‘Risk of absconding high': UK judge notes ‘confidential impediment' in Nirav Modi extradition case
Justice Michael Fordham on Thursday concluded at a Royal Courts of Justice bail hearing that there are substantial grounds for believing that if released on bail, the 54-year-old businessman would 'fail to surrender' and his risk of absconding remained high.
While Nirav's barrister argued in favour of his bail from London's Thameside prison based on the 'long passage of time' without trial, the judge highlighted the constraints of a 'confidential' process that prevented his surrender to the Indian authorities even though the legal process related to his extradition had 'run its course'.
'There is a 'legal reason' which relates to 'confidential proceedings'. The nature of this is known to the applicant (Nirav Modi), and his lawyers; it is known to the Home Office, but apart from what I have recorded, nothing is known by the CPS [Crown Prosecution Service] or by the Government of India, nor by this court,' Justice Fordham states.
CPS barrister Nicholas Hearn, appearing on behalf of the Indian authorities, confirmed to the court that he 'recognises and respects' the fact of the 'existing confidential impediment' and the fact of its confidentiality, for 'whatever reason it is being kept confidential'.
'It is appropriate, in the circumstances, that the court should proceed with the same recognition and respect. But the consequence is this: there is, as a result, a significant limitation to what this court can realistically assess, when considering the risks and implications in this case, and for that matter when considering how to characterise the now long passage of time,' the judge concluded in his ruling.
The confidential proceedings, alluded to at various previous court hearings linked with Nirav Modi, are believed to refer to an asylum application, but the exact nature of the matter is unclear.
Meanwhile, Nirav has remained in prison in London since his arrest in March 2019 and has made at least seven previous bail attempts, which have all been rejected because he poses a flight risk.
Justice Fordham said he considered the legal appropriateness for him to consider the latest bail application 'afresh' and with a 'clean slate'.
'I have had close regard to the points which have been made about the human cost of detention. That includes all of the points that have been advanced about physical and mental health, including in terms of deterioration and delays in treatment, and the concerns very properly raised in the clinicians' expert evidence,' Justice Fordham's judgment said.
'I have also taken account of the evidence about assaults and threats and the prospect of coercion… But I am not able to conclude that, when put alongside the other relevant features of the case, they can serve to displace or undermine the assessment which I have described (against bail),' it said.
There are three sets of criminal proceedings against Nirav Modi in India – the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) case of fraud in the Punjab National Bank (PNB), the Enforcement Directorate (ED) case relating to the alleged laundering of the proceeds of that fraud, and a third set of criminal proceedings involving alleged interference with evidence and witnesses in the CBI proceedings.
In April 2021, then UK home secretary, Priti Patel, ordered his extradition to face these charges in the Indian courts after a prima facie case was established against him.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
16 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Gita Gopinath leaving IMF in August to return to Harvard
Gita Gopinath, the No. 2 official at the International Monetary Fund, will leave her post at the end of August to return to Harvard University, the IMF said in a statement on Monday (July 21, 2025). IMF Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva will name a successor to Ms. Gopinath in "due course," the IMF said. Ms. Gopinath joined the fund in 2019 as chief economist — the first woman to serve in that role — and was promoted to first deputy managing director in January 2022. No comment was immediately available from the U.S. Treasury, which manages the dominant U.S. shareholding in the IMF. While European countries have traditionally chosen the Fund's managing director, the U.S. Treasury has traditionally recommended candidates for the first deputy managing director role. Ms. Gopinath is an Indian-born U.S. citizen. The timing of the move caught some IMF insiders by surprise and appears to have been initiated by Ms. Gopinath. Ms. Gopinath, who had left Harvard to join the IMF, will return to the university as a professor of economics. Ms. Gopinath's departure will offer Treasury a chance to recommend a successor at a time when U.S. President Donald Trump is seeking to restructure the global economy and end longstanding U.S. trade deficits with high tariffs on imports from nearly all countries. She will return to a university that has been in the Trump administration's crosshairs after it rejected demands to change its governance, hiring, and admissions practices. Ms. Georgieva said Ms. Gopinath joined the IMF as a highly respected academic and proved to be an "exceptional intellectual leader" during her time, which included the pandemic and global shocks caused by Russia's invasion of Ukraine. "Gita steered the Fund's analytical and policy work with clarity, striving for the highest standards of rigorous analysis at a complex time of high uncertainty and rapidly changing global economic environment," Ms. Georgieva said. Ms. Gopinath has also overseen the fund's multilateral surveillance and analytical work on fiscal and monetary policy, debt, and international trade. Ms. Gopinath said she was grateful for a "once in a lifetime opportunity" to work at the IMF, thanking both Ms. Georgieva and the previous IMF chief, Christine Lagarde, who appointed her as chief economist. "I now return to my roots in academia, where I look forward to continuing to push the research frontier in international finance and macroeconomics to address global challenges, and to training the next generation of economists," she said in a statement.
Mint
16 minutes ago
- Mint
Breakout stocks to buy or sell: Sumeet Bagadia recommends five shares to buy today — 22 July 2025
Breakout stocks buy or sell: Strong gains in major banking stocks such as HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank lifted the Indian market benchmarks — Sensex and Nifty 50 — on Monday, July 21, helping them snap a two-day losing streak despite mixed global signals. The Sensex advanced by 443 points, or 0.54 per cent, to settle at 82,200.34, while the Nifty 50 gained 122 points, or 0.49 per cent, to close at 25,090.70. The BSE Midcap index also climbed 0.55 per cent, mirroring the benchmarks, whereas the BSE Smallcap index closed on a flat note. Sumeet Bagadia, Executive Director at Choice Broking, believes that Indian stock market is indicating a trend reversal as the Nifty 50 index has bounced back strongly after inching close to 50-DEMA support of 24,900. Speaking on the outlook of Indian stock market, Bagadia said, ' The key benchmark index is facing hurdle at 25,250. On breaking above this resistance on a closing basis, we can expect the 50-stock index to touch 25,500 and 25,700 soon. So, one should maintain stock-specific approach and look at those stocks that are looking strong on the technical chart. Looking at breakout stocks can be a good option." Sumeet Bagadia recommends five breakout stocks to buy today: Nelcast, Vintage Coffee and Beverages, Royal Orchid Hotels, Chemplast Sanmar, and KRBL. 1] Nelcast: Buy at ₹ 152.7, target ₹ 163, stop loss ₹ 147; 2] Vintage Coffee and Beverages: Buy at ₹ 146.55, target ₹ 157, stop loss ₹ 141; 3] Royal Orchid Hotels: Buy at ₹ 437.8, target ₹ 470, stop loss ₹ 422; 4] Chemplast Sanmar: Buy at ₹ 467.4, target ₹ 505, stop loss ₹ 350; 5] KRBL: Buy at ₹ 414, target ₹ 444, stop loss ₹ 399. Disclaimer: This story is for educational purposes only. The views and recommendations above are those of individual analysts or broking companies, not Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.
Mint
16 minutes ago
- Mint
Buy or sell: Vaishali Parekh recommends three stocks to buy today — 22 July 2025
Buy or sell stocks: After a weak opening, the Indian stock market witnessed strong buying at the lower levels, and all three key benchmark indices finished with decent gains. The Nifty 50 index regained the psychological 25,000 and finished 122 points higher at 25,090. The BSE Sensex registered a 442-point gain and closed at 82,200, whereas the Bank Nifty index ended 669 points northward at 56,952. Eternal, ICICI Bank and HDFC Bank emerged as the top performers in the Nifty. Conversely, Reliance, Wipro, and IndusInd Bank concluded the session as the major losers. Trading volumes on the NSE cash market were slightly lower by 3% compared to the previous session. Among the sectoral indices, Nifty Financial Services, Nifty Bank, and Metal emerged as major gainers, playing a crucial role in the Nifty's rebound. On the other hand, OIL/GAS, PSU Banks, and FMCG faced the steepest declines, contributing significantly to the overall market fall. The Nifty Midcap 100 Index gained 0.62%, while the Nifty Smallcap 100 Index underperformed the Benchmark, ending flat. Market breadth remained negative, with declining stocks outnumbering advancing ones on the BSE, as indicated by an advance-decline ratio of 0.90. Vaishali Parekh, Vice President of Technical Research at Prabhudas Lilladher, believes the Indian stock market bias has improved. The Prabhudas Lillladher expert said that the probability of a trend reversal on Dalal Street has heightened as the Nifty 50 has once again bounced back from its 50-DEMA support of 24,900. However, Parekh maintained that the key benchmark index is facing a hurdle at 25,250. Speaking on the outlook of the Nifty 50 today, Vaishali Parekh said, "The Nifty 50 index has indicated a decent pullback from the significant support zone of 24,900 level, which was where the important 50-DEMA zone and the base of the channel pattern were positioned, indicating a trend reversal except for a further upward move in the coming sessions. The index would have the near-term resistance at the 25,250 zone, which needs to be breached decisively to improve the bias further and retest the 25,650 level to strengthen the trend again." The Bank Nifty index recovered strongly from the base of the 56,200 zone with a positive bullish candle formation on the daily chart on the back of good results from HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank, which helped in pulling the index and is expected to rise further with a bias improving. On the upside, the index would need to breach above the resistance zone of 57,600 level and, thereafter, expect fresh higher targets of 58,500 and 60,000 levels in the coming days, as mentioned earlier," said Parekh. Parekh said that the immediate support for the Nifty 50 index is at 24,900, while the resistance is at 25,300. The Bank Nifty would have a daily range of 56,500 to 57,600. Regarding stocks to buy today, Vaishali Parekh recommended these three buy-or-sell stocks: SJVN, Lloyds Enterprises, and Siemens. 1] SJVN: Buy at ₹ 99, Target ₹ 110, Stop Loss ₹ 95; 2] Lloyds Enterprises: Buy at ₹ 82, Target ₹ 92, Stop Loss ₹ 76; and 3] Siemens: Buy at ₹ 3155, Target ₹ 3350, Stop Loss ₹ 3100. Disclaimer: The views and recommendations made above are those of individual analysts or brokerage companies and not of Mint. We advise investors to check with certified experts before making any investment decisions.
