Trump stokes fear, confusion with pulled emergency abortion guidance
While the move doesn't change the law, doctors and reproductive-rights advocates fear it will have a chilling effect on health care workers in states with abortion bans, ultimately harming pregnant women.
Earlier this past week, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) announced they would rescind guidance issued during the Biden administration, which reinforced to hospitals that under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA,) abortions qualify as stabilizing care in medical emergencies.
Emergency rooms in states with abortion bans have been struggling since the 2022 overturning of Roe v. Wade to understand when they can legally provide emergency abortions.
After President Trump pulled the Biden-era guidance seeking to clarify that question, emergency room doctors will experience 'more confusion' and 'more fear,' according to health and legal experts who spoke with The Hill.
'Clinicians are scared to provide basic medical care, and this care is clearly in line with medical ethics … medical standards of care, and they're being put in this situation where they can't win,' said Payal Shah, director of research, legal and advocacy at Physicians for Human Rights.
Since the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022, at least 13 states have enacted near-total abortion bans, according to data from the Guttmacher Institute.
There are exceptions in these states when continuing a pregnancy poses a threat to the health or life of the mother. However, most of the language in state laws is unclear on how that determination is made, resulting in instances of emergency rooms denying care.
Doctors in states like Idaho, Texas and Tennessee have filed lawsuits requesting that lawmakers clarify when an abortion is allowed to save the life of a pregnant person. The doctors and patients involved in the lawsuits argue that state laws do not adequately protect pregnant patients in emergencies.
Many of these states have severe punishments for doctors who violate abortion bans, like steep fines and prison time.
'For clinicians, there is actually no safe way to navigate this in this moment, and ultimately, that's how these laws are designed,' Shah said. 'They're designed to cause chaos and confusion. They're often written in ways that don't use medical terminology.'
Without clear guidance, pregnant women suffer and sometimes die, as ProPublica has reported. One striking example of this is the 2023 case of Kyleigh Thurman, a Texas woman who was repeatedly denied care for a nonviable pregnancy after days of experiencing bleeding and pain.
Health care workers discovered that she had an ectopic pregnancy, which is when a fertilized egg implants and begins to grow outside of the uterus, usually in a fallopian tube. Ectopic pregnancies are never viable and are life-threatening if not treated properly.
It wasn't until her OB/GYN 'pleaded to hospital staff that she be given care,' that the hospital administered a shot ending her pregnancy, according to a complaint filed by the Center for Reproductive Rights on behalf of Thurman.
The shot came too late, and the ectopic pregnancy ruptured Thurman's right fallopian tube, which was then removed.
'If a patient is actively hemorrhaging or experiencing an ectopic pregnancy which is also life-threatening, doctors need that clear guidance that yes, EMTALA applied,' said Autumn Katz, associate director of U.S. litigation at the Center for Reproductive Rights.
A federal investigation into Thurman's case found that the Texas hospital violated EMTALA, according to a recent letter from the CMS.
'I finally got some justice,' Thurman said in a statement. 'I hope this decision will do some good in encouraging hospitals to help women in situations like mine.'
Hospitals that violate EMTALA are subject to heavy fines and, in some extreme cases, risk losing a portion of their Medicare and Medicaid hospital funding, according to the National Institutes of Health.
Former President Biden leaned on the law to preserve access to emergency abortion across the country, leading to a legal fight with Idaho, which has a strict abortion ban. The Supreme Court last year dismissed the case, declining to rule on the merits of a politically charged case.
The rescinding of these guidelines also means hospitals that violate the law will likely not be investigated as often as they were under previous administrations, according to Shah. That lack of punitive risk means that hospitals could be incentivized to deny life-saving care for patients.
'The standard of EMTALA is pretty high,' said Katherine Hempstead, senior policy adviser at Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. 'This kind of takes that layer of reassurance away, and it will make a lot of providers feel very vulnerable.'
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Medscape
17 minutes ago
- Medscape
Digital Twins: Medicine's New Crystal Ball?
Digital twins are rapidly emerging as powerful tools in personalized medicine and beyond. In healthcare, they serve as virtual representations of a patient's body, body parts, specific organs, and systems, such as the circulatory and nervous systems. Functional modeling of the state and behavior of the body or its components has the potential to provide information for clinical and research applications. The goal is to simulate how an organ, system, or even the entire body responds to stimuli and circumstances of clinical relevance to the patient, thereby deriving useful conclusions. These models may be descriptive, predictive, prescriptive, or even generative, capable of filling in missing or unavailable data. A central challenge is accurately replicating the physicochemical, physiological, anatomical, and, when needed, psychological attributes relevant to each specific use case. Building clinically useful digital twins depends on integrating diverse data sources, which is a technically complex task. However, when successful, it enables a dynamic 'dialogue' with the model to evaluate its current state, forecast evolution, and simulate responses to interventions such as therapies. It is important to emphasize that digital twin simulations are tailored to individual patients — they do not represent a generic or archetypal patient but instead aim to create a personalized model for a specific individual. One example is a project led by the Spanish National Cancer Research Centre (CNIO), which is developing digital twins of women with advanced cancer using artificial intelligence. This initiative, titled 'High-Definition Oncology in Women's Cancer,' is part of the Precision Medicine Infrastructure Associated With Science and Technology program. These digital twins consist of multiple layers of information integrated into a single model that reflects reality for a specific application. In the aforementioned project, a wide range of data were incorporated into the digital twin models, spanning tumor metabolism, gene and protein expression, physiological indicators such as circadian rhythms, heart rate, and physical activity, emotional well-being, and conventional clinical data from diagnostics to treatment protocols. Adding more 'layers' of information enhances the model complexity and accuracy, enabling incremental improvements and expanded functionality. A notable innovation in this case is the biological clock model developed by the CNIO, which estimates a patient's biologic age. This can help assess whether biologic aging accelerates or slows during disease progression, providing insight into the effect of treatment. This may guide clinicians in adjusting treatment intensity or modifying therapeutic combinations according to the patient's evolving biologic state. The layers of information used and their integration are key aspects of each type of digital twin, ensuring that it is not only functional but also clinically relevant. In many ways, digital twins serve as 'maps,' both literal and figurative. In the most direct sense, they can guide the planning of physical interventions such as surgical procedures. Broader Applications In addition to simulating the effects of therapies, digital twins can model the natural progression of diseases and support long-term care planning. They may help anticipate the onset of certain conditions, particularly hereditary diseases, when risk factors are present but symptoms have yet to appear. These models offer valuable tools for proactive risk prevention and management. In the context of prevention, the ability to present a stronger, data-driven case — even if derived from simulations — could help persuade patients and improve adherence to preventive care guidelines. Integration With Medical Devices From a certain perspective, digital twins resemble a technology-driven 'crystal ball.' Once refined, these models could allow clinicians to explore alternative therapeutic scenarios and identify the most effective treatment strategies. This minimizes reliance on trial and error, enabling faster data-driven decisions in a controlled simulation environment, a kind of clinical sandbox. A key area of synergy lies between the digital twins and medical devices. Wearable technologies, for instance, can supply real-time or periodic health data that dynamically update a patient's digital twin. Conversely, digital twins can enhance the medical device field by enabling the optimization of device configurations or implant placements. Their integration into the body and potential physiological effects can be modeled and simulated in advance, allowing for more precise and personalized interventions. These models also help to synthesize and manage large volumes of complex data. By serving as intelligent filters, they reduce the cognitive load on clinicians, offering clear visualizations and simulations that support more confident decision-making, especially in complex or uncertain clinical situations. Applications and Regulatory Considerations Digital twins hold promise across a wide range of medical applications, from early diagnosis, prognosis, and personalized therapy selection to treatment monitoring and relapse prevention. In fields such as neurology, cardiology, and oncology, these models have already shown potential. Digital twins have already been applied in neurology, cardiology, and oncology. Focusing on Spain-based developments, two recent advances featured by Univadis Spain , a Medscape Network platform, stand out: One involves using digital twins for research on the human brain to uncover mechanisms linked to psychosis remission, and the other demonstrates the use of digital twin improvements in the diagnosis of premature ventricular contractions. While the field is evolving rapidly, it remains in its early stages. Although technical hurdles and regulatory complexities are expected, the long-term potential is significant. Digital twins could enable faster and safer evaluations of multiple treatment paths and support virtual experimentation in a risk-free environment. One major challenge is clinical validation. Digital twins must be tested with real-world longitudinal data and demonstrate that their predictions provide added value compared to current clinical guidelines. Equally crucial is the development of interoperable, cross-border data infrastructure that enables scalable, coordinated adoption across healthcare systems worldwide. A final and crucial aspect to consider is data privacy, ownership, and ethical use of digital twins. Beyond the data itself, fundamental questions arise about digital twin models: Who owns a person's digital twin? Should these models be transferable, and if so, under what conditions? Informed consent is central to addressing these issues and ensuring the responsible use of digital twin technologies in clinical practice. The use of digital twins in clinical trials is already being explored, and their potential extends further to medical training and patient education, particularly in explaining therapeutic options. As technology evolves, the range of future applications continues to expand.
CBS News
20 minutes ago
- CBS News
Democratic lawmakers denied entry to Alligator Alcatraz immigration detention site
A group of Florida Democratic state lawmakers was blocked from entering the Alligator Alcatraz immigrant detention facility in the Everglades Thursday, despite citing legal authority for an official legislative site visit. Florida Democratic Party Chair Nikki Fried issued a statement following the incident, saying, "Lawmakers on the ground were just blocked from entering a state-funded detention site because of so-called 'safety concerns.' This is a taxpayer-funded facility, run by the State of Florida. Our elected officials have every legal right to walk through those gates." Fried added, "What are Ron DeSantis and his administration trying to hide? If it's unsafe for lawmakers to visit, how is it safe for anyone inside?" Democrats raise concerns over conditions Ahead of the attempted site visit, the Democratic lawmakers said in a joint statement, "As lawmakers, we have both the legal right and moral responsibility to inspect this site, demand answers, and expose this abuse before it becomes the national blueprint." They also voiced concerns about conditions for detainees. First group of detainees arrives The first group of detainees arrived at the facility, according to a spokesperson for Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier. "Detainees began arriving last night. Under President Trump's leadership, we are working at turbo speed on cost-effective and innovative ways to deliver on the American people's mandate for mass deportations of criminal illegal aliens," said Tricia McLaughlin, assistant secretary at the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. "We will expand facilities and bed space in just days, thanks to our partnership with Florida." The facility, located at the Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport, is expected to house up to thousands when fully operational. Built in just eight days across 10 miles of Everglades terrain, the center includes more than 200 security cameras, over 28,000 feet of barbed wire and 400 security personnel, according to state officials.
CNN
20 minutes ago
- CNN
Video: George Takei draws parallels between 1940's Japanese-American internment camps and ICE detentions
"Star Trek" actor and activist George Takei tells CNN's Audie Cornish about his family's experience in a 1940's Japanese-American internment camp, saying Americans "need to speak out" as he sees what is happening with ICE detentions today as "the same thing" as what he experienced.
