A family was awarded $1.5 million after US border officers wrongfully detained their 9-year-old. Their lawyer shares which AI tool helped him win the case.
Some lawyers continue to fall for made-up cases generated by artificial intelligence. Others are quietly finding ways to make the technology work for them.
Joseph McMullen, a San Diego civil rights and criminal defense attorney, is one of them. Last year, he said, he used AI-powered legal software to help him win a major case by sifting through evidence and making his filings more persuasive.
The case that led McMullen to rethink his tools started with a 9-year-old girl, a passport photo, and a border agent who thought something didn't add up.
In 2019, Julia, a fourth grader, and her 14-year-old brother, Oscar, rose early every weekday morning to cross the US-Mexico border to go to school. The siblings were born in the US but lived in a Tijuana border town, court records show. For local kids, the commute was as familiar as brushing their teeth.
They'd crossed the border many times without incident until March 18, when a US Customs and Border Protection officer noticed a dot on Julia's passport photo that looked like a mole she didn't have in person.
Julia was taken to a secondary inspection area and interviewed alone, which the court would later find violated the agency's policy on questioning children. In a lawsuit, the family alleged that border officers pressured her to claim she was her Mexican cousin.
The government denied any coercion and argued that the length of the children's detention was justified because Julia repeatedly identified herself as her cousin. A Customs and Border Protection spokesperson declined to comment.
Julia was detained for 34 hours, and Oscar for roughly 14 hours, before they were reunited with their mother.
Swearing off ChatGPT
As he built his lawsuit against Customs and Border Protection over the children's detention, McMullen, who runs his own law practice, turned to technology to interpret the evidence.
By early 2024, he had three federal civil trials in three months. Time was short, and help was scarce.
He approached tools like ChatGPT with deep skepticism. In one of his early tests, the chatbot surfaced a case that seemed perfect — until he realized it didn't exist. "That was it. Never again," he said.
Barely a month went by without another story of a lawyer getting burned by bogus case law. Judges were catching on. A public database maintained by legal data analyst Damien Charlotin lists 120 cases where courts caught lawyers using fake or hallucinated citations. Most of the cases were in the US in the past 18 months.
Still, the idea of using AI stuck with McMullen. Unlike lawyers who lean heavily on case law, he spends most of his time combing through police reports, surveillance footage, transcripts, and emails, then figuring out what he has, what's missing, and what story the evidence tells.
He wondered how better tech could help him, like taking a metal detector to a haystack.
Get to the point
There was no jury in his trial against CBP, which meant US District Judge Gonzalo Curiel would make the decision.
That made written filings even more crucial. "It was important to make it as easy as possible for [Curiel] to get the information that I really wanted him to look at," McMullen said.
Another attorney recommended Clearbrief, a tool that integrates with Microsoft Word and lets lawyers link every factual claim to the underlying evidence. The plugin recognizes citations using natural language processing and automatically generates links to relevant case law or documents.
When an attorney files a brief using Clearbrief, a judge or any recipient can open a hyperlinked version in Word or a browser. Each citation becomes interactive: Clicking on one pulls up the exact source text side-by-side with the brief, allowing the reader to verify claims faster without digging through exhibits or databases.
While preparing for trial, McMullen found a California unlawful detainment case that had resulted in a large damages award. To try and steer Curiel toward a similar judgment, he used Clearbrief to link an appellate brief from that case — buried deep in a district court docket — directly in his trial memo.
McMullen said being concise in briefs is not just about saving time; it is a persuasive strategy in itself.
Effective advocacy, he said, isn't about "inundating a finder of fact with all the evidence," but presenting "the most important things that you need to know." (He's certain Curiel and his clerks were thorough in their review.)
"Being efficient with anyone's time is persuasive," he said.
Clearbrief and the competition
Lawyers can also use Microsoft Word to hyperlink text.
The Clearbrief difference, founder and CEO Jacqueline Schafer said, is that it automatically creates the hyperlinks and checks the citations against databases like LexisNexis and vLex Fastcase. The tool flags any mismatch between what the lawyer writes and what the source says.
Schafer said it speeds up drafting and reduces the burden on judges to confirm that every citation is accurate and not the product of an AI hallucination.
Clearbrief's client list includes law firms, courts, and legal departments with names like Hogan Lovells, Microsoft, and the American Arbitration Association. The service starts at $200 a month per user for solo practitioners and small teams, with higher rates for larger organizations.
Westlaw and LexisNexis also offer tools to assist with legal research and drafting, but they don't affect how the final document appears to the court or recipient.
Another Clearbrief feature McMullen relied on was timelines. The tool turned over dozens of depositions and other records and created a case chronology, complete with hyperlinks to the source documents that support the dates and events shown in the timeline.
McMullen didn't submit the timeline in court — it was "maybe a thousand lines" — but he read it closely in trial prep to make sure he hadn't missed anything.
Better outcomes
Last year, Curiel ruled that CBP falsely imprisoned the siblings and was liable for the "intentional infliction of emotional distress" in the 2019 incident. Oscar's grades went down. Julia suffered from insomnia and nightmares. Their parents sought therapy for them both.
Curiel wrote in his decision that the government's conduct was "beyond the bounds" of what is "usually tolerated in a civilized community. " He ruled that the agency must pay the family $1.5 million in total damages.
The US government appealed the decision, then dropped its appeal.
Many legal tech startups promise lawyers they'll be able to take on more cases. For McMullen, the promise of AI isn't about churning through more cases so much as going deeper on the ones he has. He said he used the time he saved to visit Julia's family in Mexico.
"There are several aspects of the practice that are gratifying," McMullen said. But, "there's not a single person who says, 'I really love the tedium of formatting that table.'"
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNN
3 hours ago
- CNN
Mexican drug cartel used hacker to track FBI official, then killed potential FBI informants, government audit says
A Mexican drug cartel hired a hacker to surveil the movements of a senior FBI official in Mexico City in 2018 or earlier, gathering information from the city's camera system that allowed the cartel to kill potential FBI informants, the Justice Department inspector general said in a new report. The hacker also was able to 'see calls made and received' by the FBI official and their geolocation data in a major breach of operational security that occurred as the FBI was working on the case of former Sinaloa cartel boss Joaquin 'El Chapo' Guzmán Loera, the inspector general said. The hacker tracked people coming in and out of the US Embassy in Mexico City before zeroing in on the FBI's assistant legal attache, a role that works closely with Mexican law enforcement, the report said, citing an FBI case agent at the time. The report did not identify the hacker. 'According to the case agent, the cartel used (information provided by the hacker) to intimidate and, in some instances, kill potential sources or cooperating witnesses,' says the inspector general report, which was a broader review of the FBI's approach to protecting sensitive information and avoiding surveillance. The stunning new details offer a rare look at how technology can be exploited in the high-stakes battle between US law enforcement and the violent Mexican cartels that control illicit drug trade. The Trump administration has made cracking down on cartels a national security priority, in part by declaring them as foreign terrorist groups. The FBI, DEA and US military have in recent years used advanced surveillance techniques to try to infiltrate Sinaloa and the Jalisco New Generation Cartel, the other big Mexican cartel that US officials say smuggles large volumes of deadly fentanyl into the US. CNN reported in April that the CIA was reviewing its authorities to use lethal force against the cartels. With El Chapo now behind bars, the cartels themselves are increasingly run by a younger generation of tech-savvy drug lords. 'We've identified people in the cartels that specialize in cryptocurrency movements,' a senior DEA official previously told CNN. 'The cartels run a multi-billion-dollar global enterprise and utilize sophisticated technology to enhance their business operations,' Derek Maltz, who until May served as the acting DEA administrator, told CNN. 'They utilize state-of-art sophisticated surveillance techniques to identify law enforcement activities and their adversaries.' The new inspector general report raises broader concerns about the threat of high-tech surveillance to US national security. 'Some within the FBI and partner agencies, such as the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), have described this threat as 'existential,' the report said. There have been 'longstanding' risks posed by 'ubiquitous technical surveillance' — jargon for the widespread availability of data to adversaries — to the FBI's criminal and national security cases, the report said. But recent advances in commercial technology 'have made it easier than ever for less-sophisticated nations and criminal enterprises to identify and exploit vulnerabilities' related to such surveillance, according to the report. The FBI is working on a 'strategic plan' to address some of the inspector general's concerns about the bureau's approach to the threat, the report said. The bureau referred questions about the inspector general's report to the Justice Department. CNN has requested comment from the department.
CNN
3 hours ago
- CNN
Mexican drug cartel used hacker to track FBI official, then killed potential FBI informants, government audit says
A Mexican drug cartel hired a hacker to surveil the movements of a senior FBI official in Mexico City in 2018 or earlier, gathering information from the city's camera system that allowed the cartel to kill potential FBI informants, the Justice Department inspector general said in a new report. The hacker also was able to 'see calls made and received' by the FBI official and their geolocation data in a major breach of operational security that occurred as the FBI was working on the case of former Sinaloa cartel boss Joaquin 'El Chapo' Guzmán Loera, the inspector general said. The hacker tracked people coming in and out of the US Embassy in Mexico City before zeroing in on the FBI's assistant legal attache, a role that works closely with Mexican law enforcement, the report said, citing an FBI case agent at the time. The report did not identify the hacker. 'According to the case agent, the cartel used (information provided by the hacker) to intimidate and, in some instances, kill potential sources or cooperating witnesses,' says the inspector general report, which was a broader review of the FBI's approach to protecting sensitive information and avoiding surveillance. The stunning new details offer a rare look at how technology can be exploited in the high-stakes battle between US law enforcement and the violent Mexican cartels that control illicit drug trade. The Trump administration has made cracking down on cartels a national security priority, in part by declaring them as foreign terrorist groups. The FBI, DEA and US military have in recent years used advanced surveillance techniques to try to infiltrate Sinaloa and the Jalisco New Generation Cartel, the other big Mexican cartel that US officials say smuggles large volumes of deadly fentanyl into the US. CNN reported in April that the CIA was reviewing its authorities to use lethal force against the cartels. With El Chapo now behind bars, the cartels themselves are increasingly run by a younger generation of tech-savvy drug lords. 'We've identified people in the cartels that specialize in cryptocurrency movements,' a senior DEA official previously told CNN. 'The cartels run a multi-billion-dollar global enterprise and utilize sophisticated technology to enhance their business operations,' Derek Maltz, who until May served as the acting DEA administrator, told CNN. 'They utilize state-of-art sophisticated surveillance techniques to identify law enforcement activities and their adversaries.' The new inspector general report raises broader concerns about the threat of high-tech surveillance to US national security. 'Some within the FBI and partner agencies, such as the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), have described this threat as 'existential,' the report said. There have been 'longstanding' risks posed by 'ubiquitous technical surveillance' — jargon for the widespread availability of data to adversaries — to the FBI's criminal and national security cases, the report said. But recent advances in commercial technology 'have made it easier than ever for less-sophisticated nations and criminal enterprises to identify and exploit vulnerabilities' related to such surveillance, according to the report. The FBI is working on a 'strategic plan' to address some of the inspector general's concerns about the bureau's approach to the threat, the report said. The bureau referred questions about the inspector general's report to the Justice Department. CNN has requested comment from the department.
CNN
3 hours ago
- CNN
Mexican drug cartel used hacker to track FBI official, then killed potential FBI informants, government audit says
A Mexican drug cartel hired a hacker to surveil the movements of a senior FBI official in Mexico City in 2018 or earlier, gathering information from the city's camera system that allowed the cartel to kill potential FBI informants, the Justice Department inspector general said in a new report. The hacker also was able to 'see calls made and received' by the FBI official and their geolocation data in a major breach of operational security that occurred as the FBI was working on the case of former Sinaloa cartel boss Joaquin 'El Chapo' Guzmán Loera, the inspector general said. The hacker tracked people coming in and out of the US Embassy in Mexico City before zeroing in on the FBI's assistant legal attache, a role that works closely with Mexican law enforcement, the report said, citing an FBI case agent at the time. The report did not identify the hacker. 'According to the case agent, the cartel used (information provided by the hacker) to intimidate and, in some instances, kill potential sources or cooperating witnesses,' says the inspector general report, which was a broader review of the FBI's approach to protecting sensitive information and avoiding surveillance. The stunning new details offer a rare look at how technology can be exploited in the high-stakes battle between US law enforcement and the violent Mexican cartels that control illicit drug trade. The Trump administration has made cracking down on cartels a national security priority, in part by declaring them as foreign terrorist groups. The FBI, DEA and US military have in recent years used advanced surveillance techniques to try to infiltrate Sinaloa and the Jalisco New Generation Cartel, the other big Mexican cartel that US officials say smuggles large volumes of deadly fentanyl into the US. CNN reported in April that the CIA was reviewing its authorities to use lethal force against the cartels. With El Chapo now behind bars, the cartels themselves are increasingly run by a younger generation of tech-savvy drug lords. 'We've identified people in the cartels that specialize in cryptocurrency movements,' a senior DEA official previously told CNN. 'The cartels run a multi-billion-dollar global enterprise and utilize sophisticated technology to enhance their business operations,' Derek Maltz, who until May served as the acting DEA administrator, told CNN. 'They utilize state-of-art sophisticated surveillance techniques to identify law enforcement activities and their adversaries.' The new inspector general report raises broader concerns about the threat of high-tech surveillance to US national security. 'Some within the FBI and partner agencies, such as the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), have described this threat as 'existential,' the report said. There have been 'longstanding' risks posed by 'ubiquitous technical surveillance' — jargon for the widespread availability of data to adversaries — to the FBI's criminal and national security cases, the report said. But recent advances in commercial technology 'have made it easier than ever for less-sophisticated nations and criminal enterprises to identify and exploit vulnerabilities' related to such surveillance, according to the report. The FBI is working on a 'strategic plan' to address some of the inspector general's concerns about the bureau's approach to the threat, the report said. The bureau referred questions about the inspector general's report to the Justice Department. CNN has requested comment from the department.
