
Eddie Howe isn't celebrating Paul Mitchell's exit. Uncertainty is a team-killer
In June 2022, when Dan Ashworth began work as Newcastle's sporting director after four months of gardening leave at Brighton & Hove Albion, he spoke about 'helping the club to grow and achieve long-term success'. Twenty months later, he was again tending his beautiful roses and waiting to join Manchester United.
Advertisement
For Newcastle and sporting directors, long-term is very much the wrong term.
Mitchell's role was '90 per cent recruitment', according to Darren Eales, the chief executive, which by the very blunt metric of actually buying first-team players, makes his tenure 100 per cent unsuccessful, so far at least — Mitchell has another month to shift that dial and the club are pushing to get transfers done.
Ashworth, said Mehrdad Ghodoussi — who, along with Amanda Staveley, his wife, initially ran Newcastle post-takeover and were minority owners — would be a 'key hire, the person that drives the football operation, who creates the structure. It's like building a house: if you don't have the right foundations, it will fall down.' To continue that analogy, Ashworth left with the roof not yet fitted and the cement still wet.
There is another theme here, too. Over the space of 16 months, Mitchell, Ashworth, Ghodoussi and Staveley will all have departed and so, too, will Eales, who arrived on Tyneside two months after Ashworth and who announced last September that he had been diagnosed with a chronic form of blood cancer. They are all pivotal figures, responsible for running the club, buying players, setting budgets or setting the tone and much else besides.
On the pitch, Eddie Howe's team was a model of excellence and stability for the second-half of the season just ended, winning the club's first domestic trophy for 70 years and qualifying for the Champions League. Above him in the boardroom, it has been constant churn.
Does this churn matter? Given the Carabao Cup win, a pair of Wembley finals over two years, playing in Europe's leading club competition for two seasons out of three, and successive league finishes of fourth, seventh and fifth, arguably not at all. Who cares what the suits are doing when Howe has discovered alchemy?
Advertisement
Yet this — categorically — would not be a theory Howe himself subscribes to and those who have portrayed Mitchell's rapid exit as some kind of victory have called it wrong. There was no celebrating. What Howe wants is new players as quickly as possible and his immediate concern was about the knock-on effects of losing the man whose role was supposed to be '90 per cent recruitment'.
Howe said as much on Sunday after Newcastle's place in the Champions League next season was cemented. 'Speed is key for us and I've reiterated that many times internally because we have to be dynamic,' he said. 'We have to be ready to complete things very, very quickly because good players don't hang around for long.'
Newcastle have not signed a first-team-ready player for three consecutive transfer windows. Last summer, they sold Elliot Anderson, who had been earmarked for a significant role, to Nottingham Forest to help balance the books. They also sold Yankuba Minteh, who his since made 32 Premier League appearances for Brighton as a right-winger, a position Howe has wanted to reinforce for years.
In January, they trimmed more fat they didn't really have, selling Miguel Almiron back to Atlanta United and allowing Lloyd Kelly to join Juventus, initially on loan but with an obligation to buy. In financial terms, those deals were necessary and represented decent business, but in football terms, which is what Howe cares about, it left his squad desperately shallow.
After all that, they now have headroom under the Premier League's profit and sustainability rules (PSR). They have scope for manoeuvre — and a good thing too, because the squad needs a significant refresh. Howe wants a goalkeeper, a right-winger, a centre-half and potentially a forward. Targets have been deliberated over and fixed upon.
Advertisement
What he doesn't need is confusion or delay. In his leaving statement, Mitchell said 'the club is in a fantastic position to continue building', but the architect left with Ashworth's defection and now the contractors and engineers are going too. When it comes to the bigger-picture stuff, Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund (PIF), Newcastle's majority owners, are notoriously slow to move, and an interim structure needs to be capable of swift decisions. The club say it will be, but judgement can only be deferred.
Mitchell's departure, in tandem with Eales — and at least partially caused by it, given their long-standing relationship — means a second consecutive summer of upheaval for Newcastle and Howe who, at this stage, has no inkling of who he will be reporting to next season and who his immediate boss will be. This feels sub-optimal.
Football and football people crave certainty. Players want to know precisely what their roles are and to look around their dressing-room knowing team-mates feel the same. Managers want to know what to expect from their players and feel confident that tactical instructions will be carried out. From above, they want authority and backing. Uncertainty is a team-killer.
When Staveley and Ghodoussi left Newcastle last July, Howe lost two huge allies and advocates. The three of them had worked closely together in the early days post-takeover, forging a tight, intimate relationship and he was kept informed of everything, good or bad. They left a vacuum. Newcastle felt like less of a family and more corporate. When Mitchell arrived, Howe was given scant notice.
If that was bruising, then Mitchell's forthright, brusque personality and desire to make his own mark at Newcastle did not help the healing process. 'It was the wrong attitude to come in with,' an associate of Howe said, speaking on condition of anonymity. 'If the club was really at a low point then you could understand that idea of changing everything. It didn't need that. It just needed a bit of support.'
After the PSR shambles, when Newcastle held negotiations with Liverpool over selling Anthony Gordon, Chelsea enquired about Alexander Isak, and after Mitchell led a long, fruitless pursuit of Crystal Palace's Marc Guehi, Newcastle's dressing-room was rife with uncertainty. Every player knew they had a price. With no quality additions, they were less convinced about Newcastle's ambitions. Howe felt less certain in his relationships. He was less clear about what the club's vision was, so how could he persuade his players?
In a sport of marginal gains, Newcastle began the season a few percentage points off. They were inconsistent, either nabbing results while not playing well or playing better but proving incapable of seeing games out. With no reinforcements and little support network, it was left to Howe and his backroom team to shake players out of it. It meant months of introspection and effort.
Advertisement
'No one fully understands apart from Eddie and his staff just how difficult this season has been,' the associate said. 'Things could have gone very differently.' This was the byproduct of uncertainty.
In the meantime, Howe and Mitchell muddled along. They were not stags butting heads. The early tension had first been around personality and then transfers and with Newcastle unable or unwilling to buy anybody, transfers were largely irrelevant. They were never going to be close mates, but Howe put his head down and got on with it.
Perhaps that tension would have flared up again this summer. Perhaps Mitchell's expertise and experience would have come to the fore and everyone would have been delighted. Perhaps his legacy will turn out to be the 'fantastic position', he spoke about and Newcastle will get their deals done, which is the minimum Howe deserves after a truly transformational season.
Howe has delivered an elite performance. Newcastle's team operated at an elite level for six months, showing what they are capable of. Their marketing and commercial departments are getting there after long years of shrivelled ambition, but in terms of infrastructure and facilities they are not yet an elite club.
'That's what we want to be,' Howe said when The Athletic put these points to him last weekend. 'That's what we're desperate to continue to be. But if I answer that with a definitive yes, I'm not sure it would be wise. I'll let you judge. But we crave that, we want that. Now my summer will be focused purely on trying to make us stronger and better for every challenge we're going to face.'
But now he will also have to focus on forging new partnerships, with Eales' replacement and Mitchell's, whatever their job descriptions are and whatever the new structure is. Once again, there will be different people who are tasked with running Newcastle or who are instrumental in shaping what Newcastle should be, either as a squad or as a club.
To a certain extent, Howe knew what he would be getting with Mitchell: a headache. Now he doesn't know again. In part, this is to do with circumstances. In an ideal world, a CEO would appoint the sporting director who would seek out the best fit as manager, but at Newcastle they did it the other way around. Equally, nobody could have predicted Eales' illness and, after this extraordinary and rewarding season, he must now belatedly take care of himself and his family.
Advertisement
To return to the start, there will be no winner from Mitchell's departure if, come August, Howe looks around his dressing room and again sees uncertainty flicker in his players' eyes. And to borrow again from Ghodoussi's analogy, if building a club is really like building a house, do Newcastle yet have the 'right foundations'? Or are they once more being knocked down in order to start over?
One thing is certain: their master craftsman cannot be expected to keep picking up the pieces.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Amazon faces UK lawsuits worth up to $5.4 billion from retailers, consumers
LONDON (Reuters) -Amazon faces two mass lawsuits from retailers and consumers worth up to 4 billion pounds ($5.4 billion) for allegedly abusing its dominant position, after a London tribunal on Thursday certified the cases could proceed. Andreas Stephan, a competition law academic, is bringing one of the cases on behalf of over 200,000 third-party retailers, worth up to 2.7 billion pounds. His lawyers allege that Amazon manipulates the "Buy Box" feature on its website to its own advantage and favours products that use Amazon's own logistics centres and delivery network. Consumer advocate Robert Hammond is separately bringing a case valued at up to 1.3 billion pounds on behalf of millions of Amazon customers for similar alleged abuses of dominance. Amazon argued that the Competition Appeal Tribunal should certify the cases to proceed, an early step in the proceedings, including because the economic methodology for proving the cases was flawed. But the tribunal certified both cases on an opt-out basis, meaning members of the claimant class will be part of the case unless they decide otherwise. An Amazon spokesperson said: "These claims are without merit and we're confident that will become clear through the legal process. "Amazon has always focused on supporting the 100,000 businesses that sell their products on our UK store, and more than half of all physical product sales on our UK store are from independent selling partners." Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
UK vehicle production declines in H1 2025
New vehicle manufacturing in the UK saw a decrease of 11.9% in the first half of 2025, with total production reaching 417,232 units, according to the latest figures published by the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT). A slight recovery was noted in June, where car production increased by 6.6%, although this was compared to a period last year that faced challenges such as model changeovers and supply chain disruptions. Switch Auto Insurance and Save Today! The Insurance Savings You Expect Affordable Auto Insurance, Customized for You Great Rates and Award-Winning Service Overall, car output for the year to date has fallen by 7.3%, with 385,810 cars produced. The commercial vehicle sector experienced a more severe decline, with production dropping by 45.4% to 31,422 units due to restructuring efforts at manufacturing plants. In contrast, the production of electrified vehicles saw a modest rise of 1.8%, resulting in 160,107 units produced, which accounted for 41.5% of total output in the first half of the year. The UK automotive industry remains focused on exports, with 76.9% of production intended for international markets, the report said. The European Union is the largest destination for UK car exports, making up 54.4% of the total, followed by the US at 15.9%, China at 7.5%, Turkey at 4.1%, and Japan at 2.7%. These five markets together represent over 80% of the UK's overseas sales. Despite a decline in export volumes over the past three months, culminating in an 18.7% drop in June, the US continues to be the largest single export market for UK vehicles, highlighting the significance of the recent UK-US trade agreement, which provides reduced tariffs for UK automotive exports. Looking forward, the global economic environment remains uncertain, with projections indicating a 15% decrease in total vehicle output to 755,000 units for 2025. However, a potential recovery is anticipated in 2026, with a forecasted increase of 6.4% bringing production to 803,000 units. The report suggests that the swift implementation of the new industrial strategy could enhance the UK's competitiveness in the automotive sector, potentially restoring its position among the top 15 global auto manufacturing locations and contributing an estimated £50bn to the economy. Additionally, the government's automotive sector strategy, DRIVE35, outlines initiatives aimed at supporting the industry's economic and environmental objectives. The introduction of the Electric Car Grant, which allocates £650m for electric vehicle incentives, may also stimulate the domestic market and improve the UK's attractiveness for industrial investment. SMMT chief executive Mike Hawes said: 'Global economic uncertainty and trade protectionism have taken their toll on automotive production across the globe, with the UK no exception. The figures are not, therefore, unexpected but remain very disappointing. 'However, there are foundations for a return to growth. The industry is moving to the technologies that will be the future of mobility. Our engineering excellence, highly-skilled workforce and global reputation are strengths, and we have an Industrial Strategy with advanced manufacturing and automotive at its core. "With rapid delivery and the right conditions, UK Automotive can reverse the current decline and deliver the jobs, economic growth and decarbonisation that Britain needs.' "UK vehicle production declines in H1 2025" was originally created and published by Motor Finance Online, a GlobalData owned brand. The information on this site has been included in good faith for general informational purposes only. It is not intended to amount to advice on which you should rely, and we give no representation, warranty or guarantee, whether express or implied as to its accuracy or completeness. You must obtain professional or specialist advice before taking, or refraining from, any action on the basis of the content on our site. Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
28 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Ben Stokes claims first five–for since 2017 as England bowl India out for 358
England captain Ben Stokes claimed his first five-wicket haul since September 2017 after Rishabh Pant courageously defied injury to help India to 358 all out at Emirates Old Trafford. Stokes' five for 72 saw him move level on 229 career wickets with Darren Gough on day two of the fourth Rothesay Test but he shared top billing with Pant, who was seen arriving at the ground in a moon boot. Advertisement While he will not keep wicket – substitute Dhruv Jurel was behind the stumps as England raced to 77 without loss at tea – Pant resumed his innings less than 24 hours after retiring hurt on 37 in agony. Reports in India suggest Pant suffered a fractured metatarsal when inside edging a Chris Woakes yorker on to his right foot, although the tourists have not publicly announced the severity of the problem. He was given a standing ovation when he emerged from the pavilion just before lunch, hobbling down the steps, and he steadily grew in confidence, launching Jofra Archer for six en route to a battling 54. Advertisement Archer, though, who collected three for 73, had the last laugh as for a second innings in succession, he sent Pant's off-stump flying, although the dangerous left-hander's extra runs could yet prove vital. Archer made the breakthrough with the second new ball in his first over as India resumed on 264 for four, squaring up Ravindra Jadeja, who was on his way for 20 after nicking to second slip. England were frustrated despite helpful bowling conditions as overnight batter Shardul Thakur and Washington Sundar put on 48 to take India past 300 before Stokes claimed his third wicket. Thakur fell nine runs short of his fifty after being persuaded into a drive, with a thick edge flying to gully, where Duckett leapt to his left to take a terrific catch before Pant re-emerged. He played and missed at his first couple of balls off Stokes and was then struck on the glove from his third, a worrying sight for India as he injured his left index finger at Lord's last week. Advertisement Unable to call upon a runner because they have been outlawed in Tests, Pant limped through for a couple of singles. Upon the resumption, Pant steadily walked back to the crease where a waiting Stokes – with a wide grin – pointed at his left hand, a good-natured nod to last week's timewasting row. Sundar survived an lbw review off Archer but was bounced out by Stokes, who nicked off Kamboj three balls later for his fifth five-for and first since his career-best six for 22 against the West Indies nearly eight years ago. England, though, did not seem to know how to handle Pant, with Stokes fractionally off target with a couple of yorkers, while Pant blazed an extraordinary leg-side six off an Archer slower ball. He was castled neck and crop in an almost identical rerun of his second-innings dismissal at Lord's last week, with Archer finding a hint of movement away from round the wicket to uproot off-stump. India lost their final four wickets for 21 when England and Archer successfully reviewed a glove down the leg-side off Jasprit Bumrah, who presented an altogether more different threat with the ball. Advertisement Zak Crawley took 14 balls to get off the mark and survived an lbw review off Mohammed Siraj after offering no shot on height on 26 but he provided able support for Duckett, who got off to a flyer. After gloving his first ball off Kamboj down leg just out of reach of the diving Jurel, Duckett feasted on a number of deliveries on his pads to go to tea on an unbeaten 43. Crawley was 33 not out.