Moment trans netball player flattens opponent before being banned from league as rival teams threaten to boycott matches
Footage shows Manawa Aranui, a former elite men's player, crashing into an opponent during a hard but legal play in Australia.
4
4
4
4
The rival Romsey player hits the deck as Aranui — towering over her — immediately offers a hand to help her up.
The clash on Sunday's match has since sparked outrage across the Victorian netball community with.
On Wednesday, the Riddell District Netball Football League (RDFNL) announced that Aranui and another transgender player from Melton Central have now been banned for the rest of the 2025 season.
The bombshell move came after Melton South Netball Club threatened to boycott all games involving the pair over safety fears.
The league said: 'After lengthy consideration and consultation, the RDFNL has ruled that the two transgender participants be excluded from the RDFNL Netball Competitions for the remainder of the 2025 season on the premise that both participants exhibit superior stamina and physique over their competitors deeming Section 42 of the Sex Discrimination Act relevant.'
That section of the law allows sporting bodies to exclude players if "strength, stamina, or physique" could create an unfair advantage or risk.
Aranui — who previously starred in men's netball — has become a lightning rod in Australia's growing trans-in-sport debate.
She was named best on ground in a Division 1 grand final for Melton Central, fuelling calls for a ban.
Melton South netball coordinator Melissa Dawson said: 'One of the players is six foot something – it's ridiculous. Netball Victoria needs to put the safety of biological females first.'
B Grade player Erin added: 'I went up for the ball and just got pushed and dropped. They're so much stronger, and I'm genuinely scared I'll get hurt.'
Trans women are NOT women, Supreme Court rules in win for anti-woke campaigners after battle over female-only spaces
She said she would sit out any future games against Melton Central if the players remained in the lineup.
Another player added: 'It deters women from playing the sport they love. We've worked hard to keep girls in the game.'
Women's rights campaigner Sall Grover also weighed in, demanding Aranui's immediate removal from female competitions.
'There are many mixed-sex netball competitions at the recreational level,' she said.
'Everyone on those teams is making a choice to participate in a mixed-sex competition.'
Grover, founder of women-only social app Giggle for Girls, warned: 'Males on female teams put the females in danger, while taking away the limited opportunities there are for sportswomen.'
She continued: 'There are protections in the Sex Discrimination Act for female-only sport — look them up.
'It's about women having the right to play sport without fear of injury or losing opportunity.'
Despite being ruled ineligible by the Ballarat Football Netball League in April, Aranui was still playing for Melton Central until the RDFNL stepped in this week.
Melton Central president Paul Sinclair previously confirmed both transgender players would continue taking the court while the club awaited direction from Netball Victoria.
Now, that direction appears to be coming into sharper focus.
Netball Victoria has launched a formal investigation, engaging an independent expert to assess concerns raised by multiple clubs and players.
A spokesperson said: 'We support and welcome netballers of all backgrounds. That includes gender diverse players who have rights under anti-discrimination laws.'
Netball Victoria's 2018 policy — developed with Proud 2 Play and based on national guidelines — allows players to compete based on self-identified gender, not legal sex.
But the fierce backlash has put pressure on officials to review how those policies are applied when safety and fairness are raised.
Equality Australia argues against blanket bans, insisting 'community-level sport should focus on inclusion and participation.'
But critics say the current system fails to protect female athletes.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
4 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Australian activists allege they were ‘brutalised psychologically' after Israeli military detained Gaza aid boat
Two Australian activists say they were 'brutalised psychologically' and treated 'like criminals' by the Israeli military, including being strip-searched, shackled and denied external communication, after a boat they were on was intercepted and detained while attempting to transport aid to Gaza as part of the Freedom Flotilla Coalition. Journalist Tania 'Tan' Safi and human rights activist Robert Martin were among 21 activists on board the Handala when it was intercepted on Sunday and transported to Israel. It had carried food, baby formula, nappies and medicine, as Palestinians continue to starve in what UN-backed hunger experts have called a 'worst-case scenario of famine' unfolding. Sign up: AU Breaking News email On Friday morning local time, the Australians landed at Sydney airport after spending days in Israeli custody. Safi told reporters they were still 'a little bit wobbly' and felt 'very sore and weak'. The Handala crew had previously confirmed they would go on a hunger strike if the IDF intercepted the boat and detained its passengers. 'It feels like a bit of a dream at the moment to be honest … it's been a rough ride,' Safi said. 'We were dehydrated and exhausted. We've been disconnected from the world.' Safi said at least 30 IDF members boarded Handala when it was intercepted, and claimed all were armed, some with four guns. 'They knocked me in the leg with one of their machine guns,' Safi said. 'They were playing this odd psychological game of offering water and food with the camera crew, trying to get us to accept things from them, but none of us would. 'We don't want to take anything from an entity that is starving babies to death.' Safi said after arriving at the port of Ashdod, about 40km south of Tel Aviv, their bags were taken and they were placed in an interrogation room. Many items were still missing, she said. They confirmed reports that US labor activist Chris Smalls was physically assaulted by the IDF – including being choked and kicked in the legs. 'Chris, the only black man, was pinned down by seven or eight men,' Safi said. 'When I asked about him they came into the room and dragged me out by my arms, I'm still bruised from it. 'They pulled me out and threw me down on the floor, they made me take off all my clothes, they strip-searched me right there, made me squat up and down … they treated us like we were criminals.' Eventually Safi said they were able to see someone from the Australian embassy, who lobbied for the pair to be able to contact their friends and family and to access legal representation. 'In these prisons, we saw face-to-face the soullessness and the cruelty and brutality,' Safi said, adding that they had awoken to the sounds of a fellow inmate 'howling and screaming and crying in pain'. 'There were moments where they would handcuff me and grab the handcuffs and just throw me against the wall.' Martin said he had been 'manhandled' along with a few others when initially demanding legal representation. 'We had no rights … I have a lot of medication, they didn't allow any medication at all,' he said. 'The Australian government demanded I be able to make phone calls to my loved ones, they did not allow me to do that either, and anybody else.' Eventually, Martin said, the pair were shackled and transported from Tel Aviv to Jordan. In Jordan, they received assistance from the embassy and were taken to hospital, where they were temporarily deemed unfit to fly due to their weak condition. 'We thought they were going to just dump us there, that was very, very scary for us not knowing, having no phone, no money, no access to anything,' Martin said. Safi said they didn't realise how poor their condition was until they were hooked up to the IV in hospital and told they were 'really unwell'. 'I just passed out and slept for like 16 hours,' Safi said. 'I couldn't sleep [in prison] … they shine the torch in your face until you wake up, or they bang on the door every time you fall asleep. 'We did not commit any crimes. They tried to get us to sign documents that said we had entered Israel illegally, which is not true … we were taken completely against our will and brutalised psychologically in every way.' The last boat sent by Freedom Flotilla, the Madleen, was intercepted by the Israeli army in international waters on 9 June and towed to the Israeli port of Ashdod. It carried 12 campaigners on board, including Swedish activist Greta Thunberg, who were eventually expelled by Israel. In 2010, nine flotilla activists en route to Gaza on board the Mavi Marmara flagship vessel were shot a total of 30 times by Israeli soldiers. Five were killed by close-range gunshot wounds to the head. The Israeli embassy in Canberra and Israeli ministry for foreign affairs were approached for comment.
The Guardian
4 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Five Labor MPs defy NSW premier and vow to attend pro-Palestine march across Sydney Harbour Bridge
Several New South Wales Labor MPs have defied their premier, Chris Minns, by vowing to march across Sydney Harbour Bridge in support of Gaza this weekend as police attempt to challenge the protest in court. Labor's Stephen Lawrence, Anthony D'Adam, Linda Voltz, Cameron Murphy and Sarah Kaine were among 15 NSW politicians who signed an open letter on Thursday evening calling on the government to facilitate 'a safe and orderly event' on Sunday. Police were due to oppose the protest in the NSW supreme court on Friday afternoon. If successful, that move would strip protesters of certain legal protections and leave them vulnerable to arrest if they decided to proceed with a so-called 'unauthorised' march. Lawrence said the state's 'slow and steady demonisation of protest' risked repeating the events which led to Sydney's first Gay and Lesbian Mardi Gras march in 1978 being met with police violence. In a statement posted on Facebook on Friday morning, Lawrence criticised 'the passage of laws that allow police to be used to end protests the government doesn't like'. 'We have seen in these respects one long, unprincipled capitulation to reactionary politics and it is dangerous,' the Labor MLC said. 'I am a member of the Labor party, not the Liberal party. Our party is founded on protest and collective action. Attending is my way of sending a message that, in my view, we need to change course.' Lawrence said while the circumstances of the protest were 'not ideal', the event had become 'absolutely inevitable' which he said was 'largely because of the way it has been mishandled'. He said he wanted to attend Sunday's march to express his 'utter revulsion' at Israel's actions – which he said other countries, including Australia, had provided cover for. The other NSW parliamentarians who signed the letter calling on the government to allow the march over the harbour bridge were independents Alex Greenwich and Jacqui Scruby and the Greens' Jenny Leong, Tamara Smith, Kobi Shetty, Sue Higginson, Cate Faehrmann, Abigail Boyd and Amanda Cohn. Libertarian John Ruddick was also on the list. Greenwich, the state MP for Sydney, said he shared the 'widespread community horror' over what was happening in Gaza and said marching across the bridge would send a powerful message of solidarity. 'Having successfully lobbied the previous Coalition government to allow a march across the Sydney Harbour Bridge in support of LGBTQ equality during Sydney WorldPride, I know it can be done,' he said in a statement. On Tuesday afternoon, the deputy police commissioner Peter McKenna announced the force had rejected an application from the protest organisers proposing a route across the Harbour Bridge to the US consulate, citing safety risks as the reason. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion He said at the time, police were open to negotiating alternative routes. However, the protest organisers, the Sydney-based Palestine Action Group, said in a statement that the protest 'must go ahead' and vowed to fight in court for their right to stage a protected protest. The premier on Friday morning said he expected 'everybody in NSW to respect the outcome of the court's decision'. 'I acknowledge there's a lot of people in Sydney, in NSW, that want to be part of a protest,' Minns told reporters. 'They're very concerned about what's happening in Gaza to Palestinians and they want to be heard.' Minns said people who were planning to participate in the protest would still have 'every opportunity to be heard' even with an alternative route. Earlier in the week, he suggested a march over the bridge would cause the city to 'descend into chaos'. Sydney's weekly pro-Palestine rallies have typically involved marches through the CBD. A march across the Harbour Bridge could still go ahead on Sunday if even the court sides with police but protesters could face being arrested under anti-protest laws if they obstructed traffic, for example.
Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Revealed: NRL agents learn their fate after alleged fight outside a PUB during 2024 Australian Schoolboys carnival
Two prominent NRL agents have been issued huge fines and massive suspensions following an alleged fight outside a NSW pub last year. NRL officials confirmed on Thursday they plan to ban Nash Dawson for nine months and Gavin Orr six months respectively over the alleged incident. The duo will also be fined $15,000 and $10,000, with the pair given five business days to respond to the breach notices. Combined, Dawson and Orr represent some of the game's best talent. Dawson manages the affairs of many NRL stars, namely Broncos stars Ezra Mam and Reece Walsh, Dolphins fullback Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow and Roosters young gun Robert Toia. Orr is the owner and director of sport at Pacific Sport Management, whose talent list includes Eels pivot Dylan Brown, Broncos winger Selwyn Cobbo, Melbourne Storm halfback Jahrome Hughes and Dragons veteran Valentine Holmes. 'The notices allege that both agents have breached the NRL Accredited Agent Scheme Rules and the Accredited Agents' Code of Conduct following a physical altercation at the Australian Secondary Schools Rugby League Championships in 2024,' the NRL said in a statement. 'It is also alleged the agents failed to co-operate with the NRL integrity unit. 'Under the Accredited Agents' Code of Conduct, Accredited Agents are required to operate with high personal and professional standards.' The altercation is believed to have happened outside of a pub, while the pair were in Port Macquarie on the Mid North Coast of NSW last year during the Australian Secondary Schools Rugby League Championships. Realistically, the impact on either of the pair's clients is likely to be minimal, given Dawson and Orr's colleagues can handle matters in their absence. It comes after fellow agents Mario Tartak and Matthew Desira were also recently handed bans from the NRL for breaches of the accredited agent scheme. Tartak - who is the director of Crown Sports Management - has Damien Cook and Josh Addo-Carr on his books. He has been proposed a 12-month suspension and $25,000 fine while Desira is facing a six-month suspension and $10,000 fine. Desira is the director of Aria Management Group, with Jayden Campbell, Greg Marzhew and Bronson Xerri key clients.
