Dentist fined £150,000 for keeping patients' teeth too clean
Britain is facing a hidden dental disaster as kids are needing multiple teeth removed at their first ever appointment.
NHS dentist Rob Mew revealed the shocking cases he has encountered after opening his doors to one new child patient every Thursday, reports the Mirror.
The Mirror travelled to Devon, one of Britain's worst 'dentistry deserts' as part of theut Dentisrs for All campaign.
Our sister site visited Fairfield House Dental Surgery in Exmouth which is one of the few in Devon still seeing NHS patients.
Owner Rob passionately believes in the NHS and its founding principle that it should care for patients from "cradle to grave".
However, that is the only reason his practice still treats NHS patients, as it could earn hundreds of thousands of pounds more going private.
Rob has been fined £150,000 by the NHS in a funding "claw back" effectively for maintaining his patients healthy teeth through regular check ups and preventative work.
It is an example of the widely discredited NHS dental payment contract which is causing dentists to quit the health service in their droves to see only private patients.
Every Thursday, Rob opens his NHS books for local children, many of whom have gone years without a check-up. Some have never been seen at all.
Rob, who has three kids of his own, aged ten, eight and four, said: "That's one of the reasons I do it because I have young children but it's quite emotional. We were seeing four and five year olds who had so much decay we just had to send them to hospital to get extractions. There's such a backlog of sending these kids to have general anaesthetic to get the teeth out so we're trying to maintain them until they get their teeth extracted.
'One of the dentists saw a seventeen year old who hadn't seen a dentist in ten years and needed 28 fillings. You've got really emotional parents that are feeling really guilty that they have got themselves into this position. One of our nurses said she couldn't work on that list because it was too upsetting because she has kids of a similar age. It's a really sad situation.'
Rob's practice, Fairfield House Dental Surgery, has been serving patients for over 100 years. It offers free supervised tooth brushing in schools, and sends its team out to breastfeeding and toddler groups to teach parents about oral health.
Rob, 43, said: 'We're blessed with a group of patients who've been with us for a long time, some have been coming here for more than 50 years. So that's why I'm still with the NHS because it feels like the right thing to do, to keep going for them. It's a kind of cradle to grave service which is what the NHS was supposed to be. But that's the only reason we're doing it - out of good will.'
Why is top dentist being 'fined' £150,000 for keeping his patients' teeth too healthy?
Rob Mew owns a rare example of a thriving NHS dental practice in the middle of a dental desert. Fairfield House Dental Surgery employs ten dentists and does free outreach work in the local community to improve oral health.
Despite all this, Rob's being forced to return £150,000 in NHS money, as the surgery had not carried out enough Units of Dental Activity (UDA). It was having to pay £50,000 a month over three months.
UDAs are the metric used by the NHS in its dentistry payment contract which has been deemed 'not fit for purpose' by Parliament's Health and Social Care Committee.
Under the current deal, practices must carry out a set number of Units of Dental Activity (UDAs) every year or face financial penalties.
The contract requires practices to agree to perform a set number of UDAs - and they are penalised if they come in below or above this. A check-up is worth one UDA while giving a patient a filling racks up three UDAs.
Rob told the Mirror: 'We are being penalised for preventing patients requiring more UDAs. We have £150,000 'claw back' this year but we have 19,000 NHS patients which is more than the practice has ever had. The clawback is for not doing enough UDAs but when patients are being looked after better they don't have as much need for dental work.'
Fairfield surgery gives his patients a check up every 12 months whereas other practices call lower risk patients back for check ups every two years. Rob said: 'We are seeing them yearly and that's one UDA. We are preventing loss of tooth. A GP practice is paid for how many patients they have on their list. That's how they should be funding dentistry.'
Rob says between five and ten people call the practice every day desperate to be seen by an NHS dentist. He has taken on as many as he can but has just started a waiting list. He said: 'We have got patients travelling to be seen here from as far away as north Wales, Manchester and Sheffield.
"The NHS dental contract in England only funds enough for half the population to be treated so these patients have moved away but can't get a dentist. And the Exmouth population is exploding and we have a load of new housing but no more dentistry money to treat the people in those houses.'
A key Mirror campaign demand is reform of the controversial NHS payment contract which disincentivises dentists from treating the patients who need it most. Dentists get paid the same for delivering three or 20 fillings, often leaving the practice treating NHS patients at a loss.
Last week the Government published its Ten Year Health Plan which pledged that "by 2035 the NHS dental system will be transformed" - but the British Dental Association insists contract reform must happen much sooner.
Rob said: 'With these most vulnerable patients with high needs it's really tricky for the practice to to make that work [financially].
'We had a family last Thursday with three kids and they had never been seen by a dentist. There was decay everywhere and they clearly need a lot of work and the parents are saying we haven't been able to be seen anywhere. And they're just tired because they've been calling around practices trying to get in and it kind of gets put on the back burner.
'We had a 14 year old girl come in a couple of weeks ago and she had four crowns put on her back teeth. And you're thinking, if we hadn't handled that soon she would have a couple of back teeth missing and then a lower denture.'
Dental surgeries are being squeezed by soaring costs, with Fairfield House Dental Surgery now scrambling to raise £30,000 just to buy a new dentist's chair.
Rob has worked in the NHS in some form for 28 years, starting at the age of 15 in a hospital kitchen. He added: 'I've got a lot of good will towards the NHS so yeh I try my best to make it work.'
But NHS dentistry cannot rely on good will alone.
The British Dental Association (BDA) has told the Public Accounts Committee the UK Government is propping up NHS services by relying on practices delivering care at a loss - fuelling an exodus of NHS dentists into lucrative private work.
Figures from the BDA show a typical practice loses over £40 for every set of NHS dentures it fits, and £7 for each new patient exam. A damning report from Westminster's Health Select Committee branded the state of NHS dentistry as 'unacceptable in the 21st century'.
And under the current NHS contract, dentists are restricted by quotas,limiting how many patients they can see and procedures they can carry out each year.
To make matters worse, the Tories have slashed funding in real terms for over a decade. England's £3billion dental budget now only stretches far enough to treat half of the population.
This week, ministers are expected to reveal long-awaited details on plans to finally reform the system. Labour pledged to overhaul the dental contract before the last General Election, but there are serious doubts about whether meaningful change will happen in this Parliament, or whether the Treasury will cough up the cash needed for real reform.
It's understood the UK Government will announce new plans on Tuesday aimed at reversing the current system, one which discourages dentists from taking on patients who need complex care.
Care minister Stephen Kinnock, who has responsibility for dentistry, told the Mirror: 'It isn't right that it's less cost effective for dentists to take on patients who need more complex and extensive treatments like crowns and bridges.'This is why this government will overhaul the dental contract to make it more attractive to offer NHS dental care, especially for those who need it most. As we deliver on the Plan for Change, we're fixing NHS dentistry to make it fit for the future.'
The Government's announcement will also include confirmation of 700,000 extra urgent and emergency dental appointments this year. Officials say these emergency slots will become part of standard NHS provision, and that practices will be paid separately to deliver them, alongside routine check-ups.
Devon worst 'Dental Desert'
It's now harder to get an NHS dentist in the South West of England than anywhere else in the UK, with Devon emerging as one of the country's worst so-called 'dental deserts'.
New figures from the annual GP Patient Survey show that just 72% of people with an NHS dentist in Devon managed to get an appointment, way below the national average of 84%.
Survey responses were grouped by regional Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) which include NHS bodies, local councils and voluntary organisations. The One Devon ICB is responsible for the health of the population in the county. Among people who were already in with an NHS dentist, Devon saw just 72% of people successfully get an appointment. In the wider South West region this was 74% while for England as a whole it was 84%.
Of those who attempted to get an appointment at a practice they had not been seen at before, only 14% were successful in Devon. This compared to 19% in the South West region and 33% as the average for England.
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
The big caveat is that many will not have tried to get an appointment if they thought they had no chance.
The data shows only a minority of dentists are taking on new adult patients, and in Devon and the South West, hardly any are.
British Dental Association chair Eddie Crouch said: 'This shows why the government is right to commit to major surgery for NHS dentistry, rather than mere sticking plasters. But we need pace. This service is on the critical list, and demoralised dentists are walking away every day this contract remains in force. If we don't make a break in this Parliament there may not be a service left to save.'
A spokeswoman for the Department of Health and Social Care said: 'This government inherited a broken NHS dental system but we are getting on with fixing it through our 10 Year Health Plan.
'We have already begun the rollout of 700,000 extra urgent dental appointments, a 'golden hello' scheme is underway to recruit dentists to areas with the most need and we are reforming the NHS dental contract, with a shift to focus on prevention and the retention of NHS dentists - including introducing tie-ins for those trained in the NHS."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
26 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Resident doctors' strikes risk derailing Labour's NHS recovery plan
Patients left in pain and discomfort. Thousands of appointments and operations cancelled. Much of the reaction to the decision of resident (formerly junior) doctors in England to stage their third six-month series of strikes over pay in just 16 months has focused on the disruption to NHS services. But their stoppages also threaten to pose serious problems – political, economic and reputational – for the government. For Keir Starmer, Wes Streeting and inescapably Rachel Reeves too, this is a situation replete with risk but without an obvious solution. First, it will make the already tricky delivery of the government's main NHS pledge – to restore the 18-week wait for planned hospital care by 2029 – even harder. Last July, Labour inherited a waiting list that stood at 7.6m treatments and appointments. After a year of the party overseeing the NHS, it remains at a stubbornly high 7.4m. On current trends, ensuring that 92% of those waiting get seen within 18 weeks of referral by a GP as promised looks like a real stretch even without strikes. As the NHS Confederation chief executive, Matthew Taylor, says: 'Hitting the 92% target is a difficult enough ambition without further industrial action.' Second, a fresh round of strikes by doctors in training could embolden other NHS staff groups to do the same. That is a real fear among health bosses. Other health unions envy the 22% rise for 2023-24 and 2024-25 that the then junior doctors got within days of Streeting becoming health secretary and noted that it came after they withdrew their labour on 11 occasions, for a total of 44 days, in 2023 and 2024. Resident doctor stoppages could well encourage others. The Royal College of Nursing and Unison recently initiated indicative ballots about possible strike action. Both have done so in recent years and have restive memberships, many of whom see NHS salary rounds as involving doctors who are far better paid getting preferential treatment yet again. As the Health Foundation noted recently, even though the strikes by doctors, nurses, ambulance crews and others ended, 'there remains significant underlying dissatisfaction with pay' among NHS staff trying to cope with more than three years of historically high inflation. Third, a government that has got itself into huge difficulties over the cost of winter fuel payments and disability benefits will struggle to offer a bigger pay rise than the 5.4% it unveiled in May – at least, not in the form of extra cash from a Treasury that does not have it. That leaves open the possibility that ministers could agree a bigger rise with the British Medical Association (BMA) and tell the NHS to fund it. But with the health service already grappling with a forecast deficit of £6.6bn for this year, it has no money to spare. There is no obvious middle ground for Streeting and the BMA to meet on. He has insisted that this year's 5.4% settlement will not be reopened. The union for its part says he needs to produce 'a credible offer' to address a 20% real terms fall in resident doctors' pay and start to 'negotiate a path to full pay restoration' – or face strikes that could last until next January. The recent readiness of the medical profession's younger members to take industrial action in pursuit of their 29% pay claim suggests they will not back down. Streeting struck a deal with a BMA weary after 44 days of strikes and fruitless negotiations with the previous government. It will take all his persuasive skills, and a pragmatism so far unseen in the BMA's approach, for the same to happen again.
The Independent
29 minutes ago
- The Independent
HRT-alternative for women experiencing hot flushes gets green light
The Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) in the UK has approved elinzanetant, a new non-hormonal daily pill for menopausal hot flushes, making it the first global regulator to do so. Developed by Bayer, elinzanetant offers an alternative to hormone replacement therapy (HRT) for women experiencing vasomotor symptoms, commonly known as hot flushes. The medication works by calming specific brain signals that become overactive due to declining oestrogen levels during menopause, which disrupt the body's temperature regulation. Clinical trials demonstrated that the drug is safe, well-tolerated, effectively reduces hot flushes, improves sleep, and enhances the quality of life for women compared to a placebo. While not yet available on the NHS, the MHRA's approval means elinzanetant can be purchased privately in the UK and will be considered by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE).
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Plans for NHS diagnostic centre in Peterborough win approval
Plans for a community diagnostic centre aimed at reducing patient waiting times have been means building work can begin next month on the facility in Wellington Street, Peterborough, which should be open in West Anglia NHS Foundation Trust, which submitted the plans, said it would offer scans and cardiology and respiratory diagnostic Coffey, its chief executive, said she was "incredibly pleased" that planning approval had been granted. "As an organisation, we are working tirelessly on reducing diagnostic wait times, and opening the [centre] will undoubtedly improve patient experience," she Coffey said the government's 10-year plan for the NHS had highlighted the need to shift care out of hospitals and into the centre will have CT, MRI, Dexa, X-ray, ultrasound and fibroscan Pakes, the Labour MP for Peterborough, said it would ease pressure on hospitals."As Peterborough grows, we need local services that grow with us," he said."This centre is a big boost for patients and for our brilliant NHS staff."The plans were approved by Peterborough City Council on Monday. Follow Peterborough news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.
