Experts Urge Fix As Government Expands Failing Lunch Scheme To Primary Schools
The revised version of the school lunch programme, rolled out to secondary and full primary schools in January 2025, saw the Government partner with national consortium the School Lunch Collective to achieve drastic reductions in the programme cost. The new version of the programme is being plagued by a multitude of problems, including delivery of unsafe and unpalatable food, massive wastage of uneaten meals and packaging, and the nutritional quality of the lunches plummeting.
Nutrition experts found the government-funded school lunches are failing nutrition standards. The new lunches now provide only about half the energy recommended for a school lunch. Despite all providers being contractually obliged to meet the Ministry of Education's Nutrition Standards, none of the 13 meals provided by School Lunch Collective that were examined by nutrition experts met them. This means the lunches are no longer healthy - despite the programme being named the Healthy School Lunches programme.
This is hardly surprising, given the School Lunch Collective members, Libelle and Compass, were failing to consistently deliver good quality lunches under the previous funding model, when they were receiving nearly three times the funding per lunch.
"It's not a cost saving if it's not delivering the nutrition our most disadvantaged children need to succeed at school. Under the previous model, schools could choose how they provided lunches to their tamariki, with many walking away from Compass and Libelle to either do it themselves or work with local community businesses. Tamariki got better food for less cost. Our growing teenagers are now getting less to eat and being told to be grateful for it", says Professor Lisa Te Morenga, Health Coalition co-chair and Massey University researcher.
"This Government has prioritised productivity, but hungry, undernourished children cannot learn effectively nor be productive. More than a quarter of children in Aotearoa face poverty and food insecurity - this programme is designed to help those kids. These children are our future workforce; we need to invest in them", says Professor Te Morenga.
"I'm extremely angry and disappointed this government continues to ignore our voices and our evidence of the success of locally provided lunches. Instead, they want to remove what's working to save a few dollars - at the expense of our tamariki. We need to be investing in our tamariki and their future, says Seletute Mila, Tumuaki/Principal of Arakura School.
"The changes to Ka Ora, Ka Ako have set back the progress schools were making in helping New Zealand's disadvantaged children. The programme must be fixed now- by being appropriately valued for the potential it has to lift our most disadvantaged children out of poverty and to lead healthy, productive lives. This benefits us all. We are calling for this current mean and draconian model to be abandoned. Raise the funding and give communities the flexibility to provide the best nutritious food they can for their tamariki," says Professor Te Morenga.
More information
Reports from schools across Aotearoa reveal serious failures in the revised programme, including:
Unsafe food: The NZ Food Safety Authority is investigating concerns, as reported by BusinessDesk.
Lack of allergy-friendly meals: Students with allergies are left without safe options, as reported by BusinessDesk.
Waste and inefficiency: Unappealing meals are going uneaten, and previous systems to redistribute food to students or charities are no longer happening.
Excess rubbish: The new system generates more landfill waste than before.
Poor nutrition: The lack of fruit likely means lower fibre intake.
Lack of transparency: Schools and families don't know the actual nutritional value of meals.
Halal concerns: No clear process ensures meals meet halal dietary needs.
Late or missing deliveries: Many schools report meals not arriving on time.
Repetitive and insufficient portions: Meals lack variety and are often too small.
No direct communication: Schools can no longer work directly with suppliers.
No student feedback: Tamariki have no way to voice concerns about their meals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
7 hours ago
- 1News
Govt gives green light and $83m for Waikato medical school
The Government has approved a business case and $83m in funding for a new Waikato University medical school, as part of a plan to strengthen the health workforce. The New Zealand Graduate School of Medicine will receive more than $150 million from the university — supported by philanthropy — according to the Government, bringing total funding to more than $200 million. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said the third medical school for New Zealand would not just be a "significant investment" for the health system but for Hamilton and the Waikato region. "New Zealand simply isn't training enough doctors to meet the future needs of our growing aging population or to replace those doctors retiring, and that has to change." The new school was a "practical step" to change that by boosting the medical workforce, creating new educational opportunities in the Waikato and helping deliver better care closer to home, he said. ADVERTISEMENT "It's certainly a big win for the future of our health workforce; it's a big win for the Waikato; and, most importantly, for patients." Health Minister Simeon Brown said the school would focus on primary care and rural health. "Today's decision will enable the University of Waikato to begin construction on new teaching facilities later this year and start planning for clinical placements, while giving more students the opportunity to study medicine in New Zealand," he said. Experts have warned that the initial proposal for the facility was likely to be unaffordable. (Source: 1News) The medical school would add 120 doctor training places annually from 2028, offering a graduate-entry programme "providing a flexible new pathway into medicine that helps attract a broader range of students and build a stronger, more diverse workforce". "It's an innovative model that supports our focus on strengthening primary care, making it easier for people to see their doctor, helping Kiwis stay well and out of hospital." The Government approved precisely $82.85 million in direct funding for the project. ADVERTISEMENT Brown's office said a full cost-benefit analysis was presented to Cabinet before any proposal was finalised. ACT had negotiated for the analysis to be completed before any binding funding decision could be approved, in its coalition agreement with National. Universities Minister Shane Reti said the funding decision represented a "real boost for tertiary education in the Waikato". "By expanding access to medical training, we're creating new opportunities for students from across the region and beyond, while also helping to future-proof the local workforce," he said. "This is exactly the kind of forward-thinking initiative this Government wants to see from our universities – investing in regional growth, building local capability, and delivering on the needs of rural communities." The Health Minister added the new places were "on top of the 100 additional medical training places that are being added over the term of this Government across the University of Auckland and University of Otago". Report found more cost effective training could be delivered by the two existing schools and both universities could increase intakes quicker with increased funding. (Source: 1News) ADVERTISEMENT Auckland and Otago universities had previously offered to train more medical students if that could be supported by the Government. Pro-Vice-Chancellor Health Sciences at Otago, Associate Professor Megan Gibbons, acknowledged today's announcement of a third medical school as part of the Government's strategy to address New Zealand's healthcare workforce needs. "We are disappointed that Government did not follow the alternative and more cost-effective option of further increasing the intakes into the country's existing medical schools," she said. "However, any investment that supports growing and sustaining the health workforce is a step toward strengthening care for our communities — particularly in rural and underserved regions." Four-year programme to begin in 2028, first graduates by 2032 University of Waikato vice-chancellor Professor Neil Quigley called the announcement a "landmark moment" for New Zealand. "We will be offering a programme that selects and trains doctors in a fundamentally different way and will complement New Zealand's two existing medical schools. ADVERTISEMENT "It will be designed to produce more graduates who choose to become GPs and who want to work in regional and rural communities." Quigley said the four-year programme would begin in 2028, with first cohort graduating and entering the workforce in 2032. Pro vice-chancellor of health Professor Jo Lane said the New Zealand Graduate School of Medicine curriculum would train "the doctors New Zealand needs". "Our curriculum will prioritise clinical placements in regional and rural health settings, allowing graduates to experience working with diverse populations while building deep connections in the communities they serve."
RNZ News
9 hours ago
- RNZ News
New Waikato medical school gets government green light
The government has green-lit a new medical school at the University of Waikato, ending months of delays due to coalition wrangling. It was a National election promise, and it has finally got the go ahead, with the government announcing it will front up around $80 million while the University pays $150 million for the project. It will add 120 doctor training places each year, starting in 2028. The announcement also came as inflation edges to a 12-month high, and the Minister in charge of Pharmac released a new letter of expectations. Political reporter Lillian Hanly spoke to Melissa Chan-Green. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
Scoop
9 hours ago
- Scoop
Delighted With The Announcement Of A Third Medical School At Waikato University Focussing On Rural Doctors
Hauora Taiwhenua is excited by the Prime Minister's long-awaited announcement of the support for a third medical school at Waikato University. It is well known that New Zealand is suffering from an acute shortage of family doctors, and that shortage is the most pronounced in rural areas. Going into the last election, the National Government had promised to fund a proposal from Waikato University that put forward a very different approach to the existing two Medical Schools at Auckland and Otago. The proposal was to offer opportunities to existing graduates and provide a significant part of the training in rural and regional New Zealand. The coalition Government had asked for a detailed business case before continuing that commitment. Cabinet has today given the green light, meaning that the Waikato proposal could show positive financial, as well as medical, outcomes for the country. Hauora Taiwhenua's CEO, Dr Grant Davidson, stated, 'We are thrilled that the Government has met its election promise to provide a rurally focussed medical training programme in New Zealand. This will complement the excellent training programmes already in operation at Auckland and Otago, while providing a graduate-entry option with strong community immersion. It will give hope to rural general practice that the continuance of a targeted workforce for rural communities is important to this Government.' The Waikato proposal follows well-proven design principles for rural medical training in both Australia and Canada. Clear research shows that rural-origin students who train in rural areas and are trained by rural health professionals are six times more likely to work in those rural areas post-graduation. While graduates from the Waikato programme will be able to follow any medical specialty, as is the case with graduates from Auckland and Otago, we hope that by having more exposure during the training to general practice, that a higher percentage of graduates will see the benefits of working in the community. Hauora Taiwhenua notes that a third medical school for the population of New Zealand is not unusual. Based on Australia, we would have between four to five medical schools for New Zealand's population of over five million people. This initiative will see an extra 120 doctors trained each year starting in 2028. This will add to the extra 100 medical training placements that the Government has supported into Otago and Auckland's programmes over its current term, along with the funding of 120 Nurse practitioners and support packages for rural practices to take on graduate nurses. Last week, representatives of the nine Chapters of Hauora Taiwhenua met with the coalition Government to get an update on progress towards the published Rural Health Strategy. In holding the Government to account, one of the pressing questions was why the commitment to the Waikato proposal was delayed. Minister Brown at the time told the group that a decision was pending. It is pleasing to see that the commitment has now been honoured. Dr Davidson added that he is encouraged that "Our collective efforts strive to empower our rural communities by ensuring they have access to high-quality healthcare services delivered by professionals who understand and are committed to rural values and needs has been heard."
