Teenage footballer who died in M60 tragedy pictured as sister pays tribute
A sister has told of her "jokey and protective" 15-year-old brother in a tribute after he tragically died on a motorway.
Emergency services were called to a stretch of the M60 ring road around Manchester near junction 20 for Blackley last Sunday (July 20) but they could not save Israel Iyabor. Greater Manchester Police (GMP) said they were called to reports of a "concern for welfare" and that a teenager, later confirmed to be Israel, died at the scene. His 17 year-old sister has now opened up on her family's grief after they launched an appeal to raise funds for his funeral. She described Israel as a "class clown" but a "very protective person."
"He was protective of those close to him and those he loved" she said. "He would do anything for them and to protect them. "He was also very light-hearted and jokey. He never took himself too seriously. At school he was known as the class clown."
Israel, from Middleton and who also has a 19-year-old brother, was a pupil at Co-op Academy North Manchester and was part of the youth setup at Hyde United FC. He also played for Manchester Panthers JFC.
"He was very talented at football, he also liked to box and liked to go to the gym and do taekwando" his sister said. "He was very athletic, very sporty."
His sister said that the family were 'hysterical' when they informed of the tragedy. "When police broke the news we were very emotional. It was such a shock."
She said Israel was very close to his mother who had been left bereft. "She couldn't believe it" she said, reported the Manchester Evening News. "She was so shocked. We all are. Even now I am still shocked and trying to wrap my head around the whole thing. I sometimes catch myself thinking about him, or something reminds me of him, and I get emotional."
"I feel people should check in on there loved ones" she added. "Mental thing is a real thing. A lot of people do struggle. And you never know what someone is going through." The family have now started a GoFundMe page as they seek to raise funds for the 'dignified burial that he deserves.'
The page says: "With heavy hearts, we share the devastating loss of Israel, who was a very integral part of the lives he touched. Israel was a son, brother and most importantly a friend. Israel would often be described as a very light hearted, jokey and full of ambition. He was a comedic and care free person.
"He relentlessly wore his heart on his sleeve. He was a shoulder to cry for those around him. It's heartbreaking that he only had such a short but impactful and unforgettable time on earth with us. He had a deep love for sports, specifically martial arts and football, which he excelled at.
"He also had a deep devotion for his faith, actively participating in church and being involved within the youth sector at church. Although, his life came to an abrupt end, he touched many hearts whilst on earth. His death was shocking and unimaginable as he was such a big part of the community around him including his school, football team and friends and family.
"Many teachers, friends, family have been left distraught by his abrupt death. He was truly a shining start and his memory will live on in all the lives he touched. We are now reaching out for support asking to be able to provide him with the dignified farewell that he deserves.
"Our goal is to be able to fund the costs for his funeral, burial and memorial and support our family during such a devastating and distressing time. Any amount you can give, no matter how small, will make a difference in our life and he deeply appreciated. If you are unable to give please consider sharing this page to bring awareness."
Police have passed a file to the coroner with an inquest expected to be opened in due course. An array of flowers and football shirts have been left near the scene of the tragedy.
Hyde United held a minute's silence in his honour before their match against Curzon Ashton on Tuesday night. "Israel was more than just a talented young footballer — he was an influential, bubbly character whose energy, smile, and love for the game lit up every training session and matchday" the club said in a statement.
"His coaches describe him as an absolute joy to coach and a privilege to watch on the pitch. Hyde United sends its deepest condolences to Israel's family, friends, teammates, and everyone who had the pleasure of knowing him. He will be deeply missed by all at the club. Rest in peace, Israel."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
6 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Iran's Supreme Leader 'sleeping and getting high' as Ayatollah threatens Israel's existence from hidden bunker
Iran 's Supreme Leader spends his days 'sleeping and high on substances' in his hidden bunker, according to insiders within Israel 's national intelligence agency. A Mossad-linked X account last week shared the new information on Ayatollah Ali Khamenei in a series of attacks on his leadership. 'How can a leader lead when they sleep half the day and spend the other half high on substances? Water, electricity, life!' the account wrote. 'Consuming drugs and conversing with spirits are not desirable traits for someone leading a country,' a second post read earlier this month. It comes after Israel's Defense Minister Israel Katz warned Khamenei to stop threatening the existence of his people from his underground bunker. 'I want to convey a clear message to Khamenei the dictator,' Katz recently said. 'If you continue to threaten Israel, our long arm will again reach Tehran and with even greater force — and this time to you personally. Do not threaten, lest you be harmed.' A ceasefire has been in place between Israel and Iran since late June, following days of fiery attacks from both sides after Israel's surprise strikes wiped out top Iranian military figures and nuclear scientists. At the height of the 12-day conflict, there were widespread reports that Khamenei was hiding out in a bunker amid increased concerns for his safety. At this point, Israel had dismantled and destroyed Khamenei's senior network, wiping out key leaders and allies of the Supreme Leader. Mohammad Bagheri, the commander in chief of Iran's military and second highest commander after Khamenei, was among the first casualties identified after the strikes. Hossein Salami, commander in chief of the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps was also killed, along with Gholamali Rashid, the deputy commander in chief of the armed forces. General Amir Ali Hajizadeh, the head of the airspace unit of the Revolutionary Guards, Gen. Gholamreza Mehrabi, the deputy intelligence chief of the Armed Forces and Gen. Davood Sheikhian, the commander of air defense, were also wiped out. Simultaneously, bombs exploded at the homes of nine scientists, killing them instantly and at the same time. While the Mossad has not formally confirmed the X account's affiliation, two intelligence agents recently said the account appears authentic. 'Some of the information it has shared could only have come from Mossad,' said Beny Sabti, an Iran expert at Israel's Institute for National Security Studies. The accountholder urges supports who are 'contacting us through private messages, for your own security, please ensure you are using a VPN.' Khamenei has been accused of abusing drugs in the past, despite declaring illicit substances 'un-Islamic' in 1979 after the Iranian Revolution. Iranians face the death penalty for drug related offenses. In 2022, an Iranian academic publicly claimed the Supreme Leader had a drug habit. 'Many viewers do not know this, but Khamenei himself uses drugs,' Nour Mohamed Omara told a television station in Turkey at the time. 'He has a special village in Balochistan, where the drugs used by the leader are produced,' the academic added. 'This village is run by the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and no one is allowed in.' The same Mossad-linked account has been making efforts to reach and communicate with Iranians who are increasingly disenfranchised with their leadership. After the 12-day Iran-Israel war, the account posted: 'A ceasefire has been put into effect. Now, the extent of the damage is becoming clear. At this moment, the regime is focused on its senior officials, not on caring for its citizens. 'We stand with you and have formed a team of specialized doctors, including experts in cardiology, diabetes. pulmonary diseases, infectious diseases, oncology, as well as support for pregnant women and psychological assistance.' The account warned Iranians interested in utilizing the services to contact them via a VPN for their own safety.
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Freedom Flotilla activist ship crew are 'detained and questioned by Israeli authorities' after vessel arrives in Ashdod port
The Freedom Flotilla activist ship crew have been 'detained and questioned by Israeli authorities' after the vessel arrived in Ashdod port. It comes after the pro-Palestinian campaign group's boat heading towards Gaza was intercepted by Israeli forces on Saturday. A livestream broadcast by the organisation showed the soldiers taking control of the 'Handala' vessel. Meanwhile, the 21 activists onboard could be seen sitting on the ship's deck, holding their hands up and whistling the Italian anti-fascist song 'Bella Ciao'. The Handala had been on course to try to break an Israeli naval blockade of Gaza and bring a small quantity of humanitarian aid to the territory's Palestinian residents. An online tracking tool set up to plot the boat's path showed its position as around 30 miles from the Egyptian coast and roughly 60 miles west of Gaza when intercepted. Among its passengers is British citizen and ex-United Nations development officer, Chloe Ludden. And now, the Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) behind the vessel has given an update on its course. They have said the boat is now at the Israeli port of Ashdod, where the activists are consulting with their lawyers, who were there ready to meet them. Brazilian activist Thiago Avila, who was a passenger on the previous Freedom Flotilla, Madleen, posted the update clip to X on Sunday evening. The Madleen was similarly intercepted by the Israeli army in international waters on June 9 and also towed to Ashdod. It carried 12 campaigners on board, including prominent Swedish activist Greta Thunberg. These activists were eventually expelled by Israel. Reposted by the FFC, Mr Avila's post said: 'A quick and important update about the 21 people kidnapped by Israel on board the Handala a few hours ago. 'They arrived in Ashdod port and our team of lawyers from the Adalah Group [Palestinian-run legal centre in Israel] of Palestinians from 48 [Palestinians who had Israeli citizenship conferred on them after the 1948 war] are there to meet them. 'Our lawyers, they're experts on that, they were the ones who brought us home when we were kidnapped on the Madleen. 'And they are there waiting for them, trying to talk to them already. Reposted by the FFC, Mr Avila's post said: 'A quick and important update about the 21 people kidnapped by Israel on board the Handala [pictured departing Gallipoli Port in Italy on July 20] a few hours ago' 'And it's very important that we share this because we know how Israel works, how much they try to confuse people. 'They lie to people, they try to confuse their governments, the media and people everywhere. 'So, it's very important that we share and support this moment right now. 'It's very important that we share their SOS videos, that we share their call to actions for a hunger strike, to go to demonstrations, to take to the streets.' After the Israeli military intercepted the Handala on Saturday, the FFC posted to X: 'Before interception, the 21 crew made this statement: if attacked they will join the global hunger strike for Gaza.' Mr Avila continued: 'So many places are already organising demonstrations so here in London, we have a demonstration, I'm going to Bristol for another demonstration as well. 'In many, many countries, there are demonstrations coming out and it's very important that we support that. 'Right now, we are in a decisive moment. 'You remember on the Madleen that they probably are going to be taken to the Givon prison [in the city of Ramla, between West Jerusalem and Tel Aviv] and they're going to be separated and yes, usually it happens like this. 'And it's very important that we keep our eyes on that, visbility and safety, and that we mobilise. 'Echo the voices of the Palestinian people, expose the genocide, forced starvation, and mobilise.' Handala crew members have been interrogated by Israeli authorities, the Israel Broadcasting Authority has reported, and will be transferred to police. The Israeli Foreign Ministry has previously said attempts to break Israel's blockade of the Gaza Strip are dangerous, illegal and undercut humanitarian work. One of the Handala's passengers, American human rights defender Huwaida Arraf, has said she was released by Israeli authorities after refusing to sign a pledge not to return again. She has called for renewed attention to lifting the siege on Gaza, Al Jazeera reports. Some 11 other activists who were onboard the Handala reportedly remain detained by Israeli authorities - and it is said they have gone on hunger strike. Meanwhile, the FFC has said in a statement the boat had been 'violently intercepted' around 40 nautical miles from Gaza, with all crew detained and the cargo seized, France 24 reports. 'All cargo was non-military, civilian and intended for direct distribution to a population facing deliberate starvation and medical collapse under Israel's illegal blockade', the group added. Israel's Foreign Ministry posted on X early on Sunday morning: 'The Israeli navy has stopped the vessel Navarn [registry name of Handala] from illegally entering the maritime zone of the coast of Gaza. 'The vessel is safely making its way to the shores of Israel. All passengers are safe.' The passengers' lawyers, from legal centre Adalah, have said in a statement: 'The flotilla never entered Israeli territorial waters, nor was it intended to do so.' They continued: 'It was headed toward the territorial waters of the State of Palestine, as recognized under international law. 'Israel has no legal jurisdiction or authority over the international waters in which the vessel was sailing.' Adalah has demanded the immediate release of the passengers and disclosure of the activists' location and legal status. It comes after a seemingly pre-prepared video of British passenger Chloe Ludden was posted by the Freedom Flotilla Coalition (FFC) on its X account late on Saturday night. Captioned, 'SOS! The crew on "Handala" have been kidnapped by Israeli Occupation forces', she says in the clip on the social media platform: 'Hello everyone. 'My name is Chloe Ludden, from the United Kingdom. If you are seeing this video, we have been intercepted at sea and I have been abducted by the Israeli occupation forces or forces of a country complicit in Israel's genocide of Palestinians. 'I appeal to my comrades, friends and family, to everyone, to please put pressure on the United Kingdom's government to demand my release and the release of everyone onboard the "Handala" as soon as possible. Thank you.' The post calls for followers to email and tag the British Foreign Office. In another message on social media, the Freedom Flotilla Coalition declared: '"Handala" has been intercepted and boarded illegally by Israeli forces whilst in international waters.' There was no immediate confirmation of the operation from the Israeli military. But earlier in the day it had announced it would enforce 'the legal maritime security blockade on the Gaza Strip'. Posts of a similar format to Ms Ludden's were made for each of the passengers on the Handala, which includes European politicians and two Al Jazeera journalists. It comes after the British national posted to her own X account on Tuesday: 'Currently on the Handala Flotilla sailing to Gaza after resigning from the UN. 'We must stop asking for permission to enter a death camp. I did not leave the United Nations to abandon its founding principles. I left to live them, to act on them. 'The UN Charter stands for the dignity, freedom, and security of all peoples. So why, when these very rights are being obliterated, do we still see no meaningful response? 'This is a genocide. That is not just rhetoric - it is supported by reports, testimonies, and lived reality. 'And yet, no real consequences have followed. My resignation is not an act of walking away. It is an act of stepping up. 'Because human dignity is not protected by procedures alone, but by personal and institutional courage. 'When we carry food and medicine to Palestinians in Gaza and are told to turn back, it's not just a failure of politics. It's a failure of our moral architecture. 'This flotilla is not a threat. And Gaza is not a "crisis" to be managed. Palestine is a mirror - reflecting both our humanity and the failure of our institutions to uphold it. 'To those still within the United Nations and other bodies: This responsibility is not only for activists, for those outside. You hold tools. You have a voice. 'Stop waiting for the perfect mandate to do what is already right. 'Neutrality in the face of mass death is not diplomacy. It is abandonment. Let Gaza live. Let the mirror change us.' Ms Ludden previously worked as a scientist for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the UN's body for the science around climate change. Two French MPs, Emma Fourreau and Gabrielle Cathala, were among those detained on the Handala on Saturday. Their party leader, Jean-Luc Melenchon of France Unbowed (LFI), condemned Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netayahu. 'Netanyahu's thugs boarded Handala. They attack 21 unarmed people in territorial waters where they have no right. 'A kidnapping in which two French parliamentarians are victims', he posted on X. Mr Melenchon demanded the French government take action. Thiago Avila, a Brazilian activist who had been onboard the last FFC boat sent to Gaza, the Madleen, posted about the Handala's interception late on Saturday evening. He said: 'The Handala has just been illegally intercepted by the Zionist entity of Israel while carrying baby formula to starving children.' Gaza is facing severe shortages of food and other essentials, with the UN and NGOs warning of an imminent famine. The Handala's crew said in a post on X they would go on a hunger strike if the Israeli army intercepted the boat and detained its passengers. The Madleen was intercepted by the Israeli army in international waters on June 9 and towed to the Israeli port of Ashdod. It carried 12 campaigners on board, including prominent Swedish activist Greta Thunberg. These activists were eventually expelled by Israel. The interception of the Handala comes after Israel 's military said air drops of aid will begin on Saturday night in Gaza and humanitarian corridors will be established for UN convoys. It has yet to outline when the corridors would open or where - but added it is prepared to implement humanitarian pauses in densely populated areas. Gaza's population of more than two million people is facing severe shortages of food and other essentials after some 21 months of war - particularly after Israel enacted a more than two-month-long blockade of the embattled Strip from March until May. Previously, the UN condemned Israel's 'weaponisation of food' in Gaza, labelling it a war crime. And on Monday, the UK, France and more than twenty other Western-aligned countries issued labelling Israel's operations 'unacceptable'. It comes after the UN's human rights office reported Israeli forces had killed more than 1,000 Palestinians trying to get food at aid distribution points since the US - and Israel-backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) - started its operations in late May. GHF rejected the statistics, describing them as 'false and exaggerated statistics' from the UN. An anonymous Israeli security official claimed Hamas were responsible for fabricating 'cynical' reports of mass starvation in Gaza to The Times of Israel. Now, Sir Keir Starmer confirmed in a call with French and German counterparts the UK is working with Jordan on plans to air drop aid into Gaza and evacuate children needing medical assistance. In emergency talks held with Emmanuel Macron and Friedrich Merz on Saturday amid mounting global anger at the humanitarian conditions in Gaza, the leaders agreed it would be 'vital' to ensure 'robust plans' for an 'urgently-needed ceasefire'. 'The Prime Minister set out how the UK will also be taking forward plans to work with partners such as Jordan to air drop aid and evacuate children requiring medical assistance', a Downing Street spokesperson said. But the head of the UN's Palestinian refugee agency warned airdrops were 'a distraction and screensmoke' that would fail to reverse deepening starvation in Gaza, and could in some cases harm civilians. UNRWA chief Philippe Lazzarini said: 'A man-made hunger can only be addressed by political will. 'Lift the siege, open the gates and guarantee safe movements and dignified access to people in need.' Charities operating in Gaza have said Israel's blockade and ongoing military offensive are pushing people there towards starvation. They have warned they are seeing their own workers and Palestinians 'waste away'. Mr Lazzarini also said airdrops can be dangerous as they can fall on civilians and being able to drive aid through is more effective and safer. 'Airdrops will not reverse the deepening starvation. They are expensive, inefficient and can even kill starving civilians,' he said. 'It is a distraction and screen smoke.' No 10 said the leaders had committed to 'work closely together on a plan' to 'pave the way to a long-term solution and security in the region'. It added once proposals had been 'worked up', it will seek to advance them with other key partners. But Downing Street's recent statement made no mention of the issue of Palestinian statehood, after French President Mr Macron confirmed his country would do so in September. The Prime Minister has faced calls to immediately recognise Palestine's sovereignty, with around 221 MPs from across the political spectrum signing a letter pressuring the Government to follow suit at a UN meeting next week. It comes as Israeli airstrikes and gunshots killed at least 53 people on Friday night into Saturday, with most shot dead while seeking aid, according to Palestinian health officials and the local ambulance service. Israeli gunfire was reported twice within hours close to the Zikim crossing, and least a dozen people were killed while waiting for aid trucks in the first incident, staff at a Shifa hospital said. Israel's military said it fired warning shots to distance a crowd 'in response to an immediate threat' and it was not aware of any casualties. A witness, Sherif Abu Aisha, said people started running when they saw a light that they thought was from aid trucks. But as they neared, they realised it was Israel's tanks - and the army began to open fire, killing several people including his uncle, he said. 'We went because there is no food... and nothing was distributed', he said. Israeli forces also killed at least 11 people and wounded 120 others when they fired toward crowds who tried to get food from an entering UN convoy on Saturday evening. 'We are expecting the numbers to surge in the next few hours,' Dr. Mohamed Abu Selmiyah, director of Shifa hospital said. There was no immediate Israeli military comment. Elsewhere, those killed in strikes included four people in an apartment building in Gaza City, hospital staff and the ambulance service said. Another Israeli strike killed at least eight, including four children, in a crowded tent camp of Muwasi in the southern city of Khan Younis, according to the Nasser hospital. Elsewhere in Khan Younis, Israeli forces opened fire and killed at least nine people trying to get aid entering Gaza through the Morag corridor, according to the hospital's morgue records. Palestinian woman Warda Mattar feeds her newborn dates, instead of milk, amidst food scarcity and lack of milk, at a school where they shelter in Nuseirat in the central Gaza Strip February 25, 2024 More than 100 international aid organisations and human rights groups issued a joint letter blaming Israel for the deteriorating situation There was no immediate comment from Israel's military. Earlier this week, 111 aid agencies, including including Doctors Without Borders (MSF) and Oxfam signed an open letter warning of 'mass starvation' spreading in Gaza, as the population was 'wasting away'. 'With supplies now totally depleted, humanitarian organisations are witnessing their own colleagues and partners waste away before their eyes. 'The government of Israel's restrictions, delays, and fragmentation under its total siege have created chaos, starvation, and death', it read. The UN as well as experts have said Palestinians in Gaza are at risk of famine as children with no preexisting conditions have begun to starve to death. 'We only want enough food to end our hunger,' said Wael Shaaban at a charity kitchen in Gaza City as he tried to feed his family of six. The Israeli military says it is allowing aid into the enclave with no limit on the trucks entering. But the UN claims it has been hindered by military restrictions on movements as well as criminal looting. 'We only want enough food to end our hunger,' said Wael Shaaban at a charity kitchen in Gaza City as he tried to feed his family of six. Pictured: Internally displaced Palestinians gather in a charity kitchen to receive limited rations amid food shortages in Nuseirat Palestinian refugee camp in the Gaza Strip on July 26, 2025 The Gaza police force had previously provided security for aid delivery but it has been unable to operate after months of being Israeli airstrikes. Israel on Saturday said more than 250 trucks carrying aid from the UN and other organisations entered Gaza this week, with around 600 trucks entered per day during the latest ceasefire that Israel, which ended in March. 'Stand for Gaza, for silence is a crime, and indifference is a betrayal of humanity,' said Father Issa Thaljieh, a Greek Orthodox priest at the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem, as religious figures and the mayor called for prayers to end the war. More than 59,700 Palestinians have been killed during the war, according to Gaza's Health Ministry. Its count does not distinguish between militants and civilians but the ministry says more than half of the dead are women and children. The ministry operates under the Hamas government but the UN and other international organizations see it as the most reliable source of data on casualties. The Foreign Office has been contacted for comment. By Brendan Carlin for the Mail on Sunday The harrowing human face of the mounting humanitarian crisis in Gaza was laid bare last night. Palestinian children were pictured holding out empty pots in a desperate plea for food. They jostled with adults and other youngsters in an effort to get a share of donated food in a community kitchen in Gaza City. And inside a school sheltering displaced families, also in the region's capital, a mother was shown caring for her two disabled sons, aged four and six, who now faced what was said to be 'life-threatening severe malnutrition'. The graphic images emerged as Sir Keir Starmer appealed to Israel to allow more aid in over land and revealed the UK was 'working with Jordan to get aid into Gaza'. Separately, Irish singer and activist Bob Geldof accused Israeli authorities of 'lying' in saying that Hamas terrorists – not Israel – are responsible for the food shortages. Last week, an Israeli government spokesman said: 'In Gaza today, there's no famine caused by Israel – there is a man-made shortage, but it's been engineered by Hamas.' But in an interview to be broadcast on Sky News today, the Live Aid organiser said 'the Israeli authorities are lying'. He added: 'They're dangling food in front of starving, panicked, exhausted mothers.'
Telegraph
21 hours ago
- Telegraph
Israeli soldiers and generals are turning their back on Netanyahu over Gaza
Ron Fiener looks philosophical as he points to where the bullet struck the side of his helmet, knocking him off his feet. Just a few millimetres difference and he would have been killed, like six of his comrades were when they walked into a house in southern Lebanon last October, believing – wrongly – that it had already been checked for terrorists. 'It was a really horrible day,' the 26-year-old recalled. 'They opened the door, and behind the door were two Hezbollah fighters who immediately started firing with their rifles. Four soldiers died immediately.' Mr Fiener, a captain in Israel's 933rd Nahal Brigade, acquitted himself well, picking himself up and dragging wounded colleagues to safety as the battle raged for five hours. It was his destiny, having dreamed of becoming – like his father – an infantry officer for the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) since he was a child. It is a role which carries elite status in Israel and has been the foundation stone for many a stellar business or political career. But he now chooses a different path. He is refusing to report for another stint of reserve duty and a potential deployment to Gaza, in disgust at the ongoing war that has killed more than 59,000 Palestinians, according to the Hamas-run health ministry. He said: 'When the bombing of Gaza started again, it became clear to me that our government wants to make this war as long as they can – they don't want to end it. 'I knew then I can't go back to serving in this war.' Sentenced to 25 days in jail by Israel for refusing to serve, Mr Fiener is believed to be part of a growing wave of young Israeli reservists who feel they can no longer participate in their country's war in Gaza. The majority are not showing up to call-ups, either 'forgetting' to check their emails or pleading medical or family emergencies. Mr Fiener believes the images of starving children inside Gaza will mean fewer soldiers will turn up. Immense pressure has been building on Israel over the dire humanitarian conditions inside the strip, with aid agencies warning of mass malnutrition and widespread hunger. France on Thursday said it would more to recognise Palestine as a state. On Sunday the IDF said it was introducing a 'tactical pause' in fighting in some areas of Gaza. Mr Fiener's opinion on the futility of the conflict appears to be shared by a rising number of serving and retired senior officers who are turning against Benjamin Netanyahu's war. Gen Assaf Orion, the former head of strategic planning at the IDF, said while there were clear strategic goals in the Israel campaigns against Iran and Hezbollah in Lebanon, there was no longer any clear military imperative for the continuation of military operations in Gaza. He told The Telegraph: 'In Gaza, I suspect that the strategic train of ends, ways and means was kidnapped by ulterior motives. 'I think the main reason for a prolonged war in Gaza is political expediency.' Eran Etzion, a former deputy head of Israel's national security council, was even blunter. He said: 'By now it has long been clear to most Israelis that the main reason the Gaza campaign lingers on is because of Netanyahu's political, personal and judicial interests, and he needs the war to go on in order to sustain and even enhance his grip on power.' Many believe Mr Netenyahu fears his government will collapse if the war ended as ultra-nationalist parties in his coalition would abandon him. 'That's the main reason. It has nothing to do with Hamas and everything to do with Netanyahu.' Many believe Mr Netenyahu fears his government will collapse if the war ended as ultra-nationalist parties in his coalition would abandon him. If even some of the spate of leaks from Israel's security cabinet are to be believed, the scepticism is not confined to retired generals. Lt Gen Eyal Zamir, the IDF's chief of staff, is said to have argued that there is little more to be gained by continuing the campaign – particularly without risking the lives of the approximately 20 remaining living hostages. Although degraded into a series of, in effect, independent guerrilla units, Hamas continues to fight amid the rubble, sending a stream of IDF body bags back to Israel. Mr Netanyahu insists that Hamas must not just be broken as a military and governing force, but eradicated entirely, arguing at the same time that the best way to secure a hostage deal is to fight even harder. Israel's negotiating team returned home from Doha empty-handed this weekend, amid widespread pessimism that a deal will be agreed any time soon. The Jewish state's reputation on the international stage is in crisis, with traditional allies such as Britain, France, Canada and Australia queuing up to condemn the escalating reports of starvation. Professional servants of democratically elected leaders, like Lt Gen Zamir and those under him, are caught in the middle. This was perhaps best demonstrated this month by his opposition to a scheme of Israel Katz, the defence minister, to order the entire civilian population of Gaza into a so-called ' humanitarian city ' built on the ruins of the southern city of Rafah. The military chief was reportedly anxious to protect his officers from potential complicity in a war crime, amid outrage that the zone – described by former prime minister Ehud Olmert as resembling a ' concentration camp ' – could be a precursor to forced population transfer. It would also put his troops, who would ultimately police the perimeter and facilitate the entry of aid, under significant practical pressure. The military was further worried that Hamas would interpret the humanitarian city as a signal that Israel wanted to restart fighting after the proposed initial 60-day ceasefire, thus threatening a potential deal. The IDF leadership earned the ire of Mr Netanyahu by reporting the project could take a year and cost $4bn. While the Israeli prime minister demanded a 'shorter, cheaper, more practical' plan, it is not clear whether the initiative will ever take place. The scheme may have been too much for senior generals who are already deeply unhappy about the position their troops have been placed in under the new US-backed aid system. The UN accuses the IDF of killing more than 1,000 civilians near the new aid distribution sites in Gaza. According to multiple videos and eyewitness testimony, crowd flow in and near these sites is extremely poor, and Israeli soldiers, who provide an outer ring of security for the American contractors, open fire if Palestinians come too close. In one heated security cabinet exchange, Lt Gen Zamir reportedly forced an ultra-nationalist minister to watch a video of an incident showing how close aid seekers came to his soldiers. The IDF has now captured 75 per cent of the Gaza Strip – the goal when it began Operation Gideon's Chariot, which started in May. Last week, it pushed into the town of Deir Al-Balah, the first time it is thought troops have deliberately sought to seize an area where intelligence indicated a high likelihood hostages are being held. Mr Netanyahu and his allies argue that leaving even remnants of Hamas intact in the Strip would eventually precipitate another October 7-style massacre. They have so far rejected Arab proposals for an interim government to administer the enclave in the event of a permanent ceasefire. 'We are past the culmination point' Gen Orion said: 'The Gaza war is a long way past its culmination point. 'Every military operation, like many human endeavours, has the rule of diminishing returns. 'At some point, great successes meet growing resistance and lose their efficiency. The costs rise and the benefits are lower. In Gaza, we are way past that point.' Although the true figures are closely guarded, some campaign groups and politicians believe the rate of attendance could be as low as 60 per cent. The majority are so-called 'grey refusals', who are people who plead medical problems, family issues, or who simply go abroad during the call-up window and 'forget' to check their emails. Refusals on explicit political grounds are rarer but increasing, reflected in the growing number of public letters signed by reservists denouncing Mr Netanyahu's conduct of the war, and subsequent reprimands and dismissals. Accounts have emerged of officers frantically reaching out to reservists on social media, begging them to turn up, because their ranks are so depleted. At the same time, the acrimonious issue of Haredi conscription rumbles on, with Mr Netanyahu expected to give in on promises to force ultra-orthodox Jewish young men to turn up for military service. Mr Fiener's prison sentence was considered a relatively harsh penalty for refusal, given the maximum is 30 days. But he only served one night, as the prison was largely evacuated when Iran started firing ballistic missiles at Israel in June. Waiting to see if he will be recalled to jail, he believes the pictures and videos of what's happening in Gaza will further decrease the rate of call-up response. He said: 'There are always a lot of people who are not sure if they are willing to go and every little thing can affect them.
