US strikes only destroyed one Iran nuclear site, two others could restart in months: Report
The report is likely to cast further doubt on US President Donald Trump's assertion that Iran's nuclear programme was "blown up to kingdom come".
The US carried out strikes on Iran's Fordow, Natanz and Isfahan nuclear facilities on 22 June, assisting Israel, which had already been trading missile fire with Tehran since 13 July.
Iran responded to the strikes by firing ballistic missiles at the US's al-Udeid military base in Qatar. Washington and Doha were informed at least one day earlier about the choreographed strikes.
Shortly after, the US announced a ceasefire between Israel and Iran, capping 12 days of unprecedented fighting.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
Two days after the 22 June strikes, CNN reported that an initial assessment by the US Defence Intelligence Agency found that the main components of Iran's nuclear programme remained intact and were likely only set back by months.
The report sparked a furious response from the White House, which acknowledged its authenticity but said it was a "preliminary" and "low confidence" assessment.
The US director of national intelligence applies a three-tiered confidence rank to such analysis. In an unusual move in response to the article, CIA director John Ratcliffe released a statement saying that Iran's three nuclear sites were "severely damaged".
For its part, information coming out of Iran has been just as uncertain.
Shortly after the US attack, Iran's foreign ministry spokesman, Esmail Baghaei, said the nuclear facilities had been "badly damaged".
The Trump administration actually cited the Iranian assessment to push back against CNN's report, but Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, downplayed the impact, saying Washington did "nothing significant" to Iran's nuclear infrastructure and that Trump "exaggerated events".
Trump rejected a long war with Iran
Trump has said that the US and Iran will meet to restart negotiations. However, on Wednesday, he told reporters that he was "in no rush to talk because we obliterated their site".
Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian left the window open for negotiations in an interview with US conservative podcaster Tucker Carlson, but the foreign ministry has not confirmed any date.
The status of Iran's nuclear programme is important because it will inform how Trump responds to Israeli lobbying efforts.
Iran receives Chinese surface-to-air missile batteries after Israel ceasefire deal Read More »
US and Arab officials who have been briefed on recent diplomacy and have spoken to Middle East Eye say that Netanyahu visited the White House in July seeking American buy-in for more strikes. As the dust settles from the 12-day conflict, the results are looking more inconclusive. Israel would need American support to attack again, officials say.
Israel assassinated scores of Iranian commanders and scientists, destroyed ballistic missile launch pads and weapons facilities. But Iran is rebuilding its air defences, including by buying Chinese surface-to-air missile batteries, MEE revealed previously.
Current and former US officials believe that Israel does not want to allow Iran the chance to rebuild its defences. However, there are risks associated with restarting the conflict. Israel and the US ran through their missile interceptors during the conflict. And the focus on air defence appears to be shifting to Ukraine.
In one potential sign of Trump's limited appetite for further intervention, the NBC report said that Trump was offered an alternative battle plan by the US military that called for strikes on three additional sites in an operation that would have "stretched for several weeks", but Trump rejected it.
The plan called for the US to bomb three additional unnamed sites and more of Iran's air defence and ballistic missile capabilities.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
More than 1,000 dead in week of fighting in Syria's Sweida
More than a thousand people are believed to have been killed in a week of fighting in Syria's Sweida, even as an uneasy truce reigned across the governorate on Sunday. Humanitarian convoys were readying to enter Sweida to ease the impact of days of sectarian violence that broke out last weekend between Syrian Bedouin, Druze and government forces. Since midnight, "Sweida has been relatively calm", the Syrian Observatory on Human Rights (SOHR) reported, saying more than a thousand people had been killed over the past week. The deaths included 336 Druze fighters and 298 Druze civilians, 194 of whom were "summarily executed by members of the Defense and Interior Ministries". Also among the dead were 342 members of government security forces and 21 Bedouin, including three civilians, who were "summarily executed by Druze fighters". New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters In addition, 15 members of government forces were killed in Israeli strikes, according to the SOHR. The observatory said security forces had blocked roads leading to the province on Sunday to prevent the arrival of factional fighters. The interior ministry announced overnight that the city had been evacuated of all tribal fighters and that the clashes had ceased following President Ahmed al-Sharaa's announcement of a ceasefire on Saturday. A spokesperson for the Syrian Council of Tribes and Clans told Al-Jazeera that the fighters had left the city "in response to the presidency's call and in accordance with the terms of the agreement". Residents have been left confined to their homes without electricity and water, while food supplies are scarce. The US special envoy for Syria, Tom Barrack, said on Sunday that the country was at a "critical moment", calling for "peace and dialogue to prevail". "All factions must lay down their arms," he wrote on X. Fighting between Druze factions, Bedouin groups and troops loyal to Sharaa's administration has rocked the region since last weekend, exacerbated by Israeli air strikes. The Druze of Sweida had largely stayed out of Syria's 14-year civil war, and the governorate saw protests over living conditions in the last few years of former President Bashar al-Assad's rule. Following his ouster in December, many Druze have remained wary of the new government led by Sharaa, the former leader of an al-Qaeda affiliate that carried out sectarian attacks on the community during the war. Although Sharaa has rejected his previous affiliation and attempted to rebuild ties, several groups in Sweida have actively opposed his government. Israel has also spent several days attacking Syria, citing the defence of the Druze community. On Saturday, Washington declared it had brokered a truce between Israel and Syria to avoid further escalation. Israel had bombed government positions in Sweida and Damascus earlier in the week, with some targeting the Syrian defence ministry, military headquarters and the vicinity of the presidential palace.
Gulf Today
2 hours ago
- Gulf Today
Farmers protest unjust immigration system
During the Great Depression, my great grandfather and other farmers in Wisconsin organised penny auctions to help prevent some of his neighbors from losing their property to foreclosure. On the day a farm was put on the auction block, farmers in the area closed down the roads around the farm — the only people allowed to enter were the farmer whose property was being auctioned, a bank representative and the auctioneer. Then, when the auction was held, the farmer facing foreclosure would put in a bid for his own farm — sometimes as little as a penny, according to the Tribune News Service Today farmers are no longer organising penny auctions, but they are engaging in solidarity actions with immigrants. They are bringing their tractors to marches in defense of immigrant rights, as well as partnering with organisations that lead know-your-rights trainings and challenging warrant service agreements between Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and local law enforcement that, according to the American Civil Liberties Union, 'can embolden police to engage in racial profiling.' The flurry of ICE activity in California, which has included arresting day laborers at Home Depot and chasing down farm workers in fields, is breaking up families, devastating communities and making it impossible for farms to function. President Donald Trump's border czar, Tom Homan, has tried to justify these actions by saying that undocumented workers have broken the law, either by crossing the border without authorisation, overstaying their visas or using fake Social Security numbers to get a job. Technically, he is correct — in the same sense that enslaved African Americans broke the law when they escaped their captors. My point is that laws can be reformed, especially when they entail a clear injustice that defies common sense. Trump himself recently posted on Truth Social: 'Our great Farmers and people in the Hotel and Leisure business have been stating that our very aggressive policy on immigration is taking very good, long time workers away from them, with those jobs being almost impossible to replace.' He promised that 'changes are coming' to the nation's immigrant crackdown. While Trump quickly reversed himself, there are a host of things that Congress could do to improve the current situation. These include the American Families United Act, which provides a legal pathway for the more than million undocumented spouses of US citizens; the American Dream and Promise Act, which would grant permanent residency with the chance of citizenship to college-bound youth who came to the United States without status when they were children; and the Farm Workforce Modernization Act, which expands the H2A visa program for agricultural workers. Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, has even proposed an exemption to visa limits for fish processing workers. All of these bills should be given due consideration, as they could help prevent the government from wrecking the farm economy and ruining the lives of vulnerable people to score cheap political points. We are in this mess due to a broken immigration system that needs reform. Specifically, while ending a system of national quotas that favored migration from western Europe, the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 capped the number of immigration visas for people from the Western Hemisphere at 120,000. This provision, which passed when migration to the United States was virtually nil, is one reason why so many immigrants from Mexico and Central American states are undocumented. Another reversible wrong step is the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996, passed during the administration of President Bill Clinton. Part of his general 'tough on crime' agenda, this law permanently bars status adjustments for people who had come to the United States, left, then returned without legal authorization. In effect, Clinton made it impossible for millions of people to gain legal status if they had criss-crossed the border to care for a sick relative or attend family events.
Filipino Times
3 hours ago
- Filipino Times
Memorial mass held in Israel for Filipina caregiver killed in missile attack
The Philippine Embassy in Israel, along with members of the Filipino community, held a memorial mass on July 18 for Leah Mosquera, the Filipina caregiver who died in the Iranian missile attack in Rehovot on June 15. The mass was led by Fr. Carlos Santos and was attended by the ambassadors of Singapore, Thailand, and Nepal; Leah's sister Mae Joy; her friends in Rehovot; and several Filipino community leaders. Bishop Giacinto-Boulos Marcuzzo conveyed the condolences of Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa, the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, to the Filipino community. Bishop Marcuzzo also gave a blessing to Leah's photo at the end of the mass, followed by a flower offering by those in attendance. In her message, Philippine Ambassador Aileen Mendiola extended her sympathies to Leah's bereaved family and emphasized the importance of protecting civilians during times of war — especially migrant workers. The Philippine Embassy and the Filipino community in the Holy Land continue to offer prayers for Leah's eternal rest, and for healing and strength for the loved ones she left behind.
