Dutch schools' phone ban has improved learning, study finds
National guidelines, introduced in January 2024, recommend banning smartphones from classrooms and almost all schools have complied. Close to two-thirds of secondary schools ask pupils to leave their phones at home or put them in lockers, while phones are given in at the start of a lesson at one in five.
Researchers surveyed 317 secondary school leaders, 313 primary schools and conducted 12 focus groups with teachers, teaching assistants, students and parents. Secondary schools reported children found it easier to concentrate (75%), the social environment was better (59%) and some said results had improved (28%).
Dr Alexander Krepel, a researcher at the Kohnstamm Instituut, said interactions between pupils had improved the most. 'It's not possible to secretly take a picture of someone in the classroom and then spread it in a WhatsApp group, so there's an increase in social safety,' he said. 'Especially in the breaks between the lessons, students would be on their phones and now they're forced to talk … Maybe they also get into a fight a bit more often but schools, teachers and students are quite happy with how the atmosphere is better.'
Initial fears surrounding the ban proved unfounded, according to Freya Sixma, spokesperson for the VO-raad secondary education council, which represents schools and governing boards. 'There was quite a lot of protest at first from schools, teachers, students, parents, questions about how it would all work,' she said. 'But now you see that actually everyone is pretty happy.'
The study showed in special schools, where exceptions can be given for learning support devices, about half reported that the ban had a positive or very positive effect. In primary schools, smartphones did not have a huge effect before the ban, but a quarter were positive about it.
Mariëlle Paul, the minister for primary and secondary education, said the national guideline helped classroom discipline. 'Teachers and school leaders indicated that if an individual teacher wanted to ban the mobile from his or her class it would always be a discussion,' she said. 'More inexperienced teachers would have difficulties enforcing that.'
MPs could take a lesson from the results too, Paul added. 'Even we as adults should admit that whatever is going on, the apps, WhatsApp, Snapchat or Instagram have a form of addictiveness. We once tried to do it for a debate on education ... but that was pretty difficult.'
Statistics Netherlands reports 96% of children go online almost every day, mostly through their phones. Last month, the caretaker government advised parents to ban social media for the under-15s and limit screen time, while one MP has proposed a total ban on smartphones in schools.
Sign up to This is Europe
The most pressing stories and debates for Europeans – from identity to economics to the environment
after newsletter promotion
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
27 minutes ago
- The Independent
Ministers in talks with City over climate finance for disaster-hit nations
Senior Cabinet ministers including Rachel Reeves and David Lammy are to meet City chiefs for talks on how to unlock UK private sector climate finance and disaster risk insurance for countries facing extreme weather events. The Foreign Secretary has pledged £12 million from the Government's tightened aid budget in a bid to enable faster payouts for nations experiencing climate shocks like hurricanes and tornadoes. Mr Lammy will join the Chancellor, Energy Secretary Ed Miliband and Environment Secretary Steve Reed for the first meeting between multiple Cabinet ministers and finance leaders on Tuesday. The group is expected to discuss how the sector can play a part in channelling investment into climate initiatives in emerging markets. The Government hopes the £12 million for pre-arranged finance for disaster relief and risk insurance will cut the cost of responding to extreme weather events, and the time it takes for countries to recover from such shocks. This funding is triggered by certain warning signs — such as a forecast or weather event itself — to enable faster payouts, the Foreign Office said. It comes after the Government slashed the UK's overseas aid budget from 0.5% of gross national income to 0.3% in order to pay for increased defence spending. The UK's climate finance commitments come from its aid budget. The Foreign Secretary said: 'The climate and nature crisis is the greatest global challenge we face. Failure to act will cause unprecedented environmental damage, fuelling displacement, conflict and famine. 'Tackling this crisis is also a huge opportunity for people and businesses here in the UK, delivering on our Plan for Change. The green sector is worth trillions of pounds, and I'm determined that we seize on the economic growth, jobs and security it offers. 'The City of London, the world's leading sustainable development financing hub, has a crucial role to play in this.'
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
King to tell Macron: ‘No borders' between us
The King will tell Emmanuel Macron there are 'no borders' between Britain and France in their shared efforts to solve 'complex threats'. King Charles will speak of the vital partnership between the two countries in the face of challenges 'emanating from multiple directions', faced together as 'friends and allies'. He will make a speech at a state banquet on Tuesday night, ahead of a political summit between Sir Keir Starmer and Mr Macron later this week aimed at tackling the small boats crisis. Speaking at Windsor Castle, the King will say that the continued partnership between the UK and France remains vital in facing modern challenges, as 'our two countries face a multitude of complex threats, emanating from multiple directions'. 'As friends and as allies, we face them together,' he will say. 'These challenges know no borders: no fortress can protect us against them this time.' He will add: 'Our two nations share not only values, but also the tireless determination to act on them in the world.' The King, who has long hoped to act as a peacemaker in global affairs, is understood to be referring to multiple issues where the shared values of Britain and France are under threat, including defence, technology and climate change. He is not expected to make specific reference to any current political matter. The speech will come as Sir Keir Starmer battles to save a one-in, one-out migrant returns deal with France that hopes to unveil with the French president later this week. The Prime Minister and Mr Macron have been working on a deal in which France would take back migrants who have illegally crossed the Channel in small boats in return for the UK accepting a similar number of legal asylum seekers from France. It had been intended as a centrepiece of the Anglo-French summit on Thursday, at which new strategies to tackle small boat migrants, who have crossed the Channel in record numbers this year, will be announced. The 'one-in, one-out' agreement is an attempt to break the business model of the people smuggling gangs by showing that migrants will be returned to France once they reach UK shores. Deal still 'in the balance' But government sources said on Monday night that the deal was 'complex' and 'in the balance', with negotiations still ongoing. The Prime Minister and president are also expected to discuss joint work on civil nuclear projects and a European peacekeeping force in Ukraine in the event of a ceasefire. The King, who is politically neutral, will not be involved in any such discussions and will host the Macrons separately to their conversations with Sir Keir and other politicians. His banquet speech will instead see him embark on a charm offensive for his French guests, speaking warmly of his visits across the Channel. Mr Macron will meet Sir Keir, Kemi Badenoch, the Conservative leader, and Sir Ed Davey, the Liberal Democrat leader, in a series of political talks during the state visit. He will address MPs and peers in the Palace of Westminster's Royal Gallery and, on Thursday, join a UK-France Summit at Downing Street. The King will host Mr Macron and his wife, Brigitte, at Windsor Castle, welcoming them at midday on Tuesday with a carriage ride through the town with the Prince and Princess of Wales. In the evening, the French head of state will be guest of honour at the state banquet at St George's Hall at the castle, in which the full soft power of British diplomacy will be on display. At the dinner, which will include British and French cuisine, and music and drink from both cultures, the King will touch on the serious issues facing both governments. In his speech, with the Queen by his side, he will reflect on 1,000 years of 'shared history and culture between our two peoples', including the many historic personal connections with the Royal family. He will say that 'for centuries our citizens have admired each other, amused each other, and imitated each other', telling how he remains 'in awe of France's extraordinary attributes and achievements'. First state visit of King's reign It will be the first state visit hosted at Windsor Castle in more than a decade and the first of the King's reign. The last was in 2014, when president Michael D Higgins and his wife made the first Irish state visit to Britain. Since then, state visits have been held at Buckingham Palace, which is now partially closed for refurbishment and temporarily unsuitable for hosting duties. Mr Macron, like heads of state before him, will stay overnight in one of the private apartments at Windsor Castle with his wife. The state banquet will see the King and Mr Macron both deliver speeches, which customarily praise their respective countries and speak of both the past relationship and the future. The Princess of Wales will take part in some of the visit, including welcoming the Macrons at RAF Northolt on Tuesday morning on behalf of the King and travelling with them to Windsor. There, the King and Queen will formally greet their guests on a royal dais constructed in Windsor town centre, with the castle in the backdrop as gun salutes sound in nearby Home Park. A ceremonial welcome will be staged in the castle's quadrangle with the Queen, Prince and Princess of Wales and Mrs Macron watching as the King and Mr Macron inspect the Guard of Honour. The wider Royal family are expected to join them for lunch in the State Dining Room before they view a special exhibition of items relating to France from the Royal Collection in the Green Drawing Room.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Post Office inquiry: Landmark day for victims as initial findings expected
Tuesday will mark another big milestone in the long road to justice for the victims of the Post Office IT chair of the inquiry into it – Sir Wyn Williams – will publish the first part of his final report, focusing on compensation and the human impact of the of sub-postmasters were wrongly blamed for financial losses from the Post Office's faulty Horizon computer system, which was developed by than 900 people were prosecuted and 236 were sent to prison in what is believed to be one of the biggest miscarriages of justices in UK history. Sir Wyn put those victims at the heart of the inquiry's work, which has pored over several decades worth of technical evidence and grilled many of those who had a role in ruining so many lives. Dozens of sub-postmasters gave evidence too - many who had lost their businesses, their homes and some who served prison Wyn's findings on their treatment will surely be damning given everything he has heard since the inquiry began in inquiry became almost box office viewing - racking up more than 20 million views on YouTube, with people with no connection to the Post Office following it it is going to be months before we find out who Sir Wyn will point the finger of blame will come in part two of the report, meaning that accountability is still a long way off. 'Patchwork quilt' Sir Wyn has taken a big interest in compensation for the victims, admitting at one point that he'd stretched his terms of reference on the issue, "perhaps beyond breaking point".He held four separate hearings on redress and issued an interim report in 2023, likening the various schemes to a "patchwork quilt with a few holes in it". Victims and their legal representatives still battling to secure final payouts will be looking to see what his conclusions are on compensation and whether it is living up to the mantra of being full and fair. They hope his recommendations will result in more you might be wondering why we're only getting the first part of the final Wyn knows how pressing compensation is to many of the victims and that's why he wants to publish his recommendations on the issue as soon as possible. "It's something I am very keen to say as much about as I reasonably can," he told the inquiry last year. But the implication from this is that part two - establishing what happened and who is to blame - isn't coming out any time soon. This second report may not be published until 2026 given the sheer volume and complexity of the evidence as well as the need to give those who are criticised the chance to respond. As for justice, any criminal trials may not start until 2028. Police investigating the scandal confirmed last month that files won't be handed to prosecutors until after the final inquiry report is years of waiting, even after part one of Sir Wyn's report is published, the sub-postmasters' long road to justice will continue.
