New Plymouth District Council credits property owners $3.1 million to fix rates bungle
Photo:
Taupō District Council / Supplied
New Plymouth councillors have agreed to credit residential ratepayers an average of $102 each after a
gaffe in its annual plan
meant property owners faced a 12.8 percent rates hike rather than the 9.9 percent advertised.
At an extra-ordinary meeting on 22 July, councillors decided to try to find $3.1 million in savings to absorb the cost of the mistake.
In a chamber filled with members of the New Plymouth Ratepayers Alliance wearing black T-shirts with "Respect Our Rates" emblazoned on them, council chief executive Gareth Green kicked proceedings off with a lengthy apology.
"I stand before you today to introduce this paper for your decision making, but more importantly to own on behalf of this organisation an error which has let each of you, the community and ourselves down.
"Standing here having to introduce this matter brings me no joy, however, as your chief executive it is my responsibility to own what is a significant failing of this organisation."
The residential rates error was discovered as part of an internal review called for following an earlier GST bungle which could've cost council
$20 million in lost revenue.
The GST mistake - which had been characterised as a "typo" and "cut and paste" error - was corrected earlier this month.
As well as ironing out the average residential rates glitch, councillors also corrected an annual plan wording error relating to industrial water use which could've cost council a further $1.4 million in lost revenue.
An external Simpson Grierson review, which ran concurrently with the internal investigation, found council lacked financial reporting and modelling capability which "strongly suggests a need for training, and possibly recruitment / restructure and training".
Green was not sure exactly how the rates error occurred but said it involved an incorrect assumption about the average value of residential land.
"I put it into the context that there was a lot of pressure about getting rates down and being able to keep them down and that potentially could've contributed.
"We were going through a restructure process which adds stress and pressure into any organisation and there were a lot of other processes going on nationally and locally at the time.
"Just like in the airline sector a plane doesn't crash because one engine stops, it does when a number of things line up and we had a number of things lining up here which created this issue."
Councillors had to decide whether to offer the automatic rates remission, go ahead and charge the full 12.8 percent or initiate a Rates Replacement Proposal to increase the commercial / industrial differential rate for 2025/26 which would've required a round of consultation.
New Plymouth mayor Neil Holdom.
Photo:
RNZ / Robin Martin
Mayor Neil Holdom's recommended councillors opt for the rates remission.
He acknowledged councillor Amanda Clinton-Ghodes for repeatedly raising the issue of risk when council lost two senior finance leaders - one through a resignation - during the restructure period.
"Today's meeting is about transparency and finding a way forward. We've published the details of the errors and the external report including a suite of recommendations developed to ensure we are legally compliant and square these issues with the community in a fully transparent manner. The motion before you does that."
Deputy mayor David Bublitz said corrosion of the public trust the gaffes caused couldn't be overstated.
"The first thing we have to do is restore the trust of the public and we restore the trust of the public by doing what we said we were going to do which is rate them at the right number.
"We've got no choice. We then need to ... whoever is back [after the local body elections] ... needs to work hard to ensure that our council is a little bit leaner, a little bit more efficient and a little bit more innovative, so we can make that money back. We have to get it back."
Councillor Murray Chong wanted to be done with it and charge the full 12.8 percent.
"The real rate is 12.8 percent. That's it. We weren't being honest or we didn't realise we weren't being honest, but it wasn't 9.9 percent at all.
"So what do we do? Do we give you a remission or do we face the reality and pay it this year because the reality is because if we don't pay it this year we will have to pay it next year or we make cuts and how are we going to make cuts? We already tried to make cuts."
Chong didn't believe $3.1 million in savings could be found before June next year so council would end up borrowing to pay the shortfall.
Outgoing councillor Anneka Carlson-Matthews admitted she didn't often agree with councillor Chong, but she wasn't comfortable with lumping more debt on the incoming council either.
"To be fair I can't leave in good faith with a $3.1 million deficit for the [incoming] council on our mistake. That doesn't sit well.
"All the talk about us being able to find it [the money] and we're going to cut service levels and we're going to reign [spending] in. We reigned it in.
"And we heard from the CEO today that part of that reigning it in and restructure - which was great and we saved $10 million - was actually part of potentially why we're in the situation we are now."
Carlson-Matthews didn't believe council could find the savings without making significant sacrifices.
Councillors voted 13-2 in favour of the rates remission.
Rates bills for the first of four quarterly instalments were expected to be sent out at the end of this month as normal.
The amount owed showing on the bill would reflect the resolution in adopting the Annual Plan, but an "adjustment" or credit would be applied to each bill to reflect the decision made by the council on 22 July.
The credit would be spread across the year.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
Ruapehu Snow Economy Back In Action
Press Release – Ruapehu District Council The snow industry is critical to our economy and regional tourism, said Mayor Kirton. Its fantastic to see Whakapapa and Troa up and running again, but we must keep building on this success. Ruapehu Mayor Weston Kirton has joined Peak FM host Jesse Archer for a live broadcast from the Top of the Bruce at Whakapapa ski field to celebrate the local snow industry and the importance of economic development in the region. Mayor Kirton reflected on the journey to secure government funding that enabled the continued operation of both Whakapapa and Tūroa ski fields following the collapse of Ruapehu Alpine Lifts (RAL). 'The snow industry is critical to our economy and regional tourism,' said Mayor Kirton. 'It's fantastic to see Whakapapa and Tūroa up and running again, but we must keep building on this success.' Mayor Kirton said he was hopeful for a few more snowfalls to help extend the season and encouraged people to visit the maunga and enjoy all the experiences Ruapehu has to offer – on and off the slopes. He also stressed the need to keep building on the economic momentum generated by the ski areas. 'Council is committed to working with government and others to complete our cycle and hiking trail networks which are turning Ruapehu into a true year-round destination while providing much-needed economic resilience.' Mayor Kirton also reminded listeners to sign the petition calling on government support to restore the iconic Chateau Tongariro Hotel. 'If you haven't signed our online Parliamentary Petition please do so and help restore this iconic building to its former glory as both a heritage treasure and major contributor to the regional economy. The survey can be found on Council's website Whakapapa chief executive Travis Donoghue also joined the show, saying he felt 'beyond stoked' to see the ski field its stride after a few years of uncertainty. 'Around 300,000 people visit Whakapapa every year, and they're not just coming for the snow – they're also exploring the whole region. That's great news for local businesses.' Mr Donoghue said the school holidays had been a major success, with around 30,000 people enjoying snow play, skiing, sightseeing on the Sky Waka gondola, and even taking their first steps in the alpine environment. This weekend we're looking forward to opening* the Delta Chair and with fine weather forecast it's shaping up to be a fantastic few days on the maunga.' *NOTE: Turoa ski field is also opening up its upper mountain facilities this weekend.


Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
Cutting Vital $201m Water Works Programme In Half The Trade-Off To Deliver Affordable Water Rates
Central Hawke's Bay District Council's considering halving $201m of essential work on its water infrastructure as a trade-off to make rates more affordable. Central Hawke's Bay's water rates were forecasted to double by 2034 under modelling completed to comply with the Government's Local Water Done Well framework. The framework does not provide a clear pathway to address affordability in small rural communities, like Central Hawke's Bay. In Central Hawke's Bay we've chosen to address the affordability challenges many rural communities are facing by substantially reducing our district's capital works programme, said Central Hawke's Bay District Council Chief Executive Doug Tate. 'Our aim is to create more affordable Three Waters rates. However, it has the potential to create the opposite and erode the positive progress we've made in addressing historic underinvestment in our water assets," said Tate. The approach to reduce the district's Three Waters programme would be further developed by officers before being presented to Council for endorsement at its 21 August Finance, Infrastructure and Performance Committee meeting. 'There are both benefits and risks to the decisions facing us, but we're stepping up and providing a pragmatic option,' Central Hawke's Bay Mayor Alex Walker said. 'We know we need the entire $201m capital works programme but we're faced with a situation where we have to move.' The current water investment plan was developed for the 2021 Long-Term Plan as a short-term bubble of catch-up. Council has achieved a lot of what was needed in terms of leak reductions and critical renewals. This includes renewing 10.4 kilometres of water pipes, making major upgrades in water treatment in Takapau, Kairakau, Pōrangahau and reduced network leaks three –fold. NOTES TO EDITOR Early scenario modelling of trade-offs is on page 11 of this report The international affordability benchmark for drinking water puts it in the range of 3% - 5% of median income. Central Hawke's Bay's median household income is currently $89,000.


Scoop
2 hours ago
- Scoop
Ruapehu Snow Economy Back In Action
Ruapehu Mayor Weston Kirton has joined Peak FM host Jesse Archer for a live broadcast from the Top of the Bruce at Whakapapa ski field to celebrate the local snow industry and the importance of economic development in the region. Mayor Kirton reflected on the journey to secure government funding that enabled the continued operation of both Whakapapa and Tūroa ski fields following the collapse of Ruapehu Alpine Lifts (RAL). 'The snow industry is critical to our economy and regional tourism,' said Mayor Kirton. 'It's fantastic to see Whakapapa and Tūroa up and running again, but we must keep building on this success.' Mayor Kirton said he was hopeful for a few more snowfalls to help extend the season and encouraged people to visit the maunga and enjoy all the experiences Ruapehu has to offer – on and off the slopes. He also stressed the need to keep building on the economic momentum generated by the ski areas. 'Council is committed to working with government and others to complete our cycle and hiking trail networks which are turning Ruapehu into a true year-round destination while providing much-needed economic resilience.' Mayor Kirton also reminded listeners to sign the petition calling on government support to restore the iconic Chateau Tongariro Hotel. 'If you haven't signed our online Parliamentary Petition please do so and help restore this iconic building to its former glory as both a heritage treasure and major contributor to the regional economy. The survey can be found on Council's website Whakapapa chief executive Travis Donoghue also joined the show, saying he felt 'beyond stoked' to see the ski field its stride after a few years of uncertainty. 'Around 300,000 people visit Whakapapa every year, and they're not just coming for the snow - they're also exploring the whole region. That's great news for local businesses.' Mr Donoghue said the school holidays had been a major success, with around 30,000 people enjoying snow play, skiing, sightseeing on the Sky Waka gondola, and even taking their first steps in the alpine environment. This weekend we're looking forward to opening* the Delta Chair and with fine weather forecast it's shaping up to be a fantastic few days on the maunga.'