logo
Coal mine stalled in 'groundbreaking' climate decision

Coal mine stalled in 'groundbreaking' climate decision

Yahoo2 days ago
A controversial coal mine expansion has hit a stumbling block after a court found possible climate change harms had not been fully considered, a ruling that could have implications for other fossil fuel projects.
A community environment group from the NSW Hunter region successfully challenged an Independent Planning Commission decision to allow the expansion of the Mount Pleasant open-cut mine, near Muswellbrook.
Operator MACH Energy applied to deepen the mine and double its output, extending its life for 22 years to enable the extraction of an additional 406 megatonnes of coal.
The commission consented to the expansion in September 2022 and a judicial review brought by the community group was dismissed by the Land and Environment Court two years later.
Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group took its fight to the Court of Appeal, arguing the environment court had erred and the commission failed to consider the likely climate effects in the region.
The Court of Appeal on Thursday found the commission had accepted the project's emissions would contribute to global climate change, but there was nothing in its reasons to indicate it had considered the local impacts.
The commission's consent referred to Australia's obligations under the Paris Agreement, noting that the mine's emissions would be "accounted for" in the countries where the coal was burnt.
"The commission's obligation to consider the likely impacts of the development on the natural and built environment in the locality of the mine ... required it to address the potentially adverse effects of climate change in the locality," the judgment said.
"This obligation could not be discharged by general references to the effects of global warming on the planet generally."
Environmental lawyer Elaine Johnson, the director of the firm that represented the community group, said the court's decision was groundbreaking.
"The NSW Court of Appeal has just confirmed that the local impacts of climate change on communities are a direct consequence of continued fossil fuel production in NSW," Ms Johnson said in a statement.
"From today, climate harm must be specifically considered when deciding proposals for fossil fuel expansions."
NSW Greens MP Sue Higginson also said it was a significant legal breakthrough.
"With this decision, the government must now reckon with the fact that they have a responsibility to the whole planet when it comes to allowing more coal to be dug up and burnt," Ms Higginson said.
"The status quo of setting emissions reduction targets domestically and then exporting the climate crisis is now broken with this decision."
The case will be returned to the Land and Environment Court to consider and MACH Energy was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.
The company was contacted for comment.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Woman Backs Out of Group Trip. Now, Her Friends Want Her to Cover Everyone's Financial Loss
Woman Backs Out of Group Trip. Now, Her Friends Want Her to Cover Everyone's Financial Loss

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Woman Backs Out of Group Trip. Now, Her Friends Want Her to Cover Everyone's Financial Loss

After pulling out of a group trip for personal reasons, a woman finds herself at odds with friends who now expect her to take on the entire financial loss A woman seeks advice from the Reddit community following a dispute with two friends over a canceled Airbnb trip. The original plan was simple: three friends would be splitting a $600 rental, each contributing $200, with one friend, referred to as Friend A, paying the full amount upfront. "Friend A was the one who made the reservation and paid in full so that me and friend B would give A our share ($200.00 each) later," the woman writes in her post. But plans changed when she decided not to go anymore, citing "personal and safety reasons." Although the rental host "would only give a 50% refund" if they canceled, "both friend A and friend B still wanted to go." Even though she backed out, the poster told her friends that she'd honor her part of the agreement. 'I said if they still wanted to go I would give my share ($200.00) since I took the responsibility of being part of it before,' she explains. However, things took a turn when Friend A demanded more than just her original share. "Friend A said that I should pay $300.00 because I was the one who didn't want to go, not them, and if they were to cancel it that would be the total loss," she explains. The poster didn't agree that she should be paying more than her portion, especially since the trip was still scheduled to move forward without her. 'Why would I pay for half of the trip when is not even canceled yet?' she questions, pushing back on what she saw as an unfair request. Friend A then mentioned they would try to invite someone else to take her spot. But they made it clear that if that person declined, the poster would be expected to cover the full $300 shortfall. The next day, Friend A messaged again with an update. 'They informed me that the other person they invited did not want to go and that they had cancelled the house,' the woman writes, adding that Friend A also sent proof of a refund. Now, with the Airbnb officially canceled, Friend A insisted she should be held fully responsible for the loss. 'They expected that I paid the full amount of $300.00 because I backed out first,' she explains, even though both friends ultimately decided not to go. What made the situation even more frustrating was Friend A's refusal to ask Friend B for their share "because they too wanted to go." "I told them that if they ask for person's B share or not is not my problem, my only responsibility now is paying my part," the woman replied. To her, the fair thing would be for everyone to pay based on the final outcome. 'Now that the refund was made I believe that the correct amount for each person to pay is $100.00,' she argues, since the Airbnb host only refunded 50% of the $600 total. She reiterates that she never asked the group to cancel. 'I never forced them to not go but actually said I would still pay MY part in full and they chose not to go,' she writes. From her perspective, she upheld her end of the plan, and what they did afterward was out of her hands. Despite the pushback from Friend A, she decided to settle what she believed was fair. 'I refused and sent $105.00 for my share and told them that was my share and that it would be all I was going to pay,' she shares, sticking firmly to her decision. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. In an edit to the post, the woman shared that Friend A's "reasoning for not going through with the trip was because they didn't want to split food and gas into 2, but 3." Adding yet another layer of tension to the story, the poster revealed that the friend initially "wanted a bigger and prettier house that could fit 4-5 people, but I didn't want that one because it was too expensive (about $850)." The situation left her feeling stuck, unsure if setting boundaries over what she owes makes her selfish or simply fair. But one thing she's certain of is this: 'My only responsibility now is paying my part.' Read the original article on People Solve the daily Crossword

Tesla hit with shocking sales news in key market: 'Good riddance'
Tesla hit with shocking sales news in key market: 'Good riddance'

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Tesla hit with shocking sales news in key market: 'Good riddance'

New sales numbers showed that many Canadians are steering clear of Tesla, but the Elon Musk-led company isn't the only electric vehicle brand facing struggles north of the border. According to Jalopnik, a new report from Automotive News revealed that 9,000 Teslas were registered in Canada in the first six months of the year. Comparatively, data from 2024 showed the EV automaker delivered more than 26,000 new cars in Canada in the same time frame last year. That's a stunning 67% drop. Overall, EV registration in Canada has dropped 32% in the first half of 2025 amid several changes. Canada halted the Incentive for Zero-Emission Vehicles program in January. Additionally, Quebec's EV rebate program hit pause for two months before resuming. The decline in EV sales in Canada could have significant long-term environmental impacts. EVs emit less heat-trapping pollution over their lifetimes than their gas counterparts, even if you account for the electricity generated for charging. As for Tesla specifically, many have attributed the company's decline to CEO Musk's involvement with the Trump administration and involvement in global politics, with many consumers viewing support for the brand as support for Musk's politics and considering EVs from other brands. Wavering prices may have also dissuaded Canadian buyers. Tesla first raised prices on Model Y and Model 3 in February, according to Jalopnik. Another price hike came following Canada's retaliatory tariff imposed on cars imported from the United States. Most Jalopnik readers weren't at all surprised by the dwindling sales. "Tesla is toast," one commenter wrote. "Good riddance." Amid Tesla's troubles, competing brands have gained momentum in other markets around the world. In fact, a recent survey of car owners in the United Kingdom revealed that EV drivers have no plans to return to costly gas-guzzling cars for their next vehicle purchase, preferring to stick with electric instead. Making other eco-friendly investments can pay off in the long run for EV drivers. Fueling with solar energy at home is cheaper than spending on public charging stations or relying on the grid. Drivers can keep costs low by using EnergySage to compare quotes from local installers and save up to $10,000 on solar installations. Do you think a majority of Americans will have EVs in 20 years? Absolutely Only in some states No way I'm not sure Click your choice to see results and speak your mind. Join our free newsletter for good news and useful tips, and don't miss this cool list of easy ways to help yourself while helping the planet.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store