SNP rebels challenge John Swinney with radical independence plan
They have unveiled a plan to open independence negotiations with the UK Government if nationalist parties get a majority of the popular vote in next year's Holyrood election.
A motion outlining the plan has been submitted for discussion at the SNP conference in October, and has been backed by 43 regional branches, The Herald reported.
If selected for discussion, it will rival Mr Swinney's motion outlining his new independence plan, which the First Minister unveiled earlier this week.
Mr Swinney said the SNP winning an outright majority at Holyrood should force Sir Keir Starmer to drop his opposition to allowing another independence referendum.
He argued a precedent had been set at the 2011 election, when Alex Salmond led the SNP to a majority win and David Cameron, the then prime minister, authorised a vote.
But Alex Neil, a former SNP health secretary, told The Telegraph Mr Swinney was 'living in cloud cuckoo land' given the current level of public support for the SNP.
It has previously emerged that some of the rebel group of SNP members want to oust Mr Swinney as party leader amid concerns he is not doing enough to achieve independence.
The motion setting out their alternative blueprint is a direct challenge to his authority by the rebel group, which will meet in Perth on Aug 9.
It invites the conference to instruct 'the Party to prioritise obtaining a mandate from the sovereign Scottish people to deliver independence.'
This will be possible if the independence-supporting parties – the SNP, the Greens and Alba – together achieve a majority of the ballots cast in the regional list vote for Holyrood, it states.
Graeme McCormick, one of the people behind the strategy, told The Herald: 'If we get a majority of pro-independence votes on the list, we'll open negotiations with the UK Government around independence. If the negotiations aren't successful, then we'll move to dissolve the union. It's perfectly legal to do so.
'Our plan is coming from members with experience of how states work – we aren't just dewy-eyed 'the dream will never die' nationalists. We've invited John to come and speak with us, and look forward to discussing this with him. I think the strength of what we have requested is clear.'
But a party source predicted that the motion would not be selected by the party's conference committee, which decides what will be discussed at the Aberdeen gathering.
The provisional conference agenda will be published on Aug 8 after the committee has considered all the submitted motions.
Successive UK governments have repeatedly turned down SNP calls for a second referendum, with the UK Supreme Court ruling in 2022 that only Westminster can allow another poll.
Sir Keir said last month that he could not imagine another referendum being staged while he is prime minister, and an SNP victory in the May 2026 election would not change his mind.
When she was first minister, Nicola Sturgeon claimed there should be another referendum if there was a majority of independence-supporting MSPs, including SNP and Green members.
But Mr Swinney's new benchmark of an outright SNP majority is much more difficult to achieve under Holyrood's electoral system, which is partly based on proportional representation.
Rachael Hamilton, the Scottish Tory deputy leader, said: 'This spat just demonstrates how out of touch John Swinney and the SNP are with ordinary Scots. Under the nationalists, our public services are in meltdown and taxes are sky high. But instead of fixing the mess they've created, they're fighting about how best to push their independence obsession.'
Alastair Cameron, the chairman of the Scotland in Union campaign group, said: 'Imagine if the SNP spent as much time exploring how to save the NHS rather than fighting over different wheezes for an unwanted second referendum. This is a party that has lost its way and is detached from the people of Scotland.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Little Boats Crackdown! Members of criminal gangs in Britain who advertise migrant Channel crossings online could face 'five years in jail'
Criminal gangs who advertise small boat crossings across the English Channel or fake passports online could spend up to five years behind bars under new legislation. Ministers are looking to create a new offence under the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Bill already going through Parliament in an attempt to crackdown on criminal gangs promoting Channel crossings on the Internet, The Mirror reports. Under the proposed law, offenders could receive a prison sentence of up to five years and a hefty fine. Assisting illegal migration is already a crime, but officials hope the changes will give more powers to police to disrupt criminal gangs. Around 80 percent of migrants arriving to the UK by small boats say they used social media to find someone associated with a criminal gang who could smuggle them into the country. According to the Home Office, many of those who make the perilous crossings across the Channel are sold a 'false narrative' about their ability to live and work in the UK. 'Selling the false promise of a safe journey to the UK and a life in this country – whether on or offline – simply to make money, is nothing short of immoral,' Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said. 'These criminals have no issue with leading migrants to life-threatening situations using brazen tactics on social media. We are determined to do everything we can to stop them – wherever they operate.' Ministers are looking to create a new offence under the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Bill already going through Parliament The potential new measure comes the Government announced last week that members of people-smuggling gangs who send migrants across the Channel in flimsy boars will face financial sanctions. The new powers target smugglers and those who supply them with money and equipment. Foreign Secretary David Lammy said the measures are 'the world's first sanctions regime targeted at gangs involved in people smuggling and driving irregular migration, as well as their enablers.' Those in breach of the rules can have UK assets seized, be barred from using British banks and be banned from entering Britain. The government said the new rules are authorised by existing sanctions legislation. British lawmakers won't get a chance to debate them until they return from a summer break in September. Keir Starmer has pledged to stop criminal gangs sending thousands of migrants each year on dangerous journeys across one of the world's busiest shipping lanes. A group of migrants run from the beach into the water to reach an inflatable dinghy to leave the coast of northern France in an attempt to cross the English Channel to reach Britain as tougher migration controls were announced, at the beach of Petit-Fort-Philippe in Gravelines, near Calais, France, July 17, A migrant tries to board a smuggler's inflatable dinghy in an attempt to cross the English Channel off the beach of Gravelines, northern France on July 29, 2025 The Prime Minister has said the crime gangs are a threat to global security and should be treated like terror networks. Some 37,000 people crossed the channel in 2024, and more than 22,000 so far in 2025 - an increase of about 50 percent from the same period last year. Dozens of people have died attempting the journey.
Daily Mail
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
You can say that again! Rachel Reeves admits Labour has left voters 'disappointed'
Rachel Reeves has admitted that the Labour Government has 'disappointed' people. But the Chancellor insisted she had got the balance right between tax, spending and borrowing. She told an audience at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival that her job involved making tough decisions, even if they are unpopular. She told the Iain Dale All Talk Show: 'The reason people voted Labour at the last election is they want to change and they were unhappy with the way that the country was being governed. 'I'm impatient for change as well, but I've also got the job of making sure the sums always add up. You certainly can't do everything straight away, all at once.' Ms Reeves pointed to Labour's £200million investment in carbon capture in Scotland, which she said was welcomed by the energy industry. Rachel Reeves (pictured) has admitted that the Labour Government has 'disappointed' people. But the Chancellor insisted she had got the balance right between tax, spending and borrowing Reeves told the Iain Dale All Talk Show: 'The reason people voted Labour at the last election is they want to change and they were unhappy with the way that the country was being governed. Defending Labour's record, she said her party had the 'balance about right' At the same time, Labour's windfall tax, she said, was not liked by the sector. 'But you can't really have one without the other,' she said. Defending Labour's record, she said her party had the 'balance about right'. 'But of course you're going to disappoint people,' she added. 'No one wants to pay more taxes. Everyone wants more money than public spending – and borrowing is not a free option, because you've got to pay for it. 'I think people know those sort of constraints, but no one really likes them and I'm the one that has to sort the sums up.'
Daily Mail
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The most obnoxious MPs I've met, by ANDREW PIERCE: One physically attacked me. One called me a 'total c***'. And one philandering minister made a VERY sinister invitation. After 40 years in Westminste
It was 1988 when I first started working in Parliament as an ambitious young reporter, meaning I've met more than my fair share of Westminster characters over the decades. Some MPs – despite what you might think – are diligent, decent, dedicated men and women, working gruelling hours and thankless roles to make life for their constituents better. Others, shall we say, are not. Indeed, several MPs and peers I've had the misfortune of meeting across the political spectrum have been among the rudest and most unpleasant in any field. Here are some of the worst offenders I've met during my 40 years in journalism... NICHOLAS RIDLEY The first minister I crossed swords with in my professional life was Sir Nicholas Ridley, one of the cabal of Tory MPs who had plotted the Iron Lady's victory as party leader in 1975. It was 1983 and I was writing a story for my first newspaper, the Gloucestershire Echo, about plans for a major housing development on prized Green Belt land in his Cirencester and Tewkesbury constituency. I had spoken to Sir Charles Irving, the Tory MP for neighbouring Cheltenham, who was suitably outraged. But Ridley, a Treasury minister, stubbornly refused to return my calls. From bottom left, clockwise: Peter Mandelson, Ted Heath, David Cameron, Michael Portillo and Alastair Cambell Not to be thrown off the scent, I went to his constituency office where he was holding a Friday surgery and patiently waited in the queue to see him. When I introduced myself, Ridley – holding his trademark cigarette – exploded with rage. 'I'm a Government minister, and you are a spotty youth! Show me some respect,' he spat as he marched me from his office. But I had my scoop. 'Government minister refuses to condemn major housing development on the Green Belt in the heart of his Cotswold constituency' ran the headline – and went on to be picked up by several national news outlets. He always returned my calls after that. FERGUS MONTGOMERY I've only ever had to run for it once in the Commons – and that was in the early 1990s when I revealed that the Tory MP Sir Fergus Montgomery was hosting a party for showbusiness legend Dame Shirley Bassey. I had been to a similar event on the Commons terrace the year before so thought nothing of pointing out Montgomery's impeccable showbusiness connections. In fact, I assumed he would be delighted. So I was somewhat surprised when I arrived in the Commons on the day my article was published to come face to face with the former private secretary, who was puce with rage. Grabbing the lapels of my jacket, he began to shout so loudly that flecks of spittle formed at the corners of his mouth. Andrew Pierce has met several MPs and peers across the political spectrum who have been among the rudest and most unpleasant in any field 'I told my constituency officers the party wasn't happening this year because I didn't want them there,' he raged. 'They now think I'm a snooty liar. You've put me in an impossible position.' A string of four-letter expletives followed. Attempts by fellow MPs to calm him down seemed to make matters worse. There was no reasoning with him and, as his rage deepened, I made a decision: I legged it. But the surprisingly agile Montgomery gave chase, waving his fist in the air and shouting to any confused onlooker who would listen: 'Stop that man!' GEORGE FOULKES That wasn't the only time one of my scoops almost led to a thrashing. Around the same time, the bulbous-nosed Labour MP George Foulkes took grave exception to my report that he had been found face-down in a gutter after a scotch whisky reception. Lunging at me at a reception in The Reform Club – the famous home-from-home of Jules Verne's protagonist in Around The World In Eighty Days – he barked: 'I want a word with you, sonny.' Unfortunately, he was a little unsteady on his feet. He lunged too far, went flying and sent a table full of drinks glasses crashing on to the tiled floor. It made for an interesting follow-up. DAVID CAMERON In 1990, David Cameron left Andrew with an expensive lunch bill, where the wine alone was £75 – the equivalent of about £200 today – and impossible to get through on his expenses, but Andrew got his revenge years later My first unfortunate encounter with a future prime minister didn't come until 1990 when I had lunch with David Cameron, who was then a special adviser to chancellor Norman Lamont. Even then, I thought that he looked and sounded like a future Tory leader, oozing Old Etonian entitlement. He arrived at the restaurant, the trendy central London bistro Joe Allen, before I did – a vital time-keeping lesson that I've never forgotten. 'Hope you don't mind, old chap,' he crowed as I arrived. 'I've ordered the wine.' I didn't mind at all – until I was left with the bill. The wine alone was £75 – the equivalent of about £200 today – and impossible to get through on my expenses. Fortunately, I was able to wreak my revenge some years later when he was Leader of the Opposition. From my bird's eye view in the press gallery high above the Commons chamber, I noticed during one of his appearances that his hair was thinning on top. What did I do with this interesting nugget of information? Of course, I wrote about it – and dubbed him Friar Tuck. When we bumped into each other outside Parliament a few days later, he erupted. Forefinger stabbing the air, effing and blinding with his puffy cheeks turning blood red, he shouted: 'I'm so bloody furious with you, Pierce. You are – and always have been – a total c***.' And I thought politicians were supposed to have thick skins... ALAN CLARK Thatcher groupie Alan Clark, an unrepentant philanderer, lived in Saltwood Castle in Kent with his long-suffering wife Jane, picture together. Andrew wrote about the former defence minister's affair with a judge's wife and her two daughters Then there was the former defence minister and Thatcher groupie Alan Clark, an unrepentant philanderer, who lived in Saltwood Castle in Kent with his long-suffering wife Jane. After I wrote about his affair with a judge's wife and her two daughters – whom he referred to as the 'coven' in his diaries – he approached me in the Commons in 1994, when he was between seats. 'I gather you're Andrew Pierce,' he said somewhat pleasantly. 'You're a poxy prig. Do come to my home – but be warned, four knights stayed there the night before they went to Canterbury Cathedral to kill Archbishop Thomas Becket.' Needless to say, I never took him up on his kind offer. JOHN GUMMER After the widely-disliked environment secretary John Gummer survived yet another John Major Cabinet reshuffle in 1995, I decided to introduce myself. 'What is it the prime minister sees in you that eludes the rest of us?' I asked. He replied tartly: ' 'Journalism is popular mainly as fiction. Life is one world and life seen in the newspapers another.' That's G. K. Chesterton, you oaf.' Looking me up and down, he added: 'As for you, you're in a different world altogether.' MICHAEL PORTILLO In 1996, Michael Portillo lost his seat by 1,443 votes. Could it have anything to do with a story Andrew wrote about the Conservative Association in his Enfield Southgate constituency and a McDonald's bid to take over the defence secretary's HQ, which outraged residents? Back in the summer of 1996, defence secretary Michael Portillo was the rising star of the Tory party and the frontrunner to replace flailing leader John Major after the election the following year. I picked up a story that the Conservative Association in his Enfield Southgate constituency had accepted an offer of £325,000 from McDonald's – £100,000 more than any other bidder – allowing the fast food giant to take over his HQ. Local residents were outraged. As was Portillo. I had never spoken to him before but he telephoned the Mail's news desk in a fury just before midnight. When we spoke, his tone was menacing: 'I know your editor, I know your proprietor. Think very carefully before you write any more about this.' Thanking him for his career advice, I went on to report that Portillo was chums with Geoffrey Tucker, who was one of the fast food chain's political consultants, and I also discovered that the main Conservative HQ in London would benefit to the tune of a £100,000 loan. The night of the 1997 election, his Labour rival Stephen Twigg called me to say he thought the McDonald's row would shave just 2,000 votes off Portillo's huge 15,000 majority. In fact, in one of the defining moments of Labour's election landslide victory, Portillo lost by 1,443 votes. ALASTAIR CAMPBELL Months before Labour's 1997 election win, a light-hearted exposé caused a stir – and led to Andrew's first encounter with Tony Blair's pugnacious all-powerful spin doctor, Alastair Campbell Enjoying better luck that election was, of course, Tony Blair, who won voters over with his suave speeches and mischievous smile. A little too mischievous as it turned out. Months before his win, he appeared on Des O'Connor's TV show and told the gripping story of how, as a schoolboy, he had managed to lose his father Leo at Newcastle train station while travelling back to Fettes College in Edinburgh – and stowed himself away on a plane to the Bahamas. The adventure could have come straight from the pages of a James Bond novel – the most famous fictional alumnus of Fettes. To put it mildly, I was sceptical. I managed to track down Blair's father, who was 73 at the time. He laughed out loud when I told him about the 'great escape' and replied that Blair had an over-active schoolboy imagination. My light-hearted exposé caused a stir – and led to my first encounter with Blair's pugnacious all-powerful spin doctor, Alastair Campbell. He marched into my office in Parliament and announced to the room: 'Pierce is finished as he has exploited Tony's father.' After many reassurances to confused onlookers that I had not taken advantage of an elderly man, I am, thankfully, still going strong almost three decades later. While Blair was far too canny to be rude to reporters, that encounter was typical of his henchman Campbell: brutal and coarse. PETER MANDELSON The other high priest of political spin, Peter Mandelson, never forgave me for a harmless story while he was campaigning to be the Labour MP in Hartlepool in the 1992 election. Standing in a fish and chip shop, with an incongruous Hartlepool FC football scarf tied tightly round his neck, he pointed behind the counter and asked: 'Can I have a tub of that delicious looking guacamole mousse?' Peter Mandelson never forgave Andrew Pierce for a harmless story he wrote while the high priest of political spin was campaigning to be the Labour MP in Hartlepool in the 1992 election To which the burly owner spluttered: 'It's bloody mushy peas.' It made an entertaining story – and the first of many calls from the Prince of Darkness demanding my dismissal. Now the ambassador to the US, he lives in Washington DC with his partner Reinaldo, whose relationship I revealed in the Sunday Express in 1998. Somewhat hypocritically, despite pushing for gay rights in public, Mandelson was mortified. He lobbied the proprietor, Labour peer Lord Hollick, not to run the story. When it was printed, he demanded my head (again) but failed. However, he did get the scalp of the editor, one Amanda Platell, now a star columnist on the Daily Mail and my very best friend. I was so outraged by her treatment I resigned my post the next morning. TED HEATH In Blackpool, at the Tory party conference in 1999, former prime minister Ted Heath said to Andrew: 'Who on earth invited you? I hope you're enjoying yourself because you won't be invited again' To dinner at the Tory party conference in Blackpool in 1999 with former prime minister Ted Heath, who hosted lavish soirées at the River House Hotel in Lancashire. The grand location meant Ted could avoid any contact with pesky Tory activists if he stayed in a mere conference hotel. But clearly it wasn't only the grassroots supporters he didn't want to see that season. Despite sitting feet from me, Heath pointedly ignored me throughout the dinner. Puzzled, I eventually said: 'Sir Edward, I'm Andrew Pierce from the...' 'I know exactly who you are,' he interrupted. 'Who on earth invited you? I hope you're enjoying yourself because you won't be invited again.' Thankfully, our curmudgeonly exchange didn't continue. About 30 minutes later, he fell into a deep sleep at the table and we were all asked to leave. BARONESS YOUNG I have been accused of many things by politicians but the abuse from Baroness (Janet) Young, the only woman to serve in Margaret Thatcher's Cabinet, was the most astonishing. Young had led the parliamentary campaign against Labour's Bill to lower the age of gay consent from 18 to 16 – which eventually passed in 2000. I spotted her in the House of Lords shortly after the historic vote and went to introduce myself. She was not impressed. 'Oh, it's you,' she said with disgust. 'You're the homosexual who pushed for an equal age of consent. Congratulations. You have enabled old predatory men to prey on young boys. I hope you are proud of yourself.' BORIS JOHNSON In 2007, when Andrew leaked that David Cameron had ordered Boris Johnson to run for Lord Mayor, he denied the story and said: 'Andrew Pierce is a miserable, simpering scuzzbucket' In 2007, I wrote that the then relatively unknown Boris Johnson was being ordered by Tory leader David Cameron to run for London mayor. He hotly denied it – I think. Much of what he shouted down the phone was in Latin so went over my head. But when the London Evening Standard seized on the story, he told them in plain English: 'Andrew Pierce is a miserable, simpering scuzzbucket.' Two weeks later it was confirmed that Boris would be the Tory candidate after all, in a race he went on to win. Boris, of course, is now one of my esteemed colleagues at the Daily Mail in a sign that no ill will or personality clashes last forever in Westminster. Sadly I cannot say the same for the 'scuzzbucket' jibe, which remained on my Wikipedia page for years.
