Quashing Pocso FIR, Delhi High Court directs accused to do community service at hospital
Justice Sanjeev Narula quashed the FIR after an 'amicable resolution' of the case involving alleged harassment and exploitation of a minor girl. The court ordered the accused to perform community service at Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan Hospital from June 1 to 30, where he will be instructed and assigned duties by the medical superintendent.
'In the event of any absenteeism, default, or misconduct on the part of the Petitioner during the course of the community service, the same shall be immediately reported by the Medical Superintendent to the concerned SHO, who shall, in turn, inform the APP for placing the matter before this Court and seeking appropriate orders, including revival of the FIR,' the court further directed.
The court recorded that it is quashing the FIR 'solely out of deference to the express wishes of the Complainant and in the interest of her privacy'.
This was after the complainant informed the court that she is currently exploring matrimonial prospects and wants to move on from the incident, further stating that a pending criminal case may pose a serious impediment to her future opportunities and personal relationships, as well as causing social stigma.
As per the case, in 2017, the complainant shared private photographs with the accused. After they stopped communicating, the accused allegedly began demanding money from the complainant in February 2018, threatening to make the photographs public if their demands were not met. These demands continued until August 2019, when the complainant filed an FIR and a chargesheet was later filed in the case.
The two subsequently 'amicably resolved their disputes' and signed a settlement deed in May this year, with the complainant agreeing to the quashing of the FIR.
Justice Narula reasoned, 'The facts narrated disclose a pattern emblematic of the darker undercurrents of the social media age, where technology is misused to exert control, induce fear, and compromise dignity. Considering this, at the outset, the Court was not inclined to quash the FIR in a perfunctory manner… In the present case, bearing in mind the overarching aim of facilitating rehabilitation and the Complainant's express wish to put the matter behind her, the Court is of the view that no larger public interest would be compromised by allowing the petition.'
Recording its disapproval of the conduct of the accused, the court noted that the allegations pertain to a deeply troubling pattern of coercion and intimidation directed at a school-going minor, including threats to publicly disseminate her private photographs in exchange for money.
'Such behaviour, if true, reflects a gross misuse of digital platforms and an alarming disregard for consent and personal dignity. Nevertheless, the Complainant has unequivocally expressed her desire to move on from this chapter, and has articulated social and emotional burden that the continued pendency of this criminal case may place upon her, particularly in the context of her future prospects, including marriage,' the court recorded.
The court, however, left it open for the complainant to revive the FIR.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
Avail municipal services through Puramitra app
Tirupati: MunicipalCorporation Commissioner Narapureddy Mourya said the Puramitra App introduced by the Municipal Administration department will help the residents avail all the municipal services from their homes. People can pay taxes, file complaints and also avail all other services through the App and wanted all the residents to make use of the App. The Commissioner along with senior officials inspected the door-to-door survey which was taken up by the government Statewide to collect details of the people living in the urban areas including their socio-economic condition employment, education etc. Directing the field staff to strive for early completion of door-to-door service, she urged the residents to extend their cooperation to the survey aimed at preparing a comprehensive report on the people living in the urban areas. Trainee Collector Raghuvamsi and Deputy Commissioner Amaraiah were also present.
Hans India
2 hours ago
- Hans India
HCA paid `1 crore for cricket balls that were never received!
Hyderabad: Hyderabad Cricket Association president A Jagan Mohan Rao and four others who were arrested by the Telangana Crime Investigation Department in connection with an misappropriation case, allegedly paid over Rs 1 crore for procuring 8,340 cricket balls, none of which were received, according to the remand report submitted by the CID. According to the CID, it is a case of alleged forgery of documents for the purpose of cheating and misappropriation of funds with criminal breach of trust by the HCA office bearers. Based on the complaint of Dharam Guruva Reddy, General Secretary of Telangana Cricket Association, a criminal case was registered under sections 465, 468, 471, 403 409, 420 R/w, 34 of IPC on Wednesday. The report stated, 'The accused persons have not followed the Tender Procedures and violated all General Principles laid in Telangana Public Procurement (Transparency) Act-2017 and the By-Laws of HCA and paid amount of Rs 1,03,74,118 to Indiana Sports towards purchase of 8,340 cricket balls. The investigation established that no single ball was received and distributed to the concerned as per records and it clearly shows that the total amount was misappropriated.' The investigation revealed that the accused Jagan Mohan Rao and others of paying Rs 56.84 lakh for procurement of clothing and dress material violating general principles laid in Telangana Public Procurement (Transparency) Act 2017 and the By-Laws of HCA. The investigation is established that no material has been received and distributed among the concerned as per records. During the investigation, it was revealed that Jagan Mohan Rao, in collusion with Rajendra Yadav and his wife G Kavitha, allegedly created forged documents of Sri Chakra cricket club, which was called Gowlipura Cricket Club by forging the signatures of C Krishna Yadav, president of GCC. These forged documents were allegedly used as genuine, enabling Jaganmohan Rao to dishonestly gain entry into HCA as president.
Indian Express
3 hours ago
- Indian Express
Express View: On Bihar SIR, listen to the Court
The Supreme Court has not stayed or stopped the Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Bihar, an exercise that has stoked confusion on the ground and raised spectres of disenfranchisement. But that's not the most important message after the EC's day in court Thursday. It is, instead, this: The Court has flagged important issues that the Commission would do well to heed and act upon, before it files its counter-affidavit in a fortnight — the SC is scheduled to hear the matter again on July 28. Even as the Court has framed its concerns with a respectful tentativeness, given that it is addressing a constitutional authority, the EC must know that they resonate widely. It needs to ask itself whether the electoral roll revision exercise — unprecedented not in itself, but for asking for documentation at the stage of enumeration, for shifting the burden of proof onto voters, and for disregarding the sanctity of existing electoral rolls — can be carried out according to due process with only months to go before the Bihar election. It needs to consider seriously the Court's suggestion that, 'in the interest of justice', it should include more accessible and ubiquitous options like the Aadhaar card, ration card and voter ID card in its list of required documents. The Court has asked the EC to give reasons for not including these. The EC must know that the onus is now on it to prove that it is acting in good faith. It is ironic that the EC, for long seen to be one of India's most trusted institutions, should find itself in the dock. The reforms initiated and supervised by the EC in a sprawling country of staggering diversities have ensured that the Indian election sets the gold standard for the conduct of free and fair polls, and for ensuring that no voter is left out, every vote is counted in. Now, that institution must show that it also listens, that it knows when not to stand on prestige. For, at stake is its own record and legacy, and more importantly, the integrity and credibility of the process that it has refined and fine-tuned so painstakingly. Apart from suggesting the inclusion of three documents in the EC list, and pointing out that the tight timeline creates practical difficulties, including in the matter of providing a reasonable opportunity for a hearing in cases of deletion, the Court has also drawn attention to the question of remit. It is the Ministry of Home Affairs, not the EC, the SC has rightly said, whose task it is to ascertain or verify citizenship. But most of all, the EC must listen to the Court because it is giving the Commission another opportunity to listen to the voice of India's voters. Ground reports in this paper have captured some of those voices, especially in vulnerable sections that are more likely to fall through the cracks of a complicated bureaucratic exercise. The EC must listen to the undocumented people, the poor and the migrants, the SCs and STs and extremely backward castes, and to the women who move from their parents' homes to their marital homes. It must update and clean the electoral rolls, of course, and make them more accurate. But it must do so without making the process arduous for the people, and without stoking their anxieties.
