Hewlett-Packard lost hundreds of millions in Autonomy acquisition, judge rules
The company claimed at a nine-month trial in 2019 that Mr Lynch inflated Autonomy's revenues and 'committed a deliberate fraud over a sustained period of time', which it said forced it to announce an 8.8 billion dollar (£6.5 billion) write-down of the firm's worth just over a year after the acquisition.
In a ruling in 2022, Mr Justice Hildyard said the American firm had 'substantially succeeded' in their claim, but that it was likely to receive 'substantially less' than the amount it claimed in damages.
He said that Autonomy had not accurately portrayed its financial position during the purchase, but even if it had, HPE would still have bought the company, but at a reduced price.
A hearing was then held last year to decide the amount that Mr Lynch must pay in damages, before the businessman died aged 59 along with his 18-year-old daughter, Hannah, and five others when his yacht, the Bayesian, sank off the coast of Sicily last August.
On Tuesday, Mr Justice Hildyard ruled that HPE suffered losses amounting to £697,876,753 through the purchasing of Autonomy, some of which is set to be paid by Mr Lynch's estate.
He also ruled that Mr Lynch's estate is liable to pay part of around 47.5 million dollars in damages, which is worth around £35 million.
Some of the money is due to be paid by Sushovan Hussain, Autonomy's former chief financial officer, who was also sued by HPE.
He was convicted in April 2018 in the US of wire fraud and other crimes related to Autonomy's sale, and was sentenced to five years in prison.
While he has since settled HPE's claim, he could still be required to pay damages.
A further hearing to deal with matters including interest, currency conversion and whether Mr Lynch's estate can appeal against the decision is set to be held in November.
Handing down his ruling, Mr Justice Hildyard expressed his 'great sympathy' for Mr Lynch's family, calling his death a 'tragedy'.
He said: 'It is a source of anxiety to me that I have to deliver a judgment that will inevitably cause further stress on those involved.'
In the 197-page ruling, he said he considered that HPE's claim 'was always substantially exaggerated' and that the five billion dollars figure claimed 'was not based on detailed analysis'.
Following the ruling in 2022, Mr Lynch, who was also the founding investor of cybersecurity giant Darktrace, was extradited to the US in May 2023 to face criminal charges after his removal was approved by the then-Home Secretary Priti Patel.
He was cleared of accusations that he orchestrated a fraud and conspiracy over Autonomy's sale in the US in June 2024, and was celebrating the acquittal on his yacht at the time of his death.
In a statement written before his death, issued posthumously by his representatives on Tuesday, Mr Lynch said: 'Today's High Court ruling reflects that HP's original five billion dollar damages claim was not just a wild overstatement – misleading shareholders – but it was off the mark by 80%.
'HP acquired Autonomy for 11.6 billion dollars and today's judgment is a view that Autonomy's actual value was not even 10% below the price HP paid.
'This result exposes HP's failure and makes clear that the immense damage to Autonomy was down to HP's own errors and actions.
'An appeal process will be considered later this year.
'The English civil case included hearsay evidence from the US and we were never able to question or cross-examine those witnesses.
'This is in direct contrast to the rights of defendants in the US legal system.
'When in the US criminal trial we were able to cross-examine the relevant witnesses, a very different story emerged. Why is the English legal system so trusting?'
A spokesperson for HPE said: 'We are pleased that this decision brings us a step closer to the resolution of this dispute.
'We look forward to the further hearing at which the final amount of HPE's damages will be determined.'
Jeremy Sandelson, who was appointed by the court as administrator of Mr Lynch's estate, said he would be 'examining the judgment carefully', including whether to appeal both the 2022 ruling and the judgment on Tuesday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Libya Herald
41 minutes ago
- Libya Herald
Secular and religious agree on need for Libya's gradual energy subsidy reform
The secular and religious worlds have come to agreement on the need for Libya to gradually reform its fuel subsidies in the unlikely bedfellows of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and Libya's (western region) Grand Mufti (the highest religious authority). Dar Al-Ifta, the highest religious body, released a video clip last Thursday (24 July) of the Grand Mufti of Libya, Sadeg al-Ghiriani, basing his religious recommendation on Libya's fuel subsidy reform on the IMF's study published this month entitled 'Energy Subsidy Reform in Libya'. Speaking on the problems of Libya's economy, the Mufti said ''the first step to reforming the waste of public money that Libya is currently experiencing is to lift the (energy) subsidies, almost half probably more, of which go to the money of criminals and smugglers''. Drawing on the IMF Al-Ghariani continued ''The report issued by the IMF calling for the lifting of energy subsidies is a study by international experts, the government should take advantage of it and gradually lift subsidies, as the report suggested, as there is no country in the world where gasoline and energy are sold at the price that it is sold at (LD 0.15 / US$ 0.09 per litre) in Libya''. Lack of trust in government – fear of failure to compensate for subsidy removal Dealing with some of the opposition Libyans have to the introduction of fuel subsidy reforms, the Grand Mufti said Libyans 'should not let their emotions carry them away by saying they fear if subsidies are removed the government will not live up to its promise to substitute it with a direct cash payment (equivalent to their realistic average annual consumption of fuel). ''Do Libyans agree to at least a third of their state budget being wasted away, robbed by thieves for illicit use and profligacy? This (continued squandering of public money) is not appropriate to the behaviour of any wise, Muslim or human being'', he added. ''I therefore call on the (Tripoli based Libyan) government to open this topic again based on the IMF's report and work on gradually lifting the (energy) subsidies, as suggested in the IMF report until energy prices reach their real (market) price''. The IMF study on Libya's energy subsidy reform It will be recalled that, and as reported by Libya Herald, the IMF report had stated that energy subsidies have become a significant burden on government finances in Libya. The study said the pervasive nature of subsidies has led to rampant corruption, smuggling, and a diversion of resources from essential public services. The paper identifies key barriers to reform, including opposition from vested interest groups and public apprehension regarding inflation and welfare loss. To address these challenges, a strategic reform plan is proposed, emphasizing a phased approach, a comprehensive communication plan and social protection measures to mitigate the adverse effects of subsidy removal. By taking these steps, Libya can transition towards a more sustainable framework that supports macroeconomic stability, the IMF study stated. . IMF study entitled 'Energy Subsidy Reform in Libya' concludes that reform is crucial as subsidies lead to overconsumption and premature resource depletion Fuel subsidies reached LD 60 billion, 30 percent of which is smuggled – therefore can invest just LD 5 bn in housing: CBL Governor Issa Audit Bureau 2023 Annual Report: 2023 state subsidies amounted to LD 68.5 billion Libya loses about US$ 12 billion annually in smuggled subsidies: Aldabaiba Decision to remove fuel subsidies has been taken: PM Aldabaiba ( NOC chairman Bengdara says his organisation is not a security force to combat fuel smuggling ( Aldabaiba forms ministerial committee to study mechanism for fuel subsidy reform – again ( Supreme Council for Energy adopts NOC 2023-2027 plan, including alternative energy project ( Supreme Council for Energy Affairs holds first meeting ( At Gharian cabinet meeting, Aldabaiba explains fall in black-market value of dinar and resounds alarm over fuel subsidies ( Fuel quantities, smuggling and subsidy reform – and increased oil production through PPP discussed at summit meeting ( Alternatives to fuel subsidies with cash payments delivered to Aldabaiba ( Prime minister Aldabaiba forms Ministerial committee to study reforming fuel subsidies, orders payment of family grant, increases pensions ( Libya's Economic Reform Salon proposes reforms for the country's fuel subsidies | ( Fuel subsidy reform proposal presented to Serraj government | ( Libya reduces subsidies on commercial-use kerosene | ( Subsidies are seen as an entitlement by Libyans: GNA Planning Minister | ( Government to reduce petrol subsidies | ( Cash for goods subsidy reform adopted by Tripoli authorities | ( Subsidy reform: petrol prices to be increased by 200% | ( 2014 Budget commits government to subsidy reform by Jan 2015 | ( The 2014 Budget: Subsidies up – despite deficit and oil exporting crises | ( 2014 budget expected to be LD 68.59bn – salaries and subsidies shoot up | ( Unemployment, subsidies, undiversified economy, stifled private sector – problems of Libyan economy: WB | ( Fuel subsidies removed over 30 months in three stages – Economy Minister Abufunas | ( Subsidy reform: Smugglers are the ones prospering from subsidies – Zeidan | ( Cabinet meeting forms committee on subsidies – Zeidan | ( Oil minister says fuel subsidies to go by 2016 | (
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Girl, 3, found dead on popular Greece tourist beach by horrified passer-by
A young girl was found dead on a beach near the Greek capital of Athens early on Sunday - and authorities are now carrying out investigations to determine what happened to her A little girl has been found dead on a popular beach in Greece by a horrified passer-by. The child, believed to be around two or three years old, was spotted on Eden Beach in Paleo Faliro, near Athens, in the early hours of Sunday. Reports say a man, from Egypt, spotted the girl's body on the shore and called the emergency services. Authorities rushed to the scene, where they located the child, who hasn't been identified so far. Her body was transported to the Agia Sofia Children's Hospital via ambulance, where doctors pronounced her dead. An autopsy will be carried out to determine the girl's cause of death, authorities have said. Greek newspaper Protothema reported that the child was wearing a full-zip bathing suit and was not wearing armbands when she was found. The publication added that there were no obvious signs of abuse on the girl. No child matching her characteristics has been reported missing in the area. Investigations are ongoing to determine the girl's identity and the circumstances of her death. Last week, a British tourist was tragically found dead on his sun lounger on a popular Greek beach after reportedly becoming unwell. The 74-year-old was discovered unconscious on Stalis Beach on the isle of Crete by other people at the resort at around 12pm on Sunday, July 20. Emergency services rushed to the scene and made a desperate bid to revive the man, but unfortunately their efforts proved unsuccessful. It is understood that he had first gone for a swim before returning to the sun lounger and there are reports he had a "strong feeling" of sickness shortly before his death. Paramedics from Hellenic National Center of Emergency Care (EKAB) treated the man at the scene and no cause of death has yet been given by the Greek authorities. An autopsy was due to be carried out, reported It comes after several tragic beach deaths over the last few months involving British citizens on holiday. A 73-year-old man was found dead on a beach in Agia Paraskevi, Skiathos, in Greece. And a 68-year-old lost his life after going swimming and losing consciousness on June 12.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Bus firm owned by former Rangers directors doubles profits
We revealed this week that McGill's, the 'largest independent bus firm in the UK', posted that the earnings rise was partly down to acquisitions. James and Sandy Easdale. (Image: Jeff Holmes/JSHPIX) The Greenock-based firm owned by billionaire brothers Sandy and James Easdale put forward results covering a 'wide and diverse portfolio'. The firm said: 'McGill's Bus Group is Britain's largest independently owned bus company and a pioneer in fleet decarbonisation, with over 110 zero emission electric buses.' Read the full exclusive story here ANALYSIS 📈 Why the case for a 'Scottish visa' just got stronger Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer is sticking to his red lines on Brexit. (Image: PA) At times like these the dogmatic nature of politics must really frustrate people in business. While Sir Keir Starmer sticks to his Government's red lines on Europe – meaning there will be no return to the single market, no re-joining the customs union and no freedom of movement under his watch – the UK's economic prospects will continue to be constrained. This includes in Scotland, which of course voted resoundingly to remain in the European Union in the referendum of 2016, and has been living with the consequences since. But how long can the current state of affairs continue? Starmer has so far resisted calls from the Scottish Government to introduce a "Scottish visa" to help the country deal with the labour shortages it faces, but the issue is simply not going away. Read Scott Wright's analysis here SERIES: THE BARRAS REBORN 🍽️ How The Barras stealthily became Glasgow's most exciting foodie destination The Barras has slowly but surely evolved into one of the city's most exciting foodie destinations. (Image: Newsquest) Whelks, mussels and white sugar-coated doughnuts might well be what first come to mind when you picture food from The Barras Market in Glasgow. None of the above is wrong, with the Loch Fyne Shellfish Bar on London Road celebrating 65 years in business and Danny's Donuts still firing up their fryers every weekend. But elsewhere, thanks to a team who have invested time and effort into curating a line-up of street food vendors unlike any other, The Barras has slowly but surely evolved into one of the city's most exciting foodie destinations. As part of our Barras Reborn series, The Herald sat down with market manager Chris Butler to discuss the influx of independent culinary talent now based in the East End and how this contributes to the shifting identity of a 104-year-old cultural landmark. Read Sarah Campbell's article here AROUND THE GREENS ⛳ Coming soon to a club near you: Golf vending machines A mock-up of what the proposed vending machines might look like (Image: Newsquest) This article appears as part of Kristy Dorsey's Around the Greens series Officials at discount retailer Affordable Golf are sizing up plans to roll out vending machines at clubs across Scotland selling items such as balls and gloves to players who might otherwise be caught short.
