EC Director of Public Prosecutions says he accepts criticism over Omotoso matter
Advocate Barry Madolo told Parliament's Justice Committee today that after the lead prosecutor was replaced when the problems were flagged, he didn't expect the case to fail.
READ: Pastor Timothy Omotoso acquitted on all charges of rape, human trafficking
Madolo plans to appeal the acquittal of the Nigerian pastor once the judge as responded to a request for further clarity on her judgment, in which she was scathing of the prosecutors' handling of the matter.
Madolo said that while he doesn't want to preempt the outcome of an appeal against Timothy Omotoso's acquittal, he's committed to obtaining justice for the victims.
He believes the replacement prosecutors he deployed to the protracted trial had the job in hand, given their successes in similar cases.
"I take responsibility for picking that team because I did not just pick anyone. I picked people whom I thought were capable of dealing with the matter."
Madolo said that lead prosecutor Nceba Ntelwa, against whom the judge made a litany of misconduct findings - and who was removed from the case in 2021 - is still under investigation.
Madolo told the committee he didn't think that in this case Ntelwa had been a 'good team player.'
"I put a team whom I thought was the best team. If I erred there, then the investigation will tell me I erred."
The NPA expects an investigation report into the prosecuting team to be finalised by the middle of next month.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
3 minutes ago
- IOL News
Court denies bail to man accused of murdering five-year-old Ditebogo Phalane
Elia Moeko (36) one of the three accused in the murder case of five-year-old Ditebogo Phahlane. The Pretoria North Magistrates' Court denied Moeko bail citing that he is a flight risk and may pose danger to society Image: Supplied/ NPA Lumka Mahanjana A man accused of killing five-year-old Ditebogo Phalane was denied by the Pretoria North Magistrates' Court. Elia Moeko, and his two co-accused Ali Sithole, 30, and Nido Gumbe, 29, are facing charges of murder, robbery with aggravating circumstances, possession of an unlicensed firearm, and possession of ammunition while Gumbe, a Mozambican national, faces an extra charge of illegal immigration. The charges stem from an incident which occurred on May 10, 2024, when the trio allegedly shot and killed the little boy during a botched hijacking while they were targeting his father, Tebogo Phalane. Elia Moeko (36), Ali Sithole (30) and Nido Gumbe (29). The tree accussed in the murder case of five-year-old Ditebogo Phahlane. Image: Supplied NPA/ Lumka Mahanjana Following an intensive investigation by the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation (DPCI), the suspects were arrested on May 23, 2024, while in custody at the Pretoria Moot Police Station on unrelated charges. On Wednesday, National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) spokesperson, Lumka Mahanjana said when Sithole and Gumbe abandoned their bail applications, Moeko submitted a bail affidavit, claiming that he needed to care for his two minor children and his late brother's child. "He further stated that his continued incarceration would result in a loss of income, as he operates a hair salon and offers school transport services," said Mahanjana. Meanwhile, Prosecutor Advocate Tumelo Letaoana opposed the application and led evidence from the investigating officer, Sergeant Mashudu Savhasa, who testified that Moeko was a flight risk and had misled the court by not disclosing that he had previous convictions. In addition, he was considered a danger to witnesses known to him. Magistrate Maseena Khan ruled that the accused failed to prove the existence of exceptional circumstances that would justify his release on bail. The matter was postponed to September 10, 2025 IOL News
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Mashatile fined for failing to declare diamond gift from Louis Liebenberg
The diamond was handed over to the NPA. Deputy President Paul Mashatile has been found guilty by Parliament's ethics committee for failing to declare a diamond gift received by his wife, Humile Mashatile, from controversial businessman Louis Liebenberg. Mashatile has also been in the spotlight due to his high-end lifestyle, luxury properties, and associations with corruption-accused individuals such as Edwin Sodi. According to the deputy president's office, the diamond was undergoing verification to determine its authenticity and would be declared once the verification process was complete. The office also stated that the diamond would be returned following the arrest of Louis Liebenberg last year on charges of fraud, theft, racketeering and money laundering. Despite this, a formal complaint was lodged with the Joint Committee on Ethics and Members' Interests. Parliament fines Mashatile over Liebenberg diamond Following an investigation, the committee fined Mashatile for not disclosing the 'unsolicited' gift to his wife in the parliamentary register. 'The committee, through the office of the registrar, received a formal complaint against the deputy president on 5 March 2025 for an alleged breach of the code of ethical conduct and members' Interests. ALSO READ: Mashatile reveals he spent R2.3m on travel, food, and laundry for Japan trip 'Item 13(3)(f) of the code requires members of parliament to disclose gifts received by their immediate family in the confidential part of the register,' Parliament's statement read on Thursday. 'Following consideration of the complaint and perusal of the confidential part of the deputy president's disclosed interests, the committee noted that the gift in question (a diamond from Mr Louis Liebenberg) was not disclosed.' Diamond with NPA Mashatile confirmed to the committee the precious stone had since been handed over to the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA). However, the committee argued that ethical conduct required the gift to be declared promptly, with its value to be determined and disclosed later. In addition to the fine, the committee has recommended that Mashatile be officially reprimanded in the National Assembly. 'The committee remains steadfast in its quest to ensure accountability of all members of parliament as demanded by the code. The disclosure process not only facilitates public trust in Parliament but also enhances its credibility.' READ MORE: Should Paul Mashatile be president? This ANC veteran thinks so Earlier this year, opposition party ActionSA called on the Public Protector to investigate the diamond gift and whether there were any breaches of the Executive Members' Ethics Act. 'Alarmingly, this 'gift' raises serious concerns when viewed in the context of allegations surrounding the deputy president's unexplained lavish lifestyle, claims that he too engages heavily in trading favours, and Liebenberg's reputation for 'gifting' extravagant items to high-ranking politicians and government officials as a means to buy influence,' the party said in a statement at the time. Mashatile's property declarations Mashatile recently declared ownership of a R28.9 million estate in Constantia, Cape Town, despite previously denying any property ownership in the area. In October 2024, the deputy president's office insisted that he had no properties in Cape Town aside from a house in Kelvin, Johannesburg, purchased through a bank loan with his late wife. At the time, the Constantia property was said to belong to a company linked to his son-in-law. However, new disclosures made this year list the 4 000-square-metre Constantia house as Mashatile's, along with a 9 300-square-metre home in Waterfall, Midrand, reportedly valued at R37 million and the Kelvin residence. The Hawks are currently investigating Mashatile following criminal charges laid by the DA. Last year, Mashatile declared ownership of two properties, one located in Midrand spanning 1 000 by 1 200 square metres, and another in Sandton covering 600 by 800 square metres. NOW READ: Mashatile denies family tied to multibillion-rand lottery deal
The Citizen
7 hours ago
- The Citizen
Senior advocate Seth Nthai convicted and sentenced for soliciting R5m bribe
The High Court of South Africa, Gauteng Division, in Johannesburg, convicted and sentenced former senior counsel Seth Nthai yesterday, after he pleaded guilty to corruption charges relating to a 2009 bribery scandal involving an international arbitration case. Sandton Chronicle reports that Nthai admitted to soliciting a R5m bribe from Italian businessman Mario Marcenaro during a meeting in Sandton on October 10, 2009. At the time, Nthai was representing the South African government in the high-profile Piero Foresti and others v The Government of the Republic of South Africa case. The bribe was intended to influence the outcome of the arbitration in favour of Marcenaro and his co-claimants. As part of a plea and sentence agreement, the court imposed a fine of R500 000 or two years' imprisonment. Additionally, Nthai received a five-year sentence, wholly suspended for five years on condition that he is not convicted of a similar offence during the suspension period. The court noted the severity of the offence, particularly given that the complainant in the matter was the South African government itself. The judge also considered Nthai's guilty plea, co-operation during proceedings, and his age when delivering the sentence. The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) regional spokesperson, Phindi Mjonondwane, said the investigations revealed that Nthai had disclosed confidential and strategic information about the case to Marcenaro without authorisation in exchange for the promised bribe. 'Although the R5m was never paid, the court found that the mere solicitation of such a bribe constituted a serious breach of legal and ethical duty,' said Mjonondwane. 'The case had a complex legal history, including extensive trial proceedings and the recusal of the initial presiding judge after several state witnesses had already testified. This led to the matter being restarted before a new judge, ultimately resulting in the current plea agreement.' She added that they have welcomed the conviction as a significant victory in their ongoing efforts to root out corruption. 'This conviction affirms our commitment to fighting corruption, especially within the legal profession and among public office bearers. The abuse of public trust and the justice system by legal professionals is a serious threat to the rule of law. Mr Nthai's actions were a betrayal of that trust, and this sentence sends a clear message that no one is above the law.' Mjonondwane explained the importance of maintaining integrity within state institutions. 'This outcome demonstrates that unethical behaviour, regardless of one's status or position, will be prosecuted vigorously. We will continue to act without fear or favour to protect the public interest.' The NPA has reiterated its ongoing commitment to upholding the rule of law and ensuring accountability across all sectors, particularly in cases involving the manipulation of justice for personal enrichment. Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel. Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal. Read original story on
