Israeli 'humanitarian city' plan triggers backlash
Defence Minister Israel Katz first unveiled the plan during a briefing with reporters last Monday. It envisions building from scratch a closed zone in southern Gaza during a potential 60-day ceasefire in Israel's war with Hamas, currently under negotiation in Qatar.
According to Katz, the area would initially house around 600,000 displaced people from southern Gaza and include four aid distribution sites managed by international organisations.
The entire civilian population of Gaza — more than two million people — would eventually be relocated there.
Critics, however, have questioned both the feasibility and ethics of the plan, with Israel's opposition leader citing its astronomical cost, and one expert pointing to lack of infrastructure in the area necessary to accommodate so many people.
The United Nations agency for Palestinian refugees has described the proposed facility as a "concentration camp", while Britain's minister for the Middle East and North Africa has said he is "appalled" by the idea.
"Palestinian territory must not be reduced," said Hamish Falconer on X. "Civilians must be able to return to their communities."
Nearly 21 months of war have devastated much of the Gaza Strip, displacing most of its population, creating dire shortages of food and other essentials, and killing 58,026 people, most of them civilians.
The Oct 7, 2023 Hamas attack on Israel that sparked the war led to 1,219 deaths, also mostly civilians, according to an AFP tally based on official figures
New arrivals to the proposed facility would undergo security screening to ensure they are not affiliated with Hamas, and once admitted, they would not be permitted to leave.
Israeli military would provide security "from a distance", Katz has said.
The criticism of the plan reportedly extends even to Israel's own security establishment.
Army chief Eyal Zamir lambasted the proposal at a cabinet meeting, arguing it would divert focus from the military's core objectives: defeating Hamas and securing the return of hostages taken on Oct 7.
The broadcaster Channel 12 reported that unnamed security officials viewed the plan as little more than a "gigantic tent city", and warned it could pave the way for a return to Israeli military rule in Gaza.
Such a move aligns with the long-standing goals of far-right Israeli ministers Bezalel Smotrich and Itamar Ben Gvir, key coalition partners of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Both Smotrich and Ben Gvir advocate the re-establishment of Jewish settlements in Gaza.
The projected expense of the initiative — estimated between 10 and 20 billion shekels — has further fuelled domestic outrage as the cost of nearly two years of war mounts.
"Netanyahu is letting Smotrich and Ben Gvir run wild with extremist delusions just to preserve his coalition. Instead of plundering the middle class's money, end the war and bring back the hostages," said opposition leader Yair Lapid on X on Sunday.
The Palestinian Authority was scathing in appraisal of the proposed facility, with its foreign ministry saying: "The humanitarian city has nothing to do with humanity."
That view was echoed by UNRWA, the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, which said the "plan would de-facto create massive concentration camps at the border with Egypt".
A Palestinian official with knowledge of the ongoing ceasefire talks in Qatar said Hamas rejected plans to concentrate Palestinians in a small part of the south, viewing it as "preparation for forcibly displacing them to Egypt or other countries".
Amnesty International, which has accused Israel of genocide, warned that relocating Gazans within the territory or "deporting them outside against their will would amount to the war crime of unlawful transfer".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
2 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Mandela's enduring legacy: Vision, empathy and service
ONE day, a man was having lunch with his aide and invited another person eating at a table nearby to join theirs. The latter nervously obliged. Without ever raising his eyes, the invitee hurriedly ate and left, to which the aide commented that the man must be sick. The host corrected the aide, saying the man was his jailer who used to urinate on the host's head each time he asked for water after being tortured in prison. The jailer had expected the host to retaliate. But the host, who had now become the head of state, chose not to. That host was Nelson Mandela. Although apocryphal, the story epitomises the spirit of forgiveness and reconciliation that Mandela displayed as the first black president of South Africa, who ended the evil of apartheid and paved the way for his country's peaceful transition to democracy. As we celebrate Mandela's birthday on July 18, a day the United Nations has declared Nelson Mandela International Day, it is well to reflect on who he was and what he stood for. Those who aspire to lead with courage, compassion, and integrity can learn three key lessons from one of the most influential figures of recent times. First, as with all visionary leaders who built their successful careers on an unwavering pursuit of their vision, Mandela was driven by his vision of a racism-free and equal South Africa. He courageously pursued his vision throughout his early activism in the armed wing of the African National Congress, or ANC. That earned him a life sentence in 1964, only to be freed after 27 years once apartheid became untenable. His vision inspired others to stay the course. It resulted in the first multiracial elections in 1994. With the win for the ANC, Mandela became the first black president. As he writes in his autobiography, The Long Walk to Freedom: "It always seems impossible until it is done", reminding us that challenges may appear intractable, but dedication to one's cause can lead to success. Second, he pursued his vision with high emotional intelligence — the capacity to understand the viewpoints of others, and an ability to communicate and resolve conflicts. He showed that effective leadership need not be offensive or aggressive. As he says, "If you want cooperation from humans around you, you must make them feel important." His cool, composed and humble demeanour inspired millions to rally to his cause of peace and reconciliation in a divided society. In walking his talk, Mandela shaped his nation's future. He focused on finding peaceful solutions with the apartheid government despite a widespread threat of civil war. Upon becoming the president, rather than assuming complete control, he invited other political parties, including old rivals, to join his unity government. By cooperating with his opponents, Mandela succeeded in reducing racial tensions. As he says: "Lead from the back — and let others believe they are in the front." And that brings us to the third lesson. Mandela's controversial decisions that advanced national peace over individual or party success are a classic illustration of servant leadership. As he writes: "Real leaders must be ready to sacrifice all for the freedom of their people." During the 1995 Rugby World Cup, Mandela showed one of his most memorable leadership moments. The Springboks, the national rugby team, have long signified white supremacy. As such, the team was scorned by many black South Africans. Mandela, however, saw a chance for harmony. Not only did he openly back the team, but he even showed up for the final game wearing their jersey. Mandela believed that service to others is what life is all about. As he says: "What counts in life is not the mere fact that we have lived. It is what difference we have made to the lives of others that will determine the significance of the life we lead." In this, he echoes Albert Einstein's call for a life of significance. Mandela's legacy reminds us that when leaders act courageously with purpose and are guided by values, change is possible.
Malay Mail
2 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Air raid sirens bring Taipei to a standstill in civilian drill simulating Chinese attack
TAIPEI, July 17 — Taipei's normally busy streets will come to a brief standstill today when air raid sirens send thousands of people into underground shelters in a rehearsal for a Chinese attack. The annual civilian drill is being held in cities across Taiwan this week, alongside military training, to prepare the self-governed island for a potential Chinese invasion. While Communist China has never ruled Taiwan, Beijing insists the island is part of its territory and has threatened to use force to bring it under its control. At 1:30 pm sirens will be heard across Taipei, bringing the capital city of 2.5 million people to a halt for half an hour. Traffic will be required to stop and people will be directed into shelters, including underground car parks and subway stations. The drills will also involve simulating war-time aid distribution and a mass-casualty event. Since taking office last year, Taiwanese President Lai Ching-te has sought to raise public awareness of the threat posed by China. Of the drills, 25-year-old Oscar Wang said: 'I think this is necessary because tensions across the strait are so high right now.' 'So it's important to let us ordinary people become more familiar with evacuation routes,' he told AFP. 'Reality of modern warfare' Taiwan is also keen to show the world, especially its key security backer Washington, that it is serious about boosting its defence capability. Taiwanese regular troops were joined by the largest-ever mobilisation of reservists for the 10-day 'Han Kuang' military drills, which end Friday. Rather than only repelling a Chinese attack on its shores, Taiwanese troops this year have also practised fighting invading forces in city streets. 'It is as much training as acclimating the Taiwanese population to the reality of modern warfare,' said Kitsch Liao of the Atlantic Council, a US think tank. Heavily armed troops carrying US-provided anti-aircraft Stinger missiles stormed Taipei's metro system in a night-time exercise. High-tech mobile missile launchers from the United States also have been positioned around the capital and elsewhere, in full view of the public. And shoppers in a Taipei supermarket recently became participants in a drill simulating a Chinese missile strike on the city. 'I didn't know there was going to be a drill,' Yang Shu-ting, 70, told AFP. 'My heart was beating very fast and I was inevitably nervous. I think the point is to let you know where you should hide if something happens.' Troops have also simulated various scenarios including 'grey zone harassment'—tactics that fall short of an act of war—and 'long-range precision strikes', defence officials have said. Several minor collisions involving military vehicles during the exercises highlighted the challenge of manoeuvring through Taiwan's narrow streets. Defence expert Chieh Chung said such mishaps were 'difficult to avoid' in urban areas. 'In Taiwan, many roads and bridges create significant limitations for armoured vehicles when they move through,' said Chieh, a researcher at the Association of Strategic Foresight in Taipei. 'So this becomes a problem and obstacle for both attacking and defending forces.' — AFP
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Cambodia makes 1,000 arrests in latest crackdown on cybercrime
Suspects with their hands ziptied being detained during a raid on a scam centre in Phnom Penh on July 14. - AFP\ PHNOM PENH: Cambodia on Wednesday (July 16) said that an order by Prime Minister Hun Manet for government bodies to crackdown on criminal cybercrime operations being run in the country had resulted in the arrest of more than 1,000 suspects so far this week. Hun Manet issued the order authorising state action for "maintaining and protecting security, public order, and social safety.' "The government has observed that online scams are currently causing threats and insecurity in the world and the region. In Cambodia, foreign criminal groups have also infiltrated to engage in online scams,' Hun Manet's statement, dated Tuesday, said. The United Nations and other agencies estimate that cyberscams, most of them originating from South-East Asia, earn international criminal gangs billions of dollars annually. More than 1,000 suspects were arrested in raids in at least five provinces between Monday and Wednesday, according to statements from Information Minister Neth Pheaktra and police. Those detained included more than 200 Vietnamese, 27 Chinese, and 75 suspects from Taiwan and 85 Cambodians in the capital Phnom Penh and the southern city of Sihanoukville. Police also seized equipment, including computers and hundreds of mobile phones. At least 270 Indonesians, including 45 women, were arrested Wednesday in Poipet, a town on the border with Thailand notorious for cyberscam and gambling operations, the minister said. Elsewhere, police in the northeastern province of Kratie arrested 312 people, including nationals of Thailand, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Myanmar and Vietnam, while 27 people from Vietnam, China and Myanmar were arrested in the western province of Pursat. Amnesty International last month published the findings of an 18-month investigation into cybercrime in Cambodia, which the human rights group said "point towards state complicity in abuses carried out by Chinese criminal gangs.' "The Cambodian government is deliberately ignoring a litany of human rights abuses including slavery, human trafficking, child labour and torture being carried out by criminal gangs on a vast scale in more than 50 scamming compounds located across the country,' it said. Human trafficking is closely associated with cyberscam operations, as workers are often recruited under false pretences and then held captive. "Deceived, trafficked and enslaved, the survivors of these scamming compounds describe being trapped in a living nightmare - enlisted in criminal enterprises that are operating with the apparent consent of the Cambodian government,' Amnesty International's Secretary General Agnes Callamard said. Cambodia's latest crackdown comes in the midst of a bitter feud with neighbouring Thailand, which began with a brief armed skirmish in late May over border territory claimed by both nations and has now led to border closures and nearly daily exchanges of nationalistic insults. Friendly former leaders of both countries have become estranged and there have been hot debates over which nation's cultural heritage has influenced the other. Measures initiated by the Thai side, including cutting off cross-border electricity supplies and closing crossing points, have particularly heightened tensions, with Cambodia claiming they were churlish actions of spite to retaliate for its intention to pursue its territorial claims. Thailand said its original intention was to combat long-existing cyberscam operations in Poipet. - AP
