logo
Singapore International Arbitration Centre rules in favour of Amazon in Future Group case

Singapore International Arbitration Centre rules in favour of Amazon in Future Group case

Economic Times13 hours ago

Amazon claim trimmed
Live Events
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel
The Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) has ruled in favour of Amazon in its long-standing legal battle with Kishore Biyani-led Future Group , holding that Reliance Retail- Future merger deal breached its pre-existing contract. However, Amazon has managed to get minuscule damages of Rs 23.7 crore against claimed amount of Rs 1436 crore.In a final award issued late Thursday night, the three-member tribunal said the 2020 board resolution by Future Retail Ltd (FRL) approving the sale of its retail, wholesale, and logistics assets to Reliance was in breach of contractual obligations under the Shareholders' Agreement (SHA) and Share Subscription Agreement (SSA) signed between Amazon and Future Coupons Pvt Ltd (FCPL).While Amazon had sought damages of Rs 1,436 crore, the tribunal awarded a significantly smaller sum of Rs 23.7 crore. It directed 11 promoters and parties, including Kishore Biyani , to jointly and severally pay the amount, along with interest at 10.3% annually (compounded) from March 9, 2022, until full payment. The parties are also liable to bear Amazon's arbitration and litigation costs.The tribunal noted that 835 of FRL's 1,534 retail stores were transferred in a manner that breached Amazon's contractual rights stemming from its 2019 acquisition of 49% in FCPL for Rs 1,400 crore. FCPL held a 10% stake in FRL.The Tribunal held that Amazon was entitled to damages due to the promoters' repudiatory breaches of the Future Coupons Pvt Ltd (FCPL) Shareholders' Agreement (SHA), but it rejected the quantum of Rs 1,436 crore claimed by the company.Amazon had based its claim on "reliance loss," arguing that it should be compensated for the full value of its 2019 investment in FCPL including Rs 1,430 crore paid under the Share Subscription Agreement and Rs 5 crore in associated costs.However, the Tribunal found that even if all contractual agreements had been fully performed, Amazon would not have recovered its entire investment due to the declining financial condition of Future Retail Ltd (FRL) the ultimate beneficiary of Amazon's stake in FCPL.Citing the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and FRL's deteriorating business value, the Tribunal observed that awarding full damages would unfairly shield Amazon from a commercial loss it was likely to incur regardless.'Such an award would essentially allow Amazon to escape a bad bargain,' the final award stated.Nonetheless, the Tribunal awarded Amazon total legal and related costs of Rs 77.3 crore and SGD 68,550.The Amazon-Future legal dispute began in October 2020, when SIAC's emergency arbitrator restrained Future Retail from proceeding with the Reliance deal. The Future Group had challenged the arbitration, citing the Competition Commission of India's 2022 suspension of the Amazon-FCPL deal.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

This 'F' word is pushing India backword, can't defeat China due to..., why is 6400000000000 scaring India
This 'F' word is pushing India backword, can't defeat China due to..., why is 6400000000000 scaring India

India.com

time18 minutes ago

  • India.com

This 'F' word is pushing India backword, can't defeat China due to..., why is 6400000000000 scaring India

This 'F' word is pushing India backword, can't defeat China due to…, why is 6400000000000 scaring India Indian states are going to increase their spending on social welfare schemes. It is estimated that these states will spend about 2 percent of their Gross State Domestic Product (GSDP), or Rs 6.4 lakh crore in 2025, much more than the previous year's spending. Several states have introduced schemes such as monthly income for women and free travel in government-run buses. These welfare schemes have increased the expenses of the states. This has raised concerns as this level of spending is expected to impact India in many ways. Will India Be Able to Beat China Economically? Notably, to beat China economically, India will have to take visionary steps beyond just spending on social welfare. According to a report by rating agency Crisil, spending huge amounts on welfare schemes has reduced states' ability to spend on infrastructure development and other development works. Crisil analysed the budget of 18 major states which account for nearly 90precent of the total GSDP. The central government, on the other hand, also spends huge amount on several welfare schemes such as Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGA), Jal Jeevan Mission, PM Kisan, PM Awas Yojana and PM Poshan. The central government has allocated Rs 86,000 crore for MNREGA that too only for this year. What Kind Of Warning Is This? Crisil has warned that increased state spending on welfare programs, particularly those targeting women, children, and marginalised groups, will widen their revenue deficits. This surge in spending, consistent with previous years at 1.4 to1.6 percent of GSDP between FY19 and FY24 will likely curtail states capacity for capital investment. The rise in expenditure is attributed to pre-election initiatives, including income support schemes and free public transportation for women. What Is Needed To Defeat China? To overtake China economically, India has to take concrete and far-sighted steps rather just spending on social welfare schemes. Focus on productive investments India should focus on creation of world-class infrastructure like roads, railways, ports, power, digital connectivity. These developments will reduce logistics costs and boosts industries. Investments in education, healthcare, and skills development is also needed to create a skilled and healthy workforce. India has to work on increasing public and private investment in research and development. This will promote innovation. Notably, China has invested big in this. Development of the manufacturing sector China's robust manufacturing sector significantly contributes to its economic growth. India's economic progress requires bolstering initiatives like 'Make in India' by streamlining manufacturing establishment, offering tax benefits, and enhancing global supply chain integration. Emphasis on exports China has an export-oriented economy. India also needs to expand its export base in high value-added goods and services. Policy stability A stable policy environment is essential to attract investors. Improving the ease of doing business will automatically reduce red tape. Financial discipline Both the states and the Centre must keep the fiscal deficit under control. This will reduce debt and increase revenue.

2025 TVS Apache RTR 160 With Improved Safety, Price Starts At Rs 1.34 Lakh
2025 TVS Apache RTR 160 With Improved Safety, Price Starts At Rs 1.34 Lakh

News18

time33 minutes ago

  • News18

2025 TVS Apache RTR 160 With Improved Safety, Price Starts At Rs 1.34 Lakh

Last Updated: Interested customers can reach out to the nearby authorised dealership nationwide to purchase it. The top two-wheeler maker TVS has expanded its lineup in India, and has launched the improved avatar of the Apache RTR 160. The model has been released at the starting price of Rs 1.34 lakh (ex-showroom). Interested customers can reach out to the nearby authorised dealership nationwide to purchase it. Top Elements The motorcycle shares the same style statement as the current version, featuring the same fully LED headlamp with integrated DRLs, a comfortable single seating arrangement with a stepped element a split grab rail for the rear passenger. It continues to get fuel tank extensions, flaunting the company's chrome-finish logo on it. Features The bike rides on the red alloy wheels, which makes it look aggressive in the segment. Talking about the features, the 2025 comes with an LCD instrument console that offers all the significant details about the vehicle at your fingertips. It also gets smartphone connectivity, turn-by-turn navigation and multiple riding modes, which makes it superior in the 160cc segment. and two riding modes. At the heart, Apache RTR 160 continues to use the same 159.7cc, single-cylinder, air-cooled engine. It generates a maximum power of 15.82 BHP and 13.85 Nm. First Published: June 28, 2025, 12:56 IST

Only 30% of MahaRERA recovery warrants executed; Rs 527cr still to be recovered
Only 30% of MahaRERA recovery warrants executed; Rs 527cr still to be recovered

Time of India

time43 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Only 30% of MahaRERA recovery warrants executed; Rs 527cr still to be recovered

Pune: MahaRERA's progress on recovery warrant has remained slow, with only 31% of cases executed. Despite state govt's directive to dispose of these cases within three months, merely Rs 233 crore has been recovered out of Rs 760 crore due in 1,212 cases across Maharashtra, officials told TOI on Saturday. The slow progress contradicts revenue minister Chandrakant Bawankule's assurance during the state budget session, where he emphasised speedy execution of MahaRERA's recovery warrant orders and clearing the backlog within three months. The recovery warrants are issued under Section 40(1) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act (RERA) against developers who neither complete projects nor refund homebuyers. Once issued by MahaRERA, these orders are forwarded to district collectors for action, including property attachment and recovery of dues. The districts of Mumbai Suburban, Pune and Thane continue to report the highest backlog of such pending cases. You Can Also Check: Pune AQI | Weather in Pune | Bank Holidays in Pune | Public Holidays in Pune "Though there was some improvement in execution rates, the scale of pendency remains significant. It requires more proactive coordination from revenue officials," said a senior MahaRERA official, adding that it was despite the appointment of additional collectors in multiple districts to expedite the execution of recovery warrants. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Top 5 Dividend Stocks for May 2025 Seeking Alpha Read More Undo Further compounding delays are 172 complaints, involving Rs 157 crore, that are currently pending before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), which handles cases related to insolvency and bankruptcy. These cases are in legal limbo, adding to the frustration of affected homebuyers, stated officials In a broader push for accountability, PM Narendra Modi had addressed the issue directly at the Pragati review meeting on May 29. Expressing dissatisfaction with the mere counting of "disposed" complaints, the PM questioned whether states genuinely ensured redressal. In response, Maharashtra chief secretary Sujata Saunik held a review meeting in the second week of June with collectorates across the state, directing officials to fast-track execution of recovery warrants and ensure accountability. Additional revenue officers have since been appointed to assist with enforcement. Senior citizen Arun Sheth, who has been waiting for over four years for action against a developer, said, "There's been no real movement on my case despite repeated follow-ups. It's just silence." Activists and consumer groups have also called for better monitoring tools. "MahaRERA should introduce a real-time dashboard like UP RERA's. There should be a clearly defined SOP and phase-wise targets, not just vague timelines," said activist R Prabhu. MahaRERA officials said the issue was likely to be raised in the upcoming legislative session. "It's important that revenue officials are able to give a concrete and time-bound plan for executing these orders," an official noted.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store