Group files injunction to stop the fluoridation of Calgary's drinking water
A local group is trying to put a stop to fluoridation and has filed an injunction at the Alberta Court of King's Bench.
Safe Water Calgary believes fluoridation is a public health threat to Calgarians and says the risk of damage is not worth the dental benefit.
'It's not safe, it's not effective and we have good science to prove that,' said Dr. Robert Dickson, founder of Safe Water Calgary.
Adding fluoride to Calgary's drinking water has been a long contentious issue.
Calgarians most recently had their say in 2021 during a plebiscite, with 62 per cent voting in favour of reintroducing fluoride back into the water system.
Since then, the city has spent more than $28 million to upgrade both water treatments plants to be able to add in the fluoride.
Many dentists and dental organizations say research and data proves the benefits of fluoridated water.
However, Safe Water Calgary argues fluoride contains toxic substances and puts young children at risk.
'205,000 people back in 2021 are now dictating policy for 1.6 million people who didn't vote for it back then,' said Dickson.
The group is calling for a pause on fluoridation until an expert panel can look into it and all sides can agree on how the city should move forward.
The injunction will be heard in court Wednesday at noon with a rally held outside the building at the same time.
(With files from Mason DePatie)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
29 minutes ago
- CTV News
Obesity rates in Canada increased faster during pandemic than in previous 11 years
A closeup of a beam scale in New York, Tuesday, April 3, 2018. THE CANADIAN PRESS/AP-Patrick Sison TORONTO — A new report says the prevalence of obesity increased faster during the COVID-19 pandemic than it did over the course of more than a decade beforehand, specifically in young adults. The research published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal looked at obesity rates over a 15-year period based on the body mass index of almost 750,000 people who were 18 or older. Researchers say they saw an increase of about eight per cent over the first 11 years of the study, from 2009 to 2020, compared to an increase of more than one percentage point a year between 2020 and 2023. That's about twice the pre-pandemic rate of increase. Laura Anderson, the study's author and an associate professor at McMaster University, says these findings suggest public health restrictions during the COVID-19 pandemic may have had an impact on obesity rates. Anderson says there was a 'steep increase' in obesity rates among young adults, particularly young females, who showed an increase of 4.7 per cent between 2020 and 2023 in the youngest age group. Dr. Mélanie Henderson, a pediatric endocrinologist and researcher at the CHU Sainte-Justine, says the closure of gyms, extracurricular programs, schools and workplaces led to an absence of structure, extra screen time and closer proximity to the fridge. 'It was kind of the perfect storm,' says Henderson, who had no connection to the study. She adds that adolescence is a vulnerable time that could have made younger adults more susceptible to pandemic conditions. The study also suggests that stress related to changes in job status or caregiving may have led to weight gain for some. But it also says further study is needed to better understand the causes and how they can be prevented in the future. Henderson says the first step is creating policies that ensure health-care services are available to treat and manage obesity. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 14, 2025. Canadian Press health coverage receives support through a partnership with the Canadian Medical Association. CP is solely responsible for this content. Hannah Alberga, The Canadian Press
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
'Keep the doors open': As ERs close, doctor speaks out on the challenges of practising in rural Sask.
The senior lead physician of a Saskatchewan Medical Association program that provides help for rural doctors is speaking out on the challenges they face, after a number of temporary rural emergency room closures forced by a shortage of medical professionals in the province. "We tend to get the feeling that from an emergency perspective … the importance is placed on just keeping the door open, not necessarily, you know, keeping the door open when we are adequately staffed," Dr. Francois Reitz said in an interview Tuesday, as he was coming off a 24-hour emergency room shift. Reitz works with the medical association's rural relief program, which provides short-term locum relief to general and family doctors working in rural communities with fewer than five practising physicians. The workload for health-care workers in rural areas has increased from when he first started with the program 20 years ago, he said, including greater demand from patients as health conditions have become more complex. At the same time, there is a shortage of health-care workers in rural areas. "It's not just physician shortages that we're seeing," Reitz said. "My nursing colleagues, my pharmacy colleagues, my lab techs, etc. — there's a shortage of everybody." That's resulted in many rural health-care workers who are on call "every single day," he said, which means they struggle with work-life balance or may have to reduce services. When somebody calls in sick, there's often nobody to replace them, Reitz said. "I need certain things to be able to deal with the heart attack or if there's a motor vehicle accident," he said. "If I don't have those resources available to me, I cannot do the best that I can from a rural perspective. And rural, classically, we deal with fewer resources that we have to juggle." The expectation to "keep the doors open" for health services like emergency rooms can compromise the quality of care for patients, which is top of mind for doctors, said Reitz. "Our concerns are more about not being able to provide that quality of care," he said. "When one hasn't had sleep or [doesn't] have enough staff, what is slipping through the cracks?" Shortage has been approaching for years Reitz said the current doctor shortage is not a complete surprise. He said by 2018-19, it was known the field would run into a "mass retiring of doctors," due to the number of baby boomers working at that time. Then came the COVID-19 pandemic, which was both a wake-up call and catalyst for the health-care system, he said. "I think it highlighted a lot of weaknesses within our health-care system, both with current planning and future management," said Reitz. Many health-care workers also started to reassess their roles within the system and opted for better work-life balance, leading some to restrict their practices. Residents and leaders in some rural Saskatchewan communities have started to speak out about the shortage of doctors, and how many resign early. That comes down to a few factors, said Reitz. As the population grows, the province is not producing enough physicians to replace those who leave the field, he said. Instead, Reitz said Canada has relied heavily on international medical graduates — he was recruited from South Africa just over 20 years ago. "You are more likely to find an international medical graduate in rural Saskatchewan than you are to find a Canadian graduate," he said. Typically, a rural doctor will do a roughly five-year term, Reitz said. But as recruitment relies more heavily on international doctors, there seems to be fewer who stay in rural areas long-term. For those from some religious or cultural backgrounds, it can be hard to access community, traditional foods or religious services in rural areas, he said. "Saskatchewan has traditionally been very, very difficult for international medical graduates who are not of a Christian or atheist background," Reitz said. Many come to realize they would be "happier, healthier and in a better financial state after a year … moving anywhere else, whether it's centrally or out of province," he said. Pay is another factor in turnover, with the compensation not always matching the long hours rural physicians are expected to work, said Reitz. "Being a physician is not the high-paying job that it used to be 20 or 30 years ago," he said. "But then again, how do you sell to the public that a doctor is not being adequately paid? This is something which both culturally, as well as historically, is a very difficult argument to make." 'We have a lot of interest' The head of the Saskatchewan Healthcare Recruitment Agency says it works with international applicants to try to ease the transition. "Once we are aware of an applicant, we start working with them to understand where they were educated, what their currency or practice is, if they would be new to Canada," said chief executive officer Terri Strunk. The provincial agency's role is to reach out to medical residents and graduates locally, nationally and globally to try to find physicians, she said. There are many qualifications that have to be met through the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, the national regulatory body, she said. Once a doctor is deemed eligible, the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Saskatchewan and the Saskatchewan Health Authority work to determine which vacancy they could fill, said Strunk. The province offers competitive incentives and opportunities to doctors, and "we have a lot of interest in Saskatchewan because of the nature of our physician workforce here," she said. "They want to make that decision, and then what's the fastest way I can get there." With that, there needs to be consideration for international workers around where they should be located and how they can best be prepared to practise there, said Strunk. "Practising in a rural area of Saskatchewan is different from practising in one of our rural centres," she said. "You might have a physician, you know, practising in a remote or rural community of Saskatchewan that may have never seen … an agricultural accident before." The recruitment agency has worked hard over the last year to share information with communities about which factors influence retention of health-care workers in rural and remote areas, said Strunk. "Communities are the first to want to keep their health facilities open — they want to keep their doctors there, but oftentimes they don't know what they don't know," she said. "They may not realize that … [doctor] might be feeling socially isolated, or perhaps the spouse hasn't been able to find work." The agency is also looking at what has worked for communities that have good retention, and sharing that with others through a health-care tool kit. "It's just also about making sure that we, as a recruitment agency … and the employer at the Saskatchewan Health Authority and that community know who that physician is, what their needs are, as much as we can," Strunk said.
CBC
an hour ago
- CBC
Revamp of Manitoba's air quality monitoring infrastructure needed for 'smokier future,' says expert
Social Sharing Manitoba is looking to expand the infrastructure it has to monitor air quality, a step experts say is important to better map pollution and its long-term health effects worsened by smoke billowing from wildfires. "This isn't a problem that's going away," said Christopher Pascoe, a University of Manitoba associate professor whose research focuses on the impact of wildfire smoke on chronic respiratory diseases. Thousands of people have been forced out of their homes by wildfires in Manitoba since May. It has been a record-breaking season where the province has been put under a state of emergency twice to address the influx of people fleeing from their home — some from worsening air quality. Manitoba operates four air quality monitoring stations — two in Winnipeg, one each in Brandon and Flin Flon — that collect the dirt out of the air and measure the concentration of health-harming particles lingering in the environment. Environment and Climate Change Canada said it draws data from those stations to forecast air quality. The department also pulls in information about contaminants in the air from low-cost sensors that have been installed independently by residents and communities through the province. But Sarah Henderson, a scientific director of environmental health services at the British Columbia Centre for Disease Control, said there's an opportunity to better map pollution drifting from wildfire in the long-term by expanding the infrastructure Manitoba has to monitor air quality. "Wildfires are highly episodic, highly unpredictable," Henderson said. "Four monitors doesn't tell the full story of what's going on when you're having wildfire smoke impacts." Most of the infrastructure Environment Canada uses to forecast air quality in Manitoba is clustered in the southern part of the province. According to an independently created map, which Environment Canada said shows the monitors meteorologists use to forecast air quality, there are roughly 10 stations or sensors north of Dauphin, Man., a city about 250 kilometres northwest of Winnipeg. And all but at least two of these stations in northern Manitoba are in Flin Flon,Thompson and Churchill. In remote or fly-in communities without sensors, Environment Canada said it relies on forecast models, weather observers in airports and satellite imaging to track wildfire smoke and predict its impact to air quality. "But it would be even more accurate if we had an air quality monitor in the community," Henderson said. "Smoke is really dynamic," she said. "Even within a couple of kilometres, the concentrations can be really different." For instance, it is not rare for the two air quality stations in Winnipeg — which are less than four kilometres apart — to show different concentrations of air pollutants from wildfire smoke, said Pascoe. "It can vary even across that relatively small distance," he said. "Without access to that data it makes it more difficult to … really understand what the health effects of poor air are," Pascoe said. "Especially in the north where we've got vulnerable populations that are living right next to these burning forests." One of the closest air quality monitors to Lynn Lake, a town in northwest Manitoba of around 600 people, is about 230 kilometres away in Flin Flon. Henderson and Pascoe agree that the monitor wouldn't provide an accurate reading for the town's air quality given the distance and other models are used to forecast it and trigger warnings, such as one that put Lynn Lake on evacuation alert in late June. Environment Canada said the town could get its air quality index after satellite imaging tracked the smoke that passes through it and found the closest monitor to measure the concentration of pollutants — bringing back the information to get the health risk combined with forecast models. But "you do need more stations in areas where wildfire concern is highest," Pascoe said. "Northern Manitoba … is such a large swath of area that you could have no air quality advisory in place because your air quality monitoring station in Flin Flon and Thompson says there's no air quality advisory," he said. "But in other parts of the province, there could very well be an air quality advisory that isn't being picked up." Planning for a 'smokier future' Environment Canada said they are trying to expand the number of air quality stations and sensors in Manitoba's north in hopes of better monitoring the impacts of wildfire smoke in air quality. "We have a couple tools in the toolbox, but it would obviously be very beneficial as well if we got more of these stations," said Crawford Luke, a meteorologist with the federal agency. But there are some limitations. Sensors most of the time require Wi-Fi and power to feed back the data needed to calculate air quality — a hurdle in remote communities Environment Canada is hoping to overcome, Luke said. A spokesperson for the province told CBC News the government is also planning to expand air quality monitoring using low-cost air-quality sensors in "strategic locations," specifically remote communities frequently impacted by wildfire smoke. But no specifics on the plan have so far been shared, other than saying the province is still in the process of investigating opportunities, including how to configure it best with the existing stations. In the short-term, Pascoe said more air quality infrastructure would also allow Environment Canada to better predict how smoke is drifting as wind directions change and provide more accurate estimates, including in Winnipeg, of when it is unsafe to be outside especially during the wildfire season. Henderson said Environment Canada has been trying to fill in the gaps of air quality monitoring on the map, encouraging communities to install their own sensors in recent years. It is part of transforming an air quality monitoring network that was originally established in Canada to evaluate pollution from traffic and industry. "Those are still important sources, but we have made great progress in regulating those over time," she said. "But what we do see is a lot more wildfire smoke and we're going to keep seeing that." While air quality monitors are not necessarily needed to inform the public that it is smoky outside because pollutants are visible in high concentrations, the value of having these tools is for the long-term, Henderson said. "Wildfire smoke affects your health when it's happening, but it's also going to have a longer lasting effect," she said. Those pile up over time and having better data can help scientists understand the effects of wildfire smoke in a particular location. "As we move into this smokier future, it would be great if people could have had access to something that says how many smoky days have you had in the past 10 years?" she said.
