
Italians and 'lo spread', an obsession whose time has passed
Ever since then "lo spread", or the gap between the yield on Italian benchmark bonds and their German equivalents, has been brandished by politicians and the media alike as a symbol of national pride or shame, much like a sporting victory or defeat.
After the BTP-Bund gap took a rare dip below one percentage point, or 100 basis points (bps), Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni told parliament last week "this means Italy's government bonds are considered safer than German ones."
Her economy minister, aware the narrower spread in fact meant merely that Italian bonds were considered comparatively less unsafe than before, smiled and shook his head beside her.
Fourteen years ago the attention on the spread was justified. Germany's economy was the European powerhouse and the surge in Italian yields meant Rome had to pay huge sums to service its debt and risked losing market access altogether.
Times have changed, however, and many economists say that with German benchmark bond yields rising due to a planned spending splurge on defence and infrastructure, Italians' fixation with the BTP-Bund spread now makes far less sense.
"What matters for us is the level of interest rates, not the spread with Germany," said economist Tito Boeri, a former head of Italy's state pensions agency. "If German yields rise that doesn't help Italy's public accounts."
Rome spends some 90 billion euros ($101 billion) per year, or 4% of gross domestic product to service its 3 trillion euro public debt. With the yield on 10-year BTPs still above 3.5%, that implies a heavy burden on state coffers regardless of the narrow spread with Germany.
At around 135% of GDP, Italy's debt is proportionally the second-largest in the euro zone after Greece's, and it is forecast by the government to rise through 2026.
Analysts say Meloni's unambitious but relatively prudent economic policies have reassured markets, but the recent narrowing of the spread is mainly down to developments in Germany and the United States.
Economist Lorenzo Bini Smaghi, a former European Central Bank board member, said investors' waning appetite for U.S. Treasuries had benefited European bonds and particularly high-yielding paper such as Italy's.
"If I consider Europe as a safer bet, partly because I expect the dollar to fall, I'm going to invest in European bonds, especially those that offer higher returns," he said.
Italian bond yields are still the highest of any euro zone country, reflecting the risk-premium demanded by investors, and Boeri warned that market volatility linked to U.S. economic policy meant Rome had no reason for complacency.
Italy's 10-year yield of around 3.6% compares with 3.2% on equivalent Spanish bonds and 3.4% on Greek ones.
"We need to be very, very careful because what is happening on international government bond markets shows us the slightest mistake (in economic policy) can be costly," he said.
Italy could come unstuck even without a mistake. Spread fluctuations very often reflect "risk-on" or "risk-off" market sentiment driven by international events, not Italian ones.
The BTP-Bund gap widened briefly but sharply, for example, after U.S. President Donald Trump announced swingeing trade tariffs on April 2, only to suspend many of them a week later.
"The spread widens when we see a flight to safety because Italy is not considered 'safety'," said Roberto Perotti, economics professor at Milan's Bocconi university.
A glance at the past shows the BTP-Bund spread has dipped below 100 bps under several Italian governments, sometimes surging shortly afterwards due to factors outside their control.
For much of 2009 the spread hovered between 80 and 100 bps under Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, before widening out to a peak of more than 570 bps in 2011 during the euro zone debt crisis, despite Rome following a broadly stable fiscal policy.
In 2021, under former ECB President Mario Draghi, it again narrowed to less than 100 bps only to widen to 250 the following year amid surging global inflation after the COVID-19 pandemic.
Perotti said it was understandable that Meloni should point to the narrow spread as a political success. But with Germany no longer seen as a pillar of fiscal restraint and stability, its value as an indicator had diminished.
"At the moment it doesn't have much meaning," he said.
($1 = 0.8890 euros)
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scottish Sun
5 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Football's changed beyond belief since my first game 26 years ago – cling onto fact there's still people kicking a ball
Through the money and the years, football has mutated into a monster game changers Football's changed beyond belief since my first game 26 years ago – cling onto fact there's still people kicking a ball Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) AS CRYSTAL PALACE prepare a complex legal case against demotion from the Europa League, it makes you think. If not, it should do. That within two months of the only genuinely heart-warming moment from a forgettable Premier League season, the one feel-good factor from 12 months of humdrum routine has been blown to smithereens. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 9 Crystal Palace beat Man Utd at Wembley to secure a spot in next year's Europa League Credit: PA 9 However, multi-club ownership rules saw them demoted to the Conference League Credit: Getty 9 Eagles chairman Steve Parish will battle the decision at the Court of Arbitration for Sport Credit: Shutterstock Editorial Palace won their first trophy in 120 years back in May by upsetting moneyed Manchester City in the FA Cup final — and anyone with an ounce of romance rejoiced. Yet in less time than it takes for VAR to check for your average offside, the joy has been cut short. Because the growing trend for multi-ownership and the pursuit of power among the world's richest has put football second — again. With Eagles shareholder John Textor also having financial interests in Europa-League bound Lyon, rules have been broken, say Uefa. Two clubs under the influence of the same bloke can't compete in the same competition. And fair enough. So, Palace's defiant chairman, Steve Parish, now must lead the desperate fightback via the Court of Arbitration for Sport. What was once a little-known legal body based in a mansion in Switzerland is now becoming as big a name as Kylian Mbappe or Erling Haaland. And that Nottingham Forest could not wait to grass up Palace in the hope of nicking their Europa League spot is football 2025 in a nutshell. CASINO SPECIAL - BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS 9 John Textor has since sold his stake in Palace to fellow American Woody Johnson Credit: AFP Lawyers and business tycoons have replaced centre-forwards and centrefolds as the main players at the heart of our national sport. Let's rewind to July 1999 and compare notes. The only reason I suggest this date is because that's when I started on staff at SunSport. Crystal Palace legend Geoff Thomas slams Uefa for denying them a Europa League place After bluffing my way through it for 26 years, this will be my last column before leaving so it's as good a point in time as any. Back then, on the cusp of the new millennium, Alan Shearer was widely reported as the Premier League's top earner on £34K a week at Newcastle. Roughly 100 times the average wage of the day. Shearer's £1.76million a year is dwarfed by the estimated £18.2m annually Mo Salah will trouser under his new Liverpool contract. Average wages in the UK for last year were roughly £37,000 per year. You don't have to be Carol Vorderman to work out that the gap has widened considerably. In the summer of '99, Manchester United were celebrating victory in the Champions League, Premier League and FA Cup. The only treble the fans can enjoy these days is a stiff one in the boozer after the latest abject collapse on the pitch at a fallen giant. But at least that's football related. 9 Man Utd completed the Treble in 1999 with a dramatic win over Bayern Credit: Getty 9 Jonny Evans' departure at the end of the season means there are no more players at the club who played under Sir Alex Ferguson Credit: Getty So much of what masquerades as our favourite sport has nothing to do with shirts, shorts and shin pads. And back when Tony Blair was still regarded as a half-decent PM, there was no VAR to kill the spontaneous release that is a goal being scored. In 1999, the beleaguered boss of the referees' union did not have to appear regularly on TV to desperately fight the corner of members. In 1999, not every defeat was considered a national disaster by over-hyped figures in the game. In 1999, clubs were not selling their own hotels back to themselves to get round spending rules. Spending rules brought in to stop nation states hoovering up our best teams at the expense of fair competition. In 1999, there were 17 managers of British and Irish descent working in the Prem. Today it's five. In 1999, the biggest transfer of the summer was Nicolas Anelka's exit from Arsenal to Real Madrid. The £22.5m was considered big money. Most pertinent of all, in 1999 Premier League grounds were alive. They were not stop-offs for foreign tourists sitting in silent bewilderment while clutching bags of overpriced tat from club shops. The game hasn't gone these past 26 years but it's going. 9 Somewhere in the middle of all the legal battles, foreign takeovers, stakeholders, rights holders, influencers, extortionate ticket prices, popcorn, VAR, play-acting and social media tripe, there are still people kicking footballs. Cling on to that. CAPTAINCY IS IN LEVI'S GENES FAREWELL NOTE TO CHELSEA: Levi Colwill must be your next captain. During the Club World Cup, the defender grew in stature so much off the pitch and is emerging as a superb ambassador for a club that can struggle for positive PR. From discussing his secret LEGO passion, to bold declarations that Chelsea can win the title this season, this young man has the kind of character they have been aching for at Stamford Bridge since the departures of John Terry and Antonio Rudiger. When Reece James calls it a day wearing the armband, Colwill must take over. 9 Levi Colwill was integral to Chelsea's Club World Cup triumph in the US Credit: Getty JUAN-NIL LOSS BARCELONA is 920 miles from London. Marcus Rashford seems to think it is a world away. By refusing to answer any questions in English at his unveiling by the Spanish giants he has already scored a little own goal. You can pretend it's to ingratiate himself with the Catalan locals but nobody over here is really fooled. Rashford might think he has been harshly treated by the English media but I have never met a reporter who doesn't wish him all the very best and wants him to do well for his club and for England, more importantly. And more importantly than anything to do with football, his campaign for free school meals is a standout moment as a human being. 9 Marcus Rashford joined Barcelona on a season-long loan after falling out with Man Utd manager Ruben Amorim Credit: Getty It's worth remembering that his move to Barcelona from Manchester United is only a season-long loan and that this time next year he may be back. There'll be questions then — and no hiding place behind the lingo.


The Sun
5 hours ago
- The Sun
Football's changed beyond belief since my first game 26 years ago – cling onto fact there's still people kicking a ball
AS CRYSTAL PALACE prepare a complex legal case against demotion from the Europa League, it makes you think. If not, it should do. That within two months of the only genuinely heart-warming moment from a forgettable Premier League season, the one feel-good factor from 12 months of humdrum routine has been blown to smithereens. 8 8 8 Palace won their first trophy in 120 years back in May by upsetting moneyed Manchester City in the FA Cup final — and anyone with an ounce of romance rejoiced. Yet in less time than it takes for VAR to check for your average offside, the joy has been cut short. Because the growing trend for multi-ownership and the pursuit of power among the world's richest has put football second — again. With Eagles shareholder John Textor also having financial interests in Europa-League bound Lyon, rules have been broken, say Uefa. Two clubs under the influence of the same bloke can't compete in the same competition. And fair enough. So, Palace's defiant chairman, Steve Parish, now must lead the desperate fightback via the Court of Arbitration for Sport. What was once a little-known legal body based in a mansion in Switzerland is now becoming as big a name as Kylian Mbappe or Erling Haaland. And that Nottingham Forest could not wait to grass up Palace in the hope of nicking their Europa League spot is football 2025 in a nutshell. CASINO SPECIAL - BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS 8 Lawyers and business tycoons have replaced centre-forwards and centrefolds as the main players at the heart of our national sport. Let's rewind to July 1999 and compare notes. The only reason I suggest this date is because that's when I started on staff at SunSport. Crystal Palace legend Geoff Thomas slams Uefa for denying them a Europa League place After bluffing my way through it for 26 years, this will be my last column before leaving so it's as good a point in time as any. Back then, on the cusp of the new millennium, Alan Shearer was widely reported as the Premier League's top earner on £34K a week at Newcastle. Roughly 100 times the average wage of the day. Shearer's £1.76million a year is dwarfed by the estimated £18.2m annually Mo Salah will trouser under his new Liverpool contract. Average wages in the UK for last year were roughly £37,000 per year. You don't have to be Carol Vorderman to work out that the gap has widened considerably. In the summer of '99, Manchester United were celebrating victory in the Champions League, Premier League and FA Cup. The only treble the fans can enjoy these days is a stiff one in the boozer after the latest abject collapse on the pitch at a fallen giant. But at least that's football related. 8 8 So much of what masquerades as our favourite sport has nothing to do with shirts, shorts and shin pads. And back when Tony Blair was still regarded as a half-decent PM, there was no VAR to kill the spontaneous release that is a goal being scored. In 1999, the beleaguered boss of the referees' union did not have to appear regularly on TV to desperately fight the corner of members. In 1999, not every defeat was considered a national disaster by over-hyped figures in the game. In 1999, clubs were not selling their own hotels back to themselves to get round spending rules. Spending rules brought in to stop nation states hoovering up our best teams at the expense of fair competition. In 1999, there were 17 managers of British and Irish descent working in the Prem. Today it's five. In 1999, the biggest transfer of the summer was Nicolas Anelka's exit from Arsenal to Real Madrid. The £22.5m was considered big money. Most pertinent of all, in 1999 Premier League grounds were alive. They were not stop-offs for foreign tourists sitting in silent bewilderment while clutching bags of overpriced tat from club shops. The game hasn't gone these past 26 years but it's going. Somewhere in the middle of all the legal battles, foreign takeovers, stakeholders, rights holders, influencers, extortionate ticket prices, popcorn, VAR, play-acting and social media tripe, there are still people kicking footballs. Cling on to that. CAPTAINCY IS IN LEVI'S GENES FAREWELL NOTE TO CHELSEA: Levi Colwill must be your next captain. During the Club World Cup, the defender grew in stature so much off the pitch and is emerging as a superb ambassador for a club that can struggle for positive PR. From discussing his secret LEGO passion, to bold declarations that Chelsea can win the title this season, this young man has the kind of character they have been aching for at Stamford Bridge since the departures of John Terry and Antonio Rudiger. When Reece James calls it a day wearing the armband, Colwill must take over. JUAN-NIL LOSS BARCELONA is 920 miles from London. Marcus Rashford seems to think it is a world away. By refusing to answer any questions in English at his unveiling by the Spanish giants he has already scored a little own goal. You can pretend it's to ingratiate himself with the Catalan locals but nobody over here is really fooled. Rashford might think he has been harshly treated by the English media but I have never met a reporter who doesn't wish him all the very best and wants him to do well for his club and for England, more importantly. And more importantly than anything to do with football, his campaign for free school meals is a standout moment as a human being. 8 It's worth remembering that his move to Barcelona from Manchester United is only a season-long loan and that this time next year he may be back. There'll be questions then — and no hiding place behind the lingo.


Reuters
2 days ago
- Reuters
Italy and Algeria agree to tackle terrorism and migration at summit
ROME, July 23 (Reuters) - Italy and Algeria agreed to work together to fight terrorism and control migration during an intergovernmental meeting in Rome on Wednesday, documents showed, while companies signed off on deals on sectors including energy and telecommunications. Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni met Algerian President Abdelmadjid Tebboune at the 17th-century Villa Doria Pamphili, after a trip to Algiers by Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani in March. Algeria is Rome's leading trading partner in Africa, with trade worth almost 14 billion euros ($16.4 billion) while Rome's investments there amount to 8.5 billion, Italy said. According to a document seen by Reuters, a memorandum will be signed between Italy and Algeria on fighting terrorism and its financing. The document did not say which threats the countries were focused on. The two nations will also agree on a plan to coordinate the search and rescue operations for migrants who attempt the dangerous sea crossing from North Africa to Europe. Meloni's right-wing government was elected in 2022 on a mandate to curb migrant arrivals. On the business side, Italian energy group Eni ( opens new tab this month signed a production sharing contract with oil and gas company Sonatrach worth $1.3 billion to explore and develop hydrocarbons in Algeria. A document said the two companies will sign an additional agreement on the sidelines of the summit to strengthen their cooperation. Eni buys gas from Sonatrach under a long-term contract that has made the north African country one of the key fuel suppliers for Italy after Rome severed ties with Russia's Gazprom following Moscow's invasion of Ukraine. A separate deal will involve Submarine cable company Sparkle, a unit of Telecom Italia (TIM) ( opens new tab, which is set to be sold to a consortium led by Italy's Treasury later this year. Sparkle will sign a preliminary agreement with Algerie Telecom for a new subsea cable connecting the two countries. "Algeria is a strategic partner, and we are working hard to make this partnership ever broader, stronger and more diversified," Foreign Minister Tajani said during a speech at a business forum with over 400 companies from the two nations. ($1 = 0.8521 euros)