Foreign affairs committee begins discussions on contentious Occupied Territories Bill
the Occupied Territories Bill
on Tuesday, when senior officials from the
Department of Foreign Affairs
are questioned by TDs and Senators on a summary of the Bill published by the Government last week.
The Bill begins pre-legislative scrutiny and will continue on Wednesday when
Senator Frances Black
, who originally proposed the legislation back in 2018, appears before the
foreign affairs committee
.
Supporters of the Bill want it to be rushed through the Houses of the Oireachtas and passed into law before the summer break, but most sources acknowledge that is not feasible.
Last week, the Government published the heads of the Bill – a section-by-section summary – of the Israeli Settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Prohibition of Importation of Goods) Bill 2025, its version of the Occupied Territories Bill proposed by Senator Black.
READ MORE
It would ban the import of goods produced in the Israeli settlements, which are, according to International Court of Justice, illegally occupied Palestinian territories.
'Daddy' Trump meets Nato, while defence, trade and Gaza dominate EU summit
Listen |
44:28
However, the Government's version does not include a ban on services, which it says is not possible under European law, though that is disputed by pro-Palestine campaigners. The foreign affairs officials are expected to be questioned on this point.
It is expected that many committee members will seek to agree on a recommendation for the inclusion of services in the proposed legislation when the pre-legislative process is completed and a report compiled for the Government.
The process will continue over the coming weeks as the committee hears from several groups and interested parties, though it is not clear if the Israeli government will be invited to make a submission to the committee.
Israel withdrew its ambassador, Dana Erlich, from Dublin last year in protest at what it said was the anti-Israel stance of the Irish Government, something strongly disputed by Taoiseach Micheál Martin and Tánaiste Simon Harris. Allowing the Bill to begin its passage through the legislative process was specifically cited by the Israelis as part of the reason for closing their embassy here.
'We have been putting in place arrangements for extra sittings,' said Fianna Fáil TD John Lahart, who chairs the committee. 'We'll produce a report which will tee up the Dáil debate on the Bill.'
There is some nervousness in Government about the possible consequences of passing the Bill, with the US government and business organisations underscoring their opposition to the measure.
While the amount of trade between the State and the Occupied Territories is minuscule, the proposed legislation is seen – by supporters and opponents – as an important test case. Other European countries, frustrated with the lack of EU action against Israel on Gaza, have been asking the Irish Government about the legislation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Politicians ask questions about services and the Occupied Territories Bill but get few answers
POLITICIANS QUIZZED OFFICIALS from the Department of Foreign Affairs today about the government's draft bill to ban goods from Israeli settlements, but the pending legal advice from the Attorney General regarding the inclusion of services hung over much of the discussions. The Department's political director Gerard Keown and legal advisor Declan Smyth appeared before the Oireachtas Committee on Foreign Affairs and fielded questions from TDs and Senators looking for clarity on the bill and what it entails. But it was an area not covered by the draft legislation that featured most often in the queries put to the two civil servants. Most questions related to the decision not to include services alongside goods in the bill, but politicians made little ground on the topic as Smyth repeatedly said he would not pre-empt advice from the Attorney General (AG), which both he and Keown said would be delivered to the Department 'as soon as possible'. Numerous members of the Committee requested that the two officials pass the message onto the Department and the AG that time was of the essence, while also noting that the advice would be needed to inform their work on pre-legislative scrutiny. Fianna Fáil TD Shay Brennan was one of the members who raised concerns about the 'tight timeline'. He said that waiting on the AG advice was 'not going to work' while Sinn Féin's Donnachach Ó Laoghaire was also critical of the fact that the Committee was considering the bill without it. Fianna Fáil TD Seán Ó Fearghaíl also described the situation as 'very frustrating'. 'The attorney is very well aware of the time pressures and of the political priority attached to this bill,' Smyth said. The AG already provided legal advice about the inclusion of services in the original draft of the Occupied Territories Bill, but Smyth said that because the government is moving ahead with its own version, new advice had been sought. Advertisement The reason why services were not included in this new bill was that there is a regulation at EU level that allows member states to make unilateral decisions on the importation of goods from outside the single market, but there is no corresponding one for services. This, he said, had led to a 'two-track approach' whereby the government is seeking to deal with goods as an individual state and services through diplomacy at the EU level. US pressure One question asked by Shay Brennan concerned pressure applied by other countries in response to the government's plans to pass the original Occupied Territories Bill. Keown said that there was 'contact at official level' from the US government when Joe Biden was president, but he also noted that Tánaiste Simon Harris recently said there has been no such correspondence with the current administration. Later in the hearing, Senator Garret Ahern asked Keown if that correspondence could be provided to the Committee. 'I'll have to take that back to the Tánaiste,' Keown replied. The Ditch reported last year that the US ambassador at the time, Claire Cronin, had emailed government leaders expressing concern about the bill's impact on US companies and warning of 'consequences' if the bill was passed as it was. A few days later, then-Tánaiste Micheál Martin said he was 'not surprised' that the US had concerns. Keown also told the Committee today that the Department is currently analysing the potential economic consequences for Ireland if the bill passes. This, he said, is because there are a number of states who do not agree with Ireland on the issue. He also told the Committee that a number of EU member states and countries outside the bloc have been in touch to ask questions about the proposed legislation. Keown said the hope is that other countries follow Ireland's lead and adopt similar legislation. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Russia denies stalling peace efforts amid claims it has made fresh gains in Ukraine
The Kremlin rejected allegations from a US envoy that it is delaying attempts to end its war on Ukraine , amid claims that Russia's invasion force now controls the whole of its neighbour's Luhansk region and has seized territory in Dnipropetrovsk region for the first time. Keith Kellogg, a special envoy appointed by Donald Trump , decried as 'Orwellian' the claims from Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov this week that the pace of peace efforts depended on Washington and Kyiv. 'Russia cannot continue to stall for time while it bombs civilian targets in Ukraine,' Mr Kellogg said. But Mr Peskov said on Tuesday: 'No one is stalling anything.' READ MORE Using Russia's official term for its full-scale invasion of Ukraine, which began in February 2022, he also said: 'Naturally, we are primarily interested in achieving the goals we have set for the special military operation through diplomacy. That is why we are not interested in stalling. 'Naturally, we are thankful for the efforts that Washington and the Trump team members are making to promote talks on the Ukrainian settlement.' The US president's administration has put intense public pressure on pro-western Ukraine to accept the need for painful concessions to Moscow, while showing deep reluctance to criticise the Kremlin or strengthen sanctions on Russia. [ Russia grooms Ukrainian teens as spies, saboteurs and unwitting suicide bombers ] US senator Lindsey Graham said on Sunday that Mr Trump had encouraged him to seek a vote in Congress on a new sanctions Bill that would impose 500 per cent tariffs on countries that continued to buy Russian oil. Mr Peskov said of Mr Graham: 'His position is well known to us, and it is well known to the whole world. He belongs to a group of inveterate Russophobes, and if it were up to him these sanctions would have been imposed long ago. Would that help the settlement? That is a question for those who initiate such actions.' Kyiv continues to urge the US and European states to impose and enforce stricter economic sanctions on Russia and to expand and accelerate provision of weapons, ammunition and air defence systems to the Ukrainian military. Despite high losses in troops and equipment, Russia continues to grind forward in parts of eastern Ukraine and has seized about 200 sq km of the northern Sumy in recent months. Moscow-installed officials in occupied eastern Ukraine have now claimed that all of Luhansk region is under Russian control and that the village of Dachne has become the first territory in Dnipropetrovsk region to fall to the invasion force. Kyiv has not confirmed either claim. Ukrainian forces have held only small parts Luhansk for several years, but if Russia has established full control there it would be the first entire region to fall to Moscow's troops since they seized Crimea in 2014 with barely a shot being fired. Ukrainian towns and cities are also coming under intense nightly bombardments from Russian missiles and drones. Data from the country's air force showed that Russia launched 5,337 Shahed-type drones against Ukraine last month, more than 1,100 more than in March, which was the previous record month. The Shahed is a 'kamikaze' drone with a warhead of between 15kg-50kg that explodes on impact. Russia received large numbers of them from Iran , but now makes its own version. The warring neighbours traded missile and drone strikes early on Tuesday. Sources in the Ukrainian security service said its long-range attack drones had hit Russia's Kupol military plant in the city of Izhevsk, more than 1,000km from the front line. Local governor Alexander Brechalov said three people had been killed and 35 injured in a drone strike on a factory that he did not name.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Banks and defence sectors weigh on European shares
European shares fell on Tuesday on the back of poor performances from the banking and defence sectors, as uncertainty continues to weigh on investors. London bucked the European trend to close in the green. Dublin The Iseq All-Share index started the third quarter of the year in the red, down 87.71 points to 11,334.00. The Dublin stock exchange's losses were led by Kenmare Resources which dropped 3.61 per cent. Further developments around a possible acquisition of the firm by former boss Michael Carville emerged in recent days. In a mixed day for the banks, AIB fell 2.79 per cent to €6.79, joined by Bank of Ireland which dropped 1.66 per cent to €11.885, while Permanent TSB was steady. Defensive stock Uniphar plc, the healthcare services group, dropped 2.27 per cent to €3.665, while Ryanair dipped 0.83 per cent. READ MORE Of the big caps, Glanbia were the winners on the day, rising 2.64 per cent to €12.83 as its share price continues to recover. LONDON London's internationally oriented FTSE 100 rose 0.28 per cent, while the domestically-focused midcap index added 0.54 per cent. Midcap stocks ended June by logging their best quarter in over four years while the blue-chip index logged monthly losses. Drugmaker AstraZeneca's shares rose 2.7 per cent after multiple sources told the Times that chief executive Pascal Soriot was considering moving the company's listing to the US. Traders are currently pricing in a 78 per cent chance of a rate cut by the Bank of England in August. Precious metal mining stocks led sectoral gains, rising 2.4 per cent as safe-haven gold jumped over 1 per cent on the weaker dollar and US tariff uncertainty. Endeavour Mining and Fresnillo added 2.8 per cent and 1 per cent, respectively. Hochschild Mining gained 5.3 per cent. Losses were led by aerospace and defence index, which declined 2.2 per cent. Rolls-Royce fell 2.9 per cent and Babcock lost 2.5 per cent. Food retailer Sainsbury's shares slid 1.1 per cent despite reporting a higher-than-expected rise in quarterly sales. Standard Chartered Bank shares fell 2 per cent after liquidators for Malaysia's sovereign wealth fund 1MDB sued the bank in Singapore alleging fraud that led to more than $2.7 billion (€2.29) in losses more than 10 years ago. In other news, Britain's competition watchdog cleared Aviva's £3.7 billion ($5.08 billion) takeover of smaller rival Direct Line that will create the UK's largest home and motor insurer. Shares of Aviva were up 0.8 per cent, while those of Direct Line rose 0.5 per cent Europe European shares ended slightly lower on Tuesday, with industrials and banks the biggest drags as investors weighed uncertainty over US trade deals with the July tariff deadline fast approaching and discussions on a US tax bill. The pan-European STOXX 600 index closed 0.2 per cent lower, coming off a more than 1 per cent fall for the month of June. Most regional bourses clocked declines, though UK's blue-chip FTSE 100 was an outlier with a 0.3 per cent rise. Industrials led losses among the major STOXX subsectors with a 1.7 per cent fall. Defence-related companies including Germany's Rheinmetall, Sweden's Saab and Italy's Leonardo all fell more than 5 per cent each. Banks also slid 1.3 per cent, with Germany's Deutsche Bank down the most with a 3.6 per cent decline. New York The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq fell from record highs in midafternoon trading on Tuesday, as Tesla shares were hit by a renewed spat between chief executive Elon Musk and US President Donald Trump, while better-than-expected economic data backed the US central bank's patient stance on rate cuts. Tesla dropped after Mr Trump threatened to cut off the billions of dollars in subsidies that Mr Musk's companies get from the federal government, after Mr Musk revived his criticism of Mr Trump's wide-ranging tax-cut and spending bill. The major indexes were mixed, but technology stocks led the decline among the major S&P sectors, while material stocks and the healthcare sector climbed. Shares of US-based casino operators rose after Macau reported a rise in June gambling revenue. Wynn Resorts and Las Vegas Sands, as well as MGM Resorts International climbed. – Additional reporting, Reuters, PA.
