Butler brothers secure stay on order restricting them from acting as company directors
In a judgment published last month, Ms Justice Nessa Cahill found Colum and Ciaran Butler failed to prove they acted responsibly in the operation of one of their companies, Downtul Ltd, which leased a premises at St Stephen's Green, Dublin, that operated as a Starbucks.
Advertisement
Downtul was placed in voluntary liquidation in November 2022.
The judge granted a declaration sought by Downtul liquidator Patrick O'Connell restricting the brothers from acting as company directors or secretaries for five years unless the company meets certain requirements set out in the Companies Act 2014.
Such an order means that, for the Butler brothers to act as directors of a company during that five-year period, that company must have share capital of at least €100,000 paid up by shareholders – or €500,000 in the case of a public limited company.
The judge had found that the brothers did discharge the burden of showing they acted honestly in the operation of Downtul.
Advertisement
Lawyers for the Butlers on Tuesday successfully applied for a stay on the order, after submitting that their clients would require time to get their affairs in order.
Brian McGuckian told the court his instructions were to seek a stay on the order for six months for two reasons.
He said he was firstly seeking the stay to allow the Butlers time to organise their affairs, noting that Ciaran is the director of 134 companies, while Colum is the director of over 170 companies.
Mr McGuckian said there was a general practice of the court affording directors time to organise their affairs in the context of an order of this kind.
Advertisement
He said he was also seeking a stay pending a possible appeal being brought against the High Court decision.
Padraic Lyons SC, for the receiver, said there was an obvious distinction between the granting of a stay pending an appeal, and a stay to allow the directors to get their affairs in order.
His side had received no correspondence on a potential appeal, and there were no draft grounds of appeal before the court. It was a matter for the directors to put before the court arguable grounds for appeal, he said.
Ireland
Jury views CCTV footage of Tom Niland hours before...
Read More
Mr Lyons agreed there should be a stay granted to allow the directors to organise their affairs but submitted that six months was an excessive amount of time.
Ms Justice Nessa Cahill said she would grant a stay of four months to allow the Butlers to organise their affairs.
She said she was not granting the stay pending a possible appeal, but noted the granted stay will be the same terms had she acceded to the application for a stay pending appeal.
It was a matter for the respondents if they wished to bring an applicant to appeal, she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
6 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Taoiseach Micheál Martin says he will 'definitely not' run for presidency
Taoiseach Micheál Martin has emphatically said that he is 'definitely not' going to run as a candidate for the presidency. Speaking on RTÉ radio's Morning Ireland, Mr Martin said that Fianna Fáil will consider a candidate in the coming weeks after taking 'soundings' from people within the parliamentary party. Advertisement When asked if he had spoken with Deirdre Heenan, Mr Martin said he had not. 'A lot of names have been floated in association with Fianna Fáil. I'm not responsible for the flotation of any of those names, just to make that very clear. I was elected, you know, I went to the people to say I wanted to serve Cork South Central and I wanted to lead Fianna Fáil into government. "I made that obligation to the public, and that's the context. No disrespect to the presidency or anything, but I gave commitments to the people that I would serve in Dáil Éireann for the next five years, and that is what I'm going to do." The Taoiseach also spoke about the National Development Plan, outlining the various funding sources, including projected surpluses, receipts from Apple, and funds from the Climate and Nature Fund. Advertisement "We are projecting surpluses out over the next number of years. There is the additionality of €20 billion from, as you know, the receipts from Apple, about €14 billion, all of them, will go towards the NDP, about €3 billion in terms of the AIB shares sales and a further close to €3 billion from the Climate and Nature Fund," he said. Mr Martin also emphasised the importance of infrastructure investment for job creation and economic growth, noting that the government will consider various scenarios, including IMF forecasts. 'Investment in infrastructure is important and critical for the future of jobs in this country. And we will look at all scenarios. Even the IMF is predicting, by the way, that we, in and around, and suggesting that we this capacity over the next five years in its forecast in terms of total expenditure spent by the Irish government in its analysis. 'Transport alone is receiving very substantial billions, well over €22 billion plus. So public transport will be a key feature of that. The bigger issue, which will be more private sector-driven, will be offshore wind and the development of renewables in our country. I think that's the big ticket item in respect of emissions reductions and switching from a dependence on imported fossil fuels to our own generated renewables. Advertisement "There is no way you would get to 300,000 if you don't have the private Sector contributing a significant number of houses in addition to those that will be provided as a result of the national development plan." Mr Martin added that by 2030, there will be substantially more houses built, 'there'll be far more schools built. I mean, in the last NDP, 800 schools were built. Okay, people give this impression that very little was done with the last NDP, a hell of a lot was done through the last NDP. A whole lot of hospitals were built. 'Active travel, as I said, broadband, for example, has made great strides in terms of that capital plan and the last NDP didn't. Technological University of Grangegorman was also about it; 170 kilometres of road were built, so a lot got done. So a lot of those projects, more and more of those will get done in the next time. 'Take Iarnród Éireann did extraordinarily good work under the last National Development Plan. The transformation of Kent Station, for example, is a good example of that. A lot of the universities, there will be good research projects invested and completed across the university sector," the Taoiseach said. Advertisement "I think this development plan, for example, if you add it all up, and the Minister will give greater detail over the next number of weeks, will be a very significant one for research for universities. And that will add to the competitiveness of our economy, and that's important.'
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Wetherspoon hails ‘standout' Guinness sales while breakfasts rebound
JD Wetherspoon has revealed its sales rose in recent months as it hailed Guinness as a 'standout performer' and reported a rebound in demand for breakfasts. The chain, which runs 794 pubs in the UK and Ireland, said sales increased by 5.1% in the three months to July 20, compared like-for-like with the same period last year. The volume of sales recently overtook pre-pandemic levels, the company revealed, having previously flagged a slow recovery across its estate. It highlighted strong draught sales, particularly Guinness, as well as growth for wine and an improvement in spirits. Guinness maker Diageo has consistently said demand for the Irish stout has been growing rapidly. Furthermore, good weather over the period boosted visitors, with a raft of Wetherspoon pubs benefiting from beer gardens. Wetherspoon's chairman Tim Martin said: 'Draught volumes are performing strongly with Guinness being the standout performer. 'On the food front, breakfasts, terribly slow post-pandemic, have recovered their lustre and are now well ahead. 'Chicken, also, has put in a clucking good performance and volumes in recent weeks are up by about 50% compared to pre-pandemic levels.' Wetherspoon is expecting to meet its profit forecasts for the year, despite warning over the impact of higher labour costs following increases to employers' national insurance contributions and the minimum wage. It has previously warned it is facing a £60 million hit from the higher business costs. Nonetheless, the group has said it plans to invest in its pubs over the year ahead, including staff rooms and gardens, and hopes to open another 30 sites.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
J D Wetherspoon reports rise in sales as warm weather draws crowds
July 23 (Reuters) - British pub group J D Wetherspoon (JDW.L), opens new tab reported a 5.1% rise in like-for-like sales for the 12 weeks to July 20 on Wednesday, attributing the growth to higher footfall at its pubs and stronger demand for drinks thanks to good weather. Favourable weather across Britain in recent weeks boosted sales and traffic in watering holes such as those operated by the pub chain, commonly known as "Spoons". "Sales volumes, which were very slow post-pandemic, have recently overtaken pre-pandemic levels," Chairman Tim Martin said in a statement. The company, which operates 794 pubs across the UK and Ireland, said it expects the full-year profit to be in line with market expectations despite higher costs from tax and wage hikes.
