Islanders choose Erie defenseman Schaefer with No. 1 pick in NHL draft
LOS ANGELES — The New York Islanders selected defenseman Matthew Schaefer with the No. 1 pick in the NHL draft Friday night.
High-scoring forward Michael Misa went second overall to the San Jose Sharks, and the Chicago Blackhawks took Swedish forward Anton Frondell third at the Peacock Theater in downtown Los Angeles.
The Philadelphia Flyers grabbed forward Porter Martone sixth overall before trading up for the 12th selection to get forward Jack Nesbitt, while the Pittsburgh Penguins maneuvered up and down the draft to control three picks in the top 24, swinging two trades to draft three forwards.
But the Islanders surprised nobody by using their first No. 1 selection since 2009 on the 17-year-old Schaefer, a 6-foot-2 blueliner from Hamilton, Ontario, who spent the past two seasons with the Ontario Hockey League's Erie Otters.
An exceptional puck-mover and transitional force, Schaefer scored 22 points while playing in only 17 games last season before breaking his collarbone in December. Schaefer's acumen on both ends of the ice still propelled him to the top of nearly all draft boards.
Schaefer is just the fifth defenseman picked No. 1 overall in the NHL draft since 2000, and the first since Owen Power went to Buffalo in 2021.
Schaefer persevered through tragedy to reach this milestone. Schaefer's mother, Jennifer, died of cancer 16 months ago, and he also endured the recent deaths of the Otters' owner, Jim Waters, and the mother of his billet family.
When Schaefer pulled on his Islanders sweater for the first time on the stage, he kissed a pink ribbon patch on the chest representing breast cancer awareness before breaking into tears.
'I appreciate you taking a chance on me,' Schaefer said in a video conference call with the Islanders' front office. 'I promise I won't disappoint, but especially I just want to say to my mom and all my family and friends, thanks for everything.'
The Islanders added the patch specifically for Schaefer, along with his mother's initials.
'Seeing the ribbon on my jersey, and I saw a picture, it has J.S. on my back here,' Schaefer said. 'You can see just how high-class the organization is. It really means a lot. I wish my mom could be here today. Obviously, she's with me here in spirit. ... Cancer sucks, and it's not fun. She didn't feel the best, but she was always the happiest in the family. She would do anything for us.'
Center Caleb Desnoyers went fourth to the Utah Mammoth, who moved up 10 spots in the draft lottery.
The Nashville Predators chose physical forward Brady Martin with the fifth pick before trading up for the 21st selection to get Kitchener defenseman Cameron Reid.
The fans of the host Los Angeles Kings inside the theater got fired up for their club to make the 24th selection — which the Kings promptly traded to Pittsburgh for the 31st and 59th selections, prompting groans from the crowd.
The Penguins created the majority of the surprises in the first round, first by choosing Calgary Hitmen center Benjamin Kindel with the 11th pick — much higher than many prognosticators expected.
Pittsburgh then traded the 12th pick, which originally belonged to the New York Rangers, to Philadelphia for the 22nd and 31st picks. The Flyers wanted the 6-foot-4 Nesbitt, a fast-rising center from the OHL's Windsor Spitfires last season.
The Penguins also gave a second-round pick to the Kings and swapped first-rounders so they could move up for Michigan center William Horcoff with the 24th pick.
The Anaheim Ducks took a chance on forward Roger McQueen with the 10th selection. The 6-foot-5 McQueen is widely thought to have enough talent to become an elite center, but the Saskatchewan native has been slowed by a back injury that scared off some teams.
Columbus chose the first goalie of the draft, grabbing Russia's Pyotr Andreyanov with the 20th pick.
Misa tore up the OHL last season as the captain of the Saginaw Spirit, scoring 62 goals and 134 points in just 65 games. He joins a struggling Sharks organization that chose Will Smith fourth overall in 2023 and got center Macklin Celebrini with the first overall pick a year ago.
'We just thought it was a perfect fit with what we already have here,' Sharks general manager Mike Grier said. 'Another guy to step in and be a nightmare matchup for people.'
Frondell excelled as a 17-year-old forward last season with Djurgården in Sweden's second division, showing off a two-way game that allowed him to push Misa on some draft boards. At 6-2, he could provide a large complement to Connor Bedard.
Frondell is the eighth Swedish player to be a top-three selection, joining elite company including Victor Hedman, Mats Sundin and the Sedin twins.
Martin skipped the draft, instead staying home on his family farm in Ontario.
The Boston Bruins used the seventh overall pick on Boston College center James Hagens, the consensus top prospect for this draft a year ago.
Hagens, a Long Island native coveted by many Islanders fans, slid down the board just enough to reach the Bruins, whose pick was announced by a video of Adam Sandler in character as Happy Gilmore, complete with his signature Bruins jersey.
'I'm so excited to be back in Boston, and to have Adam Sandler make the pick, that was special,' said Hagens, who cites 'Happy Gilmore' as his favorite movie. 'I love to win, and I'm really glad that I'm in Boston.'
The Seattle Kraken chose playmaking forward Jake O'Brien eighth overall.
The Islanders won the lottery to pick first in a draft that is packed with talent — while missing a few staples of recent drafts. There was no prohibitive lock of a No. 1 pick in this field, unlike the past two drafts — although Schaefer clearly came out on top for most executives.
The draft also lacked the centralized structure that has long been a staple of this annual exercise. The 32 teams' various executives are mostly at home, not strewn across the draft floor. The majority of the picks were taken to a video room just behind the stage to exchange televised pleasantries with their new front offices through video conferencing.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
NHL Draft 2025 live updates: Round 2-7 start time, latest mock draft, predictions and news
Greetings, hockey fans! Welcome to The Athletic 's live coverage of the 2025 NHL Draft's second through seventh rounds. The final day of the NHL Draft represents the welcoming of a new generation of hockey players. It's a lifelong dream achieved for these young athletes and their families. You've come to the right place for all the sights, sounds, news and analysis. Follow along as we build up to the second day of the 2025 NHL Draft.
New York Times
an hour ago
- New York Times
What the Noah Dobson acquisition means for what the Canadiens are hoping to accomplish
MONTREAL — Team-building in the NHL is a complicated process, one mired with pitfalls and obstacles and plans that go awry. There are numerous examples of teams that went through a rebuilding process that never came out the other side, or at least haven't yet. Even two of the biggest rebuild success stories, the Toronto Maple Leafs and Edmonton Oilers, have not yet claimed the ultimate prize despite drafting generational players to build around. Advertisement The Montreal Canadiens don't have generational players. They have not even come close to sniffing at that prize. But Friday's acquisition of defenceman Noah Dobson from the New York Islanders signals a seismic shift in how the Canadiens are approaching their rebuild. They have firmly exited a rebuild and entered a team-building phase, which is one step closer to entering a contending phase. In Dobson, the Canadiens believe they have acquired not only a crucial piece of their eventual championship puzzle, but also a player who shares that belief that there is in fact a championship puzzle being put together here. Dobson's fit as a player in that puzzle is almost less important than Dobson's belief in that puzzle, because his belief came from the outside, from an interested observer wondering where to continue his career. As a legitimate top-pairing, puck-moving, right-shot defenceman, Dobson would have been a coveted piece across the league. But what the Canadiens are building excited him and he wanted in, and that should be exciting to Canadiens fans who have been searching for a light in the tunnel of this rebuild. This sign-and-trade with the Islanders, this decision by Dobson to eagerly jump in on what is happening in Montreal, should serve as that light. 'Without hesitation, it was a no-brainer for me,' Dobson, 25, said of the decision to sign an eight-year contract worth $9.5 million a year to commit his prime years to the Canadiens. 'Just the opportunity to be part of the Montreal Canadiens, it's an honour. It's the best hockey market in the world. The fans are incredible. I love playing at the Bell Centre. 'And then just also the group of players they have already, the talent they have on the team and what they've been building. I'm just super excited to join that group and add to it, and I'm excited about what we can do down the road here in the future.' Advertisement It is the last part that is vital to what this means for the Canadiens and where they are in their rebuild, because it has been ages since a player in his prime felt that way about this team. And Dobson got that sense through word of mouth. He played for Team Canada in the most recent World Championships with Canadiens defenceman Mike Matheson and has a history with Nick Suzuki from the 2019 Canadian world juniors team. 'I think Martin St. Louis has a great reputation throughout the league as a coach and a person,' Dobson said. 'What I heard as a group, they enjoy coming to the rink every day. It's a fun group, a tight-knit group. They've got a great mix of lots of young kids and veterans as well. Everyone just enjoys being together as a group and they have a great time. They try and make it fun and make it exciting to go to the rink every day. 'As a player, that's all you can ask for.' And since Dobson feels that way, Canadiens general manager Kent Hughes is hopeful it will lead to more players feeling that way. 'I think it also probably makes it a more attractive place to play for a prospective forward, whether that's this year or in the future,' Hughes said late Friday night. 'We've talked about getting players who could help out in our top-six, but if we could have a team that we hope to have, similar to Florida where they're rolling two real good lines – well, they have three – but both lines would want a puck-moving D out there to get them pucks and moving. 'So I think in that regard, when the puzzle's complete, we're going to have more puck-movers to move through our lineup.' Hughes says he has spent the last three weeks on the phone 'nearly every waking hour' trying to improve his team. The Canadiens continue to say they are not desperate to improve right away, that they are not willing to do anything stupid, but there was definitely pressure on the organization to build on its first playoff berth of this rebuild, to not take a step back, to make a tangible improvement. Advertisement This move accomplished that, in more ways than one. The first is the hockey part, that the Canadiens now have two top-end puck-moving defencemen in Dobson and Calder Trophy-winner Lane Hutson that they can deploy on two pairings, potentially having an elite puck-mover on the ice for 45 to 50 minutes a game. Even if the Canadiens don't succeed in finding a top-six forward to help their second line – and Hughes says he is still trying to do that – that alone should improve the offensive performance of the forwards the Canadiens already have. 'I think if you look at how we play, we try to deny pucks a lot and deny ice and we send a lot of D back, if their D partner's up holding the blue line and they're going back to retrieve,' Hughes said. 'His ability to retrieve pucks and spring the offence for us was a big piece. We've seen how Lane's done that for us this year. We're confident. We did a lot of homework on (Dobson), a lot of people that have coached him.' The reason Hughes felt the need to express confidence in the research the Canadiens did on Dobson is he is coming off a down year, as he followed up a career-high 70 points last season with 39 points this season. Hughes called it an outlier, and over the course of Dobson's career, it would appear to be. But Dobson characterized it more as a learning experience, one that should now benefit the Canadiens. 'I think it was a difficult season at times as a whole, not just individually, but as a team,' Dobson said. 'We struggled to score a lot, collectively as a team, especially earlier in the year. The team dealt with a lot of injuries, a lot of moving parts moving in and out. Like any season, there's highs and lows throughout that. 'I think just taking the learning experience, dealing with, as a team and individually, struggling to score and produce and having to find ways to be effective each night when things aren't going in was something I really tried to learn from and grow and evolve.' Advertisement There is some mild risk here from a hockey perspective, considering how Dobson's season went, but it's mitigated by the three years of excellent hockey he played prior. He is a top-pair defenceman, despite how this season went, and the Canadiens paid a top-pair-defenceman price in both acquisition cost and with the contract, which is structured very favourably for Dobson. Noah Dobson 8 year $9.5M Cap Hit #Isles/#GoHabsGo sign & trade: Yr 1/2/3: 1M Base & 11M Signing BonusYr 4: 5M Base & 5M SBYr 5: 8.4M BaseYr 6/7/8: 7.2M Base Years 2-8: 14 Team No Trade Clause Rep'd by Olivier Fortier @wassermanhockey — PuckPedia (@PuckPedia) June 28, 2025 But more than the hockey fit, the signal the Dobson acquisition sends is almost of greater importance. It signals an emergence from a rebuild, and a willingness to smooth out the imperfections in the Canadiens' roster in order to build one capable of winning the Stanley Cup down the road. It's possible Dobson isn't the right player to drive that forward, but what the Canadiens believe him to be absolutely would drive that forward. And what that means is that every subsequent move will serve the same purpose. The Canadiens are in a different phase, an exciting phase in which a competitive team will continue being added to and improved incrementally with a long view of building a contender and a shorter view of continuing to build momentum. It is the first stepping stone this Canadiens administration has added that didn't require some sort of abstract projection of what an acquired asset could potentially mean if everything went right. Dobson's projection is not very abstract. 'I don't want to say everything happens in phases, but I guess we spent the early part of my time here trying to accumulate assets, which for the most part were draft picks, but there were prospects,' Hughes said. 'But once you go through that phase, I think you come to a time where you start to look at, how are we constructing a hockey team and how do we want to play and what are the players that fit that idea, that mandate. Advertisement 'This is probably a pretty significant sign on our part that, OK, we're adding a piece from the outside, we didn't draft it, and we're going to try to continue to take those next steps. I think part of it was driven by the success the team had and the desire the dressing room has to keep moving this thing forward.' The Canadiens made a significant investment in Dobson, and Dobson committed the prime of his NHL career to the Canadiens. They are both hoping for the same thing, that this marriage will result in rings. That end result is still abstract and still requires more work. But Dobson's acquisition is the first sign that work toward the desired end result has now begun.
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Matthew Schaefer honors late mother after getting selected first overall by New York Islanders in NHL draft
Just over a year ago, Matthew Schaefer lost his mother, Jennifer, to breast cancer. Now, he's achieved the ultimate milestone – becoming an NHL player. The 17-year-old was selected by the New York Islanders with the first overall pick in the 2025 NHL draft on Friday in Los Angeles. An emotional Schaefer, a defenseman from the Ontario Hockey League's Erie Otters, was greeted by NHL commissioner Gary Bettman on the stage at the Peacock Theater, and was presented with an Islanders sweater that included a breast cancer ribbon stitched onto the jersey. Schaefer kissed the ribbon before breaking into tears with his father and brother in the crowd. Schaefer said the ribbon was a 'surprise' to him along with his mother's initals being embroidered into the collar of the jersey. 'This is a high class organization,' Schaefer told reporters. 'To do that for me, it means a lot – it goes a long way. A lot of people can say it's just a ribbon but it means a lot for me. 'My mom is a big part of my life. And this jersey, I will hang up for sure. That ribbon has a little extra meaning to it.' Schaefer also dealt with the deaths of the mother of his billet family and Otters owner Jim Waters in the last year. Schaefer added that he misses 'the person she was' the most when asked about his mother. 'She was always so happy,' Schaefer told the ESPN broadcast. 'She's gone through so much but the personality she had – cancer sucks and it's not fun. She didn't always feel the best but she was always the happiest in the family and always made us laugh and do anything for us.' The Canadian is the Islanders' fifth selection at first overall in franchise history, and the club's first since 2009 when they drafted John Tavares. Schaefer, a Stoney Creek, Ontario native, played 17 games with Erie last season, recording seven goals and 22 points before breaking his collarbone at the 2025 IIHF World Junior Championship with Team Canada in December. He won a gold medal and served as team captain of Team Canada at the 2024 Hlinka Gretzky Cup and also won gold with Canada at the 2024 IIHF World Under-18 Championship. 🗣️ NUMBER ONE. MATTHEW SCHAEFER!!#NHLDraft | #Isles Ahead of the draft, Schaefer showed off his draft day suit which featured a picture of his mother and her signature near his heart. 'That was the biggest thing to put on my heart. I always know she is with me in spirit,' Schaefer said. Islander fans at the draft watch party at UBS Arena in Elmont, New York gave Schaefer an rousing ovation after he told the crowd the team will 'beat' their crosstown rivals the New York Rangers 'every time we play them.' Schaefer becomes the fifth defenseman to be selected No. 1 overall, the first since Owen Power by the Buffalo Sabres in 2021. The Islanders made two other selections in Friday's first round following a trade with the Montreal Canadiens earlier in the day – forward Victor Eklund and defenseman Kashawn Aitcheson. The San Jose Sharks selected center Michael Misa with the second overall pick and the Chicago Blackhawks took Swedish forward Anton Frondell with the third pick. The Anaheim Ducks picked center Roger McQueen at No. 10 overall and the 18-year-old Canadian immediately hopped onto a helicopter to go to Disneyland. The wife of late NHL superstar Johnny Gaudreau, Meredith, announced the Columbus Blue Jackets' first selection of defenseman Jackson Smith at pick 14. The NHL draft continues through Saturday.
