logo
Letters to the editor, July 12: ‘I was a rural family doctor for 30 years … when things ran smoothly, there were enough beds and emergency rooms did not close'

Letters to the editor, July 12: ‘I was a rural family doctor for 30 years … when things ran smoothly, there were enough beds and emergency rooms did not close'

Globe and Mail5 hours ago
Re 'Canadian ERs closed their doors for at least 1.14 million hours since 2019, records show' (July 5): I was a rural family doctor for 30 years. The question that no one seems to ask about the deterioration in services is how they were provided in the past with shorter waiting times and fewer staff, at a relatively lesser cost.
Dinosaurs like myself remember those days when things ran smoothly, there were enough beds and emergency rooms did not close. We might like to look at why that is, beginning with the vast number of administrators we now employ.
Having retired, I feel I can say that, but my colleagues who still work probably dare not.
Christopher Moss Cumberland County, N.S.
British Columbia's failure to provide timely emergency room closure information, as requested by The Globe and Mail, demonstrates to me just how appallingly bad the provincial Health Ministry is, along with the ER services it provides.
How do I know? I have experienced it firsthand. B.C. health authorities, which are organized regionally, seem bloated with management yet are consistently short-staffed in ERs.
This is not new; it has been this way for years. Despite all the blather from ministers of health, in this government and the one before it, little has changed.
Roger Emsley Delta, B.C.
Re 'Cut housing prices? It will be all we can do just to slow their increase' (Opinion, July 5): Columnist Andrew Coyne dismisses the idea that governments could intervene to increase housing supply, citing one study that claims it would cost $200- to $300-billion to finance construction of units for the 10 per cent of Canadians in core housing need.
I assume that this study was done by the private sector to guard its own turf. But the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation could act as its own developer to build prefabricated housing on land the government already owns, thereby avoiding the costs of land purchases and developer profit. These units could be rented at affordable rates to those in need without affecting prices in the private market, since those in core housing need were not in that market anyway.
Critics would say that governments cannot possibly run developments, but that should be considered a canard. Governments run all sorts of enterprises well, we just take them for granted.
James Duthie Nanaimo, B.C.
Re 'How Trump could make Canada better' (July 5): In all the talk about Canada's supposedly unfair supply management system, there is one word I haven't heard mentioned: quality.
It may be true that certain people have it out for Canadian dairy because American product isn't allowed to swamp our grocery shelves, but there is far more to this than economics. When we sit back with friends to enjoy a summer apéro, it is always accompanied by a Quebec Sauvagine, Oka or Cendrillon cheese.
Would these unique gems survive without a system that provides farmers the opportunity to produce high-quality product and not tasteless gloop churned out in 40-gallon drums? The American dairy industry has been in shambles for years. The free market has made it cheaper to buy a gallon of milk than a bottle of Perrier.
Canadian dairy is cultural heritage; please protect it from the cheesy bacterial culture of the 'grand fromage' south of the border.
Kevin Tibbles Les Éboulements, Que.
Re 'When did society lose its love for children in public spaces?' (Opinion, July 5): There was a time when kids ruled the streets. No longer.
I grew up on a dead-end street with 11 houses and 33 kids. Kids were everywhere.
Our grass was kid-ridden for years. My father always said that when we're finished growing the kids, we'll grow the grass.
I see more dogs than kids on neighbourhood streets these days. Give play back to the kids.
Of course to figure out what play actually is, they may have to google it.
Douglas Cornish Ottawa
Some years ago in France, I noted that most restaurants catered to families, and that children were almost universally well behaved. It seems that French parents teach their children how to behave in public spaces.
We older folk love children and delight in their company and vitality in public spaces. If, from time to time, we have to point out the niceties of social interaction to young people, it is because their millennial parents have not done so. Out of love, we are generously filling in this gap.
So the next time an adult asks, 'Didn't your parents teach you how to walk on a sidewalk?' – because those parents probably didn't – accept that as a helpful welcome to join the wonderful world we live in on a mutually appreciative basis.
Nobody wants to live in a childless society.
Richard Belliveau Ottawa
After our daughter was born, we moved into a medium-rise building. I was struck by two things: how many other babies there were, while the rest of the residents were much older.
I began hosting 'baby' holiday parties in our apartment then, in warmer months, outside in the courtyard. Us parents grew close. But that's not what surprised me.
I was struck by how many residents stopped to say how wonderful it was to see so many babies together. But when the baby crawling turned into toddler roaming, then preschooler running, I became worried.
But instead, our concierge was delighted. He said no one had used the space like this before, and we were the talk of the building.
One day he called me over: There was a complaint. I braced. Were we too loud? Did someone hate the kids?
Nope. A new mom was wondering why she wasn't invited.
Tracy Giesz-Ramsay Vancouver
Re 'Dictionary of Canadianisms offers more homegrown slang, from give'r to gong show' (July 5): A Dictionary of Canadianisms on Historical Principles, First Edition was originally published in 1967 by a crack team of lexicographers led by editor-in-chief Walter Avis, a professor and dean at the Royal Military College of Canada in Kingston.
This landmark Canadian dictionary demonstrated 'that a substantial vocabulary relating to both today and yesterday has been developed by Canadians.' The Canadian dictionary series that evolved from this critical work was a bold idea for a country that had only recently begun to consider itself a nation in its own right.
Today we have new threats to our sovereignty. We should bolster our efforts to build a more independent sovereign nation. Mapping our cultural development through Canadian English is part of this important effort.
Great support and interest should be focused on the efforts of Stefan Dollinger and our lexicographers to bring us Canadian dictionaries for these challenging times.
Elbows up, indeed.
Pete Avis Kingston
Letters to the Editor should be exclusive to The Globe and Mail. Include your name, address and daytime phone number. Keep letters to 150 words or fewer. Letters may be edited for length and clarity. To submit a letter by e-mail, click here: letters@globeandmail.com
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Measles spread 'like wildfire' among unvaccinated children in northeast B.C., health officer says
Measles spread 'like wildfire' among unvaccinated children in northeast B.C., health officer says

CBC

time31 minutes ago

  • CBC

Measles spread 'like wildfire' among unvaccinated children in northeast B.C., health officer says

A pocket of unvaccinated children in northeast B.C. allowed cases of measles in the region to spread "like wildfire," says B.C.'s deputy provincial health officer, Dr. Martin Lavoie. He made the remarks during a provincial update on the disease that has seen multiple exposures reported in and around Fort St. John, including at an elementary school, emergency room and prenatal clinic. "If the virus finds people who are not immunized, it will start infecting," Lavoie said during the July 10 presentation given to media. Over the past weeks, he added, "the virus has found communities or pockets of population that are large enough in numbers to allow the virus to all of a sudden, I would say, explode or start like a wildfire ... and then it takes some time before it dies off and runs its course." The risks of allowing it to spread, he said, included serious disease or even death. 10 hospitalized, the majority infected children According to provincial numbers, there is currently just one case of measles still active in the province. But as of July 8, 10 people were hospitalized due to the virus, with a total of 102 confirmed cases provincewide this year. That's the highest number in more than a decade, though still significantly less than a 2014 outbreak centred around B.C.'s Fraser Valley that resulted in 344 confirmed cases. In that case, the epicentre of the disease was at a school where about 360 students from kindergarten to grade 12 were infected, according to the B.C. Centre for Disease Control. Lavoie said the outbreak in northeast B.C. had followed a similar pattern, with the first case believed to be travel-related. From there, an exposure was reported at an elementary school in the community of Wonowon, around 90 kilometres northwest of Fort St. John. Subsequent exposures were then reported at shops and businesses, as well as at Fort St. John's emergency room and prenatal clinic for pregnant mothers. The majority of those infected were under 18, provincial data shows, making up 70 per cent of known infections. The actual number is likely higher, Lavoie said, as many cases are known to go unreported. Six of the 10 confirmed hospitalization cases in B.C. are located in Northern Health, with one in each of the four other health regions. Lavoie said because the population of northeast B.C. is smaller than the Fraser Valley, he did not expect total infections to climb as high as they had in 2014, though he warned there was still a risk of travel-related infections bringing it to other locations. He also noted that the virus was able to spread so successfully because it has been roughly 20 years since measles were in the region in any significant numbers, so there was an entire generation of unvaccinated people ready to be infected. Northern Health's chief medical health officer, Dr. Jong Kim, said the bulk of the infections had occurred in known "under-immunized, vulnerable communities," but he hoped the peak of infection had already been seen, with cases now on the decline. He also said outreach efforts were underway to communities in the region that are deemed to be most at risk of future outbreaks. According to the local school district, the school where the initial measles outbreak took place is 90 per cent Russian or German-speaking, in an area with religious communities who may not undergo regular vaccine schedules. Lavoie said B.C.'s immunization rate of about 84 per cent was quite good but not perfect, while B.C. Health Minister Josie Osborne said getting immunized is the best thing B.C. residents can do to protect themselves and others. Alberta experiencing highest per-capita measles rate in North America B.C. released its latest case figures one day after Alberta had reported 1,230 infections since March. While Ontario has reported the highest absolute number of cases with 2,244 confirmed infections since October, Alberta leads not only Canada, but also North America on a per-capita basis. Lavoie said his office isn't concerned that B.C. could be facing a similar situation. WATCH | The risks of measles during pregnancy: Health experts warn of measles risks during pregnancy 1 month ago Duration 1:55 Measles cases are rising in Ontario, putting pregnant people and their babies at risk. Experts are calling for better prenatal screening for measles antibodies and urging vaccination before pregnancy. "So we are very close to Alberta, of course, so they could be a source [of measles] for us as people travel back and forth," he said. "We think our coverage rates are actually not in a bad place. I said they were good, not perfect, so I would doubt we would see something that big." Lavoie also acknowledged the high case count in Ontario and urged British Columbians to protect themselves. Ontario reported last Thursday that an eighth infant had been born with congenital measles since the outbreak began last fall. Infants can contract congenital measles in the womb through their mothers who are not vaccinated, resulting in severe complications, including inflammation of the brain and death. The latest data in Ontario shows 48 pregnant people have been infected with measles, and Ontario's chief medical officer, Dr. Kieran Moore, announced in early June that an infant born prematurely and infected with measles in southwestern Ontario had died. Dr. Jennifer Vines, public health physician at the B.C. Centre for Disease Control, said during Thursday's update that B.C. has not yet seen such a case. "But we are preparing for it by engaging pregnancy experts to prepare for everything we need to know on how to manage measles in pregnancy … so we can be prepared for this unfortunate possibility," Vines said. Vines said the Ontario congenital cases reinforce the importance of everybody getting vaccinated, "but in particular, anyone who is pregnant, who knows they are susceptible to measles, getting quick follow-up if they think they have had a measles exposure, or seeking advice right away from their pregnancy provider." Lavoie said people who are pregnant and infants, including children less than 12 months old, are at risk of being infected with measles. Pregnant women and young children under the age of five also fall among the groups with a higher risk of complications and death.

Music festivals focus on harm reduction efforts as B.C.'s toxic drug crisis enters 10th summer
Music festivals focus on harm reduction efforts as B.C.'s toxic drug crisis enters 10th summer

CBC

time2 hours ago

  • CBC

Music festivals focus on harm reduction efforts as B.C.'s toxic drug crisis enters 10th summer

Thousands of people will roll up to music festivals all over B.C. this summer in search of some great tunes, good vibes and a little escape. For some, that may include the use of drugs. "Live music festivals and substance consumption, I think, have gone hand-in-hand for a long time," said Stacey Forrester with the Bass Coast Music Festival. "If we think about my parents' generation and Woodstock, it's not a new phenomenon that people consume alcohol or other drugs at a music event." What has changed, however, is just how toxic illicit drugs can be. That's where people like Forrester, the festival's harm reduction manager, come in. She's been preparing all year for her festival, which is being held this weekend in Merritt, B.C. "It's really important to me that we implement measures and talk about safety to our community throughout the whole year," said Forrester. "It's not just the [harm reduction] tent that keeps you safe, but rather we are helping our patrons build their own skills." Forrester is one of the many festival organizers focusing on harm reduction across the province, as B.C.'s toxic drug crisis persists into its 10th year. In the two months leading up to the festival, Forrester's team has increased messaging around harm reduction and making drug use safer; things like consent and access to water are included in that, but the main focus is on safer consumption. One of the biggest parts of that is drug testing. In 2024, the Bass Coast and Shambhala festivals alone tested more than 4,800 samples. About nine per cent of all drugs tested did not match what the person expected. About 11.3 per cent of samples were unknown — that is, the intended user didn't actually know what it was to begin with. But, Forrester said, just because a drug isn't what someone expected doesn't mean they choose not to take it. "Not all adulterants are necessarily detrimental or unsafe. Some things are cut with things like sugar into the sample, which isn't necessarily a risky sample," she said. "Drug checking is about giving people the informed choice to decide to consume it, to decide to dispose of it, to use less of it, to use more of it." But it's not just about drug testing; Forrester is also educating festival-goers about things like what signs to watch for for an overdose or poisoning and how to reduce the risk of running into trouble. A medical team is on site to provide care if things do take a turn, she said. While Bass Coast and Shambhala are two of the biggest festivals working hard on harm reduction, other festivals around the province are too: Rifflandia, FVDED in the Park and Otherworld are just a few of the many. Even the provincial government is putting out information to protect people. A webpage has been established to remind people about safer drug use, with tips like never using alone, making sure you know where things like first aid and water are, not mixing substances and checking drugs. Forrester said harm reduction at festivals is a "microcosm for how we can show up with each other in the world." "From my harm reduction lens, I am really here to show people that wherever you sit on the use spectrum, whether your drug of choice is alcohol or something else, you deserve to be cared for, and you deserve resources that can keep you and your loved ones safe."

Talk to medical professionals, not just ChatGPT, urge Ontario doctors
Talk to medical professionals, not just ChatGPT, urge Ontario doctors

CBC

time2 hours ago

  • CBC

Talk to medical professionals, not just ChatGPT, urge Ontario doctors

Social Sharing ChatGPT and similar artificial intelligence tools can sometimes answer patient questions accurately, but Canadian medical researchers caution that the information needs to be carefully checked before acting on what you see. The researchers' advice comes as the Ontario Medical Association (OMA) hosted a media briefing this week, discussing DIY information sources — from search engines to social media to chatbots — and their impacts, as well as what patients can do instead. It's important to warn people now, said Dr. Valerie Primeau, a psychiatrist from North Bay who leads inpatient and community programs for mental health and addictions, because patients are increasingly turning to AI tools. The chatbots give convincing and empathetic results — but the information might be fake. "I have patients now that talk to ChatGPT to get advice and have a conversation," Primeau said. "So I foresee that we will continue having this issue, and if we don't address it now and help people navigate this, they will struggle." Dr. David D'Souza, a radiation oncologist in London, Ont., who leads clinical research into image-based treatments for cancer, said depending on how patients interrupt what AI tells them, they could put off conventional treatments. "A patient came to me asking if he should wait to have his cancer that was diagnosed treated in a few years because he believes that AI will customize cancer treatments for patients," D'Souza told reporters. "I had to convince him why he should have treatment now." Given that consumers will use the tools, OMA president Dr. Zainab Abdurrahman advised if a post says "doctors have been hiding this from you," she suggests checking the websites of relevant specialist groups, such as provincial cancer care associations, to see if they back it up. Fake ads, including AI-generated images, can also lead patients astray, warned Abdurrahman, who is also a clinical immunologist and allergist. Lost nuance makes AI results harder to rely on While the technology is progressing, today's chatbots routinely answer health queries with false information that appears authoritative. In one study, Dr. Benjamin Chin-Yee, an assistant professor in the pathology and lab medicine department at Western University and his co-authors fed nearly 5,000 summaries of medical and scientific literature into AI large language models including ChatGPT and asked for summaries. They found three-quarters of the AI versions missed key parts of carefully guarded statements. For example, the journal article might say a drug was only effective in a certain group of patients while the summary leaves out that key detail, said Chin-Yee, who is also a hematologist. "The worry is that when that nuance in detail is lost, it can be misleading to practitioners who are trying to use that knowledge to impact their clinical practice." Chin-Yee said AI is an active area of research that is rapidly changing, with newer models that are more human-like and user-friendly, but there can be drawbacks to relying on the tools alone. Similarly, David Chen, a medical student at the University of Toronto, compared results provided by chatbots to 200 questions about cancer from a Reddit forum to responses provided by oncologists. "We were surprised to find that these chatbots were able to perform to near-human expert levels of competency based on our physician team's assessment of quality, empathy and readability," Chen said. But the experimental results may not reflect what happens in the real world. "Without medical oversight, it's hard to 100 per cent trust some of these outputs of these generative technologies," Chen said, adding concerns about privacy, security, and patient trust still haven't been fully explored. WATCH | Researchers use AI to help treat brain patients: MUN's Faculty of Medicine is using A.I. to treat brain patients 4 months ago Duration 5:00 Artificial intelligence is expected to revolutionize health care. And at Memorial University's Faculty of Medicine, A.I. is already being used in the treatment of patients with various brain conditions. Neuroscience professor Michelle Ploughman showed the CBC's Carolyn Stokes around her lab at the Miller Centre and demonstrated how A.I. is changing patient care. Don't rely on a single chatbot Generative AI technologies like chatbots are based on pattern-matching technologies that give the most likely output to a given question, based on whatever information it was trained on. In medicine, though, unlikely possible diagnoses can also be important and shouldn't be ruled out. Plus, chatbots can hallucinate — produce outputs that sound convincing but are incorrect, made up, nonsensical or irrelevant. "There's also been research studies that have been put out that suggested that there are hallucination rates of these chat bots that can be upwards of 20 per cent," Chen said, which could make the output "clinically erroneous." In the spring, cardiologist Eric Topol, a professor and executive vice president of Scripps Research in San Diego, Calif., published a book, Superagers: An Evidence-Based Approach to Longevity, that looked at the impact of AI on longevity and quality of life. "There's a lot of good anecdotes, there's bad anecdotes," Topol said of patients using chatbots. "It hasn't been systematically assessed in a meaningful way for public use." Topol said he advises people to consult multiple chatbots and to check that you're getting reliable information. He also suggested asking for citations from the medical literature, noting sometimes those aren't real and need to be verified. Ideally, Topol said there would be a real-world test of chatbot responses from tens of thousands of people tracking what tests were done, what diagnosis was given and the outcomes for those who used AI sources and those who didn't. But tech companies are unlikely to participate because each one wouldn't gain, he said. "It's a different world now and you can't go back in time," Topol said of using the tools wisely.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store