logo
Magic and divination in the age of AI

Magic and divination in the age of AI

Illustration by Ben Jennings
In a bookshop off London's Strand, fitted out in expensive utilitarian style – exposed ducting, unpainted plaster, birch plywood – a room of mostly young, artsy people are gathering for a talk about the future. There are cocktails and a DJ who is wearing a T-shirt that says 'Brutalism'. Facing the crowd is a sofa, above which is a projector screen displaying an AI-generated video of white, wafting things that look like fungal growths or jellyfish. Within their strands and webs are the faces of young women, their mouths moving without forming anything recognisable as words. The video was made, we are told, by someone who is a 'digital shaman'.
The talk has been convened by a group of people – a 'platform' – who are interested, in a fairly literal sense, in 'technology with spirit'. They are here to talk about the links between artificial intelligence and 'spiritual intelligence', forecasting and divination, the old gods and the new.
On the stage are an artist called Beccy, a tarot reader called Bel, and Sasha, a computer scientist who works for Google DeepMind but is also a meditator and practitioner of the Vajrayana Buddhist tradition. Beccy introduces herself as a 'climate storyteller' who creates 'imaginative acts of resistance'. This has involved, she tells us, training an AI model 'with love and respect… to welcome migrants and refugees', and also to 'generate a sense of inter-species solidarity'. People in the crowd nod enthusiastically.
Bel, the tarot reader, is not restricted to cartomancy. She also helps people – including corporate clients – to 'create oracles… systems for divination', she tells us. 'Many of them work.' Bel also works at the College of Psychic Studies, where other courses include alchemy, remote viewing and connecting with angelic beings.
Sasha, the computer scientist, works on reinforcement learning in multi-agent systems for Google DeepMind, which is owned by Alphabet, which has a market capitalisation of £1.64trn (at time of writing). But he sees a link between the old cultural practices of divination – scrying for answers in playing cards, tea leaves and the movements of birds – and the modern practice of asking ChatGPT or Gemini for the truth about something. Both types of system, he says, are 'cultural tools for generating behaviour'.
Joining the talk via the screen, in a brief and welcome break from the digital shaman's undulating forms, is Kevin, who runs an AI research group at Coventry University and a practice called Philosophy Machines. Kevin's work in AI is informed, he tells us, by his metaphysics, his willingness to ask questions about the underlying nature of reality: 'Is reality somehow constructed in a model that lives in our heads, or lives in a computer somewhere? Do we believe in things that we can't see… Do we believe that objects – rocks, clouds – have a soul, a spirit? Do we believe in angels, deities?' Companies and governments, he notes, 'exist only on paper, they only exist to the extent that everyone else believes in them'. Perhaps this is one to try in bankruptcy proceedings: does a business stop owing money if we stop believing in it? (No.)
Give any first-year philosophy student a bag of weed and you'll have to listen to similar questions being pondered for as long as you can stand it. But these seem like sensible people, who work for major companies and institutions. And they are not the only people having such conversations; beneath the AI boom is a philosophical debate, and a struggle for power.
Subscribe to The New Statesman today from only £8.99 per month Subscribe
For 45 years, people have debated a thought experiment created by the American philosopher John Searle. The experiment goes like this: there is a room into which messages are posted. The messages are written in Chinese. Inside the room is a person who doesn't speak Chinese, but who has a book containing very detailed instructions on how to arrange Chinese text into convincing responses. So, the person matches symbols they don't understand to instructions, assembles new strings of characters – which are, to them, still meaningless – and posts them out again. To the people outside the room, it appears as if the occupant can speak Chinese. But they can't.
This thought experiment, published in 1980, has become much more relevant today, as it is fundamental to the debate over whether 'AI' is, in fact, artificial intelligence. A large language model (LLM) is 'trained' by breaking up text and images into chunks (not words, but strings of characters that appear together as parts of words) and then calculating the sequence of pixels and characters most likely to be accepted as a response. The companies that sell the LLMs say this amounts to reasoning; scientists and philosophers of language disagree.
One response to this is to argue, as Sam Altman (CEO of ChatGPT creator OpenAI) does, that in this case you aren't really thinking or feeling anything either. Like his computer, you are just regurgitating input to create responses. Or, like Elon Musk, you can argue that reality is probably just a simulation anyway. In both cases, the convenient conclusion is that you can do what you like to the world and other people, because they're only as sentient as your computer – if they exist at all.
And as for magic, the amount of money being thrown around in the AI boom is so vast that anything short of the supernatural would be a disappointment to investors. A week before the talk in the bookshop, Nvidia – the chip manufacturer that is selling the shovels in this particular gold rush – achieved the highest market value in history, at $4trn. Fundamental to this valuation is the idea that machines can see the future.
In the middle of the 16th century, John Dee, the court astronomer and magician to Elizabeth I, carried in his pocket a case made from shark skin. Within the case was a circular mirror made from obsidian – black volcanic glass – that had originally been created for an Aztec priest. To a modern eye it shows nothing but a dull reflection, but to Dr Dee it was said to show angelic communications and predictions. This gave Dee a significant political power.
Most of us carry a similar artefact today, of course. We seek answers and communication from our black rectangles. We choose the news we want to read and the people we want to hear from. We see what we want to see in the black mirror, but Kevin reminded us: 'Whoever controls what is seen in the mirror, in some way, controls the future.' The mirror of ChatGPT is darker and more obscure than obsidian. Its priorities are hidden in code that is not public, and which only a handful of people could understand.
What a tarot reader really does, Bel explains, is to deal out a random sequence of cards and give them the meaning the client is looking for. The cartomancer, the haruspex and the seer are not only predicting the future, they are answering the question of how a person should meet that future. 'The underlying question,' said Bel, 'is always: tell me how to live.' As anyone from the Pope to Mark Zuckerberg will attest, this can be a very profitable question to answer.
Throughout history, people have found that the trust they put in priests and oracles was misplaced. Today, the most popular use for AI chatbots, according to a recent survey, is for therapy; millions of people are entrusting this technology with access to their most personal feelings, allowing it to intervene in their thinking, their ethics and their sense of self. They are imbuing it with what esoterics call egregore – a form of being invoked when lots of people put their faith in something. A new power, no more accountable and no less dangerous than the clerics of the past. I think I'd rather put my faith in a pack of cards.
[See also: No 10 is scrambling for a Silicon Valley payday]
Related
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Horoscope today, July 25, 2025: Daily star sign guide from Mystic Meg
Horoscope today, July 25, 2025: Daily star sign guide from Mystic Meg

Scottish Sun

time3 hours ago

  • Scottish Sun

Horoscope today, July 25, 2025: Daily star sign guide from Mystic Meg

Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) OUR much-loved astrologer Meg sadly died in 2023 but her column will be kept alive by her friend and protégée Maggie Innes. Read on to see what's written in the stars for you today. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up ♈ ARIES March 21 to April 20 That Friday feeling can get you thinking of faces and places you've been missing – and this is a great time to follow through. You have a chart of new beginnings that can help you rewrite the past and rework relationships. So let your natural winning streak take charge and follow where your ideas lead you. 3 Your weekly horoscope for Friday ♉ TAURUS April 21 to May 21 The sun spars with Pluto, and big home-based decisions can come into the crossfire – but in ways that leave you richer. Trying to ignore a gap that's growing wider does not suit your straightforward Taurus self. When you need strength to deal with this, it is there. Luck circles recently-changed names. Get all the latest Taurus horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♊ GEMINI May 22 to June 21 Talking about yourself in ways that impress and intrigue is a key factor of your chart. So get your words ready and start speaking. If you're in love, accepting that changes may be small, but are heading in the right direction, is your star skill. Single? Your soulmate has a familiar voice. Get all the latest Gemini horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♋ CANCER June 22 to July 22 As the sun and Mercury form a formidable money team, you can find new ways to deal with old cash questions. You can get more time or help, provided you're not too proud to make the request. As for love, there's a dreamy aspect to your chart that helps partners reconnect. Fresh romance can link to a former workplace. Get all the latest Cancer horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♌ LEO July 23 to August 23 Knowing the difference between self-criticism and self-support is your chart secret. Being extra hard on yourself may feel necessary for success, but when you look again, you can see a different way that asks you to believe in your own ability. A good friend's love story can include a surprise starring role for you. Get all the latest Leo horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♍ VIRGO August 24 to September 22 That half-truth or half-hope that has been on your mind needs addressing. Finding out more, with no obligation, is easier with your current chart combination of caring and questioning. Passion, all day, is positively popping – especially when you meet someone in dark clothing, or in a darkened space. Get all the latest Virgo horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions 3 In love? Switch roles for a while and have some fun Credit: Getty ♎ LIBRA September 23 to October 23 Love lessons may not have been easy to learn, but you are nearing the end of the process – plus the chance to put your new knowledge and ability into practice. Try not to waste this chance. Friends who work together well can also win together well – and a second-time-around contest can be the key. Get all the latest Libra horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♏ SCORPIO October 24 to November 22 As the moon and sun travel in tandem, two very different sides of you can take centre stage. First, your hunger for change, but in ways that really fulfil you. And second, a need to keep certain parts of your life exactly as they are. The right balance is in your own hands, and can happen now. Luck opens a yellow door. Get all the latest Scorpio horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♐ SAGITTARIUS November 23 to December 21 Your deep inner travelling spirit is waking up – ready to start moving forward. A time when you have had to shelve ambitious relocation plans can end when you take just one step in the desired direction. You also have the patience now to wait and see, when you need to. In love terms, doing anything is better than doing nothing. Get all the latest Sagittarius horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♑ CAPRICORN December 22 to January 20 People who assume a creative career is out of your reach can be thinking again. The way you dig deep into your skills, and are ready to develop them, shows your determination. Do take on board any advice or assistance offers. Love-wise, when you feel most alone is exactly when a special name is thinking of you. Get all the latest Capricorn horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions 3 A communication moon opens two hearts at once Credit: Supplied ♒ AQUARIUS January 21 to February 18 Your image is important to you – but is it accurate? If you're in love, that cool front may need to thaw a little to let a partner in. If you're single, playing hard to get can push the right partner away – so if you feel something for someone, don't be scared to show it. An 'S' conversation can have a sudden twist. Get all the latest Aquarius horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♓ PISCES February 19 to March 20 How a family works and plays together is ready for a revamp – habits can be good, but not if they trap you in a tricky situation. Just one smart suggestion can be all it takes to break the mould. At work, the sun and Mercury set high standards, but you are more than ready to be tested, so do accept the challenge. Get all the latest Pisces horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions

Daily horoscope: July 25, 2025 astrological predictions for your star sign
Daily horoscope: July 25, 2025 astrological predictions for your star sign

Metro

time3 hours ago

  • Metro

Daily horoscope: July 25, 2025 astrological predictions for your star sign

As the Sun and Pluto clash within the cosmos, hidden tensions my arise – breathe deeply, trust your instinct and let the stars realign your path. Gemini, Leo and Capricorn, inner conflict may attempt to shake your balance, but staying grounded and focusing on goals that speak to your soul will guide you back to your true path. Move through your day with confidence, know that the current of the universe is guiding you toward your true centre. Ahead, you'll find all the star signs' horoscopes for today Friday 25, July 2025. Like checking your horoscope every morning? You can now sign up to our free daily newsletter to get a personalised reading for your star sign delivered straight to your inbox. To order your unique personal horoscope based on your time, date and place of birth, visit March 21 to April 20 The Sun in Leo faces off with powerhouse Pluto, so you may be feeling bold but also challenged. This cosmic clash stirs up a tug-of-war between your desire to shine individually and the pressure to play your part in a larger group or cause. You want to lead, but deeper dynamics may be testing your ego or desire to control. Power struggles might surface, but so can breakthroughs. Head here for everything you need to know about being an Aries April 21 to May 21 You may notice conflict between a need for comfort and public ambition. It's not about choosing one over the other, it's more about redefining balance on your terms. You're evolving, and so is your sense of what stability really means. Let go of outdated expectations around influence and image. Instead, create space physically and emotionally for something more empowering. Head here for everything you need to know about being a Taurus May 22 to June 21 Conversations could get intense, revealing truths you didn't expect or didn't know you were ready for. You may be torn between playful banter and adopting a more profound perspective, but don't underestimate your power to persuade and inspire. Just be mindful not to push too hard. If something's been bubbling beneath the surface, it might erupt now, so tread with care. Head here for everything you need to know about being a Gemini June 22 to July 23 Today's Sun/Pluto clash can stir deep emotional currents. You're being called to examine any concerns around power, possessions and emotional investments. This cosmic face-off could bring a financial revelation or a shift in a close relationship where control or trust issues can arise. Don't fear intensity, embrace it as a chance to transform your attachments and priorities. Head here for everything you need to know about being a Cancer July 24 to August 23 With the Sun in your sign opposing powerful Pluto in Aquarius, the spotlight is on you, but so is the pressure. Relationships may mirror your inner struggles, highlighting where control, pride or old patterns need an upgrade. This aspect challenges you to balance self-expression with collaboration. You don't have to dim your light at all Leo, but you may need to share the stage. Head here for everything you need to know about being a Leo August 24 to September 23 Experiencing a tug of war between rest and responsibility? You may feel pulled to retreat, recharge or reflect, but your to-do list could hold you back. Something beneath the surface such as an old habit, belief or fear might need attention, so dive in. Plus, power struggles at work or issues with routines could be a call to shift your priorities. Once you do, you'll feel such a relief. Head here for everything you need to know about being a Virgo September 24 to October 23 Creative and romantic opportunities could be intensified, and you may feel you're walking a fine line between connection while also craving control. Feeling a magnetic pull toward a friend, collaborator or lover? If so, watch out for a touch of obsession that may need care. Today's cosmic power tussle can highlight your desire to stand out, so be strong, real and shine out brightly, Libra. Head here for everything you need to know about being a Libra October 24 to November 22 With the Sun beaming from your career zone and Pluto churning up emotions in your home sector, you're torn between public ambition and a deep need for privacy, or between climbing higher and retreating inward. Both deserve attention. Don't resist this chance for change, as it's helping you redefine success on your terms. Just let go of whatever impedes your happiness. Head here for everything you need to know about being a Scorpio November 23 to December 21 Your thirst for knowledge could find you caught between big ideas and deeper truths. You're craving expansion such as travel, study and adventure, but today's Sun/Pluto planetary duel asks you to transform the way you think before chasing the next big thing. And conversations could get intense, with power issues revealing themselves in intellectual debates or casual chats. Go easy! Head here for everything you need to know about being a Sagittarius December 22 to January 20 Feeling torn between emotional vulnerability and self-reliance? Issues around money, trust or control may bubble up, especially in close relationships or financial ties. Look to release old fears around dependence and step into empowered sharing. What are you holding onto that's holding you back? Transformation can start when you stop trying to influence every outcome. Head here for everything you need to know about being a Capricorn January 21 to February 19 The Sun shines in Leo and Pluto stirs up your sign, so today can feel very personal and powerful. This blend of energy puts partnerships under the microscope, revealing where influence, fear or ego might be playing too big a role. You're evolving, and so are your connections. Whether it's love, friendship or business, it's time to let go of dynamics that no longer serve your growth. Head here for everything you need to know about being an Aquarius February 20 to March 20 More Trending You may be caught between working at your tasks and diving into the mystery. The Sun/Pluto opposition invites you to transform your daily habits, not just to be more productive, but to align with what truly heals and empowers you. Control issues may arise behind the scenes or within yourself, if you're fearing burnout. Listen to what your body and intuition are quietly shouting. Head here for everything you need to know about being a Pisces View More » Your daily horoscope is here every morning, seven days a week (yes, including weekends!). To check your forecast, head to our dedicated horoscopes page. MORE: What's my horoscope for today? July 24, 2025 astrological predictions for your star sign MORE: The tarot's Year of The Hermit — what your star sign can expect for the rest of 2025 MORE: What's my horoscope for today? July 23, 2025 astrological predictions for your star sign

Horoscope today, July 25, 2025: Daily star sign guide from Mystic Meg
Horoscope today, July 25, 2025: Daily star sign guide from Mystic Meg

The Sun

time3 hours ago

  • The Sun

Horoscope today, July 25, 2025: Daily star sign guide from Mystic Meg

OUR much-loved astrologer Meg sadly died in 2023 but her column will be kept alive by her friend and protégée Maggie Innes. Read on to see what's written in the stars for you today. ♈ ARIES March 21 to April 20 That Friday feeling can get you thinking of faces and places you've been missing – and this is a great time to follow through. You have a chart of new beginnings that can help you rewrite the past and rework relationships. So let your natural winning streak take charge and follow where your ideas lead you. 2 ♉ TAURUS April 21 to May 21 The sun spars with Pluto, and big home-based decisions can come into the crossfire – but in ways that leave you richer. Trying to ignore a gap that's growing wider does not suit your straightforward Taurus self. When you need strength to deal with this, it is there. Luck circles recently-changed names. Get all the latest Taurus horoscope new s including your weekly and monthly predictions ♊ GEMINI May 22 to June 21 Talking about yourself in ways that impress and intrigue is a key factor of your chart. So get your words ready and start speaking. If you're in love, accepting that changes may be small, but are heading in the right direction, is your star skill. Single? Your soulmate has a familiar voice. Get all the latest Gemini horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♋ CANCER June 22 to July 22 As the sun and Mercury form a formidable money team, you can find new ways to deal with old cash questions. You can get more time or help, provided you're not too proud to make the request. As for love, there's a dreamy aspect to your chart that helps partners reconnect. Fresh romance can link to a former workplace. Get all the latest Cancer horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♌ LEO July 23 to August 23 Knowing the difference between self-criticism and self-support is your chart secret. Being extra hard on yourself may feel necessary for success, but when you look again, you can see a different way that asks you to believe in your own ability. A good friend's love story can include a surprise starring role for you. ♍ VIRGO August 24 to September 22 That half-truth or half-hope that has been on your mind needs addressing. Finding out more, with no obligation, is easier with your current chart combination of caring and questioning. Passion, all day, is positively popping – especially when you meet someone in dark clothing, or in a darkened space. Get all the latest Virgo horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♎ LIBRA September 23 to October 23 Love lessons may not have been easy to learn, but you are nearing the end of the process – plus the chance to put your new knowledge and ability into practice. Try not to waste this chance. Friends who work together well can also win together well – and a second-time-around contest can be the key. ♏ SCORPIO October 24 to November 22 As the moon and sun travel in tandem, two very different sides of you can take centre stage. First, your hunger for change, but in ways that really fulfil you. And second, a need to keep certain parts of your life exactly as they are. The right balance is in your own hands, and can happen now. Luck opens a yellow door. Get all the latest Scorpio horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♐ SAGITTARIUS November 23 to December 21 Your deep inner travelling spirit is waking up – ready to start moving forward. A time when you have had to shelve ambitious relocation plans can end when you take just one step in the desired direction. You also have the patience now to wait and see, when you need to. In love terms, doing anything is better than doing nothing. Get all the latest Sagittarius horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♑ CAPRICORN December 22 to January 20 People who assume a creative career is out of your reach can be thinking again. The way you dig deep into your skills, and are ready to develop them, shows your determination. Do take on board any advice or assistance offers. Love-wise, when you feel most alone is exactly when a special name is thinking of you. Get all the latest Capricorn horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions 2 ♒ AQUARIUS January 21 to February 18 Your image is important to you – but is it accurate? If you're in love, that cool front may need to thaw a little to let a partner in. If you're single, playing hard to get can push the right partner away – so if you feel something for someone, don't be scared to show it. An 'S' conversation can have a sudden twist. Get all the latest Aquarius horoscope news including your weekly and monthly predictions ♓ PISCES February 19 to March 20 How a family works and plays together is ready for a revamp – habits can be good, but not if they trap you in a tricky situation. Just one smart suggestion can be all it takes to break the mould. At work, the sun and Mercury set high standards, but you are more than ready to be tested, so do accept the challenge.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store