Deseret News archives: Remembering a judging scandal at 2002 Olympics
On Feb. 9, 2002, the figure skating pairs competition began smoothly enough at the Salt Lake Ice Center, but two days later, the Salt Lake Winter Games had an Olympic-size scandal on its hands.
The saga focuses on two skating couples: Canada's Jamie Salé and David Pelletier and Russia's Elena Berezhnaya and Anton Sikharulidze. Russia had won the past 10 pairs skating gold medals but the Canadian team was a force to be reckoned with.
On the first night of competition, at the Salt Lake Ice Center — the Delta Center was rebranded for the Olympics — the Canadian pair fell at the end the short program, but it did not warrant a deduction. Still, Salé and Pelletier were in second place.
Two nights later, Salé and Pelletier gave a flawless and crowd-moving free skate performance to 'Love Story.' And according to reports, they felt like they could win. The Russian Sikharulidze had a small stumble coming out of the axel jump during the long program. The Canadians received great technical marks from the judges but were ranked second in artistic marks. This meant that they won the silver medal, while Berezhnaya and Sikharulidze won the gold medal.
Medals were awarded that night.
But the crowd disagreed, and so did the media and many of the experts. Daily Deseret News coverage was robust and entertaining.
Later that evening, the French judge, Marie-Reine Le Gougne, had reportedly admitted to being pressured by her federation to rank the Russians first in pairs skating. This was part of a vote-trading scheme that involved the Russians ranking the French first in the ice dancing events.
On Feb. 12, the International Skating Union began an investigation. On Feb. 15, the ISU and IOC, in a joint press conference, announced that the French judge was guilty of misconduct and was suspended effective immediately. Within 48 hours, the Canadians had received gold medals, while the Russian pair was allowed to keep their gold medals.
Soon, the Olympics moved on ... to snowboarding, to skiing, to hockey, to speedskating. The Canadians enjoyed their newfound celebrity, and the Russians fumed about everything.
'Gosh! Heck! Utahans angry about skating,' wrote columnist Dave Berry, in Utah for the Games.
The Deseret News produced a daily Olympics special section throughout the Games. Here are selected articles from that section and Deseret News archives:
'IOC wants fast resolution; skaters union says wait'
'Gold medal pairs recall Salt Lake City 4 years later'
'Ceremony for duplicate gold moved up to Sunday'
'Rogge gets high marks for boosting IOC's image during 'Skategate''
'Russians criticize media influence'
'Media watch'
'A most refreshing change'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC Sports
11 minutes ago
- NBC Sports
Lizzie Deignan retires from cycling after announcing pregnancy
LONDON — British cyclist Lizzie Deignan, a former world champion who won the 'triple crown' of monuments, is retiring with immediate effect because she is expecting her third child. Deignan, who was the first British athlete to win a medal on home soil at the 2012 London Olympics, previously had announced that she would call it quits at the end of the season. But she brought forward her retirement, her team said. 'The Deignan family is growing,' the Lidl-Trek team said. 'The former world champion, who announced at the end of last year that 2025 would be her final season, has shared the joyful news that she is expecting her third child, a moment that subsequently marks Deignan's immediate retirement from the peloton.' The 36-year-old Deignan competed in her fourth Olympics in Paris last year and was 12th in the road race. She was successful on the track first and then morphed into a one-day race specialist. Deignan won the rainbow jersey at the 2015 world championships, one of her many professional road victories at the biggest races. She's won all three women's monuments: The Tour of Flanders in 2016, Liege-Bastogne-Liege in 2020 and the inaugural Paris-Roubaix Femmes in 2021. Deignan put her career on pause in 2018 when she had her first child, and planned to retire earlier but was convinced to carry on by her team. She made a successful comeback in 2019, winning The Women's Tour in her first year back to top-level competition. She missed the 2022 season to welcome her second child before returning for a second time in 2023.
Los Angeles Times
40 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
France's first couple sue Candace Owens for defamation over claims that Brigitte Macron is a man
PARIS — A lawyer for France 's first couple said they'll be seeking 'substantial' damages from U.S. conservative influencer Candace Owens if she persists with claims that President Emmanuel Macron 's wife, Brigitte, is a man. The lawyer, Tom Clare, said in an interview with CNN that a defamation suit filed Wednesday for the Macrons in a Delaware court was 'really a last resort' after a fruitless yearlong effort to engage with Owens and requests that she 'do the right thing: tell the truth, stop spreading these lies.' 'Each time we've done that, she mocked the Macrons, she mocked our efforts to set the record straight,' Clare said. 'Enough is enough, it was time to hold her accountable.' The Macrons have been married since 2007, and Emmanuel Macron has been France's president since 2017. In a YouTube video, Owens called the suit an 'obvious and desperate public relations strategy,' and said the first lady is 'a very goofy man.' Owens is a right-leaning political commentator whose YouTube channel has about 4.5 million subscribers. In 2024, she was denied a visa from New Zealand and Australia, citing remarks in which she denied Nazi medical experimentation on Jews in concentration camps during World War II. The 219-page complaint against Owens lays out 'extensive evidence' that Brigitte Macron 'was born a woman, she's always been a woman,' the couple's attorney said. 'We'll put forward our damage claim at trial, but if she continues to double down between now and the time of trial, it will be a substantial award,' he said. In Paris, the presidential office had no immediate comment. In France, too, the presidential couple has for years been dogged by conspiracy theories that Brigitte was born as a man named Jean-Michel Trogneux, who supposedly then took the name Brigitte as a transgender woman. Jean-Michel Trogneux is, in fact, Brigitte's brother. Last September, Brigitte and Jean-Michel Trogneux won a defamation suit against two women who were sentenced by a Paris court to fines and damages for spreading the claims about the first lady online. A Paris appeals court overturned the ruling earlier this month. Brigitte and her brother have since turned to France's highest court to appeal that decision, according to French media. The Macrons first met at the high school where he was a student and she was a teacher. Brigitte Macron was then Brigitte Auzière, a married mother of three children. Macron, 47, is serving his second and last term as president. The first lady celebrated her 72nd birthday in April. Macron moved to Paris for his last year of high school, but promised to marry Brigitte. She later moved to the French capital to join him and divorced before they finally married. Their relationship came under the spotlight in May when video images showed Brigitte pushing her husband away with both hands on his face before they disembarked from a plane on a tour of Southeast Asia. Macron later dismissed the incident as play-fighting, telling reporters that 'we are squabbling and, rather, joking with my wife,' and that it had been overblown into 'a sort of geo-planetary catastrophe.'
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Lizzie Deignan retires from cycling after announcing pregnancy
LONDON (AP) — British cyclist Lizzie Deignan, a former world champion who won the 'triple crown' of monuments, is retiring with immediate effect because she is expecting her third child. Deignan, who was the first British athlete to win a medal on home soil at the 2012 London Olympics, had previously announced that she would call it quits at the end of the season. But she brought forward her retirement, her team said. 'The Deignan family is growing,' the Lidl-Trek team said. 'The former world champion, who announced at the end of last year that 2025 would be her final season, has shared the joyful news that she is expecting her third child, a moment that subsequently marks Deignan's immediate retirement from the peloton.' The 36-year-old Deignan competed in her fourth Olympics in Paris last year and was 12th in the road race. She was successful on the track first and then morphed into a one-day race specialist. Deignan won the rainbow jersey at the 2015 world championships, one of her many professional road victories at the biggest races. She's won all three women's monuments: The Tour of Flanders in 2016, Liege-Bastogne-Liege in 2020 and the inaugural Paris-Roubaix Femmes in 2021. Deignan put her career on pause in 2018 when she had her first child, and planned to retire earlier but was convinced to carry on by her team. She made a successful comeback in 2019, winning The Women's Tour in her first year back to top-level competition. She missed the 2022 season to welcome her second child before returning for a second time in 2023. ___ AP sports: The Associated Press
