Rangers eviscerate SFA over 'lack of consistency' as John Brown commentary claim lands financial penalty
Raging Rangers chiefs have warned the SFA the decision to fine the club over John Brown 's Easter Road outburst threatens the credibility of the Hampden rulebook.
The Ibrox outfit have been fined £3000 for comments made by the Gers legend as he co-commented for the club's official TV channel during last month's Premiership draw with Hibs.
The retired defender lashed out at the decision by referee Nick Walsh and his VAR assistants not to award Nico Raskin 's Leith 'ghost goal', branding the incident 'corrupt'.
That was enough for the SFA to charge Rangers with a breach of Disciplinary Rule 38, which prohibits clubs publishing material that 'indicates bias or incompetence on the part of such match official'.
But furious Ibrox bosses have been left stunned after the charge was upheld by an SFA judicial panel.
And they are now demanding an explanation of why other clubs have not been punished for a string of similar incidents.
As part of their defence, the Light Blues lawyers provided numerous examples of rival commentary teams stepping out of line while broadcasting on live games.
But that wasn't enough to get Gers off the hook.
Now the Ibrox outfit have released a stinging statement which says: 'Rangers FC today has been found by a Scottish FA judicial panel to have been in breach of Disciplinary Rule 38, following a remark made during commentary of the Hibernian v Rangers game in May. The club has been fined £3,000.
'We feel it is necessary to highlight the broader concerns this outcome raises and the wider implications this has for clarity and confidence in their regulatory processes.
'John Brown spoke emotionally and spontaneously as someone who cares deeply about the club. His words were not scripted, and they were not an official club comment.
'The ruling however sets a precedent where even spontaneous, corrected remarks made during live coverage of a clear refereeing error are enough to trigger a formal sanction.
"That is neither proportionate nor consistent, especially when other clubs have made stronger comments on official platforms without consequence.
'As part of our defence today, we flagged numerous examples of similar incidents on club channels.
"These incidents raise legitimate questions about Scottish FA rules and how consistently they are enforced. To our knowledge, none of these cases appear to have resulted in charges against the respective clubs.
'The lack of consistency with the Scottish FA's policing of similar incidents leaves more questions than answers.
'That is why we will be contacting the Scottish FA chief executive and president to seek clarity on what policies and processes the Compliance Officer has in place, if any, to ensure a consistent and proportionate approach to enforcement and the equal treatment of member clubs.
'We shall also be asking the Scottish FA whether they accept that a rule that cannot be applied consistently across all clubs and all platforms risks losing credibility as a fair and enforceable regulation.
'Our aim here is to understand the rationale behind the differing outcomes. A lack of consistency, or the perception of it, undermines confidence in the disciplinary process and exposes all member clubs to uncertainty about what is and is not allowed.
'There remains no clear guidance on how clubs are expected to manage live broadcast content, though we note the panel acknowledged that the club's internal editorial guidelines may serve as a constructive step for others going forward.
'To be clear, we referenced these other examples not to suggest they should have resulted in sanctions, but to highlight the clear inconsistency in how similar incidents have been handled.
'Club media channels are, by nature, passionate and partisan. Informal, tongue-in-cheek and emotional commentary comes with the territory, especially in live settings.
'But, in choosing to pursue this case, the Scottish FA has opened the door to closer scrutiny of how similar situations are handled going forward. If this is now the standard, they will be watched closely to ensure it is applied across the board, consistently, without exception and without favour.'
Gers were served a notice of complaint from the Hampden hierarchy after Brown's lashed out with his on-air tirade.
Raskin's effort in the 2-2 last day n draw clearly looked over the line but referee Walsh waved play on.
Hibs went up the pitch and scored, prompting Rangers TV co-commentator Brown to question the integrity of the decision.
When offered the chance to clarify the comments, Brown stood by them.
The SFA's own KMI panel has since agreed that Raskin's goal should have stood in Edinburgh, despite referee chief Willie Collum backing Walsh's call not to award it.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
43 minutes ago
- The National
Robin Propper finally set to compete Rangers transfer exit
The Ibrox defender is expected to complete a transfer move to return to his former club, FC Twente. Propper had been heavily involved under Philippe Clement at [[Rangers]] but fell out of the first-team picture after the Belgian boss was dismissed. The centre-back had been heavily linked with a return to Twente, the club he left to join Rangers. Reports last week had revealed a contract stand-off due to his contract terms offered at Twente being less than his Rangers wages. However, as reported by The Rangers Review, the issues have now been resolved, with sources confident the move will go through. Read more: Russell Martin confirmed a transfer offer had been accepted for Propper with the defender set to return to Twente in the near future. It comes after Twente technical director Jan Streuer threatened to move on from Propper unless a deal could be agreed after a protracted process. He said: "All sorts of factors beyond your control (dictate transfers). Just before last season, our captain Robin Propper left at the last minute. "We really missed him. Rangers bought him. A top Scottish club. You can't compete with them. "Now there's a new manager at Rangers, he might play less. Then he might be able to return. "But he'll want to wait and see first if he actually plays less. We have to decide: do we wait for that or do we see what happens next?"
Daily Record
44 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Celtic transfer D-day fast-tracked as £40m deadline looms amidst five week countdown
The clock is ticking towards the most lucrative games of the season Another summer, another window of frustration so far for Celtic fans - and Brendan Rodgers knows the script all too well. We're just over a week away from the big Premiership kick-off and there are gaping holes all over the champions' squad. Alarm bells are ringing among the Parkhead faithful, who've seen this movie before - big sales, slow signings, and another race against the clock. Celtic have banked £27million from the exits of Kyogo and Nicolas Kuhn but are still searching for replacements. Shin Yamada might spring a surprise, but Rodgers has made it clear he wants more firepower through the door and fast. Record Sport understands at least one winger, a midfielder and a main striker remain top of Rodgers' wish list. And with just 38 days until the window slams shut, punters are understandably agitated at the lack of movement. There's been no shortage of departures - 12 out the door - but of the six new faces, only Kieran Tierney and Benji Nygren look first-team ready. As it stands, Celtic will kick off their title defence with Daizen Maeda, a 34-year-old James Forrest, and unproven pair Yang and Marco Tilio as their only fit wide options. Tilio's barely featured since arriving in 2023, and Yang has yet to convince. It's hardly ideal when a £40million, winner-takes-all Champions League playoff looms next month. Sure, plenty can happen between now and then. But there's no luxury of bedding players in. Celtic need ready-made starters, not projects. The transfer deadline falls one day later than usual this year - Monday, September 1 - with August 31 landing on a Sunday. But the real pressure point comes far sooner. Rodgers and his recruitment team have until midnight on Thursday, August 14 to register players for the playoff. UEFA rules allow two late additions to the 25-man squad until the day before the first leg on August 19/20. The Hoops will discover their playoff opponents when the draw is made on August 4 and by then, Rodgers will be hoping the board has backed him properly. These are the most lucrative games of the season - and Celtic can't afford to get caught cold. You can get all the news you need on our dedicated Celtic page, and sign up to our newsletters to make sure you never miss a beat throughout the season. We're also WhatsApp where we bring all the latest breaking news and transfer gossip directly to your phone. Join our Celtic community here.
Daily Record
an hour ago
- Daily Record
Jack Butland proves ill Rangers fit despite brilliance as Celtic transfer theory on Engels is back to front
Game On tackles the big talking points as Graeme Young and Ryan McDonald chew over the burning issues Some Rangers fans had completely lost faith in Jack Butland after a catalogue of blunders last season. But has the Ibrox shot stopper redeemed himself with his heroics against Panathinaikos on Tuesday night? That's just one of the hot topics tackled in this week's episode of Game On - available every Friday on YouTube, Spotify and Apple Podcasts - as Graeme Young and Ryan McDonald chew over all the big talking points in Scottish football, served up in handy bite-sized chunks. Across the city, the clock is ticking on Celtic's £40million winner-takes-all Champions League playoff - and fans are demanding major reinforcements. The Parkhead board has five weeks to match Brendan Rodgers' ambition, but there's an even more pressing deadline looming that simply has to take priority. Throw in some chat about Craig Gordon's No1 status at Hearts and with Scotland, plus a lively debate around Josh Taylor's place in boxing history, and there's plenty for Record Sport's resident chinwaggers to sink their teeth into. You can watch the full podcast in the player above, or listen here. Rangers transfer priorities Ryan McDonald: I think they definitely need a left-back. Max Aarons played there against Panathinaikos but he's right-footed. Jefte was linked with Chelsea in January for £12/15million, don't know where that came from. He's nowhere near that standard. Ridvan's time has come and gone. He's never going to make it at Rangers, he's too injury-prone. When he is fit, he's a decent player, but he's far too injury-prone. Rangers need to clear the decks and have players that they can rely upon week in, week out. They need robust players and Ridvan is certainly not that. I can see him going back to Turkey, so I think left-back has got to be a priority. They are looking at strengthening the attacking areas too with £10million wingers. Graeme Young: That would be a statement of intent by the 49ers. Ryan McDonald: It would be. Whether it would be a straight loan deal or a £10million option to buy for Jesurun Rak-Sakyi, it's unclear at the minute. He looks like a real talent. Speaking to some Crystal Palace fans as well, they would be disappointed to lose him. I also think Rangers need a striker. Igamane will probably leave for big money and will fund more signings. You can't rely on Danilo. And Cyriel Dessers is Cyriel Dessers. He's always going to split opinion. He's Jekyll and Hyde and the best of times but he's still got a great scoring record. If he's to go, that's 24 goals out of your team so you need to replace him. Left-back and attacking areas for Rangers to strengthen. Graeme Young: I'm going to be controversial here. Jack Butland was excellent the other night in goals, but you could see straight away that Rangers need a sweeper keeper. That opens it up and makes it a different team. The way they want to move the ball out of defence, they need a keeper that's comfortable on the ball. Jack Butland's an important player, brilliant the other night and he'll need to be very good in Athens as well. It's not on him, but it's a different position they are looking for between the sticks. Celtic's transfer ambitions Ryan McDonald: Everyone talks about how it's five weeks until transfer deadline day. But the deadline for Celtic to get players in should be Thursday, August 14 because that's when they need to register their Champions League squad for the playoffs. That's less than three weeks away. So there's a matter of urgency to get signings in. I know Celtic like to leave it late to get their big-money signings, and yes, that could depend upon whether they qualify for the Champions League. Will Yang and Marco Tilio get you through to the group stages? You saw the difference in quality against Ajax in the attacking areas. Celtic seriously need to strengthen up top and they could do with another midfielder as well. They've got a luxury of options in the middle of the park but I really feel they need a powerhouse in the engine room, someone of the ilk of Victor Wanyama. They need muscle and power in the midfield especially when it comes to playing against Europe's elite. Graeme Young: I think Nygren playing more attacking midfield has caught some people by surprise as well. The assumption was maybe that he'd play in the wing like he did last season. He's a proper player. The bit I don't understand about Celtic is you watch them in Munich, they take Bayern all the way, you'd be moving heaven and earth then to get ahead of the game on transfers. It's obvious that this team is a level up, Brendan Rodgers has managed to take them a level up in the Champions League. With the amount of money in the bank, they need proper players. There's this theory that Engels and Idah's price tags have added a hesitance to go big again, but I think it's the opposite. I think you go again because that's where you are as a club."
