Roberts-Smith's last throw of the dice
Ben Roberts-Smith has turned to Australia's highest court in a last-ditch effort to sue Nine Newspapers over war crime allegations.
Roberts-Smith claims the Federal Court bolstered its murder conclusions on the assumption that because he didn't challenge evidence, he accepted it as fact.
Roberts-Smith filed an application for special leave with the High Court of Australia on Wednesday, just a month after he failed to overturn his loss to Nine Newspapers over war crimes allegations made in a series of stories.
Federal Court Justice Anthony Besanko in June 2023 dismissed Roberts-Smith's multimillion-dollar lawsuit against The Sydney Morning Herald, The Age and Canberra Times in a landmark judgment.
Justice Besanko found that Roberts-Smith was involved in the murder of four unarmed men during his deployment in Afghanistan.
The findings were made on the balance of probabilities, which is less than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt.
His appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court was dismissed by Justices Nye Perram, Anna Katzmann and Geoffrey Kennett in May
The court found that while Justice Besanko made two errors in his judgment, they were described as 'immaterial'. Ben Roberts-Smith was found, on the balance of probabilities, to be involved in the murder of four unarmed men during his deployment in Afghanistan. NewsWire / Max Mason-Hubers Credit: News Corp Australia
Roberts-Smith's latest bid to overturn his defamation loss hinges on two grounds, including claims the Federal Court made an error by assuming he accepted facts because he didn't contest evidence.
'The Full Court erred by treating the appellant as affirmatively accepting facts that were not recontested, and using that assumed acceptance to bolster its murder conclusions, thus misconceiving the effect of unchallenged findings on appeal,' the special leave application stated.
The other ground argued the Federal Court preferred 'delayed, contradictory and memory-impaired' eyewitness accounts over Australian Defence Force (ADF) operational records.
This was in relation to Roberts-Smith's involvement in the murder of two prisoners at a compound called Whiskey 108 in 2009, the murder of a handcuffed shepherd Ali Jan at Darwan in 2012, and Roberts-Smith directing members of the Afghan partner forces to shoot a man following the discovery of a cache of weapons during an operation at Chinartu.
The application argues the findings of war crimes couldn't be reached to the requisite standard under the Evidence Act as they relied on 'inconsistent and memory-impaired recollections' from more than a decade after the events and despite 'exculpatory' ADF operational records. Roberts-Smith was Australia's most decorated soldier. NewsWire / Max Mason-Hubers Credit: News Corp Australia He has applied for special leave to appeal in the High Court. NewsWire / Max Mason-Hubers Credit: News Corp Australia
ADF records document 'lawful engagements and no executions' and would-be engagements 'consistent with the laws of armed conflict', Roberts-Smith claims.
Further, the application claims the records were discounted on 'speculative or flawed grounds', including by treating them as 'no more than repetitions of the applicant's account' or rejecting them on 'asserted inconsistencies that arose only at trial and were not evident at the time of reporting' in the cases of Darwan and Chinartu.
Finally, it argued that the findings were reached without the 'criminal-trial safeguards of a jury, prosecutorial disclosure and proof beyond reasonable doubt', and the Evidence Act had been misapplied in regard to the satisfaction of 'facts tantamount to criminal guilt'.
Roberts-Smith continues to deny the allegations, last month releasing a statement that said: 'Sunlight is said to be the best disinfectant, and I believe one day soon the truth will prevail.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
9 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Bombing kills 13 Pakistani soldiers near Afghan border
An explosive-laden car has rammed into a Pakistani military convoy in a town near the Afghan border, killing at least 13 soldiers, sources said. Four Pakistani intelligence officials and a senior local administrator told Reuters that the convoy was attacked on Saturday in Mir Ali area of North Waziristan district. Around 10 other soldiers were wounded, some critically, and they were being flown to a military hospital, the sources said. The office of the chief minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province said it was a suicide bombing, adding it killed eight security officials. Chief Minister Ali Amin Gandapur condemned the bombing and offered condolences to the soldiers' families. "It was huge, a big bang," the local administrator told Reuters, adding that residents of the town could see a large amount of smoke billowing from the scene from a great distance. One resident said that the explosion rattled the windowpanes of nearby houses, and caused some roofs to collapse. No one has so far claimed responsibility. The Pakistani military did not respond to a Reuters request for a comment. The lawless district that sits next to Afghanistan has long served as a safe haven for different Islamist militant groups, who operate on both sides of the border. Islamabad says the militants run training camps in Afghanistan to launch attacks inside Pakistan, a charge Kabul denies, saying the militancy is Pakistan's domestic issue. Pakistani Taliban also known as Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, an umbrella group of several Islamist militant groups, has long been waging a war against Pakistan in a bid to overthrow the government and replace it with its own Islamic system of governance. The Pakistani military, which has launched several offensives against the militants, has mostly been their prime target. An explosive-laden car has rammed into a Pakistani military convoy in a town near the Afghan border, killing at least 13 soldiers, sources said. Four Pakistani intelligence officials and a senior local administrator told Reuters that the convoy was attacked on Saturday in Mir Ali area of North Waziristan district. Around 10 other soldiers were wounded, some critically, and they were being flown to a military hospital, the sources said. The office of the chief minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province said it was a suicide bombing, adding it killed eight security officials. Chief Minister Ali Amin Gandapur condemned the bombing and offered condolences to the soldiers' families. "It was huge, a big bang," the local administrator told Reuters, adding that residents of the town could see a large amount of smoke billowing from the scene from a great distance. One resident said that the explosion rattled the windowpanes of nearby houses, and caused some roofs to collapse. No one has so far claimed responsibility. The Pakistani military did not respond to a Reuters request for a comment. The lawless district that sits next to Afghanistan has long served as a safe haven for different Islamist militant groups, who operate on both sides of the border. Islamabad says the militants run training camps in Afghanistan to launch attacks inside Pakistan, a charge Kabul denies, saying the militancy is Pakistan's domestic issue. Pakistani Taliban also known as Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, an umbrella group of several Islamist militant groups, has long been waging a war against Pakistan in a bid to overthrow the government and replace it with its own Islamic system of governance. The Pakistani military, which has launched several offensives against the militants, has mostly been their prime target. An explosive-laden car has rammed into a Pakistani military convoy in a town near the Afghan border, killing at least 13 soldiers, sources said. Four Pakistani intelligence officials and a senior local administrator told Reuters that the convoy was attacked on Saturday in Mir Ali area of North Waziristan district. Around 10 other soldiers were wounded, some critically, and they were being flown to a military hospital, the sources said. The office of the chief minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province said it was a suicide bombing, adding it killed eight security officials. Chief Minister Ali Amin Gandapur condemned the bombing and offered condolences to the soldiers' families. "It was huge, a big bang," the local administrator told Reuters, adding that residents of the town could see a large amount of smoke billowing from the scene from a great distance. One resident said that the explosion rattled the windowpanes of nearby houses, and caused some roofs to collapse. No one has so far claimed responsibility. The Pakistani military did not respond to a Reuters request for a comment. The lawless district that sits next to Afghanistan has long served as a safe haven for different Islamist militant groups, who operate on both sides of the border. Islamabad says the militants run training camps in Afghanistan to launch attacks inside Pakistan, a charge Kabul denies, saying the militancy is Pakistan's domestic issue. Pakistani Taliban also known as Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, an umbrella group of several Islamist militant groups, has long been waging a war against Pakistan in a bid to overthrow the government and replace it with its own Islamic system of governance. The Pakistani military, which has launched several offensives against the militants, has mostly been their prime target. An explosive-laden car has rammed into a Pakistani military convoy in a town near the Afghan border, killing at least 13 soldiers, sources said. Four Pakistani intelligence officials and a senior local administrator told Reuters that the convoy was attacked on Saturday in Mir Ali area of North Waziristan district. Around 10 other soldiers were wounded, some critically, and they were being flown to a military hospital, the sources said. The office of the chief minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province said it was a suicide bombing, adding it killed eight security officials. Chief Minister Ali Amin Gandapur condemned the bombing and offered condolences to the soldiers' families. "It was huge, a big bang," the local administrator told Reuters, adding that residents of the town could see a large amount of smoke billowing from the scene from a great distance. One resident said that the explosion rattled the windowpanes of nearby houses, and caused some roofs to collapse. No one has so far claimed responsibility. The Pakistani military did not respond to a Reuters request for a comment. The lawless district that sits next to Afghanistan has long served as a safe haven for different Islamist militant groups, who operate on both sides of the border. Islamabad says the militants run training camps in Afghanistan to launch attacks inside Pakistan, a charge Kabul denies, saying the militancy is Pakistan's domestic issue. Pakistani Taliban also known as Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, an umbrella group of several Islamist militant groups, has long been waging a war against Pakistan in a bid to overthrow the government and replace it with its own Islamic system of governance. The Pakistani military, which has launched several offensives against the militants, has mostly been their prime target.
Perth Now
11 hours ago
- Perth Now
Bombing kills 13 Pakistani soldiers near Afghan border
An explosive-laden car has rammed into a Pakistani military convoy in a town near the Afghan border, killing at least 13 soldiers, sources said. Four Pakistani intelligence officials and a senior local administrator told Reuters that the convoy was attacked on Saturday in Mir Ali area of North Waziristan district. Around 10 other soldiers were wounded, some critically, and they were being flown to a military hospital, the sources said. The office of the chief minister of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province said it was a suicide bombing, adding it killed eight security officials. Chief Minister Ali Amin Gandapur condemned the bombing and offered condolences to the soldiers' families. "It was huge, a big bang," the local administrator told Reuters, adding that residents of the town could see a large amount of smoke billowing from the scene from a great distance. One resident said that the explosion rattled the windowpanes of nearby houses, and caused some roofs to collapse. No one has so far claimed responsibility. The Pakistani military did not respond to a Reuters request for a comment. The lawless district that sits next to Afghanistan has long served as a safe haven for different Islamist militant groups, who operate on both sides of the border. Islamabad says the militants run training camps in Afghanistan to launch attacks inside Pakistan, a charge Kabul denies, saying the militancy is Pakistan's domestic issue. Pakistani Taliban also known as Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan, an umbrella group of several Islamist militant groups, has long been waging a war against Pakistan in a bid to overthrow the government and replace it with its own Islamic system of governance. The Pakistani military, which has launched several offensives against the militants, has mostly been their prime target.
Perth Now
21 hours ago
- Perth Now
‘Un-Australian': GST change set to cost $60bn
The 'worst policy change in the 21st' century is set to blow out the national budget by $60bn and keep one state in the black for years to come. The goods and services tax (GST) carve up was back in focus this week as state treasurers came out with their budgets. Queensland, NSW, Western Australia, and the ACT all delivered budgets, with one state standing above them all. Mining-rich WA is in the black, with costs tipped to come in at $2.5bn less than predicted spending. The rest, budget deficits. Western Australia has cashed in on changing GST rules. NewsWire / Nicholas Eagar Credit: NewsWire WA Treasurer Rita Saffioti used her speech to focus on the relative strength of the economy compared with other states while warning of an uncertain global outlook. 'This budget is about fortifying WA amid global shocks,' she said. Independent economist Saul Eslake argues that WA has achieved a surplus for the last seven years on the back of soaring GST revenue. 'Between 2016 and 2025, Western Australia essentially had the country by the shorts and they squeezed as hard as they could,' Mr Eslake told NewsWire. 'I call it the worst public policy decision of the 21st century.' So what changed for the WA government to achieve seven years of surplus. WHY IS WA THE LUCKY STATE? Much of WA's success comes back to two changes. The first was a change to the GST in 2018, with Mr Eslake arguing that the then Liberal federal government wanted to appease WA where it held an overwhelming majority of federal seats. Then treasurer Scott Morrison announced a review of Australia's horizontal fiscal equalisation (HFE) system, which determines the distribution of goods and services tax (GST) revenue among states and territories. Then treasurer Scott Morrison enacted the GST reforms. NewsWire / Martin Ollman Credit: News Corp Australia After a Productivity Commission inquiry, the system changed so that all states and territories received 70c for every dollar of GST raised in 2022-23. That figure increased to 75c a dollar in the new agreement, WA's GST share was 30 cents in the dollar. High iron ore prices at the time could have meant WA got just 15.6 cents of every dollar of GST raised. 'So what Morrison did was commission the Productivity Commission to do an inquiry into horizontal fiscal equalisation,' Mr Eslake said. 'The terms of reference for that were written in Mathias Cormann's office. It was a classic example of (fictional TV character) Sir Humphrey Appleby's advice that you never call an inquiry unless you know what it's going to say.' HFE's aim is to ensure that every state and territory should have an equal opportunity to provide public services. The key word is should, as states and territories are free to raise additional revenues how they please as well as fund their own state-based services. 'That principle is they are equalising the fiscal capacity of the states and territories,' Mr Eslake continued. 'And the point of that, it matters far less where you live when it comes to the quality of schooling your kids get, the quality of healthcare that you and your family get, the quality of policy or environment you get.' The price of iron ore stayed high. Rebecca Le May Credit: NCA NewsWire Mr Eslake used the example of the US, which does not have HFE, meaning different states have varying life outcomes. 'If we didn't have it, then Victorians and NSW people would have much better public services and pay lower taxes, all else being equal, than Tasmanians or South Australians,' Mr Eslake said. 'And I would argue, and traditionally most Australians have accepted, that's something that makes Australia a better and fairer place than America in particular.' The second major change for WA was the rise of China, or as Paul Keating famously said, the state got 'kissed on the a*se by a big Chinese rainbow'. This kissing, Mr Eslake argues, turned WA from being propped up into a donor state. '(In the early 2000s) WA got a bigger share of whatever federal grants were going around than they would have got if it was distributed equal per capita,' he said. 'Because the (Commonwealth) Grants Commission recognised that when gold was fixed at $35 an ounce, and iron ore was only trading at $20 a tonne and they weren't selling much of it, they couldn't raise much money for mineral oil fees, but they had a relatively high cost of providing services.' NSW used its budget to call out WA's share of GST. NewsWire/ Gaye Gerard Credit: News Corp Australia BUDGET BOTTOM LINE To get other states to support these changes, a no one is worse off provision was added, with the federal government topping up any shortfalls in GST revenues. This policy was also extended until 2029-2030 under the Albanese government. This NOWO provision turns a $9bn budget blow into a $60bn black hole. 'This is the biggest blowout in the cost of any single policy decision ever with the possible exception of the NDIS, which as (economist) Chris Richardson says is at least set up for a noble purpose,' Mr Eslake said. 'It's what is allowing Western Australia to run a budget surplus while everyone else, including the feds, are running a deficit. 'In the longer run, what it will mean is residents of Australia's richest state, WA, will have better public services and lower taxes than people who live in the eastern states, which I say is un-Australian.'
