
Lobby group weighs in against Ryanair in US legal battle
Ryanair sued the website in 2020 in Delaware, alleging that it was screen-scraping the airline's fares without permission. Screen-scraping involves accessing an airline's ticket prices and flight data, and then selling tickets for those flights through a third-party website.
After a four-day trial last July, a jury in Delaware convicted Booking.com of having caused economic harm to Ryanair.
The jury awarded the Irish airline just $5,000 (€4,293) – the minimum threshold required to state a claim under the US Computer Fraud and Abuse Act (CFAA).
However, the district court judge who heard the case then agreed with Booking.com that Ryanair had not met the requirement of proving that at least $5,000 of loss was attributable to Booking.com, which is a prerequisite to any finding of civil liability under the CFAA. Accordingly, the judge overturned the ruling.
Ryanair has now appealed against that decision, seeking to have the judge's decision reversed, or to have a new trial.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation has weighed in behind Booking.com.
The lobby group's founders were US author and lyricist John Barlow and entrepreneur Mitch Kapor. Its backers also included Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak.
It has argued that the continued reliance on the CFAA by companies to take legal actions could stymie competition.
'If unauthorised access can be predicated on a violation of a website owner's stated preferences, rather than hacking technological barriers, then companies will continue to use the CFAA to fend off competition,' the lobby group has claimed in its submission to the US Court of Appeals.
'For example, companies commonly use automated web browsing products to gather web data for a wide variety of uses.'
Those practices include manufacturers tracking performance ranking of products in the search results of retailer websites, or monitoring posts on social media, it points out.
Inhibiting competition is precisely what Ryanair sought to do here
'If the use of valid credentials in a way that has been disallowed as a matter of stated – or even unstated – policy were a CFAA violation, a company could create a password-protected 'gate', make the key freely available to all, and then send cease-and-desist letters to anyone they don't like,' Electronic Frontier Foundation said in its submission.
'This concern is not speculative. Inhibiting competition is precisely what Ryanair sought to do here, and in keeping with what companies have repeatedly tried to do in the past, with partial success.'
Ryanair has already claimed that the travel firm has 'escaped liability' after the Delaware judge overturned the jury's verdict.
'The court impermissibly usurped the role of the jury as the ultimate finder of fact when it found that no reasonable jury could conclude that Ryanair's costs due to Booking's conduct from March 1, 2022, to February 28, 2023 would have exceeded $5,000,' it has claimed.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Inside family home on Irish market for €198,500 boasting ‘superb potential' – and it's in ‘excellent location'
TAKE a look inside the family home on the Irish market for €198,500 that boasts "superb potential" - and it's in an "excellent location". This stunning property is located in Tralee, Co Advertisement 6 The pad is located in the Kerry town of Tralee Credit: Estate Agents Collect 6 And it has been on the market €198,500 Credit: Estate Agents Collect 6 The home is in a fantastic condition Credit: Estate Agents Collect 6 It features spacious and light-filled rooms throughout Credit: Estate Agents Collect This semi detached home is a three-bedroom, two-bathroom house that has been kept in fantastic condition by its current owners. And a sale has now been agreed on this fabulous pad. The house listing reads: "Immaculate 3 bed end terrace residence, ideally situated on the edge of Tralee town centre, adjacent to all amenities. "Forming part of a mature residential area, 3 Casements Avenue has the benefit of a large site, offering superb potential to extend if required. Advertisement READ MORE IN MONEY "With its south facing garden and excellent location, this property comes with viewing highly recommended." It includes a substantial modern kitchen with access to the rear garden and is perfect for This stunning kitchen has tiled and tiled flooring and is fully fitted with wooden cabinets, an oven, and a dishwasher. Double-glazed windows located around the kitchen and dining area allow plenty of natural light to enter the house. Advertisement MOST READ IN MONEY Exclusive The family home is in an excellent location, with cafes, Along with being a 20 minute from Lixnaw, Listowel town is within minutes from this fabulous property. The 'charming' Irish castle on market with a host of perks The area also includes a choice of primary and secondary schools, perfect for Located in a sought after residential area, the family home has recently been redecorated and is regularly updated. Advertisement When entering the home, viewers are greeted by a fabulous hallway with tiled flooring and a skylight window. A This comfortable area is filled with natural light and space, creating a cosy atmosphere. There are two bathrooms in this family home and the first of which is fully-tiled and includes a wash hand basin, a shower and a toilet. Advertisement First floor offerings Moving upstairs, there is a spacious and modern landing with wooden flooring. On the The second bedroom is spacious and features views overlooking the garden. It also has wooden flooring and space to fit a king-size bed. Advertisement The property's third bedroom is a modern single room that features plenty of storage space and natural light. The back garden is another major bonus to buying the pad, and it comes with ample amounts of space, greenery and a shed. The home is listed by Ger Carmody Estates and advertised on 6 The property is a three bedroom pad Credit: Estate Agents Collect Advertisement 6 It comes with a large rear garden Credit: Estate Agents Collect


Sunday World
an hour ago
- Sunday World
Son of Kinahan boss Thomas ‘Bomber' Kavanagh set up roofing company after prison release
Trainee accountant was jailed for trying to help criminal dad Jack from Tamworth, Birmingham a trainee accountant, became caught up in Bomber's criminal enterprises when he tried to help his father orchestrate a lighter sentence for drug smuggling. The plot involved acquiring and then hiding a stash of handguns, machine guns and ammunition and then alerting the National Crime Agency (NCA) to its location with X marking the spot on a map. The scheme was foiled after the NCA uncovered incriminating messages on encrypted EncroChat which had been cracked by French counterparts. Jack was arrested in May 2023 at Malaga Airport by officers from the Spanish National Police while he was travelling to Turkey. The house in Tamworth, near Birmingham He was extradited to the UK where he pleaded guilty to conspiring to possess firearms and ammunition. But in December last year, Judge Philip Katz KC accepted he was more of an 'enthusiastic messenger' than an 'organiser' as he sentenced him to three years and one month in prison. Effectively Because he had already effectively served his time on remand, the sentence secured Jack's release from Belmarsh prison, from where he appeared by video-link for his sentencing. Judge Katz told him: 'Although I accept you got involved out of misguided loyalty to your father, you entered into this agreement with your eyes open.' Unlike, Thomas Kavanagh, who was 'a notorious and leading member of an organised crime group', the defendant had no previous convictions and was a young man of good character, the court was told. Now, seven months after gaining his freedom, and as fresh financial woes were heaped on Bomber this week when the Crown Prosecution Service hit him with a €1.26 million proceeds of crime bill, Jack has taken the first steps towards building his own legal enterprise. Company documents show Jack – whose nationality is registered as Irish – registered Oakline Roofing Limited as a new company with him as its sole director on June 29. The company is one of three companies headquartered out of Bomber's family home in Sutton Road, Mile Oak, Tamworth. Two other companies, a security company and a car sale company, are shown as being headquartered at the same address. The Sunday World previously revealed that the Crown Prosecution Service had imposed a freezing order on any sale of the fortified Tamworth Property pending the outcome of the proceeds of crime probe into his activities. Kavanagh, 57, who headed UK operations for the mob and cartel lieutenant 'Flash' Gary Vickery, 42, were present to hear the outcome of the proceed of crime probe hearing in Ipswich Crown Court on Friday morning. Looking tanned and trim in a dark grey T-shirt as he sat in an interview room in Belmarsh prison, Kavanagh listened on with his arms folded as the hearing went through his assets. Officers estimated that Kavanagh's criminal profits were in the region £12.2m, but recoverable assets amounted to £1,123,096.84. 'This includes his 50% share of his fortified family mansion in Tamworth, Staffordshire, money from the sale of various other properties in the UK and a villa in Spain, and approximately £150,000 of high-end bags, clothes and accessories which were discovered when Kavanagh's house was searched following his initial arrest in 2019,' they said. Jack Kavanagh (left) and father Thomas 'Bomber' Kavanagh Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 27th


Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Jim Power: Budget countdown begins with big promises
The publication of the summer economic statement has set the budgetary process in motion, and the destination will be reached in early October. The two relevant ministers have outlined a budget package of €9.4bn, with a net tax package of €1.5bn, and an expenditure package of €7.9bn. This expenditure package will be comprised of current expenditure increases of €5.9bn or almost 75% of the total; and capital spending of €2bn or just over 25% of the total. Proposed Vat cut On the tax side, the Government has given a commitment to reduce the Vat rate for part of the hospitality sector — the food element — to 9% and this would cost around €580m in foregone taxes. If this is delivered and applies from January 1 next, it means that effectively less than €1bn would be available for personal tax changes. To put this in context, it is estimated that a 1% indexation of the employee tax credit would cost around €230m in a full year, so to index for projected inflation in 2026 would cost somewhere in the region of €460m; or a 1% decrease in the 40% tax rate would cost around €540m. If the government delivers the Vat cut from the beginning of 2026, which it has committed to, the tax package will be small. So not surprisingly, there are suggestions that the cut might be delayed until July, thereby significantly reducing the cost in 2026. If this transpires, the hospitality sector would have every right to be aggrieved. Restaurants and food businesses are the most crucial element of our tourism product, and many businesses are struggling to stay afloat. Inflation Data released by the CSO last week show that in 2024, Irish food prices are the third highest in the EU-27 and are 12% above the EU average. In the year to May, agricultural output prices increased by 20.7%, with cattle prices up by 48%. These prices obviously feed into restaurant input costs, but the pressures are compounded by labour costs, insurance, water charges, commercial rates etc. I am a supporter of the reduced Vat rate, and I think it is now more appropriate to provide some limited support to a key employer of people all over the country, and a vital part of the tourism offering, rather than to pump money through excessive expenditure into an economy that is still doing quite well. Does the Irish economic cycle need a continuation of out-of-control current expenditure now? I think not. Even if the Vat cut is pushed out, the extent of the easing of the personal tax burden will be miniscule. We should have learned from the past We should have learned our lessons from the pro-cyclical policies of the past. The summer economic statement projects planned expenditure of €108.7bn this year, which is €3.3bn higher than planned in Budget 2025, and it is likely to turn out even higher than this latest projection. Not surprisingly, the Irish Fiscal Advisory Council is not happy and has justifiably accused the Government of 'poor planning and budgeting.' Obviously, the ability of the two ministers to deliver the proposed budgetary package, and indeed to deliver the ambitious, but detail lacking, revised National Development Plan, will be heavily contingent on the future performance of the economy, and especially the actions of Donald Trump. Downward creep in projections There is not a lot of detail in relation to economic assumptions in the summer economic statement, but it is interesting to note that for 2025 the Department of Finance is projecting growth of 2% in modified domestic demand (MDD), down from 2.5% in April, and 2.9% in Budget 2025 last October. For 2026, MDD is projected to grow by 1.8%, down from 2.8% in April, and 3% in Budget 2025. There is downward creep occurring in Ireland's economic projections, which seems logical in the context of Trump-induced uncertainty. In relation to the National Development Plan, it is quite amazing that we must await detail on the projected spend until close to budget time. What in the name of God has been happening since January? The aspirations outlined in the revised plan — such as energy, water, housing, transport infrastructure, and climate change — are difficult to argue with, but delivery on time and on budget will be essential. One hopes there will be greater control, transparency and accountability in relation to National Development Plan delivery than we have seen with major infrastructure projects such as the children's hospital and the infamous bicycle shed.