Thousands of over-65s earn more than $200,000 - should they get NZ Super?
123RF
More than 9000 people aged over 65 earn more than $200,000 a year, and another 33,000 earn between $100,000 and $200,000 - and the Retirement Commissioner says it's fair to question whether they should be able to claim NZ Super as well.
The data comes from the 2023 Census. The number earning between $150,000 and $200,000 has decreased from 2018 but the number earning between $100,000 and $150,000 has lifted by 10,000.
The Census also showed that the number of people over 65 still in the workforce had increased.
Just over 24 percent of people aged over 65 were in work, up from 22.1 percent in 2013. The biggest increase was among people aged 70 to 74.
Retirement Commissioner Jane Wrightson is opposed to putting the age of eligibility for NZ Super.
She said if there were questions about the cost or fairness of the scheme, they needed to be addressed with a package of measures.
Retirement Commissioner Jane Wrightson.
Photo:
supplied
"Then you absolutely have to look at
means-testing again
. It's really unpopular but it would be improper if we didn't look at all the sensible options if the goal is to reduce the cost to the state."
She said the problem to be solved needed to be defined and then the possible solutions assessed.
"Means testing is absolutely one of those options but politicians run away from it because it's got a pretty ugly history and it does make it a more complex system. There's no doubt about it, people will start arranging their affairs and start avoiding tax and all that kind of stuff.
"But if you boil it down to a very simple thing - is it right that someone earning over $180,000 or $200,000 - I think $180,000 is probably about the mark because that's when the tax rates go up - is it right that people out there earning over $180,000 can also acquire Super, it's an extremely good question."
She said it would be easy to capture the earnings of people being paid a salary while receiving NZ Super but much harder to assess other income.
"It's both complicated and it's easy. The easiest thing is to leave well alone. The next easiest thing is to just put the age up but that is too easy because there is harm attached to that…. So that's what I'm talking about when I say please could we have a package if we do any system change at all and can we please stop talking about this as single issue?"
She said there should be a cross-party political conversation to determine a path forward.
University of Auckland associate professor Susan St John.
Photo:
RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly
University of Auckland associate professor Susan St John earlier outlined a plan to treat NZ Super as a tax-free basic income grant and put recipients on a higher tax rate.
She said it would be a
better option
that the age of eligibility or the amount paid.
It would create a situation where there was a break-even point beyond which people would be better off, on a net basis, not claiming NZ Super and instead being taxed at standard rates.
She said the tax scales she had modelled were less harsh than the abatement that applied to people receiving a benefit.
The government has introduced parental income tests for young people receiving the JobSeeker benefit and will restrict access to the member tax credit in KiwiSaver to those who earn more than $180,000.
St John said the reason that similar moves weren't made on NZ Super might reflect historical attitudes towards the "deserving and undeserving".
She said NZ Super was effectively income-tested through the tax system because people who were earning other income would pay higher rates of tax.
"Just far less draconian than the clawbacks for children with Working for Families and adults in the benefit system."
Simplicity chief economist Shamubeel Eaqub said means and income testing in Australia meant that only about 60 percent of the population would qualify for the pension. If that were true in New Zealand, it could save about $9b a year.
There are 74,850 people aged 30 to 64 earning more than $200,000.
The median income for people aged over 65 is $26,600.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
Panel with Nicky Pellegrino and Leonie Freeman Part 2
The Pancake Rocks walkway at Dolomite Point, Punakaiki. Photo: Greymouth Star / Brendon McMahon This half hour the panel talk about the "catastrophic" redundancy of 250 Westport coal miners will happen in about three years if a mine's expansion is not approved under fast-track legislation. They also hear from Patrick Volk, a local businessman who is up in arms about parking fees at Pancake Rock.
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Immigration visit law change doesn't go far enough
Pacific advocates say a proposed law change for out-of-hours immigration visits, like dawn raids, doesn't go far enough. The contentious enforcement practice involves immigration officers searching homes for people they have reasonable grounds to believe are liable for deportation between 6pm and 8am. It has been criticised for targeting Pacific people, particularly in the wake of the dawn raids era. Teuila Fuatai reports. Tags: To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
10 hours ago
- RNZ News
Pensioners pinching pennies to pay for power
Stats New Zealand figures show electricity costs have gone up almost 9 percent since June last year (file photo). Photo: 123RF Some pensioners are resorting to extreme power rationing to keep up with rising costs, turning off hot water cylinders for days at a time and heading to bed as soon as it is dark to save on electricity. Stats New Zealand figures show electricity costs have gone up almost 9 percent since June last year. Petrol has gone up 15.5 percent over the same period. Pensioner Sally told Checkpoint she managed her power down to the last cent - especially since her low-user fixed rate charge rose from 30c a day to $1.80. "The low user charge applies to people who use 8000 units a year or less, and last year, I used to use 4000 or thereabouts. Last year I used to, well, till March this year, 2700 units. "But there's no difference in the daily charge because like everybody, you still got to be connected." She said the Powerswitch website got her to change from Genesis to Frank Energy, saving $360 a year. "But now Frank Energy is quitting , and I'm going to be paying $360 more than what I just had for the last 12 months. "So it's really hard, but it's the one thing apart from food that I feel I can control, and I do that by turning off the water… I have a shower then and it stays off for three nights." Her bill last year was usually around $85 a month, but her most recent was $131. Age Concern Canterbury chief executive Greta Bond said an enormous cold snap in Christchurch meant some older residents would be staying in bed until midday to stay warm. She said the government's winter energy payment of up to $700 over five months was not enough to keep up with rising prices, and stories like Sally's were common. "We're seeing so many older people living in poverty, especially people who are on that solo superannuation, and they're really struggling to get by and doing so by severely rationing their electricity use," Bond told Checkpoint . "I was so impressed with Sally and all the strategies that she had to make her power work for her, but the fact is she's still paying quite a significant percentage more than she was last year." Some people were even eating tinned food cold because of electricity costs. Others were paying 80 percent of their superannuation on rent "and there's really not almost anything left in the remaining 20 percent to warm your home or even eat", let alone go to the doctor or - in some cases - even leave the house. "I think it's a really appalling indictment of our society when you have people who are older who are having these challenges to their dignity and wellbeing based on a few dollars." Bond urged people in this situation to reach out. "There are organisations who want to help, and I think people getting trapped in their own home by their own poverty and their electricity poverty is not a way to live." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
