Why Trump can't revoke native-born U.S. citizenship
The big picture: His Saturday Truth Social post, in which he called his longtime critic a "Threat to Humanity," marked a major escalation in the way the president targets his foes.
Zoom out: Trump has made similar threats in the past, notably toward his former ally, Elon Musk.
Asked earlier this month whether he'd consider deporting Musk after their once-friendly relationship turned sour, Trump said he'd have to "take a look."
He's also baselessly questioned New York mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani's citizenship status.
Musk and Mamdani are naturalized U.S. citizens. And O'Donnell, who was born in New York, has a constitutional right to U.S. citizenship.
Catch up quick: " Because of the fact that Rosie O'Donnell is not in the best interests of our Great Country, I am giving serious consideration to taking away her Citizenship," Trump wrote, adding she "should remain in the wonderful Country of Ireland, if they want her."
O'Donnell moved to Ireland earlier this year.
Has the Trump administration denaturalized anyone?
The Trump administration, during its immigration crackdown, has sought to restrict pathways to citizenship and revoke people's status.
The Department of Justice under Trump has begun prioritizing denaturalization when naturalized citizens are charged with crimes, and the administration has moved to restrict birthright citizenship, though doing so faces several legal hurdles.
Zoom in: The Justice Department in June announced it had "secured the denaturalization" of a convicted collector and distributor of child sexual abuse material.
"If you commit serious crimes before you become a U.S. citizen and then lie about them during your naturalization process, the Justice Department will discover the truth and come after you," Assistant Attorney General Brett A. Shumate said in a statement about the case.
Yes, but: The president does not have the authority to strip a native-born U.S. citizen of their citizenship, University of Virginia School of Law professor Amanda Frost told the Associated Press.
Can Trump constitutionally revoke O'Donnell's citizenship?
The 14th Amendment guarantees citizenship to anyone born in the U.S. — though the Trump administration has sought to chip away at those rights.
It states, "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside."
Citizens can relinquish their U.S. nationality, according to the State Department, but it must be voluntary.
Naturalized citizens can have their citizenship revoked, but there are specific requirements and a process that must be followed.
How did the Supreme Court protect people from losing their citizenship?
The Supreme Court in 1967 ruled that the government can't usually strip citizenship without the person's consent.
The high court left open the door for cases that involved fraud in the citizenship process, but denaturalization became rare after the decision, law professors Irina Manta and Cassandra Burke Robertson write.
Yes, but: The number of denaturalization cases has surged in recent years, Axios' Jason Lalljee reported.
"Denaturalization is no longer so rare," said Cassandra Burke Robertson, a professor at Case Western Reserve University's law school, in 2019, noting that the rise began under the Obama administration.
She continued, "But the Trump administration, with its overall immigration crackdown, is taking denaturalization to new levels."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
28 minutes ago
- New York Post
Ex-Secret Service director fires back at Rand Paul's accusations she lied about lack of resources given to Trump's Butler rally
Former Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle was adamant that she directed 'additional assets to be provided' for President Trump's Butler, Pa., rally a year ago and refuted Sen. Rand Paul's blistering report. Paul (R-Ky.) alleged that Cheatle had not been truthful to Congress when she testified that the Secret Service didn't deny Trump's team resources it requested for the Butler, Pa. rally. 'The Director of the Secret Service is not typically directly engaged in the approval or denial of requests for support,' she said in a statement Sunday, released by her attorney. 'For the Butler rally, I actually did direct additional assets to be provided, particularly in the form of agency counter-snipers.' Advertisement 'Any assertion or implication that I provided misleading testimony is patently false and does a disservice to those men and women on the front lines who have been unfairly disciplined for a team, rather than individual, failure.' Cheatle's attorney confirmed to The Post that her statement was directed at Paul's report and his 'defamatory comments on Face the Nation' earlier in the day on Sunday. 3 Kimberly Cheatle vehemently refuted allegations that she gave misleading testimony to Congress. The Washington Post via Getty Images Advertisement 3 Sunday marks the one-year anniversary of the Butler, Pa., assassination attempt. AP Paul, chairman of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, released his scathing report on the one-year anniversary of the assassination attempt against Trump. It concluded based on documents that there were 'at least two instances of assets being denied' by the Secret Service related to the Butler rally. That entailed a request for more Counter-Unmanned Aircraft Systems (C-UAS), which are used to counter drones, which was 'unfulfilled due to the lack of manpower to support the request.' Additionally, the Secret Service did not provide a Counter Assault Team liaison to coordinate between its operation and the local team, according to testimony from the advance agent. Advertisement Paul's report found that broadly speaking, there were at least 10 major requests for more resources from the president's team during the 2024 campaign cycle that were either denied or unfulfilled. Cheatle had testified to the House Oversight Committee nine days after the assassination attempt last year that 'for the event in Butler, there were no requests that were denied.' 'She did not tell the truth,' Paul told CBS News' 'Face the Nation' on Sunday. 'The primary request that was made by both Trump's Secret Service detail, as well as his campaign, was for counter-snipers. 'Counter-snipers were denied until Butler. So, thank God, on that day in Butler County, Pennsylvania, that was the first time he was allowed counter-snipers.' Advertisement The former Secret Service director revealed that she read through some of the report, was 'aware of certain congressional criticism,' and agrees that 'mistakes were made and reform is needed.' 3 Sen. Rand Paul had ripped into former Secret Service Director Kimberly Cheatle in his report on the assassination attempt. AFP via Getty Images She stressed that her testimony to the Oversight Committee was based on 'information provided to me by personnel from Headquarters' as well as current Secret Service Director Sean Curran, who helmed Trump's detail at the time. Cheatle also paid tribute to the families impacted by the deadly shooting at the rally. 'The tragedy that occurred on July 13, 2024, remains a profound event that deeply affected our nation,' she said. 'My thoughts and heartfelt condolences continue to be with all those impacted.' Cheatle resigned as Secret Service director a day after she testified before the House Oversight Committee. Acting director Ronald Rowe briefly took her place during the months that followed. Trump appointed Curran as Secret Service director shortly after taking office again back in January. Multiple investigations from lawmakers in Congress, as well as law enforcement, have uncovered a myriad of shortcomings in the run-up to the assassination attempt. Advertisement Despite the concerns, Trump has said that he still retains 'great confidence in these people.' 'They should have had somebody in the building [Crooks shot from], that was a mistake,' he told Fox News' 'My View With Lara Trump' in an interview that aired Saturday. 'They should have had communications with the local police, they weren't tied in. 'So there were mistakes made … But I was satisfied in terms of the bigger plot, the larger plot,' he added. 'I have great confidence in these people. I know the people. And they're very talented, very capable. But they had a bad day. And I think they'll admit that. They had a rough day.'
USA Today
31 minutes ago
- USA Today
Secret Service did not 'act on direct threats' before Trump shooting, Senate report says
WASHINGTON — Stunning failures and inexcusable negligence by the Secret Service allowed then-Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump to be shot at during a Pennsylvania rally last year, according to a scathing Senate committee report released on the anniversary of the assassination attempt. The Secret Service did not act on credible intelligence and failed to appropriately communicate with local law enforcement and Trump's protective detail ahead of the July 13, 2024, event in Butler, Pennsylvania, the report released by Homeland Security Committee Chairman Rand Paul said. "This was not a single lapse in judgment. It was a complete breakdown of security at every level—fueled by bureaucratic indifference, a lack of clear protocols, and a shocking refusal to act on direct threats," Paul, a Republican U.S. senator who represents Kentucky, said. "We must hold individuals accountable and ensure reforms are fully implemented so this never happens again.' The report details threats against Trump and errors that the committee said resulted in the near assassination of a major party's presidential candidate, the death of rallygoer Corey Comperatore, and injuries to two other attendees. The committee assessed that the failures culminated in a "preventable tragedy," for which the agency has been insufficiently held accountable. Sen. Paul on Trump shooting: 'It was a cultural cover-up for the agency' Secret Service director Kimberly Cheatle resigned, and six individuals received disciplinary action in the wake of the shooting that injured two additional attendees, the report said. But no one was fired, and the penalties were weaker than what the committee said it would have recommended. "Some of these people could be in charge of security for another presidential candidate. And really, that's a danger. That's not right," Paul said on the CBS show "Face the Nation." In the appearance, Paul said Cheatle "did not tell the truth" when she told Congress that no assets that were requested for the Butler rally were denied. He also said that counter-snipers were denied until the Butler rally. The report said that at least 10 requests by the division protecting Trump were denied or left unfulfilled during the presidential campaign. "I think it was a cultural cover-up for the agency. They did not want to assess blame. They did not want to look internally. And they wanted to discount any of their actions that might have led to this," Paul said on the CBS program. 'Saved for a reason': How Trump's second term is full of assassination attempt reminders Secret Service director: Agency 'implemented substantive reforms' after shooting In response to the report, Secret Service Director Sean Curran said in a statement provided to USA TODAY that the agency would continue to cooperate with the committee. "Following the events of July 13, the Secret Service took a serious look at our operations and implemented substantive reforms to address the failures that occurred that day," Curran said. The agency last week acknowledged "breakdowns in communication, technological issues, and human failure, among other contributing factors, led to the events of July 13." The attack was "nothing short of a tragedy" and "represents an operational failure," the Secret Service said. Since then, the agency said it has revised and streamlined its practices and requested additional resources to address recommendations made by Congress.
Yahoo
37 minutes ago
- Yahoo
'What did the president know—and when did he know it?' the former CNN host said on MSNBC Sunday.
Former CNN White House Correspondent Jim Acosta says President Donald Trump is shaking in his boots amid fallout over the infamous 'Epstein files.' 'You know, I've been around Donald Trump. I've been up close with him. I think I know when he's worried, and he is freaking out right now over these Epstein files,' Acosta said on MSNBC Sunday. 'He's twisted himself into a pretzel on this.' Acosta's comments follow after news broke late last week that the Department of Justice (DOJ) and Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) have determined that, contrary to the long-cherished beliefs of MAGA conspiracy theorists, disgraced financial Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide while awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges in 2019, rather than being murdered, and kept no 'client list' of superwealthy co-conspirators.
