Rs40b scandal exposes gaps in govt depts
During the high-level meeting chaired by Assembly Speaker Babar Saleem Swati, department representatives mostly shifted blame onto each other. The speaker criticized the departments for their poor coordination, emphasizing that this is not just a Rs40 billion scandal, but likely part of a broader corruption network potentially reaching Rs500-600 billion.
In contrast, the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) earned praise for recovering Rs20 billion from the misappropriated funds. Speaker Swati highlighted this as a rare case where no political figures are implicated, and said the scandal involves deep-rooted institutional corruption, especially within the AG Office, Finance Department, and C&W.
Despite the magnitude of the corruption, only two officials were suspended initially. The PAC ordered the suspension of additional officials across the involved departments. The AG's office was instructed to suspend two more officers within three days and initiate further action. Finance and C&W were also directed to identify and penalize more employees.
The AG claimed NAB had taken all records related to Upper Kohistan and had not returned them. However, NAB clarified that it only takes copies of documents, not originals. The Speaker reprimanded the AG for overstepping boundaries and insisted the office should have maintained copies.
The C&W Secretary revealed that an internal inquiry had led to the suspension of seven officials, but the PAC demanded all SDOs and XENs from 2019 to 2024 be suspended. The Speaker added that even check signatories must be held accountable. Contractors operating under fake companies are to be blacklisted, along with their beneficiaries.
DG Audit Sirajul Haq informed the committee that over Rs21 billion in irregularities were detected last year alone, and more discrepancies worth Rs6 billion were found in 18 districts. He stressed the need to audit a full decade's worth of records from Kohistan, promising a complete report by December.
A heated exchange also erupted between PPP MPA Ahmad Karim Kundi and Finance Advisor Muzzammil Aslam, with Kundi demanding Aslam's resignation. Aslam denied any involvement in the scandal, asserting his department's innocence. The session concluded with warnings that no department or officer would be spared accountability.
Speaker Swati summed up the sentiment: "This isn't just theftit's systematic institutional failure."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
40 minutes ago
- Express Tribune
Kidney racket busted; victim rescued
Airport Police on Saturday arrested four people, who were allegedly involved in running an illegal human kidney transplant racket, during a raid at a rented residence situated in a private housing society, also rescuing a patient, who was found restrained on a stretcher. Police sources said that the gang had been targeting vulnerable individuals by luring them with false promises of employment, only to later remove their kidneys for unlawful sale. A wider operation is now underway to trace and arrest other members and facilitators of the network. A spokesperson for Rawalpindi Police said that the raid followed a call to the emergency helpline (15), during which a caller reported screams and cries emanating from a neighbouring house. Police responded immediately and, upon arrival, discovered a man tied to a stretcher, who was subsequently freed. Preliminary investigations revealed that the victim had been drugged into a semi-conscious state and subjected to a series of medical tests, believed to be preparatory steps for the illegal removal and sale of his kidney. The swift and timely intervention of the police prevented what could have been a life-threatening act of organ harvesting. The suspects arrested at the scene were identified as Akif Aftab, Naseem Butt, Rakesh Masih, and Shawn Masih. Police also recovered surgical instruments and medical equipment used in the unlawful procedures. During questioning, the suspects admitted to trafficking kidneys to both Pakistani and foreign clients. The rescued victim informed the authorities that he had been lured under the pretext of a job opportunity. Police have affirmed that operations are ongoing to identify and apprehend the remaining members of the network. Ensuring the safety and protection of citizens' lives and property remains the foremost priority of the Rawalpindi Police, who have pledged to pursue all involved to the fullest extent of the law, the spokesman maintained. In March 2023, Rawalpindi police had unearthed a gang allegedly involved in depriving people of their kidneys and transplanting them to foreigners. Police and the Punjab Human Organ Transplant Authority (PHOTA) conducted a surprise raid at a private hospital in Morgah, arresting 10 people, including three doctors, and recovering Rs20 million from them.
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Sugar crisis
EDITORIAL: Public Accounts Committee (PAC) under the chairmanship of Junaid Akbar, a Pakistan Tehrik-i-Insaaf loyalist, has sought records of sugar mill owners and exporters to determine the cause behind the escalation in the price of sugar in the domestic market – a recurring cause reminiscent of the boom-bust cycle in the country's balance of payment position that has compelled successive administrations to periodically seek an International Monetary Fund (IMF) loan. The country is currently on the harshest-ever upfront programme – the twenty-fourth in our history, average three years per programme. The root of the recurring problem is as follows: the growers are seen lined-up with their cane outside mills which are, on occasion, not immediately accepted by the mill owners due to reasons ranging from a deliberate delay in the start of crushing due to price disputes, capacity limitations of mills and the middlemen (aarthis) exploiting farmers. Once the cane is accepted after negotiating the price downward, the mill owners begin crushing. The Sugar Advisory Board (SAB), headed by the Minister for Food Security and Research, with provincial cane commissioners and representatives from the politically powerful Pakistan Sugar Mills Association (with 80 plus members) reviews the sugar stocks to determine scarcity and or surplus. The SAB recommends exports to Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) of the Cabinet, the highest economic policymaking forum, only if there is an assurance that there are surplus stocks — an assurance that has been given time and again through data fudging — exports would in no way impact on domestic prices. In several years, allowing exports have been accompanied by a subsidy paid at the taxpayers' expense on the plea that the international price of sugar is lower than the cost to the mill owners. Mid-October 2024, Musaddiq Mailk as Sugar Monitoring Committee chair was replaced with Ishaq Dar who allowed export of 0.500 million metric tons (MT) of sugar, in addition to the already approved 0.140 million MT, based on the following data: 2.054 million MT of sugar was available with 5.465 MT consumed domestically in ten months, 0.900 million MT was projected to be used in the next two months premised on the September data (which was 0.450 million MT – a quantity that was set aside). Failure to allow legal exports, it was argued, would lead to smuggling of sugar across the Afghan border. That this argument backed by trumped-up data was flawed, as in previous years, is evident, given the subsequent rise in domestic prices reaching a high of 210 rupees per kg in Islamabad this week past prompting the Minister for Food Security to publicly propose deregulating the sugar industry as well as lifting a long-standing ban on new sugar mill licences. Would these proposed measures assist in resolving the issue for all times to come? The answer sadly is not positive because it presupposes that sugar operates in the open market where there are too many buyers and sellers to be able to influence market price. This is not the case in Pakistan where most items which are operating in open market conditions in other countries have managed to establish associations duly registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan that allows them to operate in the market as oligopolists (few buyers who collude to set prices) and through their pervasive influence in the country's politics to get approval for exports and export subsidies. In addition, lifting the ban on issuing sugar mill licences, a ban that was violated by the ruling Sharif family during a previous administration, would in all probability allow for even more of a concentration of mills in the hands of a few. This, in turn, may exacerbate the situation. To conclude, the prevalence of associations for products that operate in open market conditions in other countries must be revisited and the Competition Commission of Pakistan strengthened to take up the challenge of powerful influential groups. In addition, the government also needs to revisit sugar as a large-scale manufacturing sector with a weightage of 3.43 in the calculation of large scale manufacturing sector that provides justification for government support. And finally, there is a need to update and delink the data from those whose interest it is to manipulate it. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Sugar export scheme: PTI for formation of high-powered JV
ISLAMABAD: The Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) on Thursday called for the formation of a high-powered judicial commission to investigate what it described as one of the country's largest economic scandals – a sugar export scheme that allegedly cost the national treasury Rs287 billion. The scheme reportedly resulted in approximately Rs300 billion in unlawful profits to politically connected elites. The demand followed revelations presented to the Public Accounts Committee (PAC), which PTI said exposed a well-orchestrated scheme of plunder carried out by members of the ruling coalition and shielded by state institutions. In a statement, PTI spokesman Sheikh Waqas Akram called for a transparent and comprehensive enquiry into the scandal. He named Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, his deputy Ishaq Dar, members of the Economic Coordination Committee (ECC), and the Federal Cabinet as those who should be investigated for their alleged roles in approving and executing the controversial sugar export policy. PTI characterised the crisis not as mismanagement, but as 'a premeditated economic crime.' It alleged that sugar was exported despite domestic shortages, then re-imported at higher prices. This, the party claimed, artificially inflated costs for consumers and profited a select few. According to PTI, the policy was led by Dar during his tenure as chair of both the Sugar Advisory Board and the ECC. Akram said these approvals, which later received Cabinet assent, created a 'chain of command' linking senior government officials to the financial losses. The PAC's report, cited by PTI, estimates the national loss at Rs287 billion and points to nearly Rs300 billion in illicit gains allegedly pocketed by politically connected families and business interests. Among those named are the Sharif family, President Asif Zardari and his associates, Suleman Shehbaz, and businessman Jahangir Tareen. PTI also accused the ruling elite of misleading the public by downplaying shortages, inflating prices, and manipulating trade to generate windfall profits. The party claimed that state institutions – including the National Accountability Bureau (NAB), Federal Investigation Agency (FIA), Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), and the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) – had remained silent spectators. The statement contrasted the current situation with former Prime Minister Imran Khan's tenure, when a Sugar Enquiry Commission was formed in 2020 to investigate similar profiteering. 'Back then, the report named culprits across party lines,' the spokesperson noted. 'Today, those same networks are in power.' The party also questioned the fairness of the accountability system, claiming that legal scrutiny disproportionately targets Imran Khan while 'real plunderers of public wealth' operate with impunity. PTI has called for sugar prices to be rolled back to 2022 levels as an emergency relief measure. It also urged the PAC to demand updates from the FIA on all pending sugar-related cases and called for criminal proceedings against those involved in alleged fake exports and hoarding. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
