Edinburgh book festival has a few questions to answer
My nose twitched. The eyebrows went skywards, but why?
Here's the Sunday Mail again: 'The book festival said it would be 'spurious' and 'misleading' to suggest any link between Lloyd's appointment and the announcement of the cash, which it said had been planned for months.'
Interesting choice of words there, particularly 'spurious'. It's the kind of ten-dollar word a lawyer might use when a simple 'wrong' would have done. It is there to send a message: nothing to see here folks, so let's all just shuffle on.
Read more
It is true. On the face of it, there is nothing wrong. As the festival said when news of Ms Lloyd's appointment emerged, she was appointed following 'a fully advertised recruitment process'. I could have applied, you could have applied, but we didn't. Moreover, she would bring 'valuable experience in communications, leadership and public affairs'.
It has been more than the regulation two years since Ms Sturgeon and Ms Lloyd held positions in public life, the former as FM and the latter as her strategic adviser. Ms Sturgeon has carried on as an MSP, controversially as she has not been seen much in the Scottish Parliament. Those memoirs won't write themselves, you know.
But Lloyd is different. She is a free agent, able to do what she wants, no permission required or sought. She has every right to earn a living by selling her skills wherever she pleases. Hence the application to the books festival.
The same goes for her appointment to a firm called Flint. On its website, Flint says it 'helps businesses and investors succeed in an increasingly complex world'. Its CEO is James Purnell, former Labour MP, former minister under Blair and Brown, ex-BBC and think-tanker.
Click through and you will eventually meet the Flint team, which now includes Ms Lloyd. Listed as a specialist partner with expertise in devolved administrations, operations team, policy and political analysis, her work for the FM is outlined in glowing terms. It's impressive stuff. She's an impressive woman.
Once again, she's doing nothing wrong. Countless former aides, and elected representatives, have gone the same route, using what they learned in the public sector and applying it in the private. Put your knowledge and experience to work. Everyone who ever progressed in a career has done likewise.
To summarise, Ms Lloyd was appointed a director at the Edinburgh International Book Festival. Nothing wrong in that. She advises businesses and investors using the expertise acquired while working for the First Minister. Nothing wrong in that.
As for her book festival appointment coinciding with the award of a £300k Scottish Government grant, remember the latter had been 'planned for months', according to the event organisers. The Scottish Government said the same thing when it announced the money at the end of June: the deal had been signed off months before by ministers but was not publicised.
What I would like to know, as a taxpayer if nothing else, is exactly when Ms Lloyd was appointed books festival director, and whether anyone at the festival knew that the £300k was in the pipeline.
Why was the Government announcement held back? The money is part of a larger package of help given to the event by the Scottish Government, and there is a lot more to come. Again, were those involved in the appointment of Ms Lloyd aware of this? It's a matter of public record, after all.
Once again, nobody has done anything wrong. That happens a lot in Scotland, particularly when the Scottish Government, and the current administration in particular, is involved. You can pass any number of faces on the stairs, familiar ones like John Swinney, and swear they had a case to answer for something or other, but when it comes to holding them to account, there is nobody there. Ferries, education, NHS waiting times, growth - you name it, no one is taking the blame for failure any time soon.
You will never see any of these faces take the sort of pasting handed out last week to Professor Iain Gillespie, former principal of the University of Dundee, by the Education Committee. Yes, ministers have been questioned, but not like that.
One of the unfortunate principal's mistakes was to fail downwards when the done thing in Scottish public life is to fail upwards. Move on, move up, take the rewards but accept zero blame unless there is no other option. It was and is the Westminster way and it has transferred to the Scottish Parliament.
We'll be seeing it a lot more of this moving on as the elections approach. Get ready to hold your nose as departing MSPs, and their aides, compete for jobs in the public and private sectors. And if the SNP should win a majority again, despite their record, the failing upwards can carry on as normal.
I wonder if Ms Sturgeon will address the subject of failure when her much-anticipated session at the books festival comes to pass. If she is up for it, I would like to hear Ms Lloyd's thoughts as well. Now that she is a festival director and in what they call 'a public-facing role', there shouldn't be a problem. John Swinney too - all are welcome. Until then, I'll keep wrinkling my nose. Bewitched, no. Bothered, plenty.
Alison Rowat is a Herald feature writer and columnist
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Meltdown over Jeremy Corbyn's new party exposed their fear
Indeed, that word, 'meltdown' is becoming the common parlance with which to describe the attitudes and actions of an ailing political and media establishment to events they neither control nor understand. Such lashing out is rarely, if ever, rational. On the one hand, a party led by Jeremy Corbyn – or the 'Magic Grandpa' in the words of the once widely respected Andrew Neil – is surely pie in the sky adventurism. On the other, it poses a substantial threat to the Labour Party, and will float Nigel Farage into Number 10. You could feel the sense of entitlement and relief when Zarah Sultana's announcement of the founding of this new political force was followed by public revelations of some of the internal rifts about how to go about such a project – cue the clapped-out 'People's Front of Judea' jibes. READ MORE: How small Scottish parties are reacting to news of a new Corbyn project There is no point in denying that the backdrop to this development has been partially interrupted by various leaks to the press, before the thing has been formally launched. But all of that is secondary to the underlying fact that there can be no doubt a mass constituency for the kind of politics it represents exists. And it is this reality which adds to the mounting sense of unease, which goes beyond the electoral sphere, among an increasingly brittle ruling class. So much so, that the state has come to proscribe a non-violent protest group as a 'terrorist organisation'. Over the weekend, the Reverend Sue Parfitt (below), 83, was detained for holding a placard which read. 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action,' as a consequence of this. She was, farcically, arrested by Met Police officers for offences under the Terrorism Act. Yes, the same legislation that is purportedly designed to tackle the likes of al-Qaeda. Is this really where Yvette Cooper believes the threat to the people of the United Kingdom comes from? Or, in fact, is it far closer to the truth to say, quite obviously, that this has nothing to do with security and everything to do with clamping down on Palestine solidarity activism? Consider for a moment, that had Sue been holding a sign saying 'I support genocide', she would be free to do so. Every part of the movement has encountered the sharp end of the state, not just those who have taken part in direct action. Leading figures in the Stop the War Coalition and the Palestine Solidarity Campaign have also been arrested and charged for organising huge demonstrations, no matter how peaceful they were and are. This, of course, is not the sign of a confidence, but of grave weakness. It could not be more serious. Whatever is said in public, the UK Government knows full well the scale of the atrocities in Gaza, and their participation in it. They can take losing an argument about sundry domestic affairs. But here we are talking about genocide, the worst of all crimes against humanity. It is quite simple: they cannot allow for there to be a popular, impactful and organised current of opposition which, crucially, is determined to hold those responsible to account. READ MORE: Freedom Flotilla Coalition to launch new aid ship to Gaza Don't for a second underestimate just how upending this is for our society. So much so that the government are willing, in a fit of reactionary panic, to shred civil liberties and rights in the process of defending their position on the matter, while demonising their opponents. Any student of history knows it never ends well for the powerful when they overplay their hand. When there is a need to resort to force and repression, it only underlines the fact that the ideological line has irrevocably collapsed. Some have a keener sense of this than others, such as The Times, whose editorial stance is to oppose applying terrorist status to Palestine Action. There is, then, a sense of desperation and hysteria about it all. Which is where we return to the potential of a left party. Because it is this issue which has generated the conditions for rupture with the Labour Party, and the politicisation of a whole new generation of campaigners. Meanwhile, the links between imperial foreign policy and declining living standards are being made in the process. In the same way as extra-parliamentary protest has been demonised, a party which could represent it in parliament will be smeared and shunned. READ MORE: Lisa Nandy aide 'drafted note saying BBC is institutionally antisemitic' That is one of many reasons why developments around party formation must be hand in glove with the mass movements which give rise to the political atmosphere required to launch such an initiative in the first place. Corbyn would never have become leader of the Labour Party had it not been for the anti-war and anti-austerity campaigns. And the same is true today for any emerging electoral vehicle. This means a break not just with the Labour Party, but also with the Labourism which elevates parliamentary politics above all else. Overcoming the notion that working-class organisation and social movements are subordinate to electoralism and elections is not an optional extra. It also means learning from experience, and in Scotland, treating the differences in the political terrain here seriously. I will offer some perspectives on these issues in the coming weeks and months. Politics today is fluid, and explosions in activity and insurgency can come into the scene quickly. We have seen this on the radical right with the rise of Reform. But these things can also go up like a rocket and down like a stick. Creating lasting organisation in not easy. It requires clarity of ideas; the ability to navigate a complex period; internal cohesion and much else. But the big picture is that the foundations of politics are changing. Boxed in, shrill and dogmatic, the status quo seem ill-equipped to deal with this and with the multi-dimensional crises they are wedded to. Perhaps that is the one constant in an otherwise volatile and unpredictable world. So expect more meltdowns, at the very least.
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Less than third of electric buses funded by SNP scheme built in Scotland as 400 workers lose jobs
Only 162 of the 523 - 31 per cent - buses ordered under the Scottish Zero Emission Bus challenge fund were made in the country. Less than a third of buses funded by an SNP Government scheme were built in Scotland. Only 162 of the 523 - 31 per cent - vehicles ordered under the Scottish Zero Emission Bus challenge fund were made in the country. Some 361 were made outside of Scotland, with 287 - 55 per cent - made in China. This is higher than the 183 made in the whole of the UK. Alexander Dennis, which is in the process of closing its factories in Falkirk and centralising down south, received orders for 153 buses (29 per cent). Labour's Falkirk MP Euan Stainbank said: 'The SNP talks a lot about a green industrial revolution, but when it comes to backing Scottish jobs, their recent record tells a different story. "We've got world-class engineers building zero-emission buses right here in Falkirk—but instead of supporting them, this government is sending public money and opportunity overseas. "Nearly three-quarters of the buses in these schemes weren't built in Scotland. That's an insult to the workers at Alexander Dennis and to everyone fighting to keep heavy industry alive in our communities.' Bosses at Alexander Dennis launched a consultation last month on plans to shutter the plants at Camelon and Larbert and centralise production in Scarborough. The move would end a century of bus building in the Falkirk district and comes just weeks after the oil refinery at nearby Grangemouth was shut down, with 400 jobs lost. Stainbank continued: 'This is about more than just numbers. Every bus built in Falkirk supports skilled manufacturing jobs, apprenticeships, and local supply chains. " Alexander Dennis, one of the last remaining heavy manufacturers in the region, recently entered a consultation affecting 400 jobs. The firm has repeatedly warned of the risks posed by an uneven playing field in procurement policy, concerns that I have raised persistently in my role as Co-Chair of the British Buses APPG 'We cannot continue with ministers leaving Scottish taxpayers are footing the bill to support overseas industry, while those same taxpayers here are facing redundancy. It's time for a serious shift in approach.' Glasgow Labour MSP Paul Sweeney - who obtained the figures through a written question - said: 'The numbers speak for themselves. Of the 523 electric buses funded through the Scottish Government subsidy scheme, more than two thirds, 340 buses, have been manufactured overseas, with 287 made in China by Yutong, while only 162 buses have been manufactured in Scotland by ADL and EVM. 'What is particularly concerning is that the Scottish Government does not even collect data on where the buses are manufactured. It is clear that the Scottish Government's social value weighting in public procurement is not fit for purpose, and it needs to be bolstered to support critical manufacturers in Scotland rather than subsidising foreign competitors trying to put hundreds of skilled Scottish workers out of a job." A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'We are exploring all viable options throughout the consultation period to allow the firm to retain their hard-working employees and manufacturing and production facilities at Falkirk and Larbert. 'Since 2020, ADL secured orders for more zero emission buses than any other single manufacturer through the Scottish Zero Emission Bus Challenge Fund and its predecessor the Scottish Ultra Low Emission Bus Scheme. " ADL has received £58 million of Scottish Government subsidy for vehicles under these programmes. ADL have secured orders for more than 360 vehicles through Scottish Government zero emission bus funding programmes, compared to the 160 currently on order from Manchester.'
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Scots MP calls for tighter social media regulation after 'online knife crime glamorisation'
Kayden Moy was found with serious injuries at Irvine beach on May 17. A Labour MP has called for a stop to the "very real glamorisation of knife crime online", following the death of Scots teenager Kayden Moy. Kayden, 16, was found with serious injuries at Irvine beach on May 17. The East Kilbride teen was rushed to hospital but sadly died a short time later. Three teenagers, one aged 14 and two aged 17, have been charged in connection with his death. On Monday, during Home Office Questions at Westminster, Joani Reid - MP for East Kilbride and Strathaven - raised the issue of knife crime being glorified on social media. It comes amid the Record's applauded Our Kids ... Our Future campaign which was launched two years ago in response to a youth violence epidemic. As part of the campaign, we have repeatedly demanded for online tech giants to enforce fully their policies on tackling harmful content such as videos of young people attacking others. Ms Reid said: "Six weeks ago, Kayden Moy, a 16-year-old boy from East Kilbride in my constituency, was stabbed to death, leaving his family bereft and a community - my community - in grief. "Since Kayden's tragic death, I have received multiple videos and images of local youths posing while wielding machetes in their own homes, but the police claim that they are powerless to take any action whatever. "Does the Minister agree that much more needs to be done to stop the very real glamorisation of knife crime online, and to prevent social media from being a breeding ground for youth violence?" The minister expressed her condolences to Kayden's family and friends. She continued: "My hon. Friend is absolutely right about the role that social media can play in glamorising these types of weapons. "That is why it is so important that we have measures in the Crime and Policing Bill and the Online Safety Act 2023 to start to tackle that. As I say, it is absolutely appalling." Afterwards, Reid pledged to continue to press the issue. She added: 'Kayden's death was a tragedy for his family and a shock to the whole of East Kilbride. The worrying fact is that knife crime is rising across Scotland, even in schools, and we need to mobilise as a community to bring it under control. 'I have been sent numerous videos by concerned and frightened constituents of boys and young men posing in their bedrooms with dangerous knives and blades. The social media companies refuse to act, and the police say they have not got the power to act. But there can be no excuses for doing nothing when we all know this bravado leads on to violence. 'I will use the summer weeks to press social media companies, public authorities and the Scottish government to get their act together on knife crime and to insist we get real action and not more excuses.' As part of the Our Kids ... Our Future campaign, the Record have repeatedly demanded the Scottish Government to invest in young people, so they can be nurtured, mentored and guided in every community. Last month, Glasgow's council leader Susan Aitken described the tragic deaths of three teenagers to knife crime as 'a warning sign' in an emergency meeting on youth violence. Scotland has been rocked by three blade tragedies in less than 12 months. Alongside Kayden, Amen Teklay, an Eritrean refugee, died after being found seriously injured in Maryhill on March 5. Kory McCrimmon, 16, died after being attacked with a blade in Greenfield Park on May 31, 2024. A 14-year-old boy was sentenced to five years for the culpable homicide of Kory. The issue was brought before the full council after a powerful march on Sunday June 22 by the family of Kory McCrimmon. His grieving parents, leading the Parents Against Knives campaign, told the country "enough is enough" and demanded action from leaders in Holyrood. City leader Susan Aitken said the three deaths showed there was a growing problem with youth violence in Scotland. She said: 'If some of our young people are being drawn into violence by anti-social behaviou r that negatively affects them and the wider public then that's a problem and we need to address it. 'If other young folk are so fearful of being affected by violence that they themselves need to carry blades, that's a cycle we need to break.' Scotland's justice secretary has pledged an additional £6m to tackle youth violence after the latest summit. Cabinet Secretary Angela Constance announced the move last month and will come next year as part of the Scottish Government's Cashback for Communities Fund. Constance went on to admit there is little she can say to comfort the parents of the boys involved in all three tragedies. She said: "I know there is probably little I can say to comfort grieving families. "I also know from my direct engagement with families of victims who have suffered a fatality that what they want more than anything, is to know that this won't happen to any other families. "They also want to know that the risk of this happening to others is reduced. "That's why we are so focused on prevention because that is the best and most effective way to prevent other families from facing this." Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
