Dublin's planned MetroLink will be obsolete because of artificial intelligence, says Dermot Desmond
(AI) will make Dublin's planned
MetroLink
obsolete and the Government should abandon the €10 billion project, according to businessman
Dermot Desmond
.
Instead, Mr Desmond has urged the Government to concentrate on the coming advantages of AI , where autonomously-driven vehicles (AVs) will cut car ownership dramatically in the decades ahead.
If approved, construction of the 18.8 km mostly-underground MetroLink should begin between 2028 and 2031, with services between Swords, Dublin Airport, Dublin city centre, and on to Charlemont in south Dublin city opening in early 2035.
Equipped with driverless trains running every 3 minutes during peak hours, the MetroLink is proposed to carry 20,000 passengers each hour, each way when it opens.
READ MORE
Dermot Desmond has said he believes MetroLink will be out of date in 10 or 15 years' time. Photograph: Cyril Byrne
However, Mr Desmond is scathing of the plan, believing that public and private transportation is on the cusp globally of the biggest changes for a century or more on the back of the growth of AI.
The billionaire said he had believed that the Department of Finance should veto the MetroLink. 'I think it will be useless, out of date in 10 or 15 years' time. This is something that is not going to be required, it shouldn't be planned.'
AI and autonomous vehicles will cut the numbers of vehicles on the roads dramatically, he predicted: 'I think you need to look at what's going to happen in the future and then plan backwards.'
The billionaire investor has become increasingly interested in the subject of AI, sponsoring a conference in Belfast last month with Queen's University, which heard from major speakers from the United States and elsewhere.
'Where the change that's going to make a big difference to everybody in the world, not alone Ireland. I think that change is going to come out of transport,' Mr Desmond declared then.
'Within 15 to 25 years, I think it will be mandated that there will be autonomous vehicles. People will not be allowed to drive anything,' he said, adding that AI is already cutting travel times and saving energy.
'Public transport systems in the future will become much more efficient. Buses will know what and where the demand is and will organise themselves accordingly,' said Mr Desmond, who urged the Government to plan for wide-scale AV bus services.
The changes to come will overturn every conception held today about transport in cities, with faster journeys, less pollution and far less demand for parking because there will be fewer private vehicles, replaced by robotaxis.
Most cars today lie idle for 80 per cent of their lives. 'The most optimistic case for Dublin is a reduction of 98% in vehicle numbers,' he said, though he put most realistic reduction between 20% and 60%.
'AV cars will require less space on roads as they will be better able to travel efficiently if the margin for human error is removed,' he said, 'We already live in a world where our phones anticipate when we will leave for work and tell us how long it will take. '
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Keir Starmer promises ‘no more gimmicks' as migrant-returns deal with France kicks in
Britain has promised to begin detaining 'within days' asylum seekers who arrive there illegally on small boats, under a returns deal with France that was ratified this week. The 'one in, one out' deal was agreed last month, but only finalised in recent days. It stipulates that Britain can send a small number of small boat arrivals back to France. However, it must also accept an equal number of migrants sent by the French in the other direction, such as family members of migrants already living in the UK. Yvette Cooper, Britain's home secretary, suggested the first detainees could be sent back to France 'within weeks'. Britain's Labour government has insisted the returns deal with France will act as a deterrent to illegal immigrants. Ms Cooper declined, however, to give an exact timeline on when the first returns would take place, while Britain's home office also would not confirm how many migrants would be sent back to France under the scheme, which will operate on a pilot basis for the next 12 months. It is believed only about 50 a week will be sent back initially. READ MORE The arrival on small boats of illegal immigrants to English shores – many of whom then go on to claim asylum – has been a significant political issue in Britain since 2018. The previous Tory government devised a scheme to send such immigrants on to Rwanda, but this was scrapped by Labour immediately upon winning the election last July. Since then, however, small boat arrivals have soared, putting significant political pressure on prime minister Keir Starmer 's government. Official statistics show about 25,000 have arrived on small boats so far this year, up almost 50 per cent on 2024. Figures released by the home office in recent days show 1,047 arrived on 15 boats on Tuesday and Wednesday of last week alone. Balmy weather in Britain since May has contributed to the rise, due to calmer sea conditions that facilitate more crossings. Britain's government this week announced a further £100 million (€115 million) would be spent on border security, including funding for up to 300 extra National Crime Agency officers to tackle the issue. 'The days of gimmicks and broken promises are over – we will restore order to our borders with the seriousness and competence the British people deserve,' said Mr Starmer. The wider topic of illegal immigration and asylum seekers continues to raise tensions in Britain, a year after an outbreak of race-fuelled riots across England. There were several demonstrations over the weekend in London, Manchester and Newcastle outside hotels that provide accommodation to asylum seekers. Meanwhile, hard-right activists who have demonstrated against immigration continue to draw significant media attention in Britain. Prominent activist Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, also known as Tommy Robinson , was released on bail on Tuesday after he was arrested on Monday at Luton airport. He had been sought by UK police last week following the alleged assault of another man at St Pancras train station in London. Mr Yaxley-Lennon released a video on Tuesday in which he alleged he had been the one assailed by a man, who was filmed by a passerby lying on the ground at St Pancras, allegedly following an altercation with Mr Yaxley-Lennon. The activist complained to his social media followers that he can no longer walk the streets of Britain alone. He insisted, however, that he had not fled from Britain after the St Pancras incident, as media had reported, but that his trip abroad had been pre-planned.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Crises and fear grip Bolivia as divisive elections loom
Bolivia marks the 200th anniversary of independence from Spain on Wednesday standing in the shadow of yet another of the crises that have scarred its two centuries as a nation state. The country enters its third century essentially broke, warning recently it might soon be forced to default on its debts. A chronic shortage of dollars means it cannot pay for enough fuel imports, and queues at petrol stations are common. Rising inflation and growing shortages of basic goods make daily life an increasing grind in what has long been one of Latin America's poorest nations. In June the United Nations warned '[a]cute food insecurity is expected to deteriorate' in the country, as the lack of fuel further hinders agricultural activity following a below average harvest last year. So alarming was the report amid the worsening situation the government rushed to clarify that the UN did not think Bolivia was facing actual famine. This deepening economic and social crisis forms the background to what threatens to be one of the most divisive, and potentially violent, elections in the country's history, with voters set to go to the polls on August 17th to elect a new president and legislative assembly. The electoral contest has been defined by the implosion of the ruling Movement Towards Socialism party (or MAS, after its initials in Spanish). Having dominated Bolivian politics for the last 20 years, the MAS has in recent years descended into internecine warfare even while in power. READ MORE In part this self-immolation is the fallout from the party's unpopularity, brought on by the exhaustion of its economic and social model. This sought to use state oversight of the economy to redirect funds to Bolivia's poor indigenous, largely peasant, majority. 'This was justifiable but the government could not guarantee the investments to sustain it,' says María Teresa Zegada of the Centre for Studies of Economic and Social Reality think tank in Cochabamba. This model was exposed once the commodities bonanza that coincided with the MAS's first decade in power ended. The nationalisation of Bolivia's gas reserves by Morales in 2006 is now widely seen as a strategic error. At first it showered the state with the funds for lavish social spending. But it slowly starved the sector of investment, leading to declining exports in one of the economy's only foreign currency earners, setting the stage for the current economic crisis. But the civil war in the MAS is also a highly personalised fight between the two men the movement elevated to the presidency, incumbent Luis Arce and his former boss Evo Morales , the charismatic leader who ran Bolivia between 2006 and 2019 and an icon of the Latin American left. Evo Morales has called on voters to spoil their votes in the Bolivian presidential election. Photograph: Marcelo Perez del Carpio/Bloomberg Morales's bid for an unprecedented fourth term failed in 2019 after suspicions of fraud led to mass protests that eventually saw the army step in, forcing him into exile in Argentina. But when the MAS returned to power with the election of his former economic minister Arce, Morales thought he would resume effective control and eventually take the top job again. But Arce moved to sideline his predecessor, willed on by many elements in the MAS that had grown tired of Morales's obsession with power. The resulting internecine warfare has led to an assassination attempt, claims of a staged coup and accusations of 'lawfare' being waged by the president against his predecessor. Arce has won from a compliant electoral court a ruling barring his predecessor from seeking a fourth term. Morales is also facing charges that he fathered a child with a minor while president. He denies this though it is not the first time he has faced allegations about sex with minors. Now wanted by prosecutors, he has holed himself up in his home Chapare region, where he got his political start as a union leader of local coca growers fighting eradication efforts led by the US Drug Enforcement Agency. From there he has called on voters to spoil their ballots, warning: 'Without Evo there will be no election'. Violence has already broken out. In June pro-Morales protesters blockaded highways and confronted police, leaving five people dead, including four police officers. Arce was forced to abandon his own ambitions for re-election due to dismal approval ratings, so the MAS candidate is Eduardo del Castillo, a 36-year old lawyer who until recently was interior minister. He is polling in the low single digits. Andrónico Rodríguez may represent the Bolivian left's best hope in the upcoming presidential election. Photograph: Aizar Raldes/AFP via Getty Images With another former MAS leader having quit the race last month the best chance of the indigenous-dominated left holding on to power looks to reside with the 36-year-old senate president Andrónico Rodríguez. A one-time protege of Morales he also entered politics through the Chapare coca-growers movement. He has since broken with the MAS and is contesting the election at the head of the leftist Popular Alliance. Morales has labelled his former acolyte a 'traitor' for ignoring his calls for a boycott. But if Rodríguez can convince enough of Morales's supporters to back him rather than spoil their ballots he could force his way into a run-off round in October. His campaign pitch centres on tackling the economic crisis with measures that are 'neither neoliberal nor antisocial'. Such an appeal could resonate in a society still scarred by the memories of the economic 'shock therapy' that followed the country's last default in 1984, which led to large spikes in unemployment and poverty. The leading candidates on the right – cement magnate and Burger King franchisee Samuel Doria Medina and former president Jorge 'Tuto' Quiroga – are campaigning on pledges to slash the size of the state. But any move to rein in subsidies on fuel and food could inflame an already volatile situation. 'Out on the streets [the next president] will have to pacify the social movements and somehow alleviate the economic pressure the country is under,' says Zegada.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Lobby other EU countries to allow Irish Central Bank to drop Israeli war bonds, TDs recommend
An Oireachtas committee has recommended the Government lobby other EU states to change rules that stop the Irish Central Bank from refusing to act as a competent authority in Europe for Israeli war bonds. Third-country issuers, such as Israel, can choose any EU state as their home member state and competent authority. That authority reviews its bond prospectus and, in this case, authorises Israel to sell bonds in the EU market. Before 2021, the UK was the EU home member state under the regulation for the state of Israel. Ireland was chosen as the new home member state following the UK's departure from the EU after Brexit in 2016. Politicians from all parties have expressed concern that Ireland is the competent authority that gives authority to Israel to sell bonds in the EU market, including what Israel markets as 'war bonds'. However, the committee has been told by the Central Bank that it is powerless to refuse to act as the competent authority under current rules. The rules and criteria that determine approval of the prospectus do not cover Israel's continuing military activities in Gaza , but rather include risk rules based on financial and fiscal criteria. The governor of the Central Bank, Gabriel Makhlouf, told the Oireachtas Committee on Finance in June that Ireland had no power to unilaterally remove itself from being the competent authority. Any decision to change that situation, he said, would be made by the third country, in this case Israel, and by that third country alone. The committee, chaired by Sinn Féin TD Mairéad Farrell , published a report on Tuesday, the main recommendation of which was that the Government engage at EU level with a 'view to amending the EU Prospectus regulations to permit each individual European Central Bank to refuse to act as a Competent Authority'. It has also recommended that the Central Bank conduct an immediate internal review in advance of any renewal in September of the Israeli bond prospectus. It said that review should determine whether it is in compliance with the levels of disclosure, accuracy and transparency required by the EU Prospectus. At the meeting in June, committee members expressed concern that the continuing destruction and deaths in Gaza were not being taken into consideration in determining the right of Israel to sell bonds, which several committee members pointed out were being openly marketed as 'war bonds'. The report states: 'In response to questions around whether enhanced scrutiny is applied to sovereign bond issuers involved in armed conflict or under international investigation, representatives of the Central Bank told the Committee that a judgement is made as to whether a prospectus is particularly complex and if there are issues that are challenging to articulate. 'Ultimately, however, the judgement rests on whether the disclosure is appropriate to the financial risk.' At the meeting, members expressed concern with regard to both the exposure of the EU financially to Israel and the current situation in Israel. 'Members further described the prospectus regulatory regime as 'narrow and arguably amoral ... Jesuitical in the way that it is interpreted and applied, which is mindful of only its basic, legalistic obligations in satisfying the regulatory framework in place', the report stated. Amid cross-party opposition to the Central Bank continuing in that role, the committee has also recommended that any future review of its role as the competent authority by the regulator should take into account the nature of the case taken by South Africa against Israel under the Genocide Convention and the interim findings of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in that regard. It also said the illegal situation created by Israel in the Occupied Palestinian Territories should also be taken into account.
