I was sacked by NASA for telling TRUTH about alien mission – now I fear Mars astronauts won't come home alive
Catharine Conley, the agency's Planetary Protection Officer from 2006 to 2017, also fears SpaceX astronauts won't come home alive.
Advertisement
10
Conley claims the Mars 2020 rover Perseverance was not cleaned properly
Credit: Getty
10
An image of Mars's surface taken by the Mars 2020 rover Perseverance
Credit: AP
10
Catharine Conley worked as Nasa's Planetary Protection Officer for over a decade until she was sacked
Credit: NASA/GSFC/BILL HYRBYK
Conley first accused officials at the
The rover,
Its job is to obtain the samples which will then be collected by a
future
Mars Sample Return Mission.
Advertisement
But Conley feared any material eventually flown home could be contaminated - and the whole mission scuppered.
She claims she was suddenly removed from the position after speaking out - and suspects it was to silence her concerns.
Conley told The Sun: 'Nasa decided they didn't want to do the kind of work that I had been doing.
'They didn't want to continue with the kinds of implementation that they had been doing historically.
Advertisement
Most read in Science
Exclusive
Exclusive
'That was not something I thought was a good idea, so they decided they needed someone else for the job.
"This was basic planetary protection as it had been done for the prior 50 years or so."
Mystery space rock blazing through solar system 'may be oldest comet ever seen'
Conley, who now works as a researcher, added: 'The Mars 2020 rover was cleaned in a way that was not compatible with prior levels of cleanliness, in particular regarding the amount of contamination that was getting introduced into the samples that were being collected for return.
'I pointed out that having a 0.1% chance of contaminating any individual sample, when you have 40 samples in total, comes out to a 4 per cent chance of having Earth contamination in the samples you're looking at.
Advertisement
'That makes it fairly difficult to be confident that you can distinguish between Earth life and Mars life.
'That was not something that the people at headquarters management wanted to hear and they took the
steps
that they thought were appropriate.'
10
Mars is the fourth planet away from the sun
Credit: Getty
10
Retrieving samples from Mars is one of the most pressing priorities in space exploration
Credit: Getty
Advertisement
Conley claims she had been told of staff being careless when using gloves and protective equipment.
She also claimed to have been told of staff bringing equipment into assembly rooms that was not properly cleaned, along with an 'attitude of skepticism I encountered regularly at JPL'.
Nasa states on its website that Mars 2020 Perseverance Rover remains an active mission.
It landed in February 2021 as part of Nasa's Mars Sample Return (MSR) campaign.
Advertisement
In January the agency said it was hoping to announce plans for the returning of samples in the second half of 2026.
But that has been thrown into doubt following Donald Trump's proposed cuts to Nasa, with MSR a
casualty
.
10
A photo taken by the Mars Perseverance rover of the Malgosa Crest abrasion patch
Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech
10
Nasa intends to send a manned mission to Mars some time in the 2030s
Credit: Getty
Advertisement
China is preparing to press ahead with their own plans to return Mars samples.
It has scheduled the Tianwen-3 Mars mission for launch in 2028, collecting and bringing samples back by 2031.
But Conley still fears the same problem.
She said: 'The concerns are similar. I've been looking at some of the reports that have come out about the Chinese proposed missions, and they're saying all the right things to the extent that I can obtain information.
Advertisement
'But it is difficult to follow up on what they are actually saying they're doing.
'I certainly had experience within my duties at Nasa of engineers saying one thing and doing something else.
'So it's difficult to know. But if other space agencies are not doing anything more than Nasa did, then I would be surprised if their contamination levels are low enough that you could detect the Mars signal underneath the background from Earth.'
Despite the cuts, Trump has proposed no savings on Nasa's plans to send astronauts to Mars in the 2030s.
Advertisement
Nasa's mission to Mars
Nasa hopes to send astronauts to Mars as early as the 2030s.
The space company has been working to advance its technologies in a bid to send a human crew to the Red Planet.
It would take astronauts up to nine months to reach Mars - which even at its closest is 33.9 million miles away.
Astronauts could then spend up to 500 days on the planet's surface before returning to Earth - which would take another nine months.
The crew would spend their time on the planet collecting data and assessing the planetary alignment that would allow the spacecraft to land and depart from Mars on the same orbit.
Last year, the agency completed a year-long simulated mission that saw four crew members out in a replica habitat in Houston, Texas.
They logged 378 days in the 1,700-square-foot, 3D-printed habitat called Mars Dune Alpha.
But Conley fears that doing so without a sample return mission means a gaping hole in knowledge for what astronauts will encounter.
She also questions if astronauts will be allowed home if they fall sick.
Conley added: 'Not doing a robotic sample return means we don't have detailed information about what kinds of materials the astronauts are likely to encounter, and possibly bring back to Earth, which could be quite problematic if there is something hazardous in Mars regolith, even if it's not biological.
10
The Mars 2020 mission is collecting samples which will ultimately return to Earth for tests for evidence of alien life
Credit: Getty
Advertisement
10
The image was captured by the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter in 2008
Credit: NASA
'A question that didn't get answered during Apollo and certainly hasn't been addressed since is: if astronauts get sick after contacting Mars and we can't figure out why, should they be allowed to return?
'The fundamental problem, from my perspective, is overconfidence in thinking that we already know everything we need to know about what could happen, when we don't."
Conley also warned of Elon Musk's plans to send a manned crew to Mars through his company, SpaceX.
Advertisement
She added: 'SpaceX say they're planning to launch humans to Mars, but I have serious doubts about whether anyone would be alive when the spacecraft gets there since SpaceX doesn't seem to be developing long-term life support systems along with their rockets.
'Musk has made numerous claims about when he'll land humans on Mars that are distinctly implausible, at least if he wants the humans to be alive when they get there.
Read more on the Irish Sun
'Nasa is much more likely to be careful about preserving astronaut
health
but, ironically, seems not similarly concerned about protecting the Earth from possible Mars contamination.'
The Sun has approached Nasa for a response to Conley's allegations.
Advertisement
10
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
9 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Terrifying new Earth-sized planet found with deadly secret that would instantly kill anyone visiting
A NEW Earth-sized planet has been discovered in a faraway constellation - and it would kill any astronaut who dare travel there. Some 117.4 light-years away from Earth, scientists have stumbled across a nightmarish alien world where the planet's surface is likely molten. 5 The surface of molten exoplanet Credit: Alamy 5 An artist's impression of a molten exoplanet Credit: Alamy The planet, dubbed TOI-2431, orbits quite close to its nearest star over a very short period, resulting in a high surface temperature. Unlike Earth, which has an orbital period of 365 days, TOI-2431 orbits its star in only 5.4 hours - making it one of the shortest period exoplanets ever discovered. The alien world, located in constellation Cetus, is thought to have a surface temperature of about 1,700C (3092F). Anything that lands there would be immediately incinerated. READ MORE ON SPACE The international team of astronomers, led by Kaya Han Taş of the University of Amsterdam in the Netherlands, detected the new exoplanet orbiting a nearby star using Nasa's Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS). 5 Nasa's Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) Credit: Nasa "We have confirmed the ultra-short period planet TOI-2431 b using a combination of photometric transit data from TESS, precise radial velocity observations with the NEID and HPF spectrographs, and ground-based speckle imaging with the NESSI instrument," researchers wrote in the new The Nasa tool monitors about 200,000 bright stars near Earth, scanning for hidden planets that might cause any blips of light as they pass their star. Just last week, researchers revealed they used TESS to follow a Most read in Science Since its launch in April 2018, the satellite has identified more than 7,600 possible exoplanets - which are nicknamed TESS Objects of Interest, or TOI. Exactly 638 of these have been confirmed as alien worlds so far. Best-ever sign of ALIEN life found on distant planet as scientists '99.7% sure of astounding biological activity signal' The planet's host star is only about two-thirds the size and mass of our Sun, and appears to be pulling the planet towards a fiery death. Researchers estimated that the planet has a tidal decay timescale of about 31 million years - which is fairly short in the grand schemes of the universe. Tidal decay causes a planet's orbit to gradually shrink and spiral towards its host star - eventually leading to its destruction. The 2billion-year-old host star, which researchers believe is roughly double the temperature of its nearby planet, will eventually collide with the planet. Researchers hope they can secure time with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) to study TOI-2431 b more closely. Doing so could shed more light on the planet's surface composition, and may answer the question of whether or not it has an atmosphere. The $10 billion telescope 5 The James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) Credit: Alamy 5 An artist's impression of a molten exoplanet Credit: Alamy All you need to know about planets in our solar system Our solar system is made up of nine planets with Earth the third closest to the Sun. But each planet has its own quirks, so find out more about them all... How old is How many moons does What colour is How far away is How big is How many moons does Does How many moons does How big is How hot is the
Irish Independent
16 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Mystery of Betelgeuse twinkle solved after hundreds of years
It is Betelgeuse, and for hundreds of years astronomers have puzzled over why its twinkle grows lighter and then dimmer over time. But the mystery has finally been solved. Betelgeuse has a companion star that pushes light-blocking dust out of the way, temporarily making the star glow more brightly. The presence of the star, nicknamed 'Betelbuddy', had been theorised, but Nasa has spotted it for the first time using its Gemini North telescope, in Hawaii. Steve Howell, a senior research scientist at the Nasa Ames Research Centre in California, said: 'Papers that predicted Betelgeuse's companion believed that no one would likely ever be able to image it. 'Gemini North's ability to obtain high angular resolutions and sharp contrasts allowed the companion of Betelgeuse to be directly detected.' Betelgeuse, roughly pronounced as 'Beetlejuice', sits about 650 light years from Earth and glows 100,000 times brighter than the sun. It is so big that if it sat at the centre of our solar system, in the position of the sun, its surface would lie farther out than Mars. It is known as a variable star, getting brighter and dimmer every 400 days. In 2019 and 2020, there was a steep decrease in Betelgeuse's brightness − an event referred to as the 'Great Dimming', which led to some scientists suggesting its dulled twinkle was foreshadowing an impending supernova that would darken the star for ever. However, it turned out that the star had emitted a large gas bubble, which then cooled to form dust, temporarily blocking its shine. The Great Dimming mystery sparked a renewed interest in studying Betelgeuse, but it was not until researchers used a special technique called 'speckle imaging' that the star was discovered. Speckle imaging uses very short exposure times to freeze out the distortions in images caused by Earth's atmosphere, enabling high resolution, which, when combined with the light-collecting power of Gemini North, allowed the new star to be seen for the first time.
The Irish Sun
a day ago
- The Irish Sun
Common sweetener in fizzy drinks and yoghurt ‘can kill off the deadliest cancer'
A COMMON sugar substitute in fizzy drinks, yoghurts and gum could be used to combat one of the deadliest kinds of cancer. Researchers fermented the zero calorie sweetener and tested it against Advertisement 2 Stevia extract could be used to help fight pancreatic cancer, researchers suggested Credit: Getty 2 They tested fermented extracts against pancreatic cancer cells in a lab dish Credit: Getty In the UK, about 10,800 people are diagnosed with It's the fifth most common cause of Previous research has suggested that stevia leaf extracts could have potential "anticancer effects". Advertisement But isolating specific substances within the herb that could help protect against cancer and using them has remained challenging. Researchers from Hiroshima University suggested fermenting stevia with bacteria can structurally change the extract and produce bioactive metabolites - compounds that can impact living organisms. Study author Masanori Sugiyama, a professor in the Department of Probiotic Science for Preventive Medicine , said The team tested their theory out against pancreatic cancer cells. Advertisement Most read in Health Exclusive Exclusive "Pancreatic cancer is a highly malignant tumour of the digestive system with a poor prognosis," co-author Prof Narandalai Danshiitsoodol said. "Globally, the incidence and mortality rates of pancreatic cancer continue to rise, with a five-year survival rate of less than 10 per cent. The most common symptoms of pancreatic cancer - as patients share their stories "The primary reason "Furthermore, pancreatic cancer is highly invasive and prone to metastasis, showing significant resistance to existing treatments such as surgery, radiotherapy, and Advertisement "Therefore, there is an urgent need to identify new and effective anticancer compounds, particularly those derived from medicinal plants." Researchers used lactic acid bacteria to ferment stevia extracts. They isolated over 1200 strains from fruits, vegetables, flowers, and medicinal plants and evaluated their health benefits . They finally landed on Lactobacillus plantarum SN13T strain (FSLE) derived from banana leaves "to enhance the antioxidant and anticancer activities of stevia leaf extract through fermentation". Advertisement They tested fermented and non-fermented stevia extracts against pancreatic cancer cells in lab dishes. Fermented stevia killed pancreatic cancer cells more efficiently than the non-fermented extract, the study published in the Symptoms of pancreatic cancer PANCREATIC cancer doesn't always cause symptoms in its early stages. As the cancer grows and you do begin to show signs, these may come and go and be unspecific, making it hard to diagnose, according to Common symptoms include: Indigestion - a painful, burning feeling in your chest with an unpleasant taste in your mouth Diarrhoea and constipation - see a GP if you have runny poos for more than seven days, especially if you've lost weight as well Steatorrhoea - pale, oily poo that's bulky, smells horrible and floats, making it hard to flush Losing a lot of weight without meaning to Jaundice - yellow skin and eyes, as well as dark pee, pale poo and itchy skin This suggested that "the fermentation process enhances the bioactivity of the [stevia] extract", Prof Sugiyama said. Researchers tested out different fermentation levels to see which was most effective against cancer cells. Advertisement Lower concentrations didn't kill cancer cells immediately, but they slowed their growth. Healthy kidney cells were mostly unaffected by the stevia extracts. Researchers plan to study how fermented stevia affects cancer in mice next , to see how various dosages will work in living organisms. 'The present study has substantially enhanced our understanding of the mechanism of action of the Lactobacillus plantarum SN13T strain in the fermentation of herbal extracts, while also offering a valuable research perspective on the potential application of probiotics as natural anti-tumour agents,' Prof Danshiitsoodol said. Advertisement Since the early 1990s, pancreatic cancer incidence rates have increased by 18 per cent in the UK. The disease is often diagnosed at a late stage because it frequently lacks noticeable symptoms in the early stages. Surgery, chemotherapy and radiation can help extend patients' li ves. Read more on the Irish Sun A blood test to pick up early signs of pancreatic cancer is being trialled in patients with a recent diagnosis of type 2 diabetes - a known risk factor for the disease. Advertisement Meanwhile, researchers at Case Western Reserve University and Cleveland Clinic have developed a new type of jab to fight .
