Dominica: UN Expert Recommends Human Rights Approach For Advancing Climate Resilience
'Dominica has been able to secure a fast recovery after tropical storm Erika in 2015 and Hurricane Maria in 2017. These were catastrophic climate events,' Elisa Morgera, UN Special Rapporteur on climate change and human rights, said in a statement at end of her visit to Dominica, referring to loss of life, persistent mental health issues, destruction up to 90% of the housing stock and the loss of over 200% GDP.
'In the face of such dramatic human rights impacts of climate change to which Dominica does not contribute, high-emitting States should provide finance, as well as science and technology cooperation, to protect human rights, biodiversity and cultural heritage in proportion to their responsibility for the loss and damage experienced due to climate change in Dominica, without increasing its debt,' Morgera warned.
'Dominica's ambition to become the world's first climate resilient nation has made significant strides since 2017,' she added, noting cross-sectoral efforts to protect the rights to adequate housing, food, water, health and education, thanks to major investment of the national budget and the spirit of Koudmen – community cooperation, generosity and service.
'Shifting from top-down delivery towards transformative and collaborative approaches can further advance climate resilience,' Morgera said, 'through access to information, public participation in decision-making, and the prevention of discriminatory practices in the distribution of recovery and resilience resources.'
'Participatory approaches also contribute to paying more attention to the essential role of biodiversity and cultural heritage in climate resilience,' the Special Rapporteur added. 'This is particularly timely because of the expected expansion of tourism and imminent launch of land and marine spatial planning processes in the Nature Island of the Caribbean.'
The visit illuminated how transforming Dominica into a global resilience centre should rely on valuing and protecting the knowledge, practices and human rights of the Kalinago People – the largest remaining Indigenous peoples in the Caribbean islands, who have been the guardians of Dominica's nature and water sources for centuries.
Small-scale fishers and farmers, divers and other individuals and communities who live in close connection with nature are also making significant contributions to environmental and socio-cultural sustainability, as are young people and NGOs. 'But they are not recognised as trusted partners by the Government and face criticism for suggesting alternatives or mitigation measures,' the expert learnt during the visit.
'Dominica must urgently develop comprehensive legislation, through participatory processes, to protect human rights as part of climate resilience, including the rights of environmental human rights defenders, to prevent further environmental and cultural losses and support sustainable prosperity,' the Special Rapporteur said.
The visit also provided an opportunity to clarify the responsibilities of bilateral donors, International Financial Institutions and the UN System to prevent, and provide effective remedies for, human rights or environmental harm arising from climate resilience or development projects. The expert also urged these partners to provide direct funding to community-led and youth-led initiatives in Dominica.
The full report of the expert's visit will be presented to the 62nd session of the UN Human Rights Council in July 2026.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
25 minutes ago
- Scoop
Pacific Scholars Applaud International Ruling On Climate Change
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling welcomed by Te Poutoko Ora a Kiwa - Centre for Pacific and Global Health. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling that countries can be held legally accountable for greenhouse gas emissions has been welcomed by Te Poutoko Ora a Kiwa - Centre for Pacific and Global Health. Co-Director Li'amanaia Dr Roannie Ng Shiu commended Pacific youth and Pacific communities for their leadership and perseverance over six years of advocacy. She says their leadership demonstrated the power of young Pacific voices to shape international systems and call the world to account. 'We extend our congratulations to the Pacific youth, student leaders and our Pacific communities in the region whose courageous advocacy and strategic vision led to this moment.' 'Their tireless efforts - supported by a coalition of Pacific governments, civil society, and legal experts - have resulted in a global legal affirmation that states have clear obligations to act on climate change." The legal campaign, led by Vanuatu, was initiated by the Pacific Islands Students Fighting Climate Change (PISFCC). Its president, Cynthia Houniuhi, visited the University of Auckland's Fale Pasifika two years ago as a guest panelist for Te Poutoko Ora a Kiwa's Pacific Transnational Leadership Panel, where she joined regional leaders in discussing the future of Pacific cooperation. Dr Ng Shiu praised the leadership of Houniuhi and the cultural integrity of the campaign. 'This opinion stems from a journey led by Pacific students and communities, speaking from lived experience - rising sea levels, disrupted ecosystems, and the health and social impacts already affecting their families." That journey has now yielded a decision that will influence global climate action for years to come, says Ng Shiu. "As a young Pacific female and student, she epitomizes what it means to make the impossible possible and to redefine leadership. She's quiet and humble, but when she speaks, it's deeply impactful. In a world that often celebrates loud and assertive voices, Cynthia's thoughtful approach stands out. 'Her leadership, and the way the ICJ campaign was conducted, reflects not just climate justice but also cultural ethics. The integration of storytelling and community engagement ensures that people hear, understand, and embrace the message. This is promising for Indigenous and Pacific peoples - our ways of knowing and being are being valued by institutions like the ICJ. 'This ruling is not just about empowerment, but also accountability. It sends a message to powerful nations that passing the buck is no longer acceptable." Speaking from the Netherlands following the ICJ's advisory opinion, Cynthia Houniuhi responded with heartfelt emotion and pride, saying it marked a significant milestone in a youth-led campaign that began in the Pacific. 'This journey has been tough but deeply rewarding,' says Houniuhi. 'It's the relationships we've built along the way that have carried us. This victory belongs to all of us - especially those in rural communities who supported this work but couldn't be here to witness it.' Houniuhi emphasized the importance of communicating the technical decision in ways that resonate with local communities. 'We're committed to going back and speaking with our people - to show them that their hope was not misplaced.' Despite challenges, including the COVID-19 pandemic, the campaign adapted through digital platforms, maintaining momentum and building resilience. Houniuhi highlighted the courage and unity of Pacific youth and governments, and the importance of inclusive, community-driven advocacy. 'Our campaign has always been about collective effort. We walk toward a community goal, not individual recognition. That's our strength.' Emphasizing a collective approach over an individual focus, saw the campaign maintain ancestral storytelling traditions. 'In our advocacy, we used different aspects of our traditions as well as culture, even appearing in the courtroom using the power of wearing our own traditional attire.' She says they had to obtain permission from their chiefs in order to share their sacred stories in court submissions, ensuring cultural protocols were respected. Looking ahead, Houniuhi is seeking greater Pacific representation in international spaces such as COP and the UN General Assembly, and urges more Pacific lawyers, academics, and advocates to engage with the ICJ opinion. 'We need more Pacific voices telling our stories - not others speaking on our behalf. This is our advice, our opinion, and our future.' As the movement enters its next phase, Houniuhi's own journey continues - she hopes to pursue PhD studies at the University of Auckland, further strengthening the Pacific voice in global climate discourse. 'Barriers have already been broken. Round two - let's go.'
Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
EDS Submissions Highlight Serious Concerns Over Government's Resource Management Changes
The Environmental Defence Society (EDS) has today filed its very extensive submissions on the Government's review of national direction under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). The proposals, which are spread across three packages of Infrastructure and Development, Primary Sector and Freshwater, present an overwhelming shift towards prioritising use and development at the expense of the natural environment. National direction is the 'engine room' of the RMA. Regional policy statements and regional and district plans must 'give effect' to it and decision-makers on resource consent applications must 'have regard' to it. It therefore has significant ramifications for resource management decision-making. 'Taken together, the changes set out pose a significant risk to indigenous biodiversity, freshwater, wetlands, elite soils and the coastal marine environment. They will result in more inappropriate and environmentally damaging activities occurring in New Zealand's most sensitive places,' says EDS Chief Operating Officer and lawyer, Shay Schlaepfer. 'The environment is not in a healthy state. Monitoring shows ongoing declines in freshwater quality, more threatened and at risk species, a reduction in food producing land, continued loss of remaining wetlands and a marine environment under threat. 'The proposals are wilfully ignorant of that context. They are being pushed through under a 'growth at all costs' mentality that will result in more pollution for longer and more destruction of nature. This is not what the RMA provides for. 'EDS's key concerns with the proposals are: 1. Forestry review too narrow: The proposed changes fail to address systemic issues with forestry regulations which are resulting in extensive and damaging slash and sedimentation mobilisation events with corresponding devastating impacts on receiving environments and communities. 2. Infrastructure proposal lacks environmental considerations: The Government's expansive vision for infrastructure and development comes with no corresponding focus on protecting the natural environment. 3. Increased mining and quarrying in sensitive areas: The proposed changes will facilitate more mining and quarrying activities, directly threatening New Zealand's indigenous biodiversity, vulnerable wetlands and highly productive land. 4. Freshwater management at risk: The proposed changes would unwind decades of freshwater management progress, undermining hard-won legal protections in favour of short-term economic interests. 5. Natural hazards not taken seriously: A gaping hole in the proposals is any regulation to stop building in high hazards areas. If New Zealand is to get real about climate adaptation it needs to prioritise not making the situation worse in the first place. 'The review of national direction is being undertaken before replacement resource management laws are enacted in 'phase 3' of the Government's programme of RMA reform. Progressing substantial national direction review under a regime that is to be replaced, and then implementing those new instruments in a new regime which Ministers describe as being radically different, is a confusing, unstructured and backwards approach. 'This has been exacerbated by Minister Bishop's recent 'plan stop' announcement which has compounded uncertainty about how the package of national direction changes will be implemented. The Government needs to stop rushing and progress resource management reform on a more strategic, coherent footing. 'Most importantly, Government needs to acknowledge that economic growth and good environmental outcomes are both achievable. EDS's submissions propose changes to the policy settings which would bring the instruments into a more acceptable and lawful outcome,' concluded Ms Schlaepfer. Environmental Defence Society EDS speaks for the environment. It has influence. Since 1971, EDS has been driving environmental protection in Aotearoa New Zealand through law and policy change. That's why it's one of this country's most influential non- profit organisations when it comes to achieving better environmental outcomes. EDS has expertise in key disciplines including law, planning, landscape and science. It operates as a policy think-tank, a litigation advocate, and a collaborator – bringing together the private and public sectors for constructive engagement. EDS runs conferences and seminars on topical issues, including an annual Environmental Summit and the Climate Change and Business Conference. EDS is a registered charity and donations to it are tax-deductible.
NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Explainer: France will be the biggest Western power and first G7 member to take the step
'Such a move rewards terror and risks creating another Iranian proxy, just as Gaza became,' Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said in a statement. 'A Palestinian state in these conditions would be a launchpad to annihilate Israel - not to live in peace beside it.' Defence Minister Israel Katz called the move a 'disgrace' and a 'surrender to terror'. How has Hamas responded? Hamas, which triggered the current war with a deadly raid on Israeli communities on October 7, 2023, welcomed Macron's decision as a 'positive step' towards justice and self-determination for the Palestinian people. Why announce the move now? It comes as global anger is rising at Israel's 21-month military campaign against Hamas in Gaza, where tens of thousands have been killed and people are now starving. In making the high-profile announcement, Macron took the opportunity to reiterate calls for an immediate ceasefire. He also called for the release of all Israeli hostages; 'massive humanitarian aid' to the people of Gaza; the demilitarisation of Hamas; and the development of the Palestinian state. 'There is no alternative,' he wrote. What is the significance internationally? France will become the largest Western power and the first member of the Group of Seven major industrialised nations to recognise Palestinian statehood. Russia, China, India and more than 140 other countries already do; the United States, Britain, and Japan do not. What is the significance domestically? France is home to the largest Jewish population in Europe - globally, it trails only Israel and the United States - and the largest Muslim population in Western Europe. Macron has spoken out against anti-Semitism and Islamophobia. What is the situation in Gaza? Hamas-led fighters killed around 1200 people in southern Israel on October 7, 2023, and took 250 more back to the enclave as hostages. Israel responded with a military campaign against Hamas that has killed more than 59,500 people in Gaza, according to the Gaza Health Ministry. Now, nearly one in three people in Gaza are going multiple days without eating, the UN says, and 111 people have died of starvation, according to the Gaza Health Ministry. Hundreds more have been shot dead in recent weeks while trying to reach food aid. What is Macron's position on the conflict? Macron condemned the October 7 attacks and offered France's support to Israel in the aftermath. He has also called for an end to the fighting in Gaza, the infusion of more humanitarian aid to the enclave and progress towards a two-state solution. What did his letter to Abbas say? In the letter, Macron noted that the Palestinian leader had condemned the attack by Hamas, a rival to his own Fatah Party, and called for the return of the Israeli hostages; supported the disarmament of Hamas and its removal from government; and pledged to reform the Palestinian Authority and organise presidential and legislative elections for next year. 'In this context,' Macron wrote, 'I have the honour of confirming that, in light of your commitments, France will fully recognise Palestine as a State when I go to the United Nations General Assembly in September.'
