Hong Kong trans man wins landmark public toilet rights case
The High Court ruled in favour of the man, referred to as 'K', who argued that the restrictions violated his rights to equality, privacy, and freedom from discrimination.
The case centred on K's gender dysphoria treatment, where doctors advised him to use men's public restrooms as part of his transition. However, his Hong Kong ID card still listed him as female, meaning he risked a HK$2,000 ($255) fine under existing regulations.
Justice Russell Coleman ruled that two provisions in the law were unconstitutional, giving the government one year to amend the regulations.
The decision follows a series of legal victories for transgender rights in Hong Kong, including a 2023 ruling that struck down the requirement for full gender-affirming surgery before changing the sex marker on ID cards.
Coleman noted that the government had effectively conceded the public toilet case after the 2023 ruling.
K did not challenge the concept of sex-segregated toilets but argued that denying him access based on his ID card was discriminatory.
The court also highlighted the broader struggles faced by transgender individuals.
'Many trans people choose not to use public conveniences at all, due to fear, the threat of harassment, and to avoid having their gender identity invalidated or undermined,' Coleman wrote.
K was undergoing hormone therapy in preparation for surgery when he filed the case.
His treatment required 'real life experience,' including using facilities matching his gender identity. - AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
an hour ago
- New Straits Times
What is the status of US tariff negotiations?
WASHINGTON: US tariff negotiations with key trading partners have shifted into high gear as economies race to avoid steeper duties before an Aug 1 deadline. Many of these tariff hikes were part of a package first announced in April, under which dozens of economies were due to face higher levies – up from a 10 per cent level – over their trade surpluses with the United States. The twice-postponed deadline for duties to take effect is now Friday, Aug 1. But Washington has expanded its group of targets coming up against these tariffs, while announcing agreements with the European Union, Britain, Vietnam, Japan, Indonesia and the Philippines. A deal with the European Union unveiled on Sunday sees a 15 per cent tariff imposed on European exports to the United States, down from the 30 per cent that Trump earlier threatened. Where do other US trade talks stand? Seoul is racing to reach a deal with Washington, as Tokyo's success in landing an agreement has "amped up the pressure for South Korea," a government source told AFP. Local media reported that Seoul was preparing to propose more than US$100 billion in investment as part of a broader agreement, with expected participation by major firms such as Samsung and Hyundai Motor. The South Korean government did not confirm this. But South Korean officials have outlined proposals to deepen collaboration in sectors like shipbuilding, semiconductors and batteries. National Security Advisor Wi Sung-lak has told reporters that the two countries are in "the final and most crucial phase of negotiations" to avert Trump's proposed 25 per cent duty. Indian Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal told Bloomberg Television Thursday that he was optimistic his country could reach an agreement with the United States to avert Washington's 26 per cent tariff threat. Goyal insisted there were not any sticking points in the US-India relationship or in trade talks, and clarified that immigration rules – including those around H-1B visas for skilled workers – had not come up in negotiations. Despite Goyal's remarks, local media reported the prospects of an interim deal before Aug 1 had dimmed. Taiwanese Premier Cho Jung-tai said Thursday that officials are "working hard" on negotiations, amid worries that an unfavorable tariff level could hit the self-ruled island's economy. Vice President Hsiao Bi-khim said Taipei's negotiating team was "working almost 24 hours a day to achieve trade balance and Taiwan's industrial interests, and even to further deepen cooperation." Although Canada and Mexico were spared from Trump's "reciprocal" tariffs announced in April, goods from both countries entering the United States generally face a separate 25 per cent duty if they fall outside a North American trade pact. This figure stands to jump to 30 per cent for Mexico come Aug 1, while the level for Canada was set at 35 per cent. Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum said her administration was "doing everything" possible to avert the duties and that she would speak with Trump if necessary to try to reach a pact. Trump told reporters Friday there was no deal with Canada so far. Brazil is girding for a virtual trade embargo on its planes, grains and other goods if Trump's threatened 50 per cent tariff on its exports takes effect on Aug 1. The United States runs a trade surplus with Latin America's biggest economy, which was not originally expected to face steeper tariffs under Trump's "reciprocal" duties plan. Trump has not attempted to hide the political motivation in targeting Brazil, citing a judicial "witch hunt" against his right-wing ally, former president Jair Bolsonaro, when he unveiled the tariff rate. The political nature of the spat makes a last-minute deal appear less likely.
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
Syria announces September date for transitional parliament selection
DAMASCUS: Syrian authorities have confirmed that the selection process for a new transitional parliament will take place in mid-September, marking a key step in the country's post-war political transition. The announcement follows months of preparation under the interim government led by President Ahmed al-Sharaa, who took power after the ousting of longtime ruler Bashar al-Assad in December. According to state news agency SANA, the new 210-seat parliament will consist of 140 lawmakers chosen by local electoral bodies and 70 appointed directly by Sharaa. Mohammed Taha al-Ahmad, head of the supervisory committee overseeing the process, stated that the elections are expected between September 15 and 20, with guarantees for women's representation. The transitional framework was established after Syria's previous legislature was dissolved and replaced by a temporary constitutional declaration in March. The declaration grants the new assembly a 36-month renewable mandate, with legislative powers until a permanent constitution is adopted. Critics, however, have raised concerns over the concentration of power in Sharaa's hands and the lack of adequate representation for Syria's diverse ethnic and religious groups. Security challenges also persist, with periodic violence involving government forces and allied factions casting doubt on the stability of the transition. The local electoral bodies are set to be formed within three weeks of the decree's signing, followed by a one-week candidacy period before public debates begin. The presidency confirmed that Ahmad's committee presented the final selection plan to Sharaa on Saturday. - AFP
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Border chaos amid hope for peace
Displaced: An aerial view showing tents used by people taking shelter near a pagoda in Oddar Meanchey province, Cambodia. — AFP ACTING Prime Minister Phumtham Wechayachai and Cambodia's Prime Minister Hun Manet is set to meet today in Malaysia for peace talks over their border conflict, Bangkok said yesterday. The Thai premier's office said the talks would be hosted by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, 'with Mr Hun Manet, Prime Minister of Cambodia, to personally travel for talks'. Cambodia and Thailand earlier said the other had launched artillery attacks across contested border areas early yesterday, hours after US President Donald Trump said the leaders of both countries had agreed to work on a ceasefire. Cambodia said it fully endorsed Trump's call for an immediate ceasefire. 'We've proposed bilateral talks between our foreign ministers to conclude the conditions for a ceasefire and drawing back troops and long-range weapons,' said Phumtham. Cambodia said Thailand had started hostilities yesterday morning and that Thai forces were mobilising along the border. Thailand said it had responded to attacks from Cambodia. 'I made it clear to Honourable President Donald Trump that Cambodia agreed with the proposal for an immediate and unconditional ceasefire between the two armed forces,' Hun Manet posted on Facebook, noting he had also agreed to Malaysia's earlier ceasefire proposal. Four days after the worst fighting in more than a decade broke out between the South-East Asian neighbours, the death toll stood above 30, including 13 civilians in Thailand and eight in Cambodia. On the ground help: (Left) Evacuees displaced by the ongoing conflict between Thailand and Cambodia resting at an evacuation centre in the Thai border province of Sisaket while. — AFP More than 200,000 people have been evacuated from border areas in the two countries, authorities said. Cambodia's Defence Ministry said Thailand had shelled and launched ground assaults yesterday morning at a number of points along the border. The ministry's spokesperson said heavy artillery was fired at historic temple complexes. 'For me, I think it is great if Thailand agreed to stop fighting so both countries can live in peace,' a Phnom Penh university student Sreung Nita said. The Thai army said Cambodian forces had fired shots into several areas, including near civilian homes, early yesterday, and were mobilising long-range rocket launchers. The governor of Surin said that artillery shells had been fired into the province. 'The soldiers will continue to do their job at full steam – so Thais do not worry – until the government has reached a clear agreement that there is no danger for the people and to ensure we maintain the country's interests in order to bring the peace we want to see,' Phumtham said. Local villagers help to unload supplies donated by a charity for refugees from a truck as they take refuge in Wat Phnom Kamboar, Oddar Meanchey province, Cambodia. — AP In the Thai province of Sisaket, reporters heard shelling and said it was unclear which side of the border it was on. 'If there is a ceasefire, things will be better,' Sisaket resident Thavorn Toosawan said. Trump said on Saturday that he had spoken with the prime ministers of Thailand and Cambodia and they had agreed to meet immediately to quickly work out a ceasefire to end fighting that began on Thursday. 'Both Parties are looking for an immediate Ceasefire and Peace,' Trump wrote on social media, adding that tariff negotiations with both countries were on hold until the fighting stopped. — Reuters/AFP
