Concerns health legislation changes could 'weaken' voices of Māori communities
Photo:
Supplied/Sarah Sparks
A group of Iwi Māori Partnerships Boards (IMPBs) are concerned changes to New Zealand's health legislation will weaken the voices of local Māori communities and centralise decision-making in Wellington.
Earlier this month Minister of Health Simeon Brown announced the government will be [https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/564131/cabinet-approves-suite-of-amendments-to-pae-ora-healthy-futures-act introducing legislation for a 'suite of amendments' to the Pae Ora (Healthy Futures) Act.
Brown said the legislation would clarify and streamline the role of IMPBs, shifting their focus away from local service design and delivery, to engaging with communities on local perspectives and Māori health outcomes.
"Local IMPBs will continue to engage with their communities but will now provide advice directly to [the Hauora Māori Advisory Committee] HMAC. That advice will then support decisions made by the minister and the Health New Zealand board."
Hagen Tautari, co-chairperson of Te Tiratū Iwi Māori Partnership Board - which represented the wider Waikato region - said the changes would lead to a shift to centralised decision-making in Wellington and would undermine the community driven process the IMPBs were part of.
Removing the boards' ability to influence change and putting that responsibility back on the Ministry of Health would lead to the loss of an authentic whānau voice, he said.
"The previous minister had spoken about powering up the Iwi Māori Partnership Boards, the current minister has instead powered down them to a degree."
Previous Minister of Health Shane Reti had indicated he was keen to give IMPBs
a much broader remit
.
The 15 IMPBs were established in 2022 initially to support the Māori Health Authority and to advocate for whānau and communities in their regions.
Tautari said they do "critical work" to ensure whānau voices were collected and used to influence service design.
"When they removed [Te Aka Whai Ora] some of that responsibility was taken on board by the Iwi Māori Partnership Boards and it wasn't an ideal situation, but it was better than the alternative of having none of that. So now by reducing the powers of the Iwi Māori Partnership Boards it's a further erosion."
The boards have penned a letter to the minister outlining their concerns endorsed by the larger Te Manawa Taki IMPB collective, which comprised Te Tiratū and boards from Tairāwhiti, Bay of Plenty, Rotorua, Taupō and Taranaki.
Tautari said they supported the "intent" of the minister to ensure all New Zealanders receive timely and quality healthcare. But that intent needed to have the correct vehicle to turn aspirations into action.
The minister had possibly put too much emphasis on Health New Zealand leading that work, he said.
"By eroding what we are doing they are effectively making Te Whatu Ora a substitute for what the IMPB's are doing... they won't be able to do that because they don't have the mandate and I don't think they actually have the knowledge and the intel to actually manage that."
Another of the proposed changes was to enhance and strengthen the role played by the Hauora Māori Advisory Committee (HMAC) which provided advice to the minister and the board of Health New Zealand.
Tautari said changes were major, placing extra expectations on the committee.
"We certainly support the committee, but I feel that they are removing such a strong and powerful ally when they depower and reduce the roles of the Iwi Māori Partnership Boards. So I certainly support the minister's intent, I just think he's gone about it in a way that I don't think is conducive to progress."
It was important the IMPBs continued to advocate for and hold fast to Te Tiriti because at the end of the day it was not going anywhere, and Māori were not going anywhere, he said.
"I think it's incumbent on all of us who work in these areas to understand that Te Tiriti is a constitutional foundation and any reforms must reflect the Crown's enduring duty to uphold Te Tiriti obligations in both law and practice and not just through policy alone."
The minister of health has been approached for comment.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
44 minutes ago
- RNZ News
North Shore Hospital has entire ward of people with no medical reason to be there
North Shore Hospital. Photo: rafaelbenari/123RF North Shore Hospital has an entire ward of people stuck in hospital with no medical reason to be there. The 20-bed ward was created in May for patients who were effectively medically discharged but did not have anywhere to go for lower level care, such as an aged care facility. RNZ understands they were not under the direct care of doctors, but were looked after by nurses and allied health staff such as physiotherapists and social workers. Some were there for weeks. Health NZ's Waitematā operations director Brad Healey said started the dedicated ward to help boost capacity in the busy winter period. It had helped improve the flow of patients because people were spending less time in emergency departments and were getting the care they needed sooner, he said. Deborah Powell heads the APEX Union, which includes allied health workers. It was not unusual for the patients to be in the ward for two or three weeks, but sometimes it was longer, she said. It was not ideal but it was a good, practical decision to have them in one place rather than dotted around the hospital, she said. "It would be better to have them in the community but we just don't have that capacity out there at the moment." The head of the senior doctor's union, the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists, Sarah Dalton, said it was not good for people to be in hospital when they did not need to be. "You're much better off to be in the community where you can be dressed and walking around and doing your daily things and doing exercise and getting rehab and all of those good things," she said. Having people stuck in hospital, also helped create longer surgical waiting lists, she said. "One of the biggest contributors to cancellations of elective surgeries in hospitals is that there aren't enough staffed beds to put the patients in after their surgery." "It has a domino effect back through the hospital in terms of other people's ability to access care." The government needed to do more to fund public aged residential care and also support services that allowed people to go back to their own homes, rather than the "last resort" of having to stay in hospital, Dalton said. Association of Salaried Medical Specialists chief executive Sarah Dalton. Photo: RNZ / Nick Monro Health NZ's Brad Healey said each patient in the ward had a "responsible medical clinician" and could access medical care if their condition changed and a further medical assessment was needed. "The patients have complex discharge pathways, requiring specialist nursing and allied health workforces," he said. Those teams worked closely with the patients and their whānau to get the discharge support they needed, he said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
National pins re-election hopes on economy
Christopher Luxon is busy trying to convince people that National, not Labour, is the steady hand on the tiller amid choppy global waters. Photo: RNZ / Nick Monro Analysis: Saturday's National Party conference set out an early 2026 challenge to voters - stick with what we've got or risk it on who-knows-what. It's a line National used successfully in 2014 (remember Eminem-esque?), but that was a different National, and a different looking government. At roughly the same point in that electoral cycle, National was polling in the late forties. National in 2025 is struggling to get past the early thirties. Labour has emerged as the party New Zealanders think has the best handle on the cost of living, according to the Ipsos Issues Monitor. Of course, there is a long way to go yet. The prime minister knows this, and is counting on sunnier economic fortunes this time next year. But to borrow a well-worn Christopher Luxon phrase, the cost of living is the barnacle that won't get off the boat, and Luxon spent his speech - and much of the week leading up to it - trying to convince people that National, not Labour, is the steady hand on the tiller amid choppy global waters. The government is at pains to say it can't control global events, although it spent a lot of time criticising the previous government for blaming global events. The Trump administration's increased tariffs landed like a lead balloon on Friday, and prompted some late additions to the conference's run sheet. In his speech, Luxon acknowledged the tariffs, but said New Zealand can't just "batten down the hatch" and hope for the best. Trade minister Todd McClay took some time out of his rurals session to say he's already spoken to his US trade counterpart, and dispatched top trade diplomat Vangelis Vitalis to Washington. McClay will follow in the coming weeks. Domestically, National is still blaming the previous government for the economic conditions it inherited, and pitching that it needs a second term to truly sort it out. The party's putting a stake in the ground and saying next year's election will be all about the economy. Last Monday's 10-minute sermon from the podium , which set out the steps National had taken to address the cost of living, was a harbinger of what was to come at the weekend. Inside the cavernous National Air Force Museum, Luxon told media New Zealanders would have a "very simple choice" at the next election: "Do you trust the guys that actually crashed the economy and have no plan, or do you trust the guys in the government that's actually inherited a mess and is sorting it out and is making progress before that election?" Luxon did not mention the other "guys in the government" on Saturday. That's not unusual. This was, after all, a National Party event, full of National Party stump speeches. The party's deputy Nicola Willis, however, gave Luxon a shout-out for the "energy" it takes to keep Winston Peters and David Seymour under control. While joking he was targeting 100 percent of the vote in 2026, Luxon said after his speech that it was natural to disagree with his coalition partners, but they were aligned on the things that mattered. National leader Christopher Luxon speaks at the party's annual conference. Photo: RNZ / Giles Dexter National party supporters that RNZ spoke to were largely happy with how things were going, and how Luxon was keeping things in line. "We are very co-ordinated, very co-ordinated. We respect each other's policies and respect each other's decisions," said one member. "They're very aggressive people that he's in Parliament with, but he's handled it extremely well," said another. "It's like you're the mother in the house, and you have to herd two cats, who do co-operate sometimes, and other times they've got other agendas. From a managerial point of view, I think he's doing excellently in the light of the type of political system we've got." Some expressed wariness of what Peters would do next year, others sung from Luxon's songsheet that this was the maturity of MMP on display. "It's taking some managing, but it's all good. It's what MMP is about." "Everybody's looking at next year's election again, and obviously they want to get back in. So there's a bit of leverage, and nobody's got more experience at that than Winston." They were also convinced the country was going in the right direction, and that Luxon was the right person to steer it there. "We're starting to turn the corner. The last 18 months has been the clean-up job, and we're actually getting ready to turn the tank around now." "It just takes time, and people have got to be patient. They're doing everything that they possibly can, it's just a timing issue. Everybody's impatient." National's membership thinks the polls will firm in their favour as the public look more critically at the alternative. A Labour Party bereft of policy, juggling the niche demands of the more extreme Greens and Te Pāti Māori. Luxon wants the country to "say yes" to more. More mining, more infrastructure, more housing, more tourism, more growth. Opening up more concessions on Department of Conservation land, and charging international visitors to visit some DOC sites is part of that "say yes" strategy. Twenty to forty dollars is not a large sum to fork out for people who have paid thousands to come here, and it adds $62m to the conservation estate that New Zealanders won't have to pay for. There are still some implementation issues to work through. It remains to be seen whether New Zealanders will have to take a passport or bank statement to Cathedral Cove to get out of a fee. It's a small change, and one the government did not campaign or consult the public on, or put in its latest quarterly plan. There will be more to come as parties start to differentiate themselves and sound the election battle drums. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Middle ground needed in healthcare dispute for the sake of public
Health NZ and the Government are certainly aware of this, but reaching a solution is not as simple as agreeing to the demands of the Association of Salaried Medical Specialists (ASMS) and the New Zealand Nurses Organisation (NZNO). Across the Government's Budget, Health NZ is competing with the funding needs of housing, education, transport and more, all amid a cost-of-living crisis for the average Kiwi. Health NZ offered nurses a 3% pay rise over 27 months, plus two lump sum payments of $325. The NZNO sought a 5% pay rise over two years, along with $2000 flat rate increases for senior positions. The union also sought to restore a tikanga Māori allowance. ASMS executive director Sarah Dalton earlier told the Herald hospital specialists sought a 12% pay rise but were being offered an increase of less than 1% per year. Health NZ has described its offers to nurses and senior medical staff as 'fair'. Dalton acknowledged at the time that 12% may not be achievable but said the dispute may not be settled without a better offer. There is room for Health NZ to manoeuvre between 1% and 12%. Dalton's acknowledgment shows that compromise, at least where ASMS is concerned, is not impossible. Health Minister Simeon Brown estimated 4300 procedures, such as hip and knee operations, were delayed because of the 24-hour strike on May 1. Wait times for elective surgeries have already ballooned since the Covid pandemic, and the wait for specialist appointments and operations has continued to grow in many regions. In February, the Herald reported all of the country's hospital emergency departments were failing to assess patients with 'imminently' or 'potentially' life-threatening conditions on time. Striking doctors and nurses have rightfully pointed out staffing issues, with Health NZ recognising another 4100 nurses were needed in the next decade, on top of 2250 nursing vacancies, despite half of nursing graduates not getting job offers from Health NZ last year. Another 3450 doctors were needed in the next decade to keep up with demand. Concessions are needed from both Health NZ and its striking staff. Sign up to the Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
