logo
Eddie Howe isn't celebrating Paul Mitchell's exit. Uncertainty is a team-killer

Eddie Howe isn't celebrating Paul Mitchell's exit. Uncertainty is a team-killer

New York Times29-05-2025
'My job is to get us in five years' time to our ambition,' Paul Mitchell said, not long after his appointment as Newcastle United's sporting director. 'We have to be smarter, more intelligent.' By the time he leaves his post, at the end of June, Mitchell will have lasted barely one of those years.
In June 2022, when Dan Ashworth began work as Newcastle's sporting director after four months of gardening leave at Brighton & Hove Albion, he spoke about 'helping the club to grow and achieve long-term success'. Twenty months later, he was again tending his beautiful roses and waiting to join Manchester United.
Advertisement
For Newcastle and sporting directors, long-term is very much the wrong term.
Mitchell's role was '90 per cent recruitment', according to Darren Eales, the chief executive, which by the very blunt metric of actually buying first-team players, makes his tenure 100 per cent unsuccessful, so far at least — Mitchell has another month to shift that dial and the club are pushing to get transfers done.
Ashworth, said Mehrdad Ghodoussi — who, along with Amanda Staveley, his wife, initially ran Newcastle post-takeover and were minority owners — would be a 'key hire, the person that drives the football operation, who creates the structure. It's like building a house: if you don't have the right foundations, it will fall down.' To continue that analogy, Ashworth left with the roof not yet fitted and the cement still wet.
There is another theme here, too. Over the space of 16 months, Mitchell, Ashworth, Ghodoussi and Staveley will all have departed and so, too, will Eales, who arrived on Tyneside two months after Ashworth and who announced last September that he had been diagnosed with a chronic form of blood cancer. They are all pivotal figures, responsible for running the club, buying players, setting budgets or setting the tone and much else besides.
On the pitch, Eddie Howe's team was a model of excellence and stability for the second-half of the season just ended, winning the club's first domestic trophy for 70 years and qualifying for the Champions League. Above him in the boardroom, it has been constant churn.
Does this churn matter? Given the Carabao Cup win, a pair of Wembley finals over two years, playing in Europe's leading club competition for two seasons out of three, and successive league finishes of fourth, seventh and fifth, arguably not at all. Who cares what the suits are doing when Howe has discovered alchemy?
Advertisement
Yet this — categorically — would not be a theory Howe himself subscribes to and those who have portrayed Mitchell's rapid exit as some kind of victory have called it wrong. There was no celebrating. What Howe wants is new players as quickly as possible and his immediate concern was about the knock-on effects of losing the man whose role was supposed to be '90 per cent recruitment'.
Howe said as much on Sunday after Newcastle's place in the Champions League next season was cemented. 'Speed is key for us and I've reiterated that many times internally because we have to be dynamic,' he said. 'We have to be ready to complete things very, very quickly because good players don't hang around for long.'
Newcastle have not signed a first-team-ready player for three consecutive transfer windows. Last summer, they sold Elliot Anderson, who had been earmarked for a significant role, to Nottingham Forest to help balance the books. They also sold Yankuba Minteh, who his since made 32 Premier League appearances for Brighton as a right-winger, a position Howe has wanted to reinforce for years.
In January, they trimmed more fat they didn't really have, selling Miguel Almiron back to Atlanta United and allowing Lloyd Kelly to join Juventus, initially on loan but with an obligation to buy. In financial terms, those deals were necessary and represented decent business, but in football terms, which is what Howe cares about, it left his squad desperately shallow.
After all that, they now have headroom under the Premier League's profit and sustainability rules (PSR). They have scope for manoeuvre — and a good thing too, because the squad needs a significant refresh. Howe wants a goalkeeper, a right-winger, a centre-half and potentially a forward. Targets have been deliberated over and fixed upon.
Advertisement
What he doesn't need is confusion or delay. In his leaving statement, Mitchell said 'the club is in a fantastic position to continue building', but the architect left with Ashworth's defection and now the contractors and engineers are going too. When it comes to the bigger-picture stuff, Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund (PIF), Newcastle's majority owners, are notoriously slow to move, and an interim structure needs to be capable of swift decisions. The club say it will be, but judgement can only be deferred.
Mitchell's departure, in tandem with Eales — and at least partially caused by it, given their long-standing relationship — means a second consecutive summer of upheaval for Newcastle and Howe who, at this stage, has no inkling of who he will be reporting to next season and who his immediate boss will be. This feels sub-optimal.
Football and football people crave certainty. Players want to know precisely what their roles are and to look around their dressing-room knowing team-mates feel the same. Managers want to know what to expect from their players and feel confident that tactical instructions will be carried out. From above, they want authority and backing. Uncertainty is a team-killer.
When Staveley and Ghodoussi left Newcastle last July, Howe lost two huge allies and advocates. The three of them had worked closely together in the early days post-takeover, forging a tight, intimate relationship and he was kept informed of everything, good or bad. They left a vacuum. Newcastle felt like less of a family and more corporate. When Mitchell arrived, Howe was given scant notice.
If that was bruising, then Mitchell's forthright, brusque personality and desire to make his own mark at Newcastle did not help the healing process. 'It was the wrong attitude to come in with,' an associate of Howe said, speaking on condition of anonymity. 'If the club was really at a low point then you could understand that idea of changing everything. It didn't need that. It just needed a bit of support.'
After the PSR shambles, when Newcastle held negotiations with Liverpool over selling Anthony Gordon, Chelsea enquired about Alexander Isak, and after Mitchell led a long, fruitless pursuit of Crystal Palace's Marc Guehi, Newcastle's dressing-room was rife with uncertainty. Every player knew they had a price. With no quality additions, they were less convinced about Newcastle's ambitions. Howe felt less certain in his relationships. He was less clear about what the club's vision was, so how could he persuade his players?
In a sport of marginal gains, Newcastle began the season a few percentage points off. They were inconsistent, either nabbing results while not playing well or playing better but proving incapable of seeing games out. With no reinforcements and little support network, it was left to Howe and his backroom team to shake players out of it. It meant months of introspection and effort.
Advertisement
'No one fully understands apart from Eddie and his staff just how difficult this season has been,' the associate said. 'Things could have gone very differently.' This was the byproduct of uncertainty.
In the meantime, Howe and Mitchell muddled along. They were not stags butting heads. The early tension had first been around personality and then transfers and with Newcastle unable or unwilling to buy anybody, transfers were largely irrelevant. They were never going to be close mates, but Howe put his head down and got on with it.
Perhaps that tension would have flared up again this summer. Perhaps Mitchell's expertise and experience would have come to the fore and everyone would have been delighted. Perhaps his legacy will turn out to be the 'fantastic position', he spoke about and Newcastle will get their deals done, which is the minimum Howe deserves after a truly transformational season.
Howe has delivered an elite performance. Newcastle's team operated at an elite level for six months, showing what they are capable of. Their marketing and commercial departments are getting there after long years of shrivelled ambition, but in terms of infrastructure and facilities they are not yet an elite club.
'That's what we want to be,' Howe said when The Athletic put these points to him last weekend. 'That's what we're desperate to continue to be. But if I answer that with a definitive yes, I'm not sure it would be wise. I'll let you judge. But we crave that, we want that. Now my summer will be focused purely on trying to make us stronger and better for every challenge we're going to face.'
But now he will also have to focus on forging new partnerships, with Eales' replacement and Mitchell's, whatever their job descriptions are and whatever the new structure is. Once again, there will be different people who are tasked with running Newcastle or who are instrumental in shaping what Newcastle should be, either as a squad or as a club.
To a certain extent, Howe knew what he would be getting with Mitchell: a headache. Now he doesn't know again. In part, this is to do with circumstances. In an ideal world, a CEO would appoint the sporting director who would seek out the best fit as manager, but at Newcastle they did it the other way around. Equally, nobody could have predicted Eales' illness and, after this extraordinary and rewarding season, he must now belatedly take care of himself and his family.
Advertisement
To return to the start, there will be no winner from Mitchell's departure if, come August, Howe looks around his dressing room and again sees uncertainty flicker in his players' eyes. And to borrow again from Ghodoussi's analogy, if building a club is really like building a house, do Newcastle yet have the 'right foundations'? Or are they once more being knocked down in order to start over?
One thing is certain: their master craftsman cannot be expected to keep picking up the pieces.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

With the Christian Wilkins release, Pete Carroll and his Raiders show a blunt culture building approach
With the Christian Wilkins release, Pete Carroll and his Raiders show a blunt culture building approach

Yahoo

timea minute ago

  • Yahoo

With the Christian Wilkins release, Pete Carroll and his Raiders show a blunt culture building approach

HENDERSON, Nev. — As the Las Vegas Raiders stretched and went through warmups Friday, team owner Mark Davis sat more than 50 yards away under a shaded platform. Laid out before him was an ocean of new faces that have come to define his franchise's latest sweeping reboot — from the majority of his retooled coaching staff, his new starting quarterback, a first-time general manager, to more than 40 new players threading through the training camp depth chart. And of course, one very notable omission who became an ex-Raider on Thursday: prize 2024 free agent defensive tackle signee Christian Wilkins, who was dumped by the team in a jarring move that had already seen Las Vegas void $35.2 million of his guaranteed salary last month. It's a staggering end for a player who was expected to wreak havoc on AFC West offenses and give star Raiders defensive end Maxx Crosby a running partner who could help balance the scales against Patrick Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs. Instead, Wilkins appeared in only five games before suffering a Jones fracture in his left foot, setting the table for a potential surgery and rehabilitation that conceivably should have had him back onto the field this month. He wasn't. And now he won't ever be for the Raiders, who sent a football and culture message that might as well have been plastered onto a theater marquee at the entrance of the team's Henderson practice facility. Something like: If you're not going to be playing for us, you're not going to be sticking around with us. [Join or create a Yahoo Fantasy Football league for the 2025 NFL season] Without a doubt, that's how this new regime is planning to operate moving forward, refusing to hang onto what it views as roster-building errors from past regimes and also aiming to be aggressive in moving on from any mistakes it might commit in the future. With head coach Pete Carroll and general manager John Spytek at the controls, the mandate is to make sure the next iteration of the Raiders doesn't fall into familiar (and seemingly longstanding) pitfalls and get dragged further by roster-building blunders. For the Raiders, Wilkins became that when the team demanded for months some kind of cogent plan — most likely involving surgery — to get him back into the fold and playing football. The Raiders' brass didn't see that materializing, and that ultimately ended the relationship between a hopeful building block and the brain trust neither signed him nor saw him play a single snap. 'We took a long time to make our decision,' Carroll said. 'We watched our way through the whole thing. We're keeping really clear with what we said. I think there was no clear path to his return, and so we just had to move on.' Talking more generally about his philosophy with players, Carroll later added, 'Each practice is an opportunity for us. Each day is a statement of who we are, what we're all about. Are we there again? Are we consistent? Are we battling?' With that in mind, this looks like a roster that's going to continue to experience considerable churn through next offseason and into 2026. Spytek comes from organizations that were built in a multitude of ways, but his preference with the Raiders is to draft and cultivate the vast majority of the team's roster and then accentuate down the line when opportunities present themselves to add a player through free agency or via trade who can potentially stimulate another significant step forward. You can already see some of those fingerprints on this version of Carroll and Spytek's team. Among the swath of new talent is an 11-player draft class that is thriving under a clear reality: Those who make the team are going to be expected to play a role — and potentially a massive one — as rookies. Eventually that will roll into a 2026 draft class that already has 10 picks to continue lining the roster with talent. [Get more Raiders news: Vegas team feed] That 2025 class includes first-round running back Ashton Jeanty, who will be playing as monumental a role on the offense as he can behind a line that is still on a developmental and chemistry trek. Interestingly, Jeanty has cut a similar seriousness to acclimating to life as a pro as one of Spytek's favorites with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers — wideout Chris Godwin. Like Godwin's entry into the NFL in 2017, Jeanty put in serious time locking down all of his off-field priorities before hitting training camp. That included buying a house, getting settled into his community and building a routine so that he's not getting pulled into a multitude of directions when the season starts. Inside the Raiders' front office, that's known as walking into the league ready to be a professional player. And when it's a trait of one of your potentially special players, it can create a meaningful image for the team to promote to other incoming players. That's exactly what the Buccaneers did with Godwin's example, and it's expected to carry over with Spytek and his rookie running back. The Raiders would like to thread the Wilkins release through that needle, too. Rather than reminding the fan base and critics of the litany of free-agent signing mistakes and trade addition blunders that played a part in scuttling past regimes, the coaching staff and front office wants the decisions made and work from this camp to punctuate the foundation that's getting constructed. If you want to play football and want to be about the team, you're in. Anything less is just a waiver wire statistic that hasn't happened yet.

Chicago Bears open training camp gives fans glimpse of new systems
Chicago Bears open training camp gives fans glimpse of new systems

CBS News

time33 minutes ago

  • CBS News

Chicago Bears open training camp gives fans glimpse of new systems

The Chicago Bears held their first open training camp practice, giving fans a glimpse of the new systems being installed. While it's common for defenses to have an edge early on, Dennis Allen's unit has caught the attention of the offensive playmakers. "Not one thing looks the same on that defense," Allen said. Offensive lineman Braxton Jones had a scheduled day off Friday as he continues to recover from ankle surgery. Ozzy Trapito moved into the start spot moved into the starting spot as he competes for the starting left tackle job. Veteran Joe Thuney likes what he's seen from the rookie so far. "He's been doing a great job getting into playbook learning language," he said. "Little details, plays, combination on runs, sees blitzes, does great job, listens a lot. He's been great." The third day of camp included a few more bumps for Caleb Williams, including back-to-back interceptions, but offensive coordinator Declan Doyle said the quarterback's pre-snap process and ability to get in and out of the huddle has improved. It's going to be a process.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store