For Families of Air India Crash Victims, Report Brings No Closure
The crash and subsequent inferno killed her, along with Mr. Thakur's daughter, Adhya. There had been a small swing for Adhya in the corner of the kitchen, where she could be watched while her parents were out delivering the food her grandmother cooked.
In the weeks since the June 12 crash in Ahmedabad, India's worst aviation disaster in nearly three decades, Mr. Thakur's time has been spent on seeking answers to how such a thing could happen: a plane falling from the sky, killing at least 260 people, including all but one of 242 onboard.
The preliminary investigation report released on Saturday — the day the family would have celebrated Adhya turning 2 — left families like Mr. Thakur's unsatisfied.
The report said that fuel was switched off to both engines within seconds of takeoff, and that the airplane started losing thrust before it had even crossed the airport's perimeter.
But it had no answers as to how the fuel was switched off, or why. The report included only a brief, confusing snippet of the conversation recorded in the cockpit between the pilots, where one asks whether the other moved the fuel switch, to which the second responds that he hadn't.
Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Air India pilot's medical records examined after mental health claims
Air India crash investigators are examining the medical records of the pilot whose plane crashed in Ahmedabad amid claims that he suffered from depression and mental health problems. Captain Sumeet Sabharwal, who was 56, was months from retirement but had been considering leaving the airline to look after his elderly father following the death of his mother in 2022, The Telegraph can reveal. The pilot, who had more than 15,000 flying hours to his name, last undertook a Class I medical exam on Sept 5 last year. His records have been handed to investigators, whose initial report said their focus was on the actions of the pilots rather than a technical fault with the plane. The Airline Pilots' Association of India said it rejected the 'tone and direction' of the inquiry. Captain Mohan Ranganathan, a leading aviation safety expert in India, told The Telegraph: 'I have heard from several Air India pilots who told me he had some depression and mental health issues. He had taken time off from flying in the last three to four years. He had taken medical leave for that.' The Telegraph understands that Captain Sabharwal took bereavement leave following the death of his mother. However, Mr Ranganathan said: 'He must have been medically cleared by the company [Air India] doctors. They must have given the clearance certificate.' All but one of the 242 people on board the Boeing 787 Dreamliner were killed when the aircraft plunged into a medical student hostel last month, less than a minute after take-off from Ahmedabad airport. The preliminary report released by the Indian authorities early on Saturday indicated that switches controlling fuel flow to the jet's two engines were turned off, leading to a catastrophic loss of thrust at take-off. According to the report, one of the pilots is heard in the recovered cockpit voice recording asking the other why he cut off the fuel supply. The other pilot responds that he did not. It is not known who said what. While the initial report did not draw any conclusion, it has drawn attention to the actions of Captain Sabharwal, the plane's captain, and Clive Kundar, the First Officer. As per cockpit procedures, the pilot flying and in control of the take-off was First Officer Kundar, who would have had both hands on the control column during take-off. Captain Sabharwal, the pilot monitoring, would have had his hands free, leaving him in a position to cut off the fuel supply, Mr Ranganathan claimed. He joined Air India in 1994, building a record of more than 8,000 flying hours on this type of aircraft. After his mother's death, he moved from Delhi to Mumbai to care for his father, even considering leaving the airline altogether to devote himself fully to his family. Neighbours in Powai, Mumbai, remembered him as a quiet man who was often seen escorting his father on evening walks. 'He was a doting son who never missed a chance to take his father down for fresh air,' said one. Neil Pais, a former colleague, said the pilot was a 'thorough gentleman', telling The Telegraph: 'He was actually considering early retirement in the next couple of years. His father is very old, 90, and he was going to look after him full time. That was the plan. 'We're all human beings. Yes, there have been crew who've displayed tendencies towards mental health issues, and they've been grounded straight away. It's not allowed to go unchecked. 'Often it's more about life outside the job, which of course plays a part in how you perform. But if there's a concern, it's taken up by operations, by the right departments. They don't let anyone fly if there's any doubt.' Savitri Budhania, an elderly neighbour of Captain Sabharwal in Mumbai, said: 'I told him, 'Your father is too old to be alone.' And he replied, 'Just one or two more flights… then I'm going to just be with Papa.'' 'Who could have known that would be the last time? Whenever he wasn't flying, he would walk hand in hand with his father in the evenings. They smiled at everyone, just gentle, quiet people.' Air India declined to comment, but an official working with the Tata Group, the airline's parent company, told The Telegraph that Captain Sabharwal had not taken recent medical leave. 'He did take bereavement leave in 2022 following his mother's death, and his medical records were submitted as part of the investigation, and the preliminary report did not find anything noteworthy,' he said. Both pilots had passed the Class I medical exam, which evaluates a pilot's psycho-physical capacity, within the last two years. First Officer Kunder, 28, came from a family steeped in aviation. His mother was a flight crew member, and he began his professional career with an aircraft maintenance course at Mumbai's Bombay Flying Club before moving into the cockpit. Raised in Air India's colony at Kalina before the family moved to Borivali, he had logged 1,100 flying hours early in his career. Relatives and friends of the victims called the report's findings a 'slap in the face' and questioned how 'something so trivial as a simple switch being deactivated' had caused such a catastrophe. The Indian Commercial Pilots' Association said the crew of flight 171 had acted in line with their training and responsibilities under challenging conditions. It strongly rejected insinuations of malpractice, saying it was deeply disturbed by the speculation. Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Small plane crashes at London Southend Airport
A small plane has crashed at London Southend Airport on England's east coast, police say. "We remain on the scene of a serious incident at Southend Airport," the local Essex Police said, adding that they were alerted just before 4pm to reports of a collision involving a 12-metre plane. It was unclear how many people were on the plane. Images from UK newspaper websites, not verified by Reuters, showed a fireball rising into the air above Southend Airport, about 56km east of London. We were alerted shortly before 4pm to reports of a collision involving one 12-metre are working with all emergency services at the scene now and that work will be ongoing for several hours. 2/3 — David Burton-Sampson MP (@DavidBSampson) July 13, 2025 The East of England Ambulance Service said it had sent four ambulances and other response vehicles. The relatively small airport's website showed five international flights had been cancelled following the accident. As a precaution due to their proximity to the incident, police evacuated a local golf club and rugby club. John Johnson, who was at Southend Airport with his family at the time of the crash, said he saw a "big fireball" after the plane "crashed head first into the ground". Johnson told the PA news agency: "We all waved at the pilots, and they all waved back at us. "The aircraft then turned 180 degrees to face its take-off, departure, powered up, rolled down the runway. "It took off and about three or four seconds after taking off, it started to bank heavily to its left, and then within a few seconds of that happening, it more or less inverted and crashed just head first into the ground. "There was a big fireball. Obviously, everybody was in shock in terms of witnessing it. All the kids saw it and the families saw it. I phoned 999, reported it. "The airport's fire service responded straight away, two fire engines, and then Essex Police, East of England Ambulance Service and Essex Fire and Rescue Service, as well as a helicopter emergency medical service, all responded to the scene." The local member of parliament, David Burton-Sampson, urged people to stay away and let the emergency services do their work. "My thoughts are with everyone involved," he said. with PA and AP
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
What we know so far amid incident at Southend Airport after small plane crashes
A small plane has crashed at Southend Airport today (Sunday, July 13), with residents being advised to avoid the area. Multiple fire crews, Essex Police, paramedics and the airport's onsite firefighters are on the scene after residents reported seeing a 'huge fireball' and 'explosion' at the airport. Essex County Fire and Rescue Service said four crews, along with off-road vehicles, attended the incident. Four ambulances and four hazardous area response team vehicles are at the scene, the East of England Ambulance Service said. We have sent 4 ambulances, a rapid response vehicle, 4 Hazardous Area Response Team vehicles, 3 senior paramedic cars and Essex and Herts Air Ambulance to Southend Airport responding to reports of an incident involving an airplane. This is a live incident and still developing. — EEAST Ambulance Service (@EastEnglandAmb) July 13, 2025 A 12-metre-long plane is reported to have crashed at Southend Airport just before 4pm today (Sunday, July 13). Images on social media show a huge plume of smoke rising above the airport, with residents saying they have seen a 'huge fireball'. An air ambulance has also been sent to the airport, according to the East of England Ambulance Service, alongside other emergency vehicles. A spokesman for Essex Police said: "We were alerted shortly before 4pm to reports of a collision involving one 12-metre plane. "We are working with all emergency services at the scene now and that work will be ongoing for several hours. "We would please ask the public to avoid this area where possible while this work continues." A spokesman for Essex County Fire and Rescue Service said: "We were called to an incident involving a light aircraft at Southend Airport today at 3.58pm. "Crews from Southend (two), Rayleigh Weir and Basildon (two), along with off road vehicles from Billericay and Chelmsford attended. "We are continuing to work at the scene with our emergency services and aviation partners. "Please avoid the area if possible while this work continues." David Burton-Sampson, MP for Southend West and Leigh, has said he is aware of an incident at the airport. I am aware of an incident at Southend Airport. Please keep away and allow the emergency services to do their work. My thoughts are with everyone involved. 🙏🏽 — David Burton-Sampson MP (@DavidBSampson) July 13, 2025 He said: "I am aware of an incident at Southend Airport. Please keep away and allow emergency services to do their work. "My thoughts are with everyone involved." Recommended reading: Live: Huge 'fireball' seen as 12-metre plane crashes at Southend Airport Emergency services confirm a small plane has crashed in incident at Southend Airport Daniel Cowan, leader of Southend Council, has said: "I am aware of an incident at Southend Airport. The authorities are working through it. I hope all involved are okay." Matt Dent, a Labour councillor for the city, shared on social media: "I am aware of the live serious incident ongoing at London Southend Airport. At present all I know is that a small plane has crashed at the airport. "My thoughts are with all those involved, and with the emergency services currently responding to the incident."
