarian aid in Beit Lahia, northern Gaza, on Wednesday. Picture: Ahmad Salem/Bloomberg via Getty Images Habib's father escaped a bombing by seconds at one two weeks ago. 'I warned my brother not to go there,' Habib said. 'My dad went once. He walked for four or five kilometres to get there with his friends and neighbours. 'Bombs started falling when they were sitting there waiting for the aid trucks. My dad fled. When he went back, he saw the place where he had been sitting was bombed. More than 50 people were killed there that day. He knew some of them. People know it's too dangerous to go, but they have no choice. They have no water or food, so they're going to die anyway His family has remained in their home in North Gaza despite an evacuation order. 'They know it's dangerous, but they have nowhere else to go,' Habib said. His family moved south as refugees under previous evacuation orders, but those areas were still attacked. 'Nowhere is safe in Gaza,' Habib said. A neighbour's home was bombed this week — killing all 20 people inside, many of them children. Some were refugees from another part of Gaza who went to seek shelter with relatives. One was Habib's age and he knew them to see around the area since he was a child. More than 70 of Habib's friends and relatives have been killed since the bloody conflict erupted. Many of his school friends are now dead. Palestinian women mourn the death of loved ones, killed during overnight Israeli strikes, outside the morgue of Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City on June 26, 2025. Picture: Omar Al-Qatta/AFP) His mother was warned to leave the home as a large building just 10m away was about to be targeted by airstrikes in recent days. 'She left and it was bombed five minutes later,' Habib said. Their home was also damaged in the blast. It has already been hit multiple times, but the family feels forced to stay and try to repair it. Outside is a sea of mangled buildings, some pulverised, others half collapsed, large concrete slabs teetering at alarming angles over piles of dust and debris. His father was walking down a nearby street when an Israeli intelligence agent called his mobile phone, asking him to remove a woman who was still in a building that was about to be bombed. 'He could see exactly where my father was and told him where to go,' Habib said. He got the woman out and the building was bombed 'Israel knows everything about us, they have our phone numbers, they know our underwear size.' Palestinians search for usable items in the rubble of heavily damaged and collapsed buildings after Israeli attacks on Al-Shati refugee camp in Gaza City on June 26, 2025. Picture: Saeed MMT Jaras/Anadolu via Getty Images Meanwhile, Taoiseach Micheál Martin said the EU's failure to reach a unified stance on the Gazan humanitarian crisis was 'a huge stain'. Europe will lose its credibility unless it unifies to end the blockade on the strip to get urgently-needed aid to the people of Gaza, he said this week in Brussels. On Wednesday, draft legislation was published which would ban the sale of Israeli goods produced in occupied Palestinian territories in Ireland. However, it did not include any reference to services also being banned. The Israeli Settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Prohibition of Importation of Goods) Bill 2025 draft will now be sent for pre-legislative scrutiny by the Oireachtas foreign affairs committee. Read More Colin Sheridan: Giving up on Gaza now is a surrender to immorality that will shame our children
