NY prisons must comply with law limiting solitary confinement, judge says
Judge Daniel Lynch ruled the state Department of Corrections and Community Supervision could not invoke emergency provisions to suspend the so-called HALT Solitary Confinement Act and keep inmates in their cells more than 17 hours a days or suspend programming and recreation in the prisons.
'The court understands the defendants' concerns regarding DOCCS staffing and the resulting safety risks,' Lynch wrote. 'However HALT is a duly enacted law and the people have a strong interest in seeing the implementation of laws enacted by their elected representatives.'
Lynch set July 11 as the date the order would become effective, in order to give prison officials time to adjust, he wrote.
'The department is reviewing the decision,' DOCCS spokesman Thomas Mailey said.
The initial class action lawsuit, Alfonso Smalls vs. DOCCS Commissioner Daniel Martuscello, was filed by the Legal Aid Society on April 17 after Martuscello ordered elements of HALT suspended Feb. 20 due to the strike.
When the prison guards strike ended on March 10, Gov. Kathy Hochul fired roughly 2,000 officers who had refused to return to work — increasing an already existing staffing gap.
But the law's suspension meant that inmates were being kept in their cells longer than the law allows, isolated and deprived of basic services, the lawsuit alleged.
Smalls, the lawsuit alleges, was isolated in his cell for 22 to 24 hours a day from Feb. 20 through at least April 17, when the suit was filed. During the prison guards' strike, he was locked in 24 hours a day, allowed to leave only for three 8-minute showers, the society said. After the strike ended, Smalls was allowed to leave his cell for just 90 minutes to one hour and 45 minutes a day.
'We are grateful that the court recognized the grave harm caused by DOCCS's unlawful suspension of the HALT Solitary Law and acted to stop it,' said Antony Gemmell, supervising attorney with the Prisoners' Rights Project at The Legal Aid Society.
'This decision reaffirms that no agency — regardless of political pressure — can unilaterally disregard laws enacted to protect human rights,' he said. 'HALT was passed to end the torture of prolonged solitary confinement, and this injunction is a critical step toward ensuring the state honors that commitment and upholds the dignity of those in its custody.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
7 minutes ago
- CBS News
Cause of death revealed for two girls killed in sailboat crash near Miami Beach
The Miami-Dade Medical Examiner Department released Thursday the cause of death for two girls killed in Monday's sailboat crash off Miami Beach. According to the medical examiner's report, 7-year-old Mila Yankelevich and 13-year-old Erin Ko Han died from accidental drowning. The two girls were among five campers and a camp counselor who were on the sailboat when it was struck by a barge in Biscayne Bay, between Hibiscus Island and Monument Island, authorities said. The sailboat was dragged under the barge which had a crane on top and what appeared to be pilings for a dock. The U.S. Coast Guard said the barge had been supporting construction work in the Miami Beach area prior to the accident. An 8-year-old girl and an 11-year-old girl injured in the crash remain at Jackson Memorial Hospital. A 12-year-old girl and a 19-year old woman were evaluated after the crash but were not taken to a hospital. Their names have not been released. The children were part of a summer sailing camp operated by the Miami Yacht Club and affiliated with the Miami Youth Sailing Foundation. Ko Han, who was from Chile, moved with her family to the United States in 2024. That's according to her former school, Colegio San Pedro Nolasco Vitacura in Santiago, which posted her obituary on Facebook. "Erin left a mark that's indelible. It's indelible. So that's very important for us to pass that on. While she was here, she was a light for us, for our school," elementary school director Francisca Aburto said. "For me, I also taught Erin before taking over as principal. I was her teacher in fifth grade, and in sixth grade. It was a wonderful experience." Ko Han's former homeroom teacher Paula Escobar said: "She was a beautiful, happy, healthy girl who had her whole life ahead of her." Yankelevich was the youngest daughter of television producer and director Tomas Yankelevich and actress Sofia Reca. Her grandparents are Cris Morena and Gustavo Yankelevich, two prominent Argentine media producers. They flew to Miami on Wednesday to be with family. Marcelo Tinelli, a friend of the family and popular Argentine television host, posted on X that he was "devastated" by Mila's death. "I can't believe it," he wrote. "My immense love to the entire family, who are part of my life." Mila, who lived in both Surfside and Argentina with her family, is remembered as a joyful child who loved dancing, singing and dressing up in costumes. The Coast Guard, which is the lead agency in the crash investigation, said Tuesday it will be thorough. "Know that we grieve with you. We will not take this lightly and we will not forget. We owe you answers and we are committed to finding them," Coast Guard Miami Sector Commander Frank Florio said. Coast Guard officials said all of the children were wearing life jackets at the time of the collision. Florio said they have interviewed the captain of the tugboat that was piloting the barge. "We did do alcohol testing and we have conducted the chemical testing as well," he said. Those test results are pending. The Coast Guard has asked the public for any information they may have on the crash. They said they are casting a wide net hoping to get as much information as possible for investigators. Ted Scouten and Mauricio Maldonado contributed to this report.
Associated Press
8 minutes ago
- Associated Press
SiebenCarey Attorney Susan M. Holden Inducted Into the International Academy of Trial Lawyers
With Only 500 Members Nationwide, Holden in Elite Company Minneapolis, Minnesota--(Newsfile Corp. - July 31, 2025) - Susan M. Holden of Minneapolis-based SiebenCarey Personal Injury Law was inducted as a Fellow into the International Academy of Trial Lawyers (IATL) during the organization's recent 2025 Mid-Year Meeting. 'Selection as a Fellow at the Academy represents a pinnacle career accomplishment in the legal profession,' said Jim Carey, SiebenCarey's managing partner. 'It's the real deal, and no surprise to us. Susan has served her clients and the profession at the highest levels, earning her place among the giants of the trial Bar.' The International Academy of Trial Lawyers is an invitation-only fellowship of lawyers with a singular mission-to protect and promote the Rule of Law. Founded in 1954, the Academy comprises the world's top trial lawyers, as measured by skill, experience, ethics, and civility. It represents both sides of the trial bar: prosecutors and defense lawyers in criminal cases; plaintiff and defense counsel in civil litigation. 'Standing shoulder to shoulder with so many remarkable lawyers was truly humbling and inspiring,' Holden said of the induction ceremony held July 25, in Vancouver, British Columbia. 'I look forward to furthering the Academy's mission to learn, mentor, and drive justice forward.' Holden's peers have also selected her for several of the profession's other most prestigious membership organizations, including the American College of Trial Lawyers, the International Society of Barristers, and the American Board of Trial Advocates. Holden also earned certification as a Civil Trial Specialist by the Minnesota State Bar Association in 1995, a distinction held by fewer than 1% of Minnesota lawyers. Holden's primary practice area is personal injury and wrongful death cases. She is a partner at SiebenCarey and has been representing injured individuals and their families at the firm since graduating from Mitchell Hamline School of Law in 1988. She currently resides in Blaine, Minn. [ This image cannot be displayed. Please visit the source: ] IATL president Joe H. Tucker, Jr. (center right) presents the award recognizing SiebenCarey attorney Susan M. Holden (center left) as an Academy Fellow. Also pictured are Holden's husband Brian Gaviglio (far left) and Theresa Bevilacqua, the Minnesota attorney with Dorsey & Whitney who introduced Holden for induction. To view an enhanced version of this graphic, please visit: About Fellowship in the International Academy of Trial Lawyers The Academy stands as the world's foremost trial lawyer organization, dedicated to excellence, advocacy, and legal reform. The membership includes 500 active trial lawyers in the United States and over 150 Fellows from 30 countries, representing both plaintiffs and defendants in civil cases, as well as prosecutors and criminal defense lawyers. For more information, visit: About SiebenCarey Founded in 1952, SiebenCarey is one of Minnesota's largest and most widely respected personal injury law firms, successfully representing over 70,000 injury victims. For over 70 years, the firm has employed experienced lawyers and professional staff to handle personal injury, workers' compensation, wrongful death, and medical malpractice claims. The offices are located throughout Minnesota in Minneapolis, Lakeville, and Duluth. For more information, visit: # # # Media Inquiries Steve Miller on behalf of SiebenCarey 612-860-8623 [email protected] Kevin Griffin International Academy of Trial Lawyers Executive Office [email protected] To view the source version of this press release, please visit
CBS News
8 minutes ago
- CBS News
Man sentenced to 12 years, 9 months for 2013 Minneapolis gas station shooting
A man who pleaded guilty to shooting a man at a Minneapolis gas station in 2013 was sentenced Thursday to 12 years and nine months. Suleiman Ali, 31, pleaded guilty in July to one count of second-degree murder for the Oct. 30, 2013 shooting. The victim was found at the intersection of Washington Avenue South and 12th Avenue South in the driver's seat of a car with multiple gunshot wounds to the head. Documents say that the victim had been on the phone with a woman, who later told officers she had driven to the gas station with her friend and another man to buy weed for the victim. Surveillance video showed Ali getting out of the woman's car and entering the gas station. He was wearing a letterman-style jacket, pieces of which were later found at the scene. During the initial investigation, police learned that Ali had fled the country, likely to Somalia. The case went cold until mid-2022 when another woman told police that Ali had called her after the shooting and asked for money to help him leave the country. Ali had admitted to shooting the victim, charging documents said. In 2024, investigators learned Ali was back in the country and living in Fargo, North Dakota. He was taken into custody on May 1, 2024. He was sentenced to 153 months with 465 days credit for time already served.
