Supreme Court sides with Utah in air quality lawsuit
The U.S. Supreme Court sided with Utah and Oklahoma on Wednesday in a case that started over disagreements with the Clean Air Act, and evolved into a debate over where certain lawsuits could be heard.
The high court issued a unanimous opinion in Oklahoma v. Environmental Protection Agency on Wednesday, ruling that local courts can hear objections to federal air quality laws, rather than defer to courts in Washington D.C.
The case stems from a 2015 decision by the Environmental Protection Agency, or EPA, that made air quality standards for ozone more strict.
Ozone pollution happens when nitrogen oxides react with volatile organic compounds, often called VOCs, according to the EPA. Essentially, when pollutants from cars, refineries, boilers and other sources of emissions react to sunlight and hot temperatures, ground-level ozone forms.
Ozone pollution can be common in Utah, especially during summer months. It's been linked to a number of health issues, causing respiratory problems and even intellectual disabilities, according to a recent study from the University of Utah.
States were required to submit plans outlining their compliance with the new ozone standards, which included how they would adhere to the Clean Air Act's 'good neighbor' provision — essentially, how the state would try to reign in emissions that might impact air quality in other states.
SUBSCRIBE: GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
The EPA rejected plans put forward by 21 states, including Utah and Oklahoma, which sued the agency in the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals in Colorado. But the EPA argued the lawsuits should be heard in a Washington D.C. Circuit Court, since its rule disapproving of the state air quality plans constituted a 'single, nationally applicable action.'
The Colorado court complied — but Utah and Oklahoma disagreed, instead taking the issue of jurisdiction to the Supreme Court.
And in Wednesday's opinion, written by Justice Clarence Thomas, the court agreed, handing the case back to the 10th Circuit in Colorado.
'These two disapprovals are undisputedly locally or regionally applicable actions. A (state implementation plan) is a state-specific plan, so an EPA disapproval on its face applies only to the State that proposed the (state implementation plan),' Thomas wrote.
In a statement, Utah Attorney General Derek Brown celebrated the ruling, describing it as a win for Utah.
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
'The Court agreed with Utah's argument involving the Clean Air Act that local courts should handle local issues, and the federal government should collaborate with the states — not ignore their unique differences,' Brown said. 'We are also grateful to the Trump Administration's EPA for reconsidering its ruling that required litigation in the first place, and look forward to our continued partnership on behalf of Utah.'
In March, the Trump administration announced it would reconsider the good neighbor provision, calling it 'troubled.' The EPA said it would work with states whose implementation plans were initially rejected by the Biden administration's EPA, including Utah.
Justice Samuel Alito did not take part in the decision. According to SCOTUSblog, Alito owns stock in a company that was also challenging the EPA's good neighbor provision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Daily Weather Update from FOX Weather: Southeast tropical trouble looms as Florida braces for flooding rain
Welcome to the Daily Weather Update from FOX Weather. It's Wednesday, July 2, 2025. Start your day with everything you need to know about today's weather. You can also get a quick briefing of national, regional and local weather whenever you like with the FOX Weather Update podcast. Millions of people in Florida and the Southeast are keeping a close eye on the weather forecast that could halt outdoor and beach plans across the region over the Fourth of July holiday weekend. In addition to the precipitation, the National Hurricane Center expects to be monitoring an area of disturbed weather for tropical development, which will become the main focus for forecasters through the weekend and into next week. Regardless of tropical development, Florida is expected to see additional flooding rain and thunderstorms through the foreseeable future. The first major surge of monsoonal moisture across southern Nevada on Tuesday brought widespread disruptions to the Las Vegas Valley, unleashing near-hurricane-force wind gusts that toppled trees, downed powerlines and contributed to a large fire that killed several animals. The National Weather Service office in Las Vegas issued the first Severe Thunderstorm Warning for Clark County at approximately 3:30 p.m. local time, alerting residents that developing storm cells had the potential to cause damage to roofs, trees and other structures due to strong winds. Although radar data showed limited rainfall, the damage reported across the region was linked to what meteorologists later confirmed were "virga bombs" or "dry microbursts." Flossie strengthened into a major hurricane (Category 3 or higher) on Tuesday, but forecasters say the powerful storm will begin to rapidly weaken on Wednesday as it continues to move away from southwestern Mexico. The National Hurricane Center said maximum sustained winds within Flossie have increased to 115 mph with higher gusts, and some additional strengthening is possible through Wednesday morning before steady to rapid weakening is set to begin later on in the day. One couple had the experience of a lifetime over the weekend, when they became engaged in front of a tornado in South Dakota. Stormchasers Bryce Shelton and Paige Berdomas were tracking tornadoes during a severe weather outbreak in the Mount Rushmore State, when they saw a beautiful twister in the distance. This was the moment when Shelton decided to finally pop the question. Here are a few more stories you might find interesting. 5 children die in hot cars over 8 days as advocates join families to demand action Bite mark helps experts determine this shark species bit woman on popular New York beach Millions of 4th of July travelers face potential storm-related delays across US Need more weather? Check your local forecast plus 3D radar in the FOX Weather app. You can also watch FOX Weather wherever you go using the FOX Weather app, at or on your favorite streaming article source: Daily Weather Update from FOX Weather: Southeast tropical trouble looms as Florida braces for flooding rain
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Chances increase slightly for tropical development over Fourth of July. See Florida impact
Chances for something tropical developing over or near Florida in the coming days increased while you slept. There's now a 40% chance for a tropical or subtropical depression forming over the next seven days if an area of low pressure develops in the southeastern Atlantic or Gulf by the holiday weekend, according to the National Hurricane Center. ➤ Track all active storms ➤ Weather alerts via text: Sign up to get updates about current storms and weather events by location Regardless of development, the system could bring up to 6 inches of rain to some portions of Florida through the Fourth of July weekend, according to the National Weather Service. The next named storm of the 2025 Atlantic hurricane season will be Chantal. In the eastern Pacific, Hurricane Flossie — now a Category 3 storm with 115 mph winds — is moving west-northwest away from land. Weakening is expected by the end of the day, July2. Here's the latest advisory from the National Hurricane Center as of 8 a.m. July 2: An area of low pressure could develop near the southeast U.S. Atlantic or Gulf coasts by this weekend along a weakening frontal boundary, according to the National Hurricane Center. Environmental conditions appear only marginally conducive for some slow development, but a tropical or subtropical depression could form in this region over the weekend or early next week while the system moves little. Regardless of development, heavy rainfall is possible across portions of the southeast U.S., particularly across the west-central Florida coast. Formation chance through 48 hours: low, near 0 percent. Formation chance through 7 days: medium, 40 percent. "Regardless of development, heavy rainfall is possible across portions of the southeast U.S., particularly across West-Central Florida," the Florida Department of Emergency Management said. "Those heading to the beaches for the holiday weekend from northern Florida and the Alabama and Mississippi panhandles to the Carolinas are urged to monitor the forecast, as there may be rough surf and rip currents and perhaps gusty winds should a tropical depression or storm develop," said Alex DaSilva, AccuWeather lead hurricane expert, adding, "We feel the development window is from around July 4 to early next week." Factors helping prevent tropical development include wind shear and dry air, including Saharan dust moving across the Atlantic and into the Gulf. Hurricane Flossie is about 315 miles south-southeast of Cabo San Lucas, Mexico. Maximum sustained winds are near 115 mph, with higher gusts. Flossie is a Category 3 hurricane on the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Wind Scale. Little change in strength is forecast this morning, with rapid weakening expected to begin by the end of the day. All coastal watches and warnings have been discontinued. This forecast track shows the most likely path of the center of the storm. It does not illustrate the full width of the storm or its impacts, and the center of the storm is likely to travel outside the cone up to 33% of the time. This forecast track shows the most likely path of the center of the storm. It does not illustrate the full width of the storm or its impacts, and the center of the storm is likely to travel outside the cone up to 33% of the time. The hatched areas on the National Hurricane Center's tropical outlook map indicate "areas where a tropical cyclone — which could be a tropical depression, tropical storm or hurricane — could develop," said National Hurricane Center Deputy Director Jamie Rhome. The colors make it visibly clear how likely a system could develop, with yellow being low, orange medium, and red high. The National Hurricane Center generally doesn't issue tropical advisories until there is a named storm, but there is an exception. "If a system is near land and there is potential for development, the National Hurricane Center won't wait before it issues advisories, even if the system hasn't become an actual storm. This gives residents time to prepare," Rhome said. Named storms historically develop close to the U.S. in July, especially in the Gulf and off the Atlantic coast between Florida and the Carolinas. Later in the season, tropical storms and hurricanes develop out of tropical waves moving off the coast of Africa. Elsewhere in the tropics, the National Hurricane Center is monitoring five tropical waves, including two in the Caribbean: Tropical wave 1: A tropical wave has an axis along 23W in the eastern Atlantic, from the Cabo Verde Islands southward, moving west at around 11 mph. Tropical wave 2: Another eastern Atlantic tropical wave is along 39W, south of 14N, moving westward around 17 mph. Tropical wave 3: A central Atlantic tropical wave is along 48W, south of 16N, moving westward at 11 to 17 mph. Tropical wave 4: An eastern Caribbean tropical wave is along 66W, south of 16N, moving westward at around 11 mph. Tropical wave 5: A tropical wave that had been in the western Caribbean is now crossing Central America into the eastern Pacific Ocean along 86W. It is moving west at 11 to 17 mph. Florida weather forecast for July 2, 2025 Pensacola, western Panhandle: The best chance for rain today will be along and east of I-65. Highs will be in the upper 80s to lower 90s. Tallahassee, central Panhandle: Wet pattern continues into Wednesday. We're also watching the potential development of a weak low next week, but main concerns with this feature still revolve around heavy rain. Some areas could see an estimated 4 to 6 inches of rain through the holiday weekend, with localized higher amounts possible. High of 89. Jacksonville, North/Northeast Florida: Regardless of tropical cyclone development, flooding rainfall risk increases Friday through the holiday weekend. "We are currently on a 26-day streak of the Jacksonville International Airport measuring a maximum temperature of 90 degrees" or warmer," the National Weather Service Jacksonville posted on X. "This ranks as the 20th longest stretch on record for JAX. This streak will likely continue this week." Daytona Beach to Stuart, East/Central Florida: Some morning sun then increasing clouds with scattered to numerous showers and lightning storms developing. Highs range from 88 in Daytona Beach to 87 in Stuart. West Palm Beach to Naples, South/Southwest Florida: Increasing showers and thunderstorms today may result in localized flooding, especially over east coast metro areas. Expect another warm day with afternoon highs in the upper 80s to low 90s. Fort Myers to Sarasota, West/Southwest Florida: "There remains high uncertainty with this (system with tropical potential) feature, but the main impact is expected to be heavy rainfall locally into the weekend." Highs today range from 89 in Fort Myers to 86 in Sarasota. The Atlantic hurricane season runs from June 1 through Nov. 30. Ninety-seven percent of tropical cyclone activity occurs during this time period, NOAA said. The Atlantic basin includes the northern Atlantic Ocean, Caribbean Sea and Gulf of America, as the Gulf of Mexico is now known in the U.S. per an order from President Trump. NOAA and the National Hurricane Center are now using Gulf of America on its maps and in its advisories. The peak of the season is Sept. 10, with the most activity happening between mid-August and mid-October, according to the Hurricane Center. Systems currently being monitored by the National Hurricane Center include: Tropical cyclone is the generic term used by the National Weather Service, NOAA and the National Hurricane Center for any tropical system, even if it's in the tropical Atlantic basin. To be more precise, a tropical cyclone is a "rotating, organized system of clouds and thunderstorms that originates over tropical or subtropical waters and has closed, low-level circulation," NOAA sadi. Once maximum sustained winds reach 74 mph, what it is called is determined by where it originated: : for storms in the North Atlantic, central North Pacific, and eastern North Pacific. : for storms in the Northwest Pacific. : for storms in the South Pacific and Indian Ocean. We will update our tropical weather coverage daily. Download your local site's app to ensure you're always connected to the news. And look for our special subscription offers here. This story was updated to add new information. This article originally appeared on Naples Daily News: Hurricane center tracks Florida rain impact, tropical development
Miami Herald
3 hours ago
- Miami Herald
Hurricane center says system could develop slowly off Florida coast
The National Hurricane Center continued Wednesday to keep track of a weather system that could form off one of Florida's coasts this weekend that could develop into the season's next tropical depression or storm. In its 8 a.m. tropical advisory, the NHC said an area of low pressure was forecast to develop either off of Florida's Gulf Coast or in the Atlantic along a weakening frontal boundary. "Environmental conditions appear only marginally conducive for some slow development, but a tropical or subtropical depression could form in this region over the weekend or early next week while the system moves little," forecasters said. "Regardless of development, heavy rainfall is possible across portions of the southeast U.S., particularly across the west-central Florida coast." The NHC gave it a 40% chance to develop in the next seven days. If it were to become strong enough, it could become Tropical Storm Chantal, the third named storm of the 2025 Atlantic hurricane season after Andrea and Barry. The National Weather Service in Melbourne expects higher rain chances across the region beginning Thursday whether the low pressure system develops or not as moisture piles up against the frontal boundary forming over North Florida. "Most areas are forecast to receive 1-4 inches of rainfall through the period (some much needed), but locations that receive locally high amounts multiple days in a row will become increasingly susceptible to flooding," forecasters said. Just when showers and storms would form is uncertain because of high coverage of clouds reducing the normal daytime heating effect that brings daily afternoon storms. "As the environment becomes broadly unstable, it`ll be easier for showers and storms to develop in the overnight and morning hours," forecasters said. Models vary in where the low pressure area will form, and just how slowly it may meander over the state. If its center is over the northeast Gulf near the Nature Coast, that would continue to draw moisture up over the Florida peninsula keeping rain chances very high for the state. Some models expect it to form just offshore of Jacksonville with drier air in North Florida, although still pulling moisture across South Florida. Some models expect the low to wander between the two coasts. "Ultimately rainfall looks to remain episodic, allowing areas that receive heavy rainfall time to recover and keeping the threat for flooding limited to spotsthat get repeated rounds over multiple days," forecasters said. Rain chances could continue to remain high through Sunday and into Monday depending on how the low pressure area meanders. This is the first tropical threat to the state this year. In 2024, Florida was struck by three hurricanes, all on the Gulf coast. Hurricane season runs from June 1-Nov. 30. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration forecasts 13 to 19 named storms this year, of which 6-10 will become hurricanes. Three to five of those would grow into major hurricanes of Category 3 strength or higher. ------------- Copyright (C) 2025, Tribune Content Agency, LLC. Portions copyrighted by the respective providers.
