‘Same as Phala Phala' – Police committee member not optimistic about Mchunu investigations
The portfolio committee on police and the portfolio committee on justice and constitutional development officially adopted their report, recommending to the National Assembly that an ad hoc committee be established to consider allegations made by KwaZulu-Natal police commissioner, Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi.
The committees held a joint meeting on Tuesday, during which they agreed that an ad hoc Committee was the most effective parliamentary mechanism for fully investigating Mkhwanazi's allegations.
The report further proposed that the National Assembly establish the committee within three months.
Mchunu allegations a 'constitutional crisis'
'What makes this matter urgent is that the issue of the law will be heavily challenged,' said committee member and MK party MP David Mandla Skosana.
'Solomon Mahlangu was hanged because of the so-called law, and General Mkhwanazi went out and said he wants to see justice prevail, and society is waiting for us. If the legal opinion comes against us, we must have a Plan B, because we can't sing the same song like in the 1940s, 1960s and 1970s.
ALSO READ: Senzo Mchunu investigation will take longer to finalise, says Public Protector
'We are the seventh administration. We must see this thing succeed, irrespective of all these other bureaucratic issues, which we will have to address in this matter.'
'Public Protector investigation'
Skosana further expressed a lack of confidence in the investigation being conducted by the Office of the Public Protector.
Public Protector Kholeka Gcaleka was special advisor to Mchunu when he was Minister of Public Service and Administration.
ALSO READ: Mchunu denies ties to Cat Matlala, as tenderpreneur bust with cellphone in prison
'The country is in crisis. For us to say the public protector will come up with something, I can tell you, it will be the same song as in Phala Phala and what we have seen in other matters, because people are closing ranks here,' said Skosana.
'It's painful for some of us to say these things here, to say we know the end product is. We should go into this matter with our eyes wide open. We have already seen utterances in the media. The suspended minister has now said things, and the so-called appointed minister.
'We have a constitutional crisis in this country, and we must accept that it's not going to be smooth sailing. I don't have confidence in the so-called commission because at the end of the day, once there is politics at play here, there is no justice. What is going to happen at the end of the day is exactly what happened with the Phala Phala report.
WATCH: Mbalula warns of deepfake video falsely claiming he said Senzo Mchunu is guilty
'In this issue, we need justice, because if our law is not going to restore dignity and the public trust in the Saps [South African Police Service] and the judiciary, then we're just buying time, and it's just optics. We need to get to the bottom of this. There should not be anything between us and the truth.'
'Code of ethics'
On Thursday, 10 July, the Public Protector confirmed its investigation into Mchunu, as requested by the African Transformation Movement (ATM).
'In line with section 3(1) of EMEA, which provides that the Public Protector must investigate any alleged breach of the code of ethics on receipt of a complaint contemplated in section 4, you are hereby advised that the Public Protector has initiated an investigation into the allegations you have raised,' the office said.
ALSO READ: Mchunu denies ties to Cat Matlala, as tenderpreneur bust with cellphone in prison
The party laid at least four complaints against Mchunu, including allegations of enabling interference by outside parties in Saps operations, irregularly disbanding the Political Killings Task Team, unduly delaying and derailing investigations and a conflict of interest in the awarding of a R360 million Saps contract to Matlala.
However, the Public Protector cautioned that the investigation into the matter would not be finalised within 30 days, 'due to the number of issues raised in your complaint'.
'The Public Protector will therefore submit a report when the investigation has been finalised.
'We commit, in the circumstances, to make every effort to expedite the finalisation of the investigation and will accordingly continue to keep you apprised of the progress thereof.'
READ NEXT: Magashule says Mchunu should step aside, but ANC says there is no need for that
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Eyewitness News
20 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
It's all systems go for MPs in ad hoc committee probing police graft allegations
CAPE TOWN - Members of Parliament's ad hoc committee investigating police corruption are ready to get started as early as next week. The National Assembly ad hoc committee investigating the allegations made by KwaZulu-Natal Provincial Police Commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi will meet on Tuesday as it races against time to conclude its work within three months. This week, Parliament named the 18-member committee comprising eight parties represented in Parliament. Parliament might be on a lengthy recess, but the multi-party committee is expected to meet during the break from next week. ALSO READ: - National Assembly greenlights establishment of ad hoc committee to probe Mkhwanazi claims - Parties want Mkhwanazi to expose all those implicated in alleged police corruption When the committee meets on Tuesday, the first order of business will be electing a chairperson, who will most likely come from the African National Congress (ANC). But committee member Lisa Schickerling said they're raring to go. 'We do look forward to it. It is going to be a very interesting ad hoc committee, and we really hope that we get clarity for South Africans.' The committee will start its probe in the coming weeks which will look at the nature and implications of relationships between senior police leadership and certain members of the public, among others.
IOL News
21 hours ago
- IOL News
Mchunu discloses staggering R15. 5 billion in civil claims against SAPS
Police Minister Senzo Mchunu says the SAPS paid R528 million in 2023/24 for wrongful arrests and detentions. Image: GCIS Police Minister Senzo Mchunu has disclosed that the police are facing civil claims amounting to R15.5 billion for shooting incidents and wrongful arrests and detentions that were recorded in the 2023/24 financial year. Mchunu also said the police have paid R528 million after being ordered by courts and also made settlements during the same period. He released these figures before he was placed on special leave. He was responding to written parliamentary questions from IFP MP Russel Cebekhulu, who noted 'the significant financial strain that civil claims against the State place on public resources, particularly those arising from police misconduct'. Cebekhulu had wanted to know the total number of civil claims made against the SAPS, specifically from wrongful arrests and killings by police officers, as well as the value of the claims and amount paid out. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading In his reply, Mchunu said there were 15,067 claims received for wrongful arrest and detention, and 180 for shooting incidents. He said the amount claimed for wrongful arrest and detention stood at R14.8 billion and R741m for shooting incidents. Mchunu hastened to state that the number of new claims and the amount claimed were not the amounts paid by the State during the 2023/24 financial year. He stated that the State paid a total of R466m for wrongful arrest and detention. This was made up of R445m for payments as a result of court orders and R20m in payments by settlements for wrongful arrest and detention. The amount paid for shooting incidents was R62m, made up of R57m in court order payments and R4.6m settlements. Last December, Independent Media quoted Mchunu as saying the SAPS was saddled with R56.7 billion in contingent liabilities arising from 46,621 unlawful arrests and detention claims instituted in the period from 2018 until October 2024. 'It is the contingent liability, which is a liability that may be incurred by an entity, depending on the outcome of an uncertain future event, such as the outcome of a pending lawsuit,' he said at the time. National Police Commissioner Fannie Masemola previously confirmed to the Police Portfolio Committee that they have more civil claims. 'Our contingent liability is quite high when it comes to real claims but when we pay, the amounts are down,' said Masemola. In her 2023/24 report, Auditor-General Tsakani Maluleke flagged civil claims against the SAPS, which was a defendant in several lawsuits. 'The outcome of the matters could not be determined, and no provision for any liability that may result was made in the financial statement,' she said. Asked by Cebekhulu about measures implemented to reduce the number and severity of civil claims arising from police conduct, Mchunu said the SAPS has established national and provincial steering committees to manage the civil claims. The focus was to change 'attitudes and behaviours' of SAPS employees to prevent unlawful actions. 'The national steering committee has developed and is implementing an internal communication plan, which regularly sensitises members on the root causes of civil claims and the actions that are required to prevent them from occurring. 'This committee also identifies, monitors, and engages the top 10 contributing police stations with regard to civil claims,' he said. Mchunu also said there was conducting of training on legal prescripts and mandates as well as the distribution of circulars to members as part of the internal communication plan to provide guidance and standardisation on how to affect arrest and the interpretation of the 48-hour rule regarding detention.
The Citizen
21 hours ago
- The Citizen
Parliament announces members of ad hoc committee investigating Mkhwanazi allegations
The EFF's Julius Malema is among those who have called on the public to provide information that will lead to the dismantling of criminality. Parliament has announced the members of the ad hoc committee that will investigate allegations made by KwaZulu-Natal provincial police commissioner Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi about security matters. This after the National Assembly (NA) adopted the joint report of the portfolio committee on police and the portfolio committee on justice and constitutional development on the allegations made by Mkhwanazi on 23 July. The two committees have requested the process to be concluded within 90 days of the committee being instituted, provided that the timeframe may be amended or extended if necessary. ALSO READ: Judiciary requests Mkhwanazi to provide evidence of allegations They also called for the ad hoc committee to be appropriately resourced, including having ready access to external forensic and legal advisory services. There is a further call for the possible need to provide for the protection of potential whistleblowers about the best way to facilitate public participation and transparency. 'As far as possible, meetings should be conducted openly and, whenever possible, broadcast on Parliament TV and its social media channels,' said the two committees during their joint sitting last month. 'Mkhwanazi opened the way' Addressing supporters at the EFFTurns12 rally at Khayelitsha Rugby Stadium on Saturday, EFF leader Julius Malema called on the public to come forward with information. 'People must come to parliament and tell us who the drug lords are and who is protecting them, because we need to start fighting drugs. We want to know where the guns come from in the Cape Flats and Khayelitsha,' Malema said. ALSO READ: 'Get your popcorn factory ready' — McKenzie willing to testify at the commission into Mkhwanazi allegations 'You the people know the truth, this is the time and platform to expose the rot. Do not be scared, the killing of our children must be stopped now. Mkhwanazi opened the way, we must join him and restore peace and order in South Africa. 'As long as the EFF is in that committee, we will make sure that this does not become another Section 89 report they brushed aside. Phala Phala is not dead, we will find a way to bring it into this committee.' Ad hoc committee members These are the members of the committee and their substitutes. Advocate Glynnis Breytenbach Ian Cameron Molapi Soviet Lekganyane Julius Sello Malema Mangaqa Albert Mncwango Sibonelo Nomvalo Xola Nqola Mdumiseni Ntuli Khusela Lwandlekazi Nobatembu Sangoni Ashley Sauls David Mandla Skosana Alternate Dereleen Elana James Dianne Kohler Leigh‐Ann Mathys Lisa‐Maré Schickerling Crossby Vusi Shongwe Thokozile Sokanyile Wouter Wynand Wessels READ NEXT: Julius Malema's message to KZN police commissioner Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi
