Tasha Kheiriddin: Carney will have no choice but to kill supply management
For a while there, things were going so well. Prime Minister Mark Carney — aka 'the Trump whisperer' — had morphed from critic to texting buddy of the U.S. President. Over the past three months, Carney had been chatting with Donald Trump, building backchannel goodwill. After the successful G7 summit in Kananaskis, Alta., hopes were high that Ottawa would strike a deal with Washington in 30 days, and that the rhetoric of making us the '51st state' had finally been retired.
Article content
Article content
Until last Friday, when everything fell apart.
Article content
Article content
Article content
That's when President Trump abruptly cut off trade negotiations with Canada over our three per cent digital services tax, set to take effect June 30. Aimed at U.S. tech giants Amazon, Meta, Google and AirBNB, the tax was retroactive to 2022 and would have cost them an estimated $2 billion in back payments. The tech bros howled, the president barked, and Carney blinked. Sunday night, he backed down and cancelled the tax: Monday morning, U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick thanked him for the climbdown, as did the Canadian Chamber of Commerce. Negotiations were back on.
Article content
But if you thought that was the last bump in the road, you couldn't be more wrong. In an interview broadcast Sunday morning on Fox, Trump mentioned a veritable mountain: supply management. That's the system that protects Canadian dairy, poultry and egg industries from foreign competition through quotas and tariffs, including Trump's favourite bugaboo, a 200-plus per cent markup on U.S. dairy products.
Article content
Article content
It's true that the tariff only kicks in after the U.S. exports 50,000 zero-tariff metric tons of milk and 12,500 metric tons of cheese per year — levels it is nowhere near approaching. But supply management was already a sticking point with Trump in the CUSMA negotiations under Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, and Republican lawmakers and U.S. dairy producers continue to demand its elimination.
Article content
Article content
In our country, unfortunately, it has become a hill on which political careers go to die. Case in point: People's Party Leader Maxime Bernier, whose ambition to lead the Conservative party in 2017 was thwarted by the Quebec dairy lobby after he promised to ditch the policy. And the sacred cow lives on: in June, the House of Commons and Senate passed a Bloc Québécois bill with all-party support to prevent bargaining supply management away.
Article content
Carney knows that he owes his recent election victory in large part to Quebec voters — and with a minority, needs the support of opposition parties like the Bloc to stay in power. But if Canada wants a serious trade deal with a Trump White House, supply management will have to go. Not just for the sake of negotiations, but because it's a cartel policy that has had its day.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
22 minutes ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
What the Justice Department's push to bring denaturalization cases means
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Justice Department is ramping up its plans to revoke the citizenship of immigrants who've committed crimes or pose a national security risk, according to a recent memo underscoring the Trump administration's hardline immigration agenda. Efforts to identity and go after those suspected of cheating to get their citizenship are not new to this administration. But the public push is raising concerns from advocates, who have accused the administration of trying to use immigration enforcement for political purposes. It's receiving increased scrutiny after a Republican member of Congress suggested that Zohran Mamdani, the New York City Democratic mayoral candidate, should be subject to denaturalization proceedings. Here's a look at the denaturalization process and what the Justice Department's memo means: ___ Denaturalization cases are rare The U.S. government can strip a naturalized immigrant of their citizenship if they are criminally convicted of naturalization fraud or if the government proves through civil proceedings that they illegally obtained their citizenship through fraud or misrepresented or concealed facts on their application. For years, the government's denaturalization efforts focused largely on suspected war criminals who lied on their immigration paperwork, most notably former Nazis. The Justice Department filed just more than 300 total cases between 1990 and 2017. An initiative that began under the Obama administration called Operation Janus expanded those efforts by seeking to identify people who had used different identities to get green cards and citizenship after they were previously issued deportation orders. In 2016, an internal watchdog reported that 315,000 old fingerprint records for immigrants who had been deported or had criminal convictions had not been uploaded to a Department of Homeland Security database that is used to check immigrants' identities. The same report found more than 800 immigrants had been ordered deported under one identity but became U.S. citizens under another. The first Trump administration made such investigations a bigger priority, creating a Justice Department section focused on denaturalization cases. But even then, the number of denaturalization cases remained small, as the administration didn't have the resources to bring many amid an onslaught of legal challenges to immigration policies it had to defend against, said Matthew Hoppock, an attorney in Kansas who represents people in denaturalization cases. Justice Department says it will prioritize certain cases The push was announced in a memo from the recently confirmed head of the Justice Department's Civil Division, Assistant Attorney General Brett Shumate. Shumate said the cases the department will prioritize include people who 'pose a potential danger to national security,' people who commit violent crimes, members of gangs and drug cartels and people who commit Medicaid fraud and other types of fraud. The benefits of the denaturalization process, Shumate wrote, 'include the government's ability to revoke the citizenship of individuals who engaged in the commission of war crimes, extrajudicial killings, or other serious human rights abuses; to remove naturalized criminals, gang members, or, indeed, any individuals convicted of crimes who pose an ongoing threat to the United States; and to prevent convicted terrorists from returning to U.S. soil or traveling internationally on a U.S. passport.' Hoppock said the memo sort of 'blows the doors open' for the administration to file as many as many denaturalization cases as it has the resources to file. Lawyers raise alarm about the potential impact The broad language in the memo raises the prospect 'that any offense, at any time, may be used to justify denaturalization,' said Christopher Wellborn, president of the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. 'It is not difficult to imagine a scenario where the government invokes unsubstantiated claims of gang affiliation or uses an individual's criminal record to claim that citizenship was illegally procured,' Wellborn said in a statement. Others worry the administration's public push will stoke fear among naturalized immigrants. 'The more you talk about it, the more you frame it as 'we're coming after your naturalization, we're coming after you,' the more of a chilling effect we see on people applying for naturalization,' said Elizabeth Taufa, senior policy attorney and strategist at the Immigrant Legal Resource Center. 'Even those folks that really are eligible for naturalization.' Critics have accused the Trump administration using immigration enforcement to go after people because of their speech — most notably in the case of Columbia University activist Mahmoud Khalil, whom it has sought to deport over his role in pro-Palestinian protests. 'One of our ongoing concerns is will they target these politically, will they start combing through people's immigration files if they don't like you or if they think you don't agree with the government,' Hoppock said. 'I think most Americans would support the idea of stripping someone of citizenship if they got it through fraud and they are also a dangerous person,' he said, but the concern is if they start going through 'regular folks' immigration files to find a T that is not crossed or an I that is not dotted so they can use it as a weapon.' Justice Department recently secured denaturalization in one case The department last month announced that it had successfully secured the denaturalization of a man who was convicted of possessing child sexual abuse material. The British man had become a U.S. citizen after enlisting in the U.S. Army under a provision that provides a pathway to citizenship for U.S. service members, officials said. He only listed a speeding ticket when asked on his naturalization application if he had 'ever committed a crime or offense for which you were not arrested,' and he became a U.S. citizen in 2013. Months later, he was arrested in Louisiana on child sexual abuse material charges and convicted, according to the department. 'The laws intended to facilitate citizenship for brave men and women who join our nation's armed forces will not shield individuals who have fraudulently obtained U.S. citizenship by concealing their crimes,' Shumate said in a statement at the time. 'If you commit serious crimes before you become a U.S. citizen and then lie about them during your naturalization process, the Justice Department will discover the truth and come after you.'
25 minutes ago
Carney praises Canadians' unity as July 1 celebrations continue
Début du widget Widget. Passer le widget ? Fin du widget Widget. Retourner au début du widget ? In his first Canada Day address as prime minister, Mark Carney emphasized unity in a changing world. One hundred and 58 years ago, a few provinces bet on the idea that they'd be stronger together than they ever could be apart. They were right, and so they became a new federation that's now grown into our strong, bilingual, multicultural and ambitious country, Carney said in his video address. That unity includes writing the country's next chapter together in true partnership with First Nations, Inuit and Métis. Speaking at a Canada Day event in Ottawa, the prime minister took a moment to acknowledge some recent challenges. WATCH | Carney's message to Canadians: Début du widget Widget. Passer le widget ? Fin du widget Widget. Retourner au début du widget ? Canada Day this year coincides with the 60th anniversary of the Canadian flag and the 45th anniversary of the official adoption of O Canada as the national anthem. This year's festivities at LeBreton Flats Park in Ottawa also got the royal treatment, with Prince Edward praising Canadian unity and accomplishments. Seeing this sea of red and white, there is only one sense that I have here, the Duke of Edinburgh said. Today is truly a celebration of you, and your home and your land, strong and free. Leaders gave speeches interlaced with musical performances, Indigenous cultural demonstrations and a double flypast of Snowbirds military jets. The federal Heritage Department counts 8,000 people were attending the events. Gov. Gen. Mary Simon said the country is on a journey of reconciliation that began by listening to each other, honouring the past, and holding space for the pain and resilience of Indigenous Peoples. Kindness is the thread that weaves our communities together, she said. WATCH | Prince Edward praises Canada: Début du widget Widget. Passer le widget ? Fin du widget Widget. Retourner au début du widget ? Prince Edward praises Canada's achievements in July 1 speech Prince Edward capped off a weeklong visit to Canada with a stop in Ottawa, where he gave a speech to Canada Day revellers at LeBreton Flats Park. 'Today is truly a celebration of you, your home and your land, strong and free,' he said to cheers from the crowd. Speaking at a Canada Day event in Ottawa, the prime minister took a moment to acknowledge some recent challenges. We find ourselves in a situation where our economy has been attacked by a trade war we didn't start ... in a situation where our values are being tested by attacks on democracy and freedoms — attacks that we must resist. In an interview with CBC's Catherine Cullen, Carney said we'll see if Canada and the U.S. can reach a trade deal by July 21, a previously agreed-upon deadline (new window) set by the two countries. We're doing what is necessary in order to get the best deal for Canadians. If we get the best deal for Canadians, we will agree to it. If we can't we won't — it's that simple, he told CBC. WATCH | Carney talks Canada-U.S. relationship: Début du widget Widget. Passer le widget ? Fin du widget Widget. Retourner au début du widget ? Asked about a growing separatist movement in Alberta, Carney said he remembered tensions between Alberta and the federal government when he was growing up in the province. What happened is we came together, helped build the province … everyone coming together, he said. Alberta's a great province and this is an even greater country. The same's going to happen again. Carney noted in his address that Canadians have been uniting in a more divided and dangerous world, pointing to his one-Canadian economy plan as a way to push back against instability. This is the greatest nation on Earth. Our destiny is to make it greater still — not by what we say, but by what we do. Happy Canada Day. Find out how to follow the day's celebrations by clicking here (new window). Racy Rafique (new window) · CBC News
Toronto Star
28 minutes ago
- Toronto Star
Kentucky Senate hopeful says Mitch McConnell doesn't deserve lifetime achievement award
This undated photo provided by the Morris for Senate Campaign shows Republican businessman Nate Morris who formally launched his campaign for a U.S. Senate seat from Kentucky on Thursday, June 26, 2025. ( Max Cowan via AP) flag wire: true flag sponsored: false article_type: : sWebsitePrimaryPublication : publications/toronto_star bHasMigratedAvatar : false :
