Man accused of grabbing colleague by throat and using homophobic slur loses unfair dismissal case
Workplace Relations Commission
(WRC).
Seamus Behan lost his job of 12 years as a van driver for Liberties Recycling Development and Training CLG in February of last year following the altercation with another worker just before Christmas 2023.
At a hearing of Mr Behan's complaint under the Unfair Dismissals Act 2014, Liberties Recycling told the WRC his behaviour on December 20th, 2023 amounted to gross misconduct.
The company said the finding was arrived at after what it described as a fair investigation and disciplinary process.
READ MORE
Company manager Adam Moloney said 'multiple' statements from staff recounted 'off the charts' behaviour from Mr Behan towards the other worker, Mr A.
Mr Moloney said workers told him Mr Behan was 'verbally abusive, behaving aggressively, and damaged company property' during the incident.
He said it 'wasn't clear' from the statements what had first happened other than that the two men 'pushed each other'.
Mr Moloney said Mr Behan was at reception in the depot 'shouting abuse' at Mr A, would not leave when asked and 'kept trying to go at him'.
Management tried to persuade gardaí to come, but there was no response by closing time. A duty manager suspended Mr Behan and Mr A and sent them away via separate exits.
The complainant's representative, Thomas Behan, argued that witness statements had been 'handpicked' to support a case that his client was 'violent' and that CCTV had been 'purposely left out' of the investigation.
The company said any footage of the incident was taped over during the Christmas break, so it was not available when the investigation began in the new year.
The tribunal was told the row followed a complaint made by Mr A about Mr Behan's alleged conduct towards him six days earlier. It was alleged the complainant on that occasion grabbed Mr A's hand and squeezed until Mr A asked him to let go. Mr Behan then turned to another worker and allegedly said: 'Watch how I shake a real man's hand.'
Mr Behan said he knew nothing of this informal complaint until after the incident on December 20th, with his representative arguing any difficulties between the men ought to have been addressed sooner by management.
Mr Behan said Mr A was 'an hour late' returning with a van for a shift handover on December 20th and he was 'in a hurry to get out' so as to avoid working late without pay.
'I went to your man ... he was just numb about everything. Because I didn't know anything about the 14th, I was at the van, and he was at the van. He started mumbling stuff about something, and then he got aggressive towards me,' he said.
'This guy pursued me, I went away from the van, he's aggressive, in my face, spitting in my face,' Mr Behan said, adding that the spitting was not 'intentional'.
'He's giving me lackery about Pope John Paul, lackery about my religion. He deeply upset me,' he said.
The complainant said he 'wouldn't repeat' his colleague's remarks during the disciplinary process that followed because it was 'filthy' and 'vulgar' language.
Mr Behan denied using a slur toward Mr A in the course of the altercation, as had been indicated in statements gathered by the company. 'I don't even use the word 'f****t',' he said. 'Everyone's twisting and turning statements.'
He said a female supervisor was standing between him and Mr A, so it would have been 'impossible for me to grab the man by the neck'.
He told the tribunal Mr A pushed him as the altercation continued and that the CCTV footage 'would prove that as well'.
He said he was 'well warmed up' by his colleague by the time he reached the office.
'I raised my voice. Is that a sacking offence?' he said. 'No one wanted to investigate my statement ... My statement is the truth, on my religious beliefs.'
In her decision, WRC adjudicator Eileen Campbell stated: 'Taking all the circumstances into account I find, as a matter of probability, the complainant's actions on the day and his behaviour on the day to be aggressive, uncontrolled and unacceptable.'
She added that, on balance, the company's version of events was 'more convincing than that of the complainant' and there were 'substantial grounds' justifying Mr Behan's dismissal.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
16 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Waterford landlord and son who blackmailed and intimidated woman have sentences suspended
A Waterford landlord and his son have had their sentences suspended for blackmailing and intimidation of a former tenant in their appeal case. John Guiry (50) and his son John Frampton (28), of Ballygarron, Kilmeaden, received prison sentences for intimidation and coercion last March. Guiry received a four-month sentence for coercion. Frampton received an eight-month sentence for making an unwarranted demand, with menaces, of the woman to immediately vacate her family home. The woman claimed Guiry said he wanted her out by May 5th, 2024, or he would be 'sending people' to the property. READ MORE On May 2nd, 2024, five hooded men approached her at the property. One man, understood to be Frampton, threatened to kill her if she didn't leave. The encounter left the woman and her teenage daughter 'terrified', the court heard. On July 23rd, State Solicitor Frank Hutchinson outlined the facts of the case in court in Waterford before Judge Sarah Berkeley. The court heard that May 2nd, 2024, a woman living in a rented property in Larchville reported to the Garda that a gang of five men had arrived to her home, dressed all in black with their hoods up and tied. Three men stood at the wall of the front garden while another man approached the woman and made threats to kill her and 'everyone in the house' if she didn't leave the property. He told her: 'You've had plenty of notice to get the f**k out of here. I'll be back and kill you and everyone in the house.' The women pointed to the packed boxes in the house and said she was 'getting ready to go'. The hooded man said : 'You better go or I will be back.' The woman's teenage daughter was inside the house at the time of the encounter and witnessed the threats. She took a photo of the men and the vehicle they used. The vehicle was later identified as belonging to Frampton. The woman and daughter recognised the man making the threats as their landlord's son, based on his appearance. The victim told gardaí that she had been in a dispute with her landlord Guiry over moving out of the property and had gone through proceedings with the Residential Tenancies Board (RTB). The RTB said the termination notice as invalid and ordered the woman to be paid €4,500 in damages. Mairead Deevy BL represented father and son in their appeal. Ms Deevy said that the accused offered their apologies to the victim and her family and 'had written letters to that effect'. Guiry told gardaí he was running on the Waterford Greenway at the time of the incident. Defence counsel told the court the tenant had been renting the property since 2013. In 2023, Guiry spoke to her about moving out of the property because his own daughter 'fell pregnant' and needed a place to live. Ms Deevy said: 'The tenant, quite correctly, didn't want to go as rent was €750.' Over the following months, the woman tried to find other accommodation but failed to secure a new home. The termination notice issued by Guiry was deemed invalid by the RTB. Ms Deevy said that meant Guiry would have to 'start the process all over again'. 'Rather than go through the legal means, they took the law into their own hands.' The defence presented photos taken of the house in the aftermath in the event, which purportedly showed the property as being left in a 'poor state' after the incident. Judge Berkeley was also provided character references for the defendants. Ms Deevy later said: 'I can only say it was a moment of madness.' Judge Berkeley said: 'Yes the house was left in a fairly bad state but there was no excuse for what happened.' The judge suspended both sentences for 12 months and ordered them to pay €4,500 to the victim. 'I think at this stage they've learned not to take the law into their own hands,' the judge said.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Garda convicted of assaulting teenage boy in Temple Bar
A garda has been convicted of assaulting a teenager in Temple Bar , Dublin four years ago. Lorcan Murphy (32), of Pearse Street Garda station, pleaded not guilty to two counts of assault causing harm under section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act, 1997. The assaults on the then 17-year-old took place on Essex Street, Dublin 2 and at Pearse Street Garda station on June 1st, 2021. After four hours and 20 minutes of deliberation following a trial at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court , the jury returned unanimous verdicts of guilty on both counts. READ MORE There was complete silence in the court after the jury delivered its verdict. Judge Pauline Codd thanked the jurors for their service. She adjourned the matter for sentencing until November 3rd, in order to prepare a probation report and a victim impact statement. She remanded Murphy on continuing bail.
Irish Times
9 hours ago
- Irish Times
Prison officer allegedly used riot shield to repeatedly strike inmate in van
There has been an increase in allegations of abuse of inmates by prison staff, including an incident which left a prisoner with 'significant disabilities', a European committee has found. The findings are contained in a report by the Council of Europe's Committee for the Prevention of Torture (CPT) which conducted a broad-ranging inspection of Irish places of detention, the first since 2019. Physical safety of those in male prisons 'has deteriorated sharply', the CPT said. It said there has been an increase in allegations of prisoner abuse by staff since 2019, particularly in Cloverhill and Limerick prisons. 'Incidents included slaps, punches, kicks and other violence in places without CCTV coverage, such as escort vans and reception areas,' it said. READ MORE The report described severe overcrowding in some prisons, with some inmates having a living area of just 2.8sq m. 'Meanwhile, inter-prisoner violence remains widespread, with drug-related conflict and contraband smuggling driving much of the violence,' it said. One alleged incident, which occurred in 2023, was captured on a CCTV camera secretly installed in a prison van without the knowledge of prison escort officers. The CPT said the footage captured a prison officer allegedly using a riot shield to repeatedly strike an inmate. CCTV shows the prisoner being carried out of the van 'bleeding significantly from large open wounds on his head', the CPT said. [ Irish prisons at risk of 'tragic event' if overcrowding not fixed, warn prison officers Opens in new window ] The prisoner suffered a bleed on the brain and spent several weeks in hospital. Prison records show he suffered from significant disabilities 'commensurate with a head and brain injury including memory loss.' An inquiry was later opened and a criminal investigation launched. It is understood that the officer remains suspended. The CPT called the incident 'deeply troubling'. Other incidents of prisoner abuse by staff noted by the CPT include an officer allegedly 'meting out severe physical abuse' to an inmate by putting a foot on his neck to choke him. In another alleged attack, prisoner officers kicked and punched a prisoner as he lay on the ground before one officer pulled him by the hair and tried to strangle him. The prisoner also alleged that the officers sexually assaulted him, the CPT said. The CPT said the investigation was pending at the time of their visit but that the evidence it reviewed appeared to show unnecessary force was used. 'CCTV coverage shows that a prison officer jumps on the head of the prisoner ... pulling his head down and puts the prisoner on the floor.' [ Prison service embarks on €400m building project to ease overcrowding Opens in new window ] In a lengthy document outlining its response to the CPT findings, the Irish Government undertook to update the committee on the investigation into the alleged riot shield incident and outlined measures the Irish Prison Service (IPS) has taken to improve staff monitoring and whistleblower protection. The IPS also said it would publish a notice reminding staff of the rules around the use of force and that it would improve recording of such incidents.
