Acquitted law professor Diarmuid Phelan in legal fight with State over 'enormous' trial costs
A judge will give her ruling in September as to whether the State should pay the "enormous" legal costs for Mr Phelan following a trial that ended last January.
Advertisement
The costs issue was raised this evening on the last day of the Trinity term before Ms Justice Siobhan Lankford, who presided over the 10-week murder trial that ended on January 3rd last.
Law lecturer Mr Phelan, who has assets valued in the millions, instructed two senior and two junior counsel at his trial and did not receive legal aid. He also called expert witnesses who gave evidence following the close of the prosecution case.
Mr Phelan maintained from the outset that he had no intention of shooting the deceased Keith Conlon and had acted in self-defence when he fired three warning shots. The jurors unanimously agreed with the defence case following the trial that Mr Phelan was entitled to defend himself when he came under threat on his own land.
Mr Phelan (56) went on trial in October 2024 after he pleaded not guilty to murdering father-of-four Keith 'Bono' Conlon (36) at Hazelgrove Farm, Kiltalown Lane, Tallaght, Dublin 24 on February 24, 2022.
Advertisement
Mr Conlon from Kiltalown Park in Tallaght, was seriously injured in the shooting incident on February 22 and died at Tallaght University Hospital two days later.
The defendant is a barrister, law lecturer and farmer who owns Hazelgrove, formerly a golf course in Tallaght.
It was the defence case that this was an unintended killing and what Mr Phelan had been trying to achieve in discharging the shots was not to strike Mr Conlon.
Opening the application on Thursday evening, Sean Guerin SC, who was one of two senior counsel representing Mr Phelan at his trial, told Ms Justice Lankford that the starting point - and also expressly the most important consideration - in awarding costs was the verdict.
Advertisement
Counsel submitted that Mr Phelan was entitled to his costs and the onus was really on the prosecution to show why he shouldn't succeed in the application. He said there was no substantive reason as to why costs should not be awarded.
Mr Guerin said one of the prosecution's submissions, which had previously been handed into the court, was that Mr Phelan had the option of applying for legal aid but had chosen not to do so. The lawyer said legal aid had been put in place because of the desperate injustice done to people who couldn't secure the means to defend themselves and to protect those of limited resources.
The barrister said the State appeared to be suggesting that even people of resources or means should make a legal aid application, which he suggested was a complete misunderstanding of what the legal aid scheme was. "There is no suggestion of that in the authorities and is entirely contrary to the word and spirit of the statutory scheme of legal aid," he added.
Mr Guerin went on to say that the personal financial consequences was that Mr Phelan had to bear "the enormous costs" of being on trial in the Central Criminal Court for nearly three months. "The court doesn't need to be told what those financial consequences are and how they weigh on anyone who has to meet their defence".
Advertisement
Opposing the application, John Byrne SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), argued there was no presumption in favour of costs and one cannot simply say they had been acquitted so were entitled to their costs. He said a more complex and nuanced enquiry was required by the trial judge.
The barrister said an award of costs is a discretionary order and it was "too simplistic" to say an acquittal gives rise to a presumption in favour of costs being awarded.
Ms Justice Lankford said she had not finalised her view in relation to awarding costs but asked both parties to articulate their views if she decided to award Mr Phelan his costs but confined it to legal aid costs. She noted there was quite a wide discretion in case law, where 50 per cent of costs had been awarded to applicants.
Mr Guerin told the judge there was no warrant for doing so as those weren't the costs his client had incurred. He said legal aid was not a guide or a measure as to what are the appropriate costs in a case. "If the court concluded Mr Phelan is entitled to his costs, then the appropriate order is for the adjudication of those costs in the usual way".
Advertisement
Whereas, Mr Byrne said the discretion seemed to be very wide and awarding legal aid costs was not something the court couldn't do, provided it set out the basis for it.
Ms Justice Lankford said she hoped to deliver the court's judgement as to whether Mr Phelan can recoup his legal costs from the State in the first week of September.
Ireland
Young man jailed for raping teenage girl and engag...
Read More
Mr Phelan's trial heard that Keith Conlon and others were trespassing on Mr Phelan's land at Hazelgrove Farm, Kiltalown Lane in Tallaght on February 24, 2022. Mr Phelan shot a dog belonging to one of the trespassers due to concerns the dog might go after his sheep.
An angry confrontation followed in which Mr Phelan produced a handgun and fired three shots, the third of which struck Mr Conlon in the head and caused his death. Mr Phelan said he acted in self-defence and that the fatal shooting was accidental.
The jury had rejected the State's case that when the third shot was fired by Mr Phelan, the gun was pointed in the direction of Mr Conlon, who was shot in the back of the head when it was argued he had turned away to leave. It was in those circumstances, the prosecution said, that Mr Phelan intended to either kill or cause serious injury to Mr Conlon.
Instead, the jurors accepted Mr Phelan's position that he was acting in self-defence after two trespassers were "coming to fulfil the threats they had made" and that he was fearful and facing an "imminent attack" as the men closed in on him.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Woman allegedly stabbed to death in Mount Pritchard unit - as man is charged
A woman has died after being allegedly stabbed by a man in Sydney 's western suburbs. Emergency services were called to a unit on Hemphill Avenue in Mount Pritchard, 34km west of the CBD, about 5.05pm on Sunday. Furkan Ada, 28, also known as Bruce Archer, was arrested at the scene. He was taken to Fairfield Police Station and has since been charged with murder.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Another hopeful 'spotting' of triple daughter killer Travis Decker goes cold... as manhunt for murderer dwindles in size
Yet another potential sighting of accused killer Travis Decker has gone cold as officials in Washington state have begun scaling back their search efforts for the man accused of killing his three young daughters. Authorities in the state have been searching for the 33-year-old ever since his daughters - Paityn, 9, Evelyn, 8, and Olivia, 5 - were found strangled to death at a campsite outside Leavenworth, Washington in early June. It is now believed Decker, 33, dumped their bodies and his truck, and he has been wanted on murder charges since. There was a glimmer of hope on Friday, when the King County Sheriff's Office announced it had received a tip at around 6pm that the killer father was seen near Snoqualmie Pass and the Pacific Crest Trail area - about 55 miles from Seattle. 'As locating Decker is a priority, KCSO dispatched multiple patrol units, along with TAC-30, K9 Units and Guardian 1 to aid in the search,' the sheriff's office told KIRO. 'Neighboring law enforcement agents were notified as well.' But an extensive search for the former Army Ranger came up empty, and the search efforts were called off at around 9.15pm. The announcement came just days after the Chelan County Sheriff's Office - which initially led the search efforts - said it was scaling back its response after receiving fewer tips about Decker's possible whereabouts. Much of the search efforts have been focused on national forest areas and parts of the Pacific Crest Trail - which runs from the Canadian border in Washington all the way down to the Mexican border in California. The failed search this week follows a number of similar sightings that have not materialized, with officials admitting in June that a trove of evidence taken from his suspected hiding site did not match any of his DNA. Thus far, each effort to find and capture Decker - who is wanted on state and federal charges for murder and kidnapping - have ended in a dead end. Even a tip that Decker may be hiding out in Idaho proved to be false, with someone mistaking a local man for the wanted killer. As the search efforts now reach a third consecutive month, Chelan County Sheriff Mike Morrison suggested it is 'not likely' Decker is still alive and on the loose. 'His ability to go through that area and not be detected would have been challenging, let alone the challenges involved with him having to hike through all the snow that was up there toward the Pacific Crest Trail at the time,' he told reporters on Thursday. Still, he insisted to KHQ that the department remains 'optimistic' it will locate the accused killer, even if it is just his body. 'We still recognize we have a job to do,' Morrison said. He added that deputies 'are going through and making sure that we are covering our paths twice, sometimes three times, and also making sure that we are utilizing our search and rescue investigative units appropriately.' Yet some experts, including law enforcement and security analyst Todd McGhee, have said Decker's extensive military background may have enabled him to live in the wilderness undetected. He had joined the Army in 2013 and served in Afghanistan before transferring to the Washington National Guard in 2021, a communications director for the Washington Military Department previously confirmed to the Daily Mail. The Guard was in the process of a disciplinary discharge due to Decker's absences when his daughters were killed. He had been suffering from mental health issues at the time, and had recently been diagnosed with borderline personality disorder. Decker was even court-mandated to receive mental health treatment and domestic violence anger management counseling but had refused. Police said he was also homeless and living out of his car by the time he picked up his three girls from their mother's house on May 30. Still, his ex-wife Whitney told police she didn't believe Decker was dangerous, and that he loved his daughters, with whom he had a 'good relationship.' However, dashcam footage from a May 27 traffic stop has added to the image of Decker's poor mental state at the time. Decker appeared in the 19-minute video with his arms crossed and a bored expression before he leaned on his car and then sat on the bumper. At one point, he could be seen resting his head on his truck bed as the other driver and police officer interact. After the incident, the other driver told KING 5, which obtained the video, that Decker appeared 'nervous and fidgety' and 'kept telling me not to call police' claiming he would go to jail over the accident. When the driver told Decker he had to call police to report the crash, he said the alleged killer's body language was 'almost intimidating.' 'I could tell he was not in his full senses,' the driver added. At the end of the video, Decker shook the driver's hand for nine seconds. When the driver tried to pull away, Decker continued asking if he was going to be okay, the driver said. The traffic stop happened three days before Decker picked up his daughters at their mother's house for the last time, according to police. Whitney called police after Decker failed to bring them back. She told cops he was 'quieter than usual' when he collected the girls, which was 'out of character' for him. His vehicle was eventually found on June 2, with his daughter's remains nearby. An ensuing autopsy then confirmed that the three girls died of suffocation and their deaths were ruled a homicide.
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Beautiful 17-year-old girl's killer learns his fate after gunning her down steps from her home
The man who was accused of murdering a 17-year-old Long Beach girl who was walking home from her job at McDonald's has been sentenced to 358 years to life in prison. Troy Lamar Fox, 34, was convicted in March of first-degree murder for the killing of Briana Soto, a student who was gunned down just steps from her home. The jury also convicted him of four counts of attempted murder in a separate shooting on April 9, 2024, in which he opened fire on a car carrying four minors, the Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office announced Thursday. 'Briana Soto had her whole life ahead of her - she was getting ready for her prom, her 18th birthday, and graduation,' Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman said. 'Today's sentence ensures the person who stole her future will never be free to harm another innocent person. While this punishment cannot undo the pain he caused, it is a step toward justice for Briana, her loved ones, and our community.' Lamar Fox was already in custody for an unrelated weapons violation when he was identified by Long Beach Police as the suspect who fatally shot Soto as she walked home from work. Soto was just outside her family's home on the evening of March 26 around 8:30pm when she was shot while on the phone with her mother. The teen's family heard the gunshots outside their home - rushing her to the hospital where she eventually succumbed to her injuries three days later. The suspect was caught on security footage moments after the shooting dressed in dark clothing with a mask covering his face. Long Beach Police investigated DNA, video and cell phone evidence before identifying Fox as the suspect who is believed to be involved in two other incidents on April 9 and July 7. On April 9, officers responded to a shots-fired call where a suspect, believed to be Fox, discharged a firearm in the direction of three juveniles and one adult in a vehicle. On July 7, cops arrived on the scene after a report of firearms inside of a vehicle. During the incident, officers located Fox and a juvenile suspect and later learned they were both prohibited possessors. Two firearms were recovered on the suspects and four firearms were recovered from the vehicle. Fox had an outstanding warrant for his arrest issued in November 2023 for violation of his parole terms. Following investigation into Soto's case, on September 11, detectives presented evidence to a Los Angeles Superior Court Judge and obtained an arrest warrant for Fox for the murder of the Long Beach teen. On September 13, cops took custody of Fox from the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department and booked him into the Long Beach City Jail. Police have not yet disclosed a motive behind the shootings.
